Charlie Hebdo's latest edition

Obviously I was discussing the current criticism by the co-founder, not the case you're discussing.

I can look into that case. I assume by C&P from google you mean wikipedia?

Ok, that was my mistake, as you did mention the co-founder, and I already added a link somewhere detailing the co-founders criticism of the current situation.
It was late & I had a few drinks by that time. Please excuse me for being human and making a mistake.
 
No, you have the right to criticize and offend to the limits you want to take it to.
You are responsible for your actions.
If you think Charlie Hedbo acted honourably, I support your right to think that way, and encourage you to say as much.
If you think printing offensive cartoons is helping fight extremism, I'd wish you good luck with that, but won't try to stop you from doing so.
If you wish to emulate Charlie Hedbo and set out to provoke ISIS, you have the right to do so.
If you meet the same fate as Charlie Hedbo staffers, I'd be saddened, but I won't be surprised.
I support your rights.
If your uncompromising pursuit of achieving your objectives gets other people killed, your an extremist with no regard for human life.
I don't support extremists of any sorts, even the ones that claim to represent me.

There you go again coddling the terrorists by blaming the victims. If you think someone is over the line sue them, denounce them, launch a PR campaign, run for election to outlaw their speech even, if it is THAT offensive.

That is the democratic way to deal with things but here like in many posts you sympathize with those who resort to violence and offer no comfort to their victims.
 
There you go again coddling the terrorists by blaming the victims. If you think someone is over the line sue them, denounce them, launch a PR campaign, run for election to outlaw their speech even, if it is THAT offensive.

That is the democratic way to deal with things but here like in many posts you sympathize with those who resort to violence and offer no comfort to their victims.

In a perfect world where everyone abides by the law and prefers taking people to court, your process might work.

However, you continue failing to understand 6+ billion people in the world don't all think the same. You're trying to force everyone into a western style of suing, courts and paperwork way of resolving things.

When pestered, most people won't care, but a small number will listen to certain freedom of speech (which may be perfectly legal insults and cartoons making fun of them), and instead punch (or shoot) the person dishing it out the face.

Lesson learned. And the Charlie employees kept it up for years. Even got some kinds of minor retaliation already, but still kept it going. Their luck ran out because it turns out two guys wanted to make a point and went extreme. Nobody wins in that situation. So for anyone purposely trying to fan the flames because it may be legal and they want to sell some more copies of a monthly newspaper, go ahead. But be ready for backlash. They weren't ready, because all it took was two guys to take over an office and shoot everyone who moved.

And going my the latest cover of their mag, they are still keeping it up. It's their right in France to keep doing it if they want. Nobody is stopping their print machines. But hey, don't be surprised if a handful of angry people among millions comes back for more down the line.

If somebody in school keeps shooting "harmless" spitballs at someone across the room, it gets to a point the guy getting pelted will get up and come at you. If one guy is going to dish it out, he better be prepared to take the consequences.
 
Nobody claims to represent you, they represent themselves. That independent freedom of expression is what defines them, not you. You can call them extremists all you like, They would applaud you for speaking your mind.
Have to disagree with you Willy. The are numerous groups that claim to represent each and every one of us in some way. The Federal gov't that just passed Bill C36 claims to represent Canada (that would be me). Although I'm on this board, I'm not a hobbyist, but I think Bill C36 is an intrusion on existing freedoms and privileges, so I don't support it. The Ontario Liberal gov't claims to represent the Ontarian. Belong to a labour or trade union? Don't they represent you? How about any professional association such that represent lawyers, engineers, accountants, etc. I don't support any extremism from any group, even the ones that claim to represent me. I'm for tolerance, inclusion, co-operation, and yes, sometimes compromise.
Our experiences with extremists is probably different, but my experience is that they DON'T applaud independent thought or expression. Hopefully, your experience and opinion is different.
 
No, you have the right to criticize and offend to the limits you want to take it to.
You are responsible for your actions.
If you think Charlie Hedbo acted honourably, I support your right to think that way, and encourage you to say as much.
If you think printing offensive cartoons is helping fight extremism, I'd wish you good luck with that, but won't try to stop you from doing so.
If you wish to emulate Charlie Hedbo and set out to provoke ISIS, you have the right to do so.
If you meet the same fate as Charlie Hedbo staffers, I'd be saddened, but I won't be surprised.
I support your rights.
If your uncompromising pursuit of achieving your objectives gets other people killed, your an extremist with no regard for human life.
I don't support extremists of any sorts, even the ones that claim to represent me.

Interesting that you agree with the right (as defined by Western law) of Charlie to offend but blame them for the repercussions, not the people who attacked them because of their interpretation of religion. Obviously someone who believes that murder is an appropriate response deserves to be mocked.

Looking at the past cartoons, they sure seemed like valid criticism of extremists and considering that those extremists are offended by the very existence of the things we consider important the attacks are going to happen regardless.

And considering how many of the recent extremists attacks in Europe have been directed not at people who published 'offensive' material but rather at people guilty merely of having a different religion, claiming that cartoons are at the problem is ridiculous.
 
The magazine did do cartoons mocking Jewish and Christian faith, so you are just flat out ignorant and wrong.

No you are wrong beause with my opening post i was referring to the marchers defending them mocking Islam while we all know they would be protesting anything negative against the other religions.

You don't see their bias.
 
In a perfect world where everyone abides by the law and prefers taking people to court, your process might work.

However, you continue failing to understand 6+ billion people in the world don't all think the same. You're trying to force everyone into a western style of suing, courts and paperwork way of resolving things.

When pestered, most people won't care, but a small number will listen to certain freedom of speech (which may be perfectly legal insults and cartoons making fun of them), and instead punch (or shoot) the person dishing it out the face.

Lesson learned. And the Charlie employees kept it up for years. Even got some kinds of minor retaliation already, but still kept it going. Their luck ran out because it turns out two guys wanted to make a point and went extreme. Nobody wins in that situation. So for anyone purposely trying to fan the flames because it may be legal and they want to sell some more copies of a monthly newspaper, go ahead. But be ready for backlash. They weren't ready, because all it took was two guys to take over an office and shoot everyone who moved.

And going my the latest cover of their mag, they are still keeping it up. It's their right in France to keep doing it if they want. Nobody is stopping their print machines. But hey, don't be surprised if a handful of angry people among millions comes back for more down the line.

If somebody in school keeps shooting "harmless" spitballs at someone across the room, it gets to a point the guy getting pelted will get up and come at you. If one guy is going to dish it out, he better be prepared to take the consequences.

Occasionally:
I have Fuji on ignore, but I'm pretty sure that "coddling terrorists" jab was directed towards me.
As a serving member of the CF, as a veteran of the Afghanistan mission and others less-publicized, I've given huge amounts of time away from my family as my duty demanded. I've lost very close personal friends, brothers really, in global action against extremists. Some brothers took their own lives in the aftermath, some wounds being too difficult to heal. I carry some of the same wounds, most of mine are physical and minor, but a few occasionally do go deeper.
There is a right to freedom of speech. That right is conveyed equally upon everyone, although those who have paid the most to protect this & other rights, like my dead brothers, can't participate. It may seem extremely unfair, but sometimes that how the world works.
As a professional soldier, as a father, and as a civilized man, I take extreme personal insult in being called an "appeaser", "apologist", "sympathizer" or "coddler" of terrorism. Fuji has done this to me before, and although I indicated how repulsive his comments were, and now continue to be, he offers no apologies nor takes any responsibility. He has the right to free speech, he has the right to be offensive, no-one should be allowed to infringe on his rights, so the only check on his insults is his own morality. But, as most of us on this board have learned, Fuji seems to lack that touch of humanity. Some of the best men I have ever had the privilege to know widowed their wives and orphaned their children, so that a sociopathic narcissist can sling insults onto me on the internet. Ironic, dontch'a think.
In a clean, simple nutshell, that's how I break down the world -those who know their "rights" and those who fulfill their responsibilities. Fuji has the right to be an asshole, and he's exercising that right to the extreme. But he ignores his responsibilities; not to be an asshole. He shares way more with the extremists than he will ever realized or admit to. Some folks understand the subtle difference, some folks don't and never will. I hope that I can teach my kids that difference, as well as the to the kids whose fathers died for Fujis right to be an asshole, so that they fulfill their responsibilities first and foremost. Tolerance, respect, and compassion are strength, and IMO that's the only solution against extremism.
Everyone is entitled to tell me how wrong I am, but those with the courage to sit and drink with me in person will serve as a better example than hiding behind a computer screen.
Have a great evening everyone!
 
Interesting that you agree with the right (as defined by Western law) of Charlie to offend but blame them for the repercussions, not the people who attacked them because of their interpretation of religion. Obviously someone who believes that murder is an appropriate response deserves to be mocked.

Looking at the past cartoons, they sure seemed like valid criticism of extremists and considering that those extremists are offended by the very existence of the things we consider important the attacks are going to happen regardless.

And considering how many of the recent extremists attacks in Europe have been directed not at people who published 'offensive' material but rather at people guilty merely of having a different religion, claiming that cartoons are at the problem is ridiculous.
For the umpteenth time:
Charlie Hedbo has the right to be as offensive as they want.
They painted a target on their back and dared some lunatic to take a shot at them -sure enough, a few lunatics took them up on that.
Some guys think its brave standing on the roof of a moving car, only to be killed when they fall off. I think those guys were stupid and contributed towards their own death.
You may think Charlies actions were honourable, I happen to think they were stupid. Their stupidly was a contributing factor towards them getting killed, as they were specifically targeted. They may have been innocent victims, but they were not uninvolved, random or collateral victims. Charlie wanted to provoke and they got a response to that provocation. That doesn't excuse the killers, but I think any preventable, avoidable death is stupidity -I've probably seen much more than you, so that influences my opinions. You are entitled to your opinions.
 
Occasionally:
I have Fuji on ignore, but I'm pretty sure that "coddling terrorists" jab was directed towards me.
As a serving member of the CF, as a veteran of the Afghanistan mission and others less-publicized, I've given huge amounts of time away from my family as my duty demanded. I've lost very close personal friends, brothers really, in global action against extremists. Some brothers took their own lives in the aftermath, some wounds being too difficult to heal. I carry some of the same wounds, most of mine are physical and minor, but a few occasionally do go deeper.
There is a right to freedom of speech. That right is conveyed equally upon everyone, although those who have paid the most to protect this & other rights, like my dead brothers, can't participate. It may seem extremely unfair, but sometimes that how the world works.
As a professional soldier, as a father, and as a civilized man, I take extreme personal insult in being called an "appeaser", "apologist", "sympathizer" or "coddler" of terrorism. Fuji has done this to me before, and although I indicated how repulsive his comments were, and now continue to be, he offers no apologies nor takes any responsibility. He has the right to free speech, he has the right to be offensive, no-one should be allowed to infringe on his rights, so the only check on his insults is his own morality. But, as most of us on this board have learned, Fuji seems to lack that touch of humanity. Some of the best men I have ever had the privilege to know widowed their wives and orphaned their children, so that a sociopathic narcissist can sling insults onto me on the internet. Ironic, dontch'a think.
In a clean, simple nutshell, that's how I break down the world -those who know their "rights" and those who fulfill their responsibilities. Fuji has the right to be an asshole, and he's exercising that right to the extreme. But he ignores his responsibilities; not to be an asshole. He shares way more with the extremists than he will ever realized or admit to. Some folks understand the subtle difference, some folks don't and never will. I hope that I can teach my kids that difference, as well as the to the kids whose fathers died for Fujis right to be an asshole, so that they fulfill their responsibilities first and foremost. Tolerance, respect, and compassion are strength, and IMO that's the only solution against extremism.
Everyone is entitled to tell me how wrong I am, but those with the courage to sit and drink with me in person will serve as a better example than hiding behind a computer screen.
Have a great evening everyone!

Well said. And hat's off to you and your service.

As for Fuji, whatever floats his boat. What a moron..... (that's my freedom of speech!). lol.
 
However, you continue failing to understand 6+ billion people in the world don't all think the same. You're trying to force everyone into a western style of suing, courts and paperwork way of resolving things.

No, only those who live in Western countries. If you prefer the sort of might makes right bullshit you are spewing feel free to emigrate to one of those third world shitholes where there is no rule of law and life isn't worth a damn.

In this country, and in France, we have no tolerance for people who try to limit the freedoms of others through violence.

It is the reverse of what you say: antidemocratic forces in the Muslim world are trying to force their lack of freedom on us, and while you and Seth sit there wondering how to appease them, people with backbone are saying Je Suis Charlie.
 
There you have it, folks:
I've poured my heart out in writing describing how repulsive and offensive it is, to me, to be called an "appeaser".
If I was a black man, it could be comparable to being called a "nigg*r".
And, right after that, someone calls me an "appeaser".
Why?
Because he doesn't agree with what I have to say on a topic.
He will shout me down, intimidate me into silence by using the most vile, disgusting manner available to him.
No-one is denying his right to freedom of expression.
And he has exercised that right to an extreme.
And, yes, I bear some responsibility in this, as I provided him with the ammunition he used against me.
And he's used that against me numerous times now.
And, he'll use it again.
That's what extremists do.
 
No, only those who live in Western countries. If you prefer the sort of might makes right bullshit you are spewing feel free to emigrate to one of those third world shitholes where there is no rule of law and life isn't worth a damn.

In this country, and in France, we have no tolerance for people who try to limit the freedoms of others through violence.

It is the reverse of what you say: antidemocratic forces in the Muslim world are trying to force their lack of freedom on us, and while you and Seth sit there wondering how to appease them, people with backbone are saying Je Suis Charlie.

Nobody is trying to clamp down on people's freedom of speech.

All we're saying is that not everyone will accept get ragged on lightly. Most people won't care, but some will counter someone's ragging on them with a punch in the face. To expect everyone to think and act the same is both ignorant and just as limiting on freedom. If you think everyone should sit back, act like robots and like it, go ahead, but that's not how human emotion works.

A smart person knows some people will fight back, so the smart thing to do is not cause trouble in the first place and the amount of commotion will decrease.

If you think about what the whole Charlie commotion involves, it's actually quite silly. Over the past 10 years, the mag has reoccuring childish cartoons making fun of Islam (and other political events) to be edgy with political satire to sell magazines. The mag even got retaliated against a few times already. Yet they keep on doing it. Act like an ass. Get treated like an ass. If one side is going to keep on provoking the other, at least have the balls to stand up for yourself and protect yourself. They didn't. They weren't prepared and got shot up by two guys and got away (until the police caught up with them later on).
 
...
Some guys think its brave standing on the roof of a moving car, only to be killed when they fall off. I think those guys were stupid and contributed towards their own death.....

Nice. Comparing valid criticism of ISIS to riding on the roof of a car and once again blaming Charlie because people attacked them. Nice.

And considering the number of attacks in France and elsewhere that are NOT specifically targeting anyone, the issue is far greater than a couple cartoons.
 
Nice. Comparing valid criticism of ISIS to riding on the roof of a car and once again blaming Charlie because people attacked them. Nice.

And considering the number of attacks in France and elsewhere that are NOT specifically targeting anyone, the issue is far greater than a couple cartoons.
If it offends you, I apologize.
But surely you agree I have the right to say that, although you haven't said so.

Basketcase - you have the right to travel freely on public property anywhere and anytime in this city. Everyone has that right.
Will you exercise that right in the most crimeridden & dangerous neighbourhoods at night? Is that something you're currently doing? If not, please explain why not.
if you get mugged, and eventually you will if you don't exercise some common sense, and you go to the police -they will likely ask you why were you in that neighbourhood at that time to begin with. Because they'll recognize how stupid you were to do so, although you had the right to do so. A stupid act is a stupid act. If you think Charlie Hedbo was brave, will you emulate that b**********y by flashing your Rolex as you walk through your town's most dangerous hoods?
I've said the same things about 10 times now and it is getting kind of tedious, so unless we move this discussion along lets agree to disagree, because I really don't think I need to say it 11 times.

WTF!!! we can't use b**********y. Why can't we use b**********y here!
 
Last edited:
If it offends you, I apologize.
But surely you agree I have the right to say that, although you haven't said so.

Basketcase - you have the right to travel freely on public property anywhere and anytime in this city. Everyone has that right.
Will you exercise that right in the most crimeridden & dangerous neighbourhoods at night? Is that something you're currently doing? If not, please explain why not.
if you get mugged, and eventually you will if you don't exercise some common sense, and you go to the police -they will likely ask you why were you in that neighbourhood at that time to begin with. Because they'll recognize how stupid you were to do so, although you had the right to do so. A stupid act is a stupid act. If you think Charlie Hedbo was brave, will you emulate that b**********y by flashing your Rolex as you walk through your town's most dangerous hoods?
I've said the same things about 10 times now and it is getting kind of tedious, so unless we move this discussion along lets agree to disagree, because I really don't think I need to say it 11 times.

WTF!!! we can't use b**********y. Why can't we use b**********y here!

Well, if anything it's a message board and both interesting and entertaining. Without conflict, media news bites would be boring. It's all the arguing, fighting, and killing that drive viewership/readership.

I'm not religious myself. The only time I'm in a church is when I'm invited to a wedding or a funeral. So when I read up on all sorts of conflict stemming from people bickering about this or that or killing each other because of this or that, it's just something interesting to read. Deep down, I think most of it can be avoided if one side doesn't start it, but as humans we all have our own opinion and have the freedom to react. Some people are more prone about getting their way and letting everyone know about it, while others sit back and keep to themselves. Some people don't mind if someone is ragging on them, while others will walk right up to you and confront your antics face to face.

That's not to say the people retaliating should over react and start killing, but the possibility is always there as some people react more aggressively than others. Don't tease the barking dog behind the fence and it won't bite you. It's not going to change. It has every right to bark at you and has warned you every time to not get near it or the property it's on. So best to walk right by it. But if you want to keep making stupid faces at it from the other side of the fence everyday, then be prepared to run and don't be a sore loser if it leaps over the fence one day.

It is up to the person who wants to ruffle feathers to know when to unleash their controversial viewpoint or action, and when to keep it to themselves. If someone wants to use their freedom and goof around, then be prepared to take a punch because there's no place on Earth where there are policemen standing beside you 24/7 protecting your ass.
 
Nobody is trying to clamp down on people's freedom of speech.

Wrong. Islamist extremistsvery clearly are, and you are sympathizing with them.

All we're saying is that not everyone will accept get ragged on lightly.

We have the RCMP, CSIS, their French counterparts, Interpol, and if necessary NATO to deal with that.

A smart person knows some people will fight back, so the smart thing to do is not cause trouble in the first place and the amount of commotion will decrease.

Translation: You think a "smart person" would appease the terrorists by implementing the restrictions on freedom that they are demanding, instead of standing up to them and asserting that we will not tolerate restrictions on anyone's freedom.

You then go on to blame Charlie Hedbo for "not being prepared" because the police officer assigned to protect their office who was killed in the line of duty was overwhelmed by the firepower the assailants brought.

Pathetic.