CBC tonight..without Harry Neal

MarkII

New member
Sep 22, 2004
1,902
0
0
Did anyone else miss Harry Neal? I tuned in mid way throgh the third and was quite surprised to hear this woman Cassie as the colour commentator.

It sounded more like an equestrian ervent than a hockey game. To be sure she was quite knowledgeable but it just sounded odd. Plus they didn't have her miked correctly at all..her voice was very thin compared to Bob Coles.
 
you mean Cassie Campbell...yeah I was mystified at first, I have no idea if this was a one time shot or a permanent thing. I hope it isn't permanent!
 
Harry Neal is the best color analyst in the country.

He is the only guy who can only say a few words that mean so many more.
 
what are you members of the blue and white cult smoking!!! those two fossils together are the worst commentator-analyst combos in sports, Cole makes so many mistakes on players names of teams other than the Leafs, and that Neale idiot cant remember the names of any Sens players even though they play his beloved Leafs like 8 times a year, I hope this is the beginning of getting rid of these two morons off of tv forever
 
re:HNIC really sucked tonight!

Personally I stopped watching the game tonight. I think this is another attempt to make something politically correct. Bob Cole and Harry Neale have a natural flow to them. They are great commentators in my opinion. Bob Cole pretty much called from what I watched for 10 mins. I couldn't stand to watch to the rest. The girl would put her comments in for a sec and the Bob would do the rest. There was no flow or anything. These experiments are lame and are they really necessary? I can't wait to see if Don Cherry says anything next week.
 
I don't think I was listening to the same commentary........Cassie did a marvellous job for her first attempt. She knows the game having played for our National Team for 12 years. Cassie retired as Captain in May.

I'm not knocking Bob and Harry, but come on guys, how do you think either of them did first time out. Hopefully, she has a future on HNIC.

Hey BKS, ya missed a great game. Both these teams have a real future, which is something I haven't said about the leafs in about twenty years!!
 
I thought she was just hired to do ice level level reporting. Maybe Neale couldn't get in because of the snowstorm in Buffalo, where he lives and she filled in for him.
 
I thought Cassie was very knowledgeable... having tuned in during the middle of the third period I just didn't know who she was.

I think for me it was the audio difference in their voices that made it seem like an Olympics broadcast where you have one person who is a broadcaster and the other is a rookie...the colour, the rookie always sounds very thin in terms of audio quality.

As other's have pointed out this is apparently a one game test. God knows why. Bob Cole for all of his missed shots, calls and player names is pretty much an institution on HNIC and Harry Neal..well some nights he may be stale but give him credit..most nights he was watching the leafs!

I hope this doesn't continue.

M2
 
While I agree Cassie Campbell did know her stuff, maybe its the fact I am so used to listening to Cole and Neale on Saturday nights for X number of years....
 
Not to be taken too seriously

shack said:
I thought she was just hired to do ice level level reporting. Maybe Neale couldn't get in because of the snowstorm in Buffalo, where he lives and she filled in for him.


I did overhear them saying that Neale was at home in Buffalo taking care of stuff. Anyways, I heard that next year CTV will own the rights to HNIC next year (they have more $$$ than the CBC courtesy of Bell Globe Media). Bell owns CTV, TSN, the entire CHUM franchise and probably more so it's inevitable that they will own the leafs and raptors pretty soon and probably the entire city of Toronto in the near future. All hail our corporate Masters, all hail Bell. MWA Ha HA HA HA. :rolleyes:
 
I was working in the editing room tonight and during the third period Cassie dropped to her knees and fished around for Bob's pipe. Poor old Bob was calling a leaf power-play and became more flabbbergasted than usual.

Bob: Oh my Cassie, that's a hard one, isn't it...McCabe, grips his stick...Over to Wellwood, and yes it is well, well it is wood...quick pass to Tucker, yes tucker it up baby...shoots he scores! First shot on goal and Tucker ends it.

Cheesy experiment done by the CBC.
 
I didn't watch the game, but I can honestly say I never enjoyed Neal and frequently disagreed with his takes on players. I mearly got used to and accepted him, with some grudging appreciation for the vast experience he acquired just from being steeped in the game for so long.

I can't comment on Campbell, but you guys can't expect anybody to have the same rapport and chemistry on the first night on the air as people who've been working together as long as Neal & Cole have. Nevertheless, it's a fact of life that people get old, retire or die, somebody else is going to have to step in for good one day and it will take many hours to grow into the role.
 
I don't have a problem with a female announcer. A lot of guys do but won't come out and admit it (they'd rather say they just hate "political correctness" or, in other words, equal opportunity :rolleyes: ).

That being said, the problem I had with Cassie is that, IMO, she doesn't have a "radio voice." Her voice is too high and almost nasal. IMO you need a deeper sounding voice to make good radio. Yes, men have deeper voices, but there are plenty of female radio hosts out there that can do the job. I think this was a case of "let's put Cassie on b/c we need a stand-in, she wants to do it, and she played on the Olympic team." But she doesn't have the chops for it, IMHO. She also needed to be more confident in her demeanour, but I guess nervousness can be expected for your first time on HNIC.
 
I really don't know what you all were watching but she saw the ice and the game better then any comintator I remember.... yes her voice isn't what i am used to but, but I am also not used to someone with that much expertise and able to comunicate their thoughts so well.... I learned a thing or two last night about the game....

b d
 
i can't wait for CBC to lose the NHL broadcast rights so we can have real business oriented broadcasters host all the games. The combination of 85 year old Bob Cole and anyone is lame at best, but last night with Bob some little girl was the bottom of the barrel. Her insights into the game were basic at best. I watched Lou Pinella on the Tigers-A's broadcast in the afternoon and thought ....man isn't it great to listen to a guy who knows so much of what is going through the managers heads during the game .....and then I have to listen to Bob and Cassie in the evening.....wow what a friggin let down. And don't even get me started on that moron Don Cherry during half-time.
 
Ref said:
Cheesy experiment done by the CBC.
It wasn't an experiment. Neale couldn't make it in and she was thrown into the breach. She wasn't ready for it and that's not what she was hired for and it showed.
 
she didn't even commentate properly! she just threw her 2 cents in aat the end of every play!

but on the plus side, how hot was matt stajan's girlfriend during the pre-game???
 
I though Cassie did a good job. What I was disappointed with was that she didn't take Bob Coles job instead. That old fart needs to go in the worst way.