Buzz Hargrove - ABANDON SHIP!

it's also cheaper to build cars in Canada then USA, WHY? because the big three have to pay for the employees medical insurance whicj is around $4500
per employee. Here they pay a percentage of payroll tax. Another big expense is when UAW/CAW employees retire they retain their benefits that's expensive. UAW in last round of negotiations gave gave the UAW millions to look after the paln as it was costing the employer to much. Beinga union memebr myself NOT CAW I'd say if you want them you can buy them at the reduced company rate as if you were in a group plan.
 
Quote Extract: "Such a true harbringer in regards to globalized labour. I recently came back from a conference in the US and centralized/shared/consolidated services are a wave of the future - Why pay high national wages when routine functions(customer service/accounting/ support) can be done at a fraction of the cost overseas ?"

Stating Customer Service is a routine function is one reason whay companies do have problems...customer servcie is actually a vital function to the success of a company and is what distinguishes one from another - think Bell call centres where a custome ris treated almost as an irritant.

I called once to find a car rental location close to where I was working and all the custoemr service rep could do was to tell me to look up locations on the internet (google maps etc)...he was located in India and had no idea. How could this have been a good customer service experience - him looking it up for me while I was on the phone to him and only telling me about his comanies locations close to me - I ended up using a different rental company that was not actually the closest to where I was because they could assistg me at the time!
 
Holy Cow!

In my opinion the union is not at fault for gm troubles.

I have a problem with there entitlement attitude. But that's my problem.

GM has been losing money for years, there costs are unreal. There earning per share are like -$74 which means every year they lose 42 Billion!!!!!

The problem is GM stopped Growing. As a company grows its cash-flow (money it take in and spends) grows which is all a company needs to survive. Its like paying January's bills with February's Money. but when GM stop growing it had a real problem on its hands. It couldn't pay January's bills.
and then snowball started roll down a really big hill!!!

So again in my opinion the only way GM is to survive is to reduce costs, plan and simple. Please note I used the word survive and not profitable!

This also happens to country's when the population stops growing this is why Canada needs immigrants because people are having less and less kids. So to keep it simple "Keep on Fucking Folks!"
 
Buzz Hargrove was notorious for taking everything now for the employees and not thinking about the future. The union is now in a position of having to defend jobs that are no longer economically viable in the current market. The hourly rate of 27.00 is more likt 75.00 per hour when all the benifits and government taxes are included. The retirees benefits also comw out of the current cost of a car to a large extent due to the nature of the contracts that both sides negotiated and signed.

Add to the mix a product that for the most part is average at best and you have a major problem for Ford and G.M.

The Ford problems go back to when Henry Ford 3rd( 4th or what ever) took over the chairmanship of the company. He was trying to get the line managers to go small and efficient he allowed himself to be overruled and stayed with for the most part the old type of production.

G.M. is a monolith that changes its mind like a dinosaur, very slowly and only in the case of a life threating emergency. Unfortunatly for G.M. they might not have the time or the expertise to get this fixed without bankrupcy .

The general notion that the U.S. government would not allow either Ford or G.M. to go under will not wash this time around as the president who authorized it would have to come up with the support money, short of printing it there is no money to be had.

Chrysler is now a private company and would not get any help as no politician wants to be seen helping millionairs get out of trouble.

Enough with the corporations problem, the unions have been milking the companies for the last thirty years or so like the cow would never run out. News flash cows dry.

The unions could have helped avoid this by cooperativly working with the companies to control costs and bring new products on line but the can not do that the. The mentality is just not htere with the current leadership.

The oft heard whine that there is not free trade with the importing countries is only partially true, the big three never made a product that would sell , apparantly Japan and Korea don't want cars that will not fit on their streets for some reason.

The housing crisis in the states is what killed the truck line at Oshawa, most of the full sized pickups go to tradesmen and construction companies when there is no work there are no sales.

The truck sales will pick up again when the housing markets in the States recove, G.M took the oportunity to remove a high cost truck line from operation. The improving market will be serviced by the lower priced line in Mexico and the lines in the states near the loudest senators.
 
the price of benefits to employeers is approx 15% of the persons wages, so if there making $27.00 an hour actaul cost = $31.05 an hour. another thing to look at is the cost of repair when one takes in an import car much more expensive to rapair then a north american car. Please don't tell me they don't need repairs.

PS: It would be nice to have a guy like Buzz looking after Walmart employees
 
I know a guy who builds the GM Cataloic SUV on the line manufactoring that vehicle with all labour parts ect is $40000 how much do they sell that vehicle
around $75000 - $80000, someone is making money!!!!
 
The price of the car also includes the subcontracted parts which are sometimes 30-40% of the vehical advertising, warranty work, plus the salaries of all the administrative worker bees at the company.
 
Maybe because...

dickpound said:
IF labour costs are the big issue, why are the North Americans behind the other producers in implementing labour saving technology? Sounds like the main problem is poor corporate strategy.
But it is always more fun to beat up union leaders, I guess. Old class habits.


..the union would never allow them to fire the workers that labor saving technology would put out of work?

Look...spin it how you want, but the bottom line is this - if they could fire EVERY SINGLE auto union employee, they could hire significant percentage back, along with their replacements, at half the costs.

The poor corporate strategy was allowing the unions to force them into these crazy deals in the first place...
 
that 7% number...

buckwheat1 said:
the GM issue has nothing to do with UNION wages and benefits they only account for about 7% of the cost of manufactoring the car. Just remember the FORD 150 pickup is union made and sells more of that model then any car or truck.

question: How can any company compete with wages in Mexico/China ect
when the cost of living in Canada/US is so high?

...is A LOT smaller than anything I have heard...

What I have heard is that the labor and benefits (including pension and health care for retirees) are the single most expensive component of the car...
 
Actually, I remember reading that the cost of the assembly of the vehicle is fuck all - around 11% of the sticker price.

Did a quick google search and came up with this link which appears to confirm that.

http://www.theautochannel.com/news/2005/06/03/113402.html

GM's problem isn't the guys building the cars, it's the shit quality and shit reliability of the product. Blame the Bean Counters for that one, not the slobs on the end of the air wrench.

A good friend of mine is a marketing dude. He was recently telling me that Advertising costs are a HUGE part of the sticker price of a car. For example, on average, your average BMW's sticker price includes $12,000.00 just for advertising.

Far more than to build the fucking thing.

Think about that for a moment.
 
s-husky said:
I love when someone playa 'socialist' card in an argument about Canada, as if one party isn't and therefore better. Canada is a socialist country and all the major party's are socialist. It's just that some are more so than others.

It's so funny listening to the ramblings of people who obviously have no fucking clue what socialism really is. LMFAO! :p

p.s., to the original poster, did you even need Hargrove's retirement to go on your anti-union rant? It's really obvious what your true colours are.
 
james t kirk said:
Actually, I remember reading that the cost of the assembly of the vehicle is fuck all - around 11% of the sticker price.

Did a quick google search and came up with this link which appears to confirm that.

http://www.theautochannel.com/news/2005/06/03/113402.html

GM's problem isn't the guys building the cars, it's the shit quality and shit reliability of the product. Blame the Bean Counters for that one, not the slobs on the end of the air wrench.

A good friend of mine is a marketing dude. He was recently telling me that Advertising costs are a HUGE part of the sticker price of a car. For example, on average, your average BMW's sticker price includes $12,000.00 just for advertising.

Far more than to build the fucking thing.

Think about that for a moment.

Well, you'd really have to compare a union and non-union shop to see what is going on. See where the costs are going in both cases, and figure out why one is a success and the other is not.

Playing devils advocate, you could argue that a union shop has to beat more margin out by buying crappy parts to balance out the the expensive labour to build the cars and the expensive advertising to get them off the showroom floor. I don't know if this is true, but it is an example.

The advertising costs for a BMW are likely not representative for a lower end car.

For example, if I look at Toyota's annual report, they say that their total operating costs were 24,018 billion yen. Advertising was listed as 484 billion yen, about 2% of their expenses.
 
After reading through all this rhetoric, the bottom line is Ontario, and us! The failure on any of the 3 is disastorus for all of us. Didn't any one see the failure of PMP and Polywheels this past week, 2400 jobs. All suppliers of GM, Ford and Chrysler. These jobs are not replaced by suppliers of Nissan, Honda or Toyota in Canada. Very, very few of their parts are made in Canada. You do not see any Companies like Magna or Martinrea supplying those plants, because they import them from somewhere else. Sorry, but those driving foreign cars are bringing out our own demise!
 
hungry said:
After reading through all this rhetoric, the bottom line is Ontario, and us! The failure on any of the 3 is disastorus for all of us. Didn't any one see the failure of PMP and Polywheels this past week, 2400 jobs. All suppliers of GM, Ford and Chrysler. These jobs are not replaced by suppliers of Nissan, Honda or Toyota in Canada. Very, very few of their parts are made in Canada. You do not see any Companies like Magna or Martinrea supplying those plants, because they import them from somewhere else. Sorry, but those driving foreign cars are bringing out our own demise!

The foriegn cars are not really the problem they are more a symptom. If the unions did not allways go to war to get every last dime that was available and if the companies did not cut costs ( read quality) in order to gain market share with lower prices the " foreign car problem " would not be a problem.

I am a contractor, most of my customers would rather pay me a bit more for quality work and materials than some one else for poor quality. They come back , when the big three were the only game in town you had to go there, mt family doctor ( 45 years or so just retired) buys a white Chevy every two years from habit. Thats the type of loyalty that does not really exist any more. What would have happened if they had decided to produce a car that ran well and lasted? They probably wouldn't be in this boat now.

A marketing guru once told me that it is 7 times harder to find a new customer than haveing a satisfied one come back, think about that advertising bill now.
 
Keebler Elf said:
It's so funny listening to the ramblings of people who obviously have no fucking clue what socialism really is. LMFAO!

p.s., to the original poster, did you even need Hargrove's retirement to go on your anti-union rant? It's really obvious what your true colours are.





Are you and buttwheat in the same local.:eek:





.
 
landscaper said:
Buzz Hargrove was notorious for taking everything now for the employees and not thinking about the future. The union is now in a position of having to defend jobs that are no longer economically viable in the current market. The hourly rate of 27.00 is more likt 75.00 per hour when all the benifits and government taxes are included. The retirees benefits also comw out of the current cost of a car to a large extent due to the nature of the contracts that both sides negotiated and signed.

Add to the mix a product that for the most part is average at best and you have a major problem for Ford and G.M.

Finally a voice that understands the issue.

Logic as plain and simple as described above dictates there must be a change in the union approach of blaming management or government (free trade) and squeezing the every last penny they can out of a present contract
I have been called a union basher, however to ensure their own future unions must change or go the way of the dodo bird
 
hungry said:
After reading through all this rhetoric, the bottom line is Ontario, and us! The failure on any of the 3 is disastorus for all of us. Didn't any one see the failure of PMP and Polywheels this past week, 2400 jobs. All suppliers of GM, Ford and Chrysler. These jobs are not replaced by suppliers of Nissan, Honda or Toyota in Canada. Very, very few of their parts are made in Canada. You do not see any Companies like Magna or Martinrea supplying those plants, because they import them from somewhere else. Sorry, but those driving foreign cars are bringing out our own demise!

The foriegn cars are not really the problem they are more a symptom. If the unions did not allways go to war to get every last dime that was available and if the companies did not cut costs ( read quality) in order to gain market share with lower prices the " foreign car problem " would not be a problem.

I am a contractor, most of my customers would rather pay me a bit more for quality work and materials than some one else for poor quality. They come back , when the big three were the only game in town you had to go there, mt family doctor ( 45 years or so just retired) buys a white Chevy every two years from habit. Thats the type of loyalty that does not really exist any more. What would have happened if they had decided to produce a car that ran well and lasted? They probably wouldn't be in this boat now.

A marketing guru once told me that it is 7 times harder to find a new customer than haveing a satisfied one come back, think about that advertising bill now.