Canada Creates Second Class Citizenship

"(b) was convicted of a terrorism offence as defined in section 2 of the Criminal Code — or an offence outside Canada that, if committed in Canada, would constitute a terrorism offence as defined in that section — and sentenced to at least five years of imprisonment;"

This is part of the actual law. This could have applied to Mohammed Fahmy. Convicted of terrorism in Egypt by the kangaroo court of a dictatorship, nevertheless friendly with Canada.

In any case, a Canadian Citizen, whether born abroad or not, convicted of any offense should face the same penalties. If not, you then have two classes of citizenship.
 
But most people are eligible for citizenship in the native country of their parents if it's not Canada.
I wasn't aware of most. I know the U.K. has the "grandfather" rule but I always thought that was because so many children of Brits were born in the far flung corners of "The Empire" and not in their ancestral homeland. I wouldn't be surprised if there were more people of British ancestry born outside the U.K. than in the U.K.. Think of all the people in Canada, the U.S., Ireland, Australia, New Zealand, India, Hong Kong, Singapore, etc. who can trace their root back to the U.K.

BTW: Conrad Black born in Canada is not a Canadian citizen. I think he tried to get it but Chretien said "no way". Instead Chretien gave Canadian citizenships to the Khadrs.
 
What if a kid born here of Middle Eastern parents commits a terrorist act, should he not be stripped of citizenship? Or a white Canadian born in Ottawa? What if he commits a terrorist act against India? And since when it is OK to discriminate against Canadian citizens based on a place of birth?

I would be OK with exiling anyone found guilty of the Air India bombing.

I think the dual citizenship thing is because we signed a treaty that prohibits making anyone stateless, so we can't strip a citizenship if it is their only one. But, maybe we should rip that up and make people stateless if they blow up airplanes and stuff.
 
Fact is many countries in the world do not even allow dual citizenship
If a person wishes to be Canadian they should give up other nationalities anyways

But I am in the camp that says if a foreign born person commits ANY crime we should kick them out asap
 
Let's say, as an example, a Russian Canadian born here kills a Ukrainian Canadian born here because of the Eastern Ukraine tantrum. Did he commit a terrorist act against Canada or Ukraine? And should the Canadian born Russian be deported? And since he only has Canadian citizenship, how does he get a Russian citizenship being a murderer? And if he's deported, is it OK for him to face death penalty in Russia?

Terrorism is more than simple murder
Your logic is baffling why you would think it was terrorist or anything Russia would even ask us to deport (if a Ukrainian was killed wouldn't the Ukraine be the one screaming for blood? Your example makes no sense...)
 
Fact is many countries in the world do not even allow dual citizenship
If a person wishes to be Canadian they should give up other nationalities anyways

But I am in the camp that says if a foreign born person commits ANY crime we should kick them out asap


The only country that will strip their own citizens of their citizenship if they find out they have another citizenship is China.

For most other countries, it's virtually impossible to cancel one's citizenship. At best, it's a long process. It's not like cancelling a credit card. And throwing away your old passport does not cancel your citizenship. People confuse carrying a passport and its related citizenship.

In any case, even if someone cancelled their citizenship, the law says that the government can still cancel your Canadian citizenship and ship you back from when you came from, and they don't have to prove anything. It's up to the person who they want to shop back to prove that he's not a citizen. Like trying to prove a negative.
 
The only country that will strip their own citizens of their citizenship if they find out they have another citizenship is China..

Many many countries strip citzenship
Since you brought up Asia (China) the next door neighbour Vietnam is another who will do so
We could spend all day listing countries
 
When someone's mere "opinion" consists of vile, racist spew, it doesn't matter how civil they are being, motherfucker should be raged at. Get it, motherfucker?



Vile, racist spew? Maybe you should go back and read my comments. Stop being so sensitive, bitch.
 
Vile, racist spew? Maybe you should go back and read my comments. Stop being so sensitive, bitch.

Don't waste your time explaining to nobody123, he's a stupid fucking PIG that thinks his opinion is the "word". A guy that spends all day on Terb spewing bullshit.
 
Don't waste your time explaining to nobody123, he's a stupid fucking PIG that thinks his opinion is the "word". A guy that spends all day on Terb spewing bullshit.

Thanks, Conil. Had I known that, I wouldn't have even replied to him.
 
Many many countries strip citzenship
Since you brought up Asia (China) the next door neighbour Vietnam is another who will do so
We could spend all day listing countries

Great, so our Dear Leader is reforming us according to the China Model.
 
But he cannot be sent back to anywhere else. So Canada has to keep him. Why should we keep terrorists when we can send them back?

Aside from the fact that this another stupid exercise in pre election "Look at how patriotic I am" grandstanding by Harper, why should we keep terrorists?
Because they are Canadians. If they committed a crime then prosecute and sentence them. If you believe they should never get out ever again then have them designated a dangerous offender.

Otherwise why should they be treated differently than a Canadian born terrorist? Do you think those born in other countries are not really canadian?

What happens when we expand the law from terrorists to violent crimes to break and enter to jaywalking. Basically what you want is to stop immigration from certain parts of the world and get rid of the Canadians from there as well. I would prefer if you had the courage to stand up and say it. It would be more honest.
 
Great, so our Dear Leader is reforming us according to the China Model.
With rare exceptions, Germany also does not allow dual citizenships. My German friend said the only exception he is aware of is an extremely rich German landowner.
 
I find it strange that Canada customs has given me a hard time re-entering the country. I was born and raised in Toronto...I'm as Tiranna as it gets. Where do they want me to go? :confused:
 
I find it strange that Canada customs has given me a hard time re-entering the country. I was born and raised in Toronto...I'm as Tiranna as it gets. Where do they want me to go? :confused:

They just want to talk to you.
 
You are mighty forgiving of all that violence when it suits your needs (with of course a faceless corporation on the other end... versus people, taxpayers, etc.). Funny how all that civil disobedience often turns into shopping!

Citizenship can be earned, and it can be taken away. It ain't that complicated.


It's sad to see you think like that. It's that type of thinking that causes many of today's problems, everything and everyone is a commodity to be traded and bartered....no one accepts responsiblility or accountability, its just somone elses problem.
 
Many many countries strip citzenship
Since you brought up Asia (China) the next door neighbour Vietnam is another who will do so
We could spend all day listing countries



and canada should be like other countries? what a lame idea.