Charlie Hebdo's latest edition

The folks defending this mag are a bunch of hypocritical idiots. They'd be pissed and calling for heads to roll or the artists to be fired if the mag did cartoons mocking any Jewish faith or Christianity without a 2nd fucking thought.

Fuck all those marching in defense of this rag. The surviving editors/owners are secretly laughing over all the extra profit they'll make over this.
 
The folks defending this mag are a bunch of hypocritical idiots. They'd be pissed and calling for heads to roll or the artists to be fired if the mag did cartoons mocking any Jewish faith or Christianity without a 2nd fucking thought.

Fuck all those marching in defense of this rag. The surviving editors/owners are secretly laughing over all the extra profit they'll make over this.

Yep.. Hebdo has never mocked any other religions :rolleyes:

http://www.truthrevolt.org/news/charlie-hebdo-covers-have-also-mocked-christianity-and-judaism
 
I can't help but wonder this about all the people bitching today because they can't get their hands on the current issue - have they ever paid any attention to this magazine prior to last week's tragedy? Did most of them even know it existed?
 
It seems to me that Charlie Hebdo isn't as committed to the principle of free speech as it claims to be, otherwise they would have stood behind their man & the satire he produced.

Yup, I am most definitely NOT Charlie.

Yet it was printed. Free speech in this case also means that the co-founder is free to criticize. Good for him.
 
Yet it was printed. Free speech in this case also means that the co-founder is free to criticize. Good for him.
as we are learning from the various "Charlie Hebdo" threads, free speech means different things to different people.
1) The editor approved a cartoon for print = free speech.
2) Someone takes offence to the tone of the cartoon and complains = free speech.
3) Editor, faced with criticism to the cartoon he approved for print, bounces it back to the cartoonist to apologize for = not standing behind his decision and his man; passing the buck. I don't see freedom of speech.
4) Cartoonist stands by his cartoon and refuses to apologize = standing up for freedom of speech.
5) Editor fires the cartoonist for standing up for freedom of speech = ????? I don't know what to call that. Bullshit, maybe. Cowardice? Deflecting the lawsuit from the magazine?
6) Cartoonist charged with anti-Semitism over the cartoon =??? Again, I don't know, but doesn't seem like free speech, especially in light of what the magazine did now. Its okay to offend Muslims in 2015 but not okay to offend Jews in 2008? Hypocrisy?
7) Cartoonist wasn't murdered (as far as we know) = good thing, but still not free speech, what with the whole lawsuit thing.
I guess we've learned that if you offend Allah, the Muslim faith with avenge it with blood, but offending the Jewish faith can be resolved with money......hey, those rumours about Jews lovin' money more than anything else has some basis to it!!! FREE SPEECH!!! FREE SPEECH!!!
 
The folks defending this mag are a bunch of hypocritical idiots. They'd be pissed and calling for heads to roll or the artists to be fired if the mag did cartoons mocking any Jewish faith or Christianity without a 2nd fucking thought.

Fuck all those marching in defense of this rag. The surviving editors/owners are secretly laughing over all the extra profit they'll make over this.

The magazine did do cartoons mocking Jewish and Christian faith, so you are just flat out ignorant and wrong.
 
It seems to me that Charlie Hebdo isn't as committed to the principle of free speech as it claims to be, otherwise they would have stood behind their man & the satire he produced.

Yup, I am most definitely NOT Charlie.

What does it matter whether Charlie Hedbo is committed to freedom of speech? There are certainly Islamists who go about giving speeches against freedom, who think there should be no freedom of speech at all. I support their freedom of speech as well, even though they use it to rail against freedom of speech. Freedom of speech doesn't depend on who is speaking. It doesn't depend on the beliefs of the speaker. It doesn't depend on whether you agree or disagree with what they are saying. It doesn't even depend on whether they are right.

Within limits we agree to through our parliaments and courts, freedom of speech means accepting that everyone has a right to say whatever they want, whether or not you agree with it.

In general the test cases for freedom of speech involve standing up and defending the rights of repugnant people -- many of the test cases have involved defending the rights of racists and neonazis. They are revolting -- but if you let freedom of speech slip because you dislike the speaker, then you really don't believe in it at all.
 
Yet it was printed. Free speech in this case also means that the co-founder is free to criticize. Good for him.

I was curious as to the outcome of all this. Cut & pasted from Google:

Sine continued before the [SUP]6th[/SUP] Criminal Chamber of the High Court of Lyon by the International League against Racism and Anti-Semitism (LICRA) for inciting racial hatred . This is not the first trial of Sine. In 1985, Sine had already been charged, including LICRA, of having made ​​anti-Semitic . The Attorney General of each trial requires the release [SUP][1][/SUP] [SUP],[/SUP] [SUP][2][/SUP] . He was finally acquitted of the charge of anti-Semitism February 24, 2009, the judges considering that he had exercised his right to satire [SUP][3][/SUP] . Sine continues Claude Askolovitch in defamation before the Board of the press of the Paris Criminal Court, whose complaint is dismissed March 3, 2009 [SUP][4][/SUP] .
On 30 November 2010 , the High Court of Paris ordered the company the Rotary Editions, publisher of Charlie Hebdo, to pay Sine EUR 40 000 in damages for breach of their collaboration.
In December 2012 , the Paris Court of Appeal confirmed the conviction of Charlie Hebdo and increases the amount of damages to 90 000 [SUP][5][/SUP] .

Yeah, so I"d stand by my assessment that the magazine wasn't as committed to the principle of free speech and they should have stood behind their man and the satire he produced.
 
As said before it is a magazine which is hard to love (but does indeed reflect how the French view satire), but free speech is not very free if those who are offensive are not allowed to exercise it.
 


I agree with the Pope. One shouldn't mock etc. any religion. Was the attack alright then? No, of course not. Were they asking for trouble. You bet and they got it in spades.

Would anyone here walk up to any person of any religion and put their religion down. No Way. But it's OK to do it in print? What's wrong with the picture?
 
I can't help but wonder this about all the people bitching today because they can't get their hands on the current issue - have they ever paid any attention to this magazine prior to last week's tragedy? Did most of them even know it existed?

They wanted to flip it on EBay.
 
As said before it is a magazine which is hard to love (but does indeed reflect how the French view satire), but free speech is not very free if those who are offensive are not allowed to exercise it.
No-one is denying them their right to be offensive.
The magazine set out to be provocative, and they achieved that.
Unfortunately, they provoked exactly who they were targeting - extremists. And those extremists reacted in a manner that surprised no-one.
You have the right to go to Dorchester at 2am and provoke people with free speech - would you do it? Would you encourage someone else to do it? (I'm assuming Dorchester is still a badass neighbourhood in Boston).
 
I guess we've learned that if you offend Allah, the Muslim faith with avenge it with blood, but offending the Jewish faith can be resolved with money......hey, those rumours about Jews lovin' money more than anything else has some basis to it!!! FREE SPEECH!!! FREE SPEECH!!!
Make fun of Jews = history of no violent retaliation
Make fun of Christians = history of no violent retaliation
Make fun of Atheists = history of no violent retaliation
Make fun of...... sports fans still cheering the Toronto Maple Leafs decades of losing = history of no violent retaliation

Make fun of Islam/Muslims = Charlie does have a history of retaliation (minor stuff). Never the less, everyone knows there's a small set of extremists in this religion who go overboard with retaliating. It may be a small chance of major retaliation, but the possibility is still there. Unfortunately for them, their luck ran out and got burned with the small chance actually happening.

In lots of countries, humour, satire, making fun is all well and good. Canadians are like that. I guess French people love humour like that too. But that doesn't mean everyone likes it. Got to pick your battles and know which groups of people are easy targets and like the funnies and which to avoid as they'll hit back. Just because that Charlie office is 1,000s of miles away from the mass concentration of Muslims doesn't mean it's automatically a safe haven due to distance. They keep rolling the dice but got snake eyes this time.

Until this tragedy I'd never even heard of this French mag. But after reading up about it during the event, turns out they are political type of mag with edgy cartoons and articles. And amazingly, it was interesting to see the mag already have a history of Islam satire and the retaliation it had received over the years already.

So while it's not really surprising what happened, it really comes down to a fundamental question...... why keep bugging people? Everyone knows some groups of people are more inclined to swing back, so why keep up the hassling?

Now if the answer is something like..... we sell more copies, so we get more profit. Or, well we French people love political satire. So be it. But again, don't be ignorant to consequences. it may be a low chance of something big happening against you, but the threat is there. It happened and they weren't prepared as two guys basically took over an entire office.
 
I was curious as to the outcome of all this. Cut & pasted from Google:
...

Obviously I was discussing the current criticism by the co-founder, not the case you're discussing.

I can look into that case. I assume by C&P from google you mean wikipedia?
 
No-one is denying them their right to be offensive.
The magazine set out to be provocative, and they achieved that.
Unfortunately, they provoked exactly who they were targeting - extremists. And those extremists reacted in a manner that surprised no-one.
You have the right to go to Dorchester at 2am and provoke people with free speech - would you do it? Would you encourage someone else to do it? (I'm assuming Dorchester is still a badass neighbourhood in Boston).
Ah, so we have the right to criticize and offend unless the people get too mad. I see.

If the Charlie people knew they were putting themselves at risk by standing up for their (and their country's) values then that seems pretty honourable, even if you don't agree with them.
 
Ah, so we have the right to criticize and offend unless the people get too mad. I see.

If the Charlie people knew they were putting themselves at risk by standing up for their (and their country's) values then that seems pretty honourable, even if you don't agree with them.
No, you have the right to criticize and offend to the limits you want to take it to.
You are responsible for your actions.
If you think Charlie Hedbo acted honourably, I support your right to think that way, and encourage you to say as much.
If you think printing offensive cartoons is helping fight extremism, I'd wish you good luck with that, but won't try to stop you from doing so.
If you wish to emulate Charlie Hedbo and set out to provoke ISIS, you have the right to do so.
If you meet the same fate as Charlie Hedbo staffers, I'd be saddened, but I won't be surprised.
I support your rights.
If your uncompromising pursuit of achieving your objectives gets other people killed, your an extremist with no regard for human life.
I don't support extremists of any sorts, even the ones that claim to represent me.