harleycharley said:
what a load of bullshit..... you post an accusation that insurgent "apologists" are calling WP a banned substance. i ask for ONE example of it, a simple request, JUST ONE EXAMPLE, here or anywhere else on teh internet, and instead you attack me and give me a "history lesson"......
as I said, if you werent going to provide one example of your accusation, because all you farking do is put words into people's mouths, i have nothing more to say to you.
Harley, Harley, Harley. Don't be hatin! Ok, where are the "insurgent "apologists" are calling WP a banned substance"? You want RS to show you. I think I can help out.
The first post outlines the following...
"US forces 'used chemical weapons' during assault on city of Fallujah";
"rumours have swirled that the Americans used chemical weapons on the city.";
"US troops are reportedly using chemical weapons and poisonous gas in its large-scale offensive on the Iraqi resistance bastion of Fallujah,";
"The US occupation troops are gassing resistance fighters and confronting them with internationally banned chemical weapons.";
"Some news accounts have claimed that US forces have used 'outlawed' phosphorus shells in Fallujah,";
Then TOV states:
"At what point do you right wingers' stomachs start to turn and you say, "Enough"? How much has to happen for you to repudiate this guy?".
Well, you see, I found this topic interesting, well at least the part where TOV is insinuating that WP is a chem wpn. This is where I took interest, I'm not really interested in the other mud-slinging crap.
However, you ask RS a couple of times for one example:
"insurgent "apologists" are calling WP a banned substance. i ask for ONE example of it, a simple request, JUST ONE EXAMPLE,". I think what I have outlined provides more than one example of how TOV is pointing out that the US used WP (nobody denies) which he then claims is "a chemical weapon or poisonous gas"...HE IS DEAD WRONG. Also, how about the statement: "The US occupation troops are gassing resistance fighters and confronting them with internationally banned chemical weapons."; Really? WP is internationally banned? Since when? This is the issue being discussed here.
In addition, the quote TOV uses: "US troops are reportedly using chemical weapons and poisonous gas in its large-scale offensive on the Iraqi resistance bastion of Fallujah,". Would you care to define chem wpns and poisonous gases...you know what, better yet, I will for you, and if you choose to debate this with me I welcome you to do so:
Chemical weapons consist of three main categories: NBB as I remember them, Nerve, Blood and Blister. Nerve agents include GA,GB, GD, GF, and VX. Blood agents include AC, and CK (not to be confused with CK1). Blister agents (most commonly known - mustard) are H, HD, L, and CX. Pulomonary agents (choking) include CG, PFIB and HC. Then of course, everyone's favorite and commonly found in the hands of LE, Riot Control Agents such as CS and CN.
Only weapons holding these agents are deemed to be "Chemical weapons".
So, in summary, TOV did in fact claim that WP was a banned weapon through the quotes he used. The law of armed conflict does not prohibit the use of WP. So exactly what is your issue here, I don't understand. Is it the fact that the US used WP? Yeah, it's nasty. Yeah some civ died for sure, too bad they didn't leave the city when warned of the impending action, perhaps they felt they didn't need to who knows, I feel for them, it would be a horrible way to go.
But what is the cental point of debate here? I took it as the use of, as TOV quoted, "the use of chemical weapons and poisonous gases." This is completely false and I have not seen you or anyone else prove otherwise.
You seem to want proof, well I think I have given it to you. Now, you please prove to me the allegations TOV is embracing, specifically the use of chemical weapons at Falluja. These allegations are to me, unfounded terrorist propaganda what you have whole-heartedly bought into.
PS You might ask what my experience in this field is, well, not to get into specific details; I have decontaminated vehicles covered in mustard and have handled various nerve agents. I have had extensive training in this field and will welcome any
friendly banter on the subject.