Carpenter vs. Clemens

the_big_E

New member
Feb 28, 2003
3,435
1
0
The Hammer
For the time being, I've had enough of the hockey threads so...who will win the NL Cy Young? It's obviously between these two guys because Dontrelle Willis hasnt been as good lately. It's tough to choose one over the other, but right now I'd give it to both of them. If Carpenter has like 8 more wins than Clemens, he should get it. This is going to be an ongoing debate.

As of August 16th, here are there numbers:
Chris Carpenter (http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/players/5771)
17-4, 2.25 ERA, 0.98 WHIP, 169 K's, 180.1 IP, .212 BAA

Roger Clemens (http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/players/3340)
11-4, 1.32, 0.93 WHIP, 148 K's, 164 IP, .186 BAA

Okay I change my mind, its not Clemens' fault the Astros cant score, he should get it. And did I mention he's freakin' 43 years old!!!
 
the_big_E said:
For the time being, I've had enough of the hockey threads so...who will win the NL Cy Young? It's obviously between these two guys because Dontrelle Willis hasnt been as good lately. It's tough to choose one over the other, but right now I'd give it to both of them. If Carpenter has like 8 more wins than Clemens, he should get it. This is going to be an ongoing debate.

As of August 16th, here are there numbers:
Chris Carpenter (http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/players/5771)
17-4, 2.25 ERA, 0.98 WHIP, 169 K's, 180.1 IP, .212 BAA

Roger Clemens (http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/players/3340)
11-4, 1.32, 0.93 WHIP, 148 K's, 164 IP, .186 BAA

Okay I change my mind, its not Clemens' fault the Astros cant score, he should get it. And did I mention he's freakin' 43 years old!!!



and to think these two were both teammates........
 
I think a key stat that is missing is the fact that Carpenter has 6 complete games and Clemens has 0. If Clemens pitched deeper into the games he would have more wins but significantly higher ERA/WHIP numbers. Pitchers tend to give it up after batters have seen them for the fourth time and their arms are tiring. By pitching complete games it gives your team's bullpen rest which helps your team out too.
 
hammertm said:
If the season ended today i go with Carpenter, but alot can change in their last 8-10 starts each.

Yep and yep
 
Right now, if they voted, I think Carpenter would win quite easily. The most important stat by far is wins/losses in which Carpenter is well ahead. The secondary stats are closer. Clemens has a better ERA but Carpenter's got K's, innings and complete games.

As much as I dislike Clemens, I have to admit the numbers he's putting up at his age are truly spectacular. Just because they're amazing for his age though, doesn't mean they're better than Carpenter's.
 
Had the Jays had a chance to ...

... keep both of em. Halladay may have been 3rd in the rotation. Sick or what! I know ... just dreaming.
 
If the season is to end today and Roger Clemens wins the CY over Carpenter, then Randy Johnson should have won it last year in place of Clemens.

Johnson 2004 Stats:

Games Started: 35
Innings Pitched: 246.2
Strike Outs: 290
Walks: 44
ERA: 2.60
Opppnents Batting Average: 0.197
Wins: 16
Losses: 10

Clemens 2004 Stats:

Games Started: 33
Innings Pitched: 214.1
Strike Outs: 218
Walks: 79
ERA: 2.98
Opppnents Batting Average: 0.217
Wins: 18
Losses: 4


As you can see, Johnson had all superior numbers than Clemens except for wins. Had Arizona score more runs, Johnson would have gotten his second triple crown. Heck, he'll be dominating practically all picthing stats.
 
Well, officially Jake Peavy was the ERA champ in 2004. However, he only pitched 166.1 innings on 27 starts. He missed time at the beginning of the season.