Can Blue Ray Discs Be Copied

Kilgore Trout

Active member
Oct 18, 2008
2,489
0
36
Just wondering if anyone knows whether blue ray discs can be copied.

I get the feeling in 2 or 3 years that Rogers Video rentals will be mostly or all blue ray rentals because you can see the slow encroachment taking place now. DVD's get less and less space and blue ray gets more and more.

But I like to make a copy of evey movie I watch in case I want to re watch it in a couple of years and I'm worried about whether I'm going to be able to make copies of Blue Ray discs.

So, question is: does anyone know if hackers have found a way around blue ray copy protection built into blue ray discs because I have never heard of anyone who has copied a blue ray disc.
 
Kilgore Trout said:
But I like to make a copy of evey movie I watch in case I want to re watch it in a couple of years and I'm worried about whether I'm going to be able to make copies of Blue Ray discs.
The commercial copy you bought will outlast any copy you burn. Commercial DVD equipment makes a better copy than anything a home PC unit burner can. Some homemade DVD copies are failing to open after only a year and a half.

There's always a way to defeat copy protection, this probably goes for blue ray to.
 
It's been done for at least a year or so:

http://www.slysoft.com/en/anydvdhd.html

I usually rip the movies on to a huge external drive. When I need to have them on a DVD I just burn it on a DVD+RW and watch it but I haven't done that in ages cause now I have a media player called WD TV hooked up via HDMI which plays pretty much anything I put on a USB stick and connect to it.
 
Yes, well sort of.

Blu-ray discs have several layers of copy protection.

The first layer AACS, has been cracked. However, newer versions of it have been released but they have been cracked too.

The second layer BD+ is basically a virtual computer that runs on a Blu-ray player and can do all sorts of stuff like examine the machine, patch security holes (in the Blu-ray player), verify that securitys have not been changed, etc. Again, it has been hacked but newer versions have been released.

There is also BD-ROM Mark that is just in the testing phase so far (I think). I is a seperate piece of encryption that is no stored on the disc so it can't be copied. Rather it is a peice of hardware that "gives approval" to the Blu-ray player to play a Blu-ray disc when it is inserted. If it's not there then the disc will not play.
 
samcan said:
huge external drive.

Must be for thses sixe movies.
How well does slysoft work, have heard mixed reviews.
I've never used it but I would imagine it requires constant updates for when new versions of AACS and BD+ are released.
 
SilentLeviathan said:
Yes, well sort of.

Blu-ray discs have several layers of copy protection.

The first layer AACS, has been cracked. However, newer versions of it have been released but they have been cracked too.

The second layer BD+ is basically a virtual computer that runs on a Blu-ray player and can do all sorts of stuff like examine the machine, patch security holes (in the Blu-ray player), verify that securitys have not been changed, etc. Again, it has been hacked but newer versions have been released.

There is also BD-ROM Mark that is just in the testing phase so far (I think). I is a seperate piece of encryption that is no stored on the disc so it can't be copied. Rather it is a peice of hardware that "gives approval" to the Blu-ray player to play a Blu-ray disc when it is inserted. If it's not there then the disc will not play.

Is this some kind of DRM thing or does the lens need to read it?
 
I used to do this with DVD years ago but not enough time to take care of these fun stuff anymore!

However, as you see, there so many so-called HD movies either on Torrent sites or newsgroups. So, I am guessing people out there already figure this one out. So, I agree. The answer is a big YES! ;)
 
samcan said:
Is this some kind of DRM thing or does the lens need to read it?
Do you mean BD-ROM Mark? From my understanding it requires "special technology" to insert the mark onto the Blu-ray disc during the mastering process. It's not read by the lens when it's inserted into the Blu-ray player but is somehow detected using a "licensed piece of hardware" inside the Blu-ray player. It will prevent casual copying of the discs since you it is an actual physical layer of copy protection. It is something that is put onto the disc that is not read as data, so it can be copied even with a straight bit-by-bit copy of the disc, yet it can still be detected by other specialized devices.
 
Just curious?

Is it possible to use a VCR to tape Blue Ray movies?
Back in the 80s I copied lots of movies with VCRs and still have them all and most still play well. I have little insterest in copying DVD movies and such but was just wondering if a VCR will copy a DVD movie?
 
Answer is YES!
How?
Ask the makers of ANYDVD.
go to their website to find out.
 
Now if I could only find a newer movie worth copying to try that.
That's the main reason for not copying any new movies .... don't think any are worth copying.
 
Most are listed in newsgroups also.
 
Last edited:
WoodPeckr said:
Is it possible to use a VCR to tape Blue Ray movies?
Back in the 80s I copied lots of movies with VCRs and still have them all and most still play well. I have little insterest in copying DVD movies and such but was just wondering if a VCR will copy a DVD movie?

Yes, but too much work not worth it really, I think. Copying them to your computer and then transfer them to VCR tape. Time consuming!

About couple of years ago, I moved everything ... and I mean, everything, to my HDDs. The total space is now about 8 TB. and I have about a little over 3 TB free space. Mix of low quality movies as well as high plus lots of MP3s. 3 Apple TVs and my trustworthy iMac 17 (early 2006) serve my little palace!

WoodPeckr said:
Most on listed in newsgroups also.


Newsgroups always ;)
 
WoodPeckr said:
Is it possible to use a VCR to tape Blue Ray movies?
Back in the 80s I copied lots of movies with VCRs and still have them all and most still play well. I have little insterest in copying DVD movies and such but was just wondering if a VCR will copy a DVD movie?
You need to rip the movie from the DVD/Blu-ray disc and then put it onto the VCR tape. So it depends on whether or not the encryption has been broken. On DVDs it has been so it's not an issue. However, on Blu-rays the encryption hasn't been premanently broken so you might be able to do it for some discs but not all.

I don't see the point of doing it for Blu-ray movies since they're whole advantage over DVDs is quality so you would lose all of that putting it on a VCR tape. I would just avoid the hassle and rip the DVD version onto VHS.
 
WoodPeckr said:
Back in the 80s I copied lots of movies with VCRs and still have them all and most still play well.

This is amazing! All my VHS tapes that are older than 10 years have turned to "mush" (very grainy). A couple of years ago I recopied the VHS onto DVD discs (very labour intensive). VHS tapes is crap!
 
Rockslinger said:
This is amazing! All my VHS tapes that are older than 10 years have turned to "mush" (very grainy). A couple of years ago I recopied the VHS onto DVD discs (very labour intensive). VHS tapes is crap!
It seemed to vary with the quality of the original in both regular movies and porn copied. High quality movies still look good while the lower quality movies degraded and look more grainy. Some 80s home movies made with a RCA video camera, not a camcorder, still look great .... like live TV.
Used TDK SA videotape 95% of the time then.
 
WoodPeckr said:
High quality movies still look good while the lower quality movies degraded and look more grainy.

You may want to make a DVD copy while the VHS tape is still good. Buy a DVD recorder (probably less than $100 now) and do it at home. Please note that there is no quality loss in the DVD copy.
 
HMMM.....

I think that the original question was about copying a BlueRay disc, but I'm not sure if Trout meant "direct copy" as in rip the disc, burn the image, or as in "is there a way to make a copy?"

I would think that if you played the disc and captured the output (HDMI), onto a hard drive, you would be able to burn it back onto a BlueRay disc. You would not, however, get all the "extras"... no alternative language, no subtitles, no chapters, etc. but you would have a 1080P BlueRay copy of the main movie.

Second "workaround".. Bump down the output of the BlueRay player to 720P and run it into a DVD recorder. Play the DVD back through an upconverting DVD player to 1080P. Once again, no "extras" in the recording, but it should produce a very close to original look.
 
Whosyodaddy said:
HMMM.....

I think that the original question was about copying a BlueRay disc, but I'm not sure if Trout meant "direct copy" as in rip the disc, burn the image, or as in "is there a way to make a copy?"

I would think that if you played the disc and captured the output (HDMI), onto a hard drive, you would be able to burn it back onto a BlueRay disc. You would not, however, get all the "extras"... no alternative language, no subtitles, no chapters, etc. but you would have a 1080P BlueRay copy of the main movie.

Second "workaround".. Bump down the output of the BlueRay player to 720P and run it into a DVD recorder. Play the DVD back through an upconverting DVD player to 1080P. Once again, no "extras" in the recording, but it should produce a very close to original look.
HDMI is encrypted to prevent exactly that. DVD recorders also have "locks" on recording through HDMI and the component input to prevent that too.
 
Shoot, why not just point a camcorder at the TV screen playing the Blu-Ray movie? Then download the camcorder onto a DVD disc.