Bush = Saddam ??

The Mugger said:
You know Roger what Harley and his type don't get here is that can't possibly justify by any means Al Qaeda actions by the past and future actions of the Americans. Hell do we include the fact that Great Britain maybe more responsible since it was their rather brutal colonial past that created the US.

Do we include the rather murderous regimes of Mao and Stalin who amongst their victims were Muslims or that fear of those regimes caused the US to ramp up it's military. It is nonsense on Harley's part plain and simple.

You know, I can respect terrorism to a certain extent in a war against an overwhelming enemy but I have a hard time respecting groups that targets civilians of their own group they wish to protect - see Annam Jordan. The IRA, PLO, Basque and others made demands, OBL and his group has past judgement on my way of life and deemed me unworthy to live that life.

I have no more sympathy for a group of people who have declared war on me than if some country declared war. I believe that if someone bloodies my nose, I have the right to hit them with a sledgehammer.

If Annam Jordan has shown us anything, these people have little or no regard for any kind of diversity even amongst fellow believers. As such I really don't see how anyone can not call this a war.
Great points Mugger. To make any references to justify the acts of terrorism is to apologize, rationalize and defend it. What possible twisted logic rationalizes the blowing to bits of people at a wedding party in Amman? That failed married suicide bomber with the suicide belt strapped across her waist that didn't detonate is both TRULY PATHETIC and HORRIFYING.
 
harleycharley said:
what a load of bullshit..... you post an accusation that insurgent "apologists" are calling WP a banned substance. i ask for ONE example of it, a simple request, JUST ONE EXAMPLE, here or anywhere else on teh internet, and instead you attack me and give me a "history lesson"......

as I said, if you werent going to provide one example of your accusation, because all you farking do is put words into people's mouths, i have nothing more to say to you.

in a moment, you are on Ignore.
LMAO. Terrorists usually go out with a bang too!:p
 
harleycharley said:
ah yes, just before Ignore....

What possible twisted logic rationalizes the blowing to bits of between 27,000 and 100,000 Iraqi citizen's while they ate, slept, pissed, played, talked, cowered in fear, etc in Baghdad during the "shock and awe" campain? That the worlds biggest superpower commited such a crime is TRULY PATHETIC and HORRIFYING.

i have yet to see you ever blame the US for a single civilian death or to express horror at it. i have expressed horror MANY times at the insurgent's targeting and murder of civilians.....

Good bye.
Don't let your humiliatingly foolish foray into this thread keep you from providing those excellent comments about Bambi, Kimber and Bobbi in the SC section.:p
 
..number one most of you right wingers laughed when this was first reported, I believe one dumbass's comment was "well it wasnt on CNN", so wrong again dummies. Not sure how many times some of you have to be wrong before you finally understand you dont know everything.
Second, if there was any doubt as to the intensity of the fighting going on over there, that video of what went on in Falljuha should dispel those myths.
Iraq is the worst disaster in US history, I cannot even begun to fathom the depths of the hatred that millions of muslims will feel watching that video.
Dubya is destroying America by these actions, he is a disgrace as are those who so enthusiastically support whole scale slughter, without even having a valid reason for doing so.
Acting like old woman, scared of the big bad terrorism men hiding in the closet, just like Rog.
 
harleycharley said:
what a load of bullshit..... you post an accusation that insurgent "apologists" are calling WP a banned substance. i ask for ONE example of it, a simple request, JUST ONE EXAMPLE, here or anywhere else on teh internet, and instead you attack me and give me a "history lesson"......

as I said, if you werent going to provide one example of your accusation, because all you farking do is put words into people's mouths, i have nothing more to say to you.

Harley, Harley, Harley. Don't be hatin! Ok, where are the "insurgent "apologists" are calling WP a banned substance"? You want RS to show you. I think I can help out.

The first post outlines the following...

"US forces 'used chemical weapons' during assault on city of Fallujah";

"rumours have swirled that the Americans used chemical weapons on the city.";

"US troops are reportedly using chemical weapons and poisonous gas in its large-scale offensive on the Iraqi resistance bastion of Fallujah,";

"The US occupation troops are gassing resistance fighters and confronting them with internationally banned chemical weapons.";

"Some news accounts have claimed that US forces have used 'outlawed' phosphorus shells in Fallujah,";


Then TOV states: "At what point do you right wingers' stomachs start to turn and you say, "Enough"? How much has to happen for you to repudiate this guy?".

Well, you see, I found this topic interesting, well at least the part where TOV is insinuating that WP is a chem wpn. This is where I took interest, I'm not really interested in the other mud-slinging crap.

However, you ask RS a couple of times for one example: "insurgent "apologists" are calling WP a banned substance. i ask for ONE example of it, a simple request, JUST ONE EXAMPLE,". I think what I have outlined provides more than one example of how TOV is pointing out that the US used WP (nobody denies) which he then claims is "a chemical weapon or poisonous gas"...HE IS DEAD WRONG. Also, how about the statement: "The US occupation troops are gassing resistance fighters and confronting them with internationally banned chemical weapons."; Really? WP is internationally banned? Since when? This is the issue being discussed here.

In addition, the quote TOV uses: "US troops are reportedly using chemical weapons and poisonous gas in its large-scale offensive on the Iraqi resistance bastion of Fallujah,". Would you care to define chem wpns and poisonous gases...you know what, better yet, I will for you, and if you choose to debate this with me I welcome you to do so:

Chemical weapons consist of three main categories: NBB as I remember them, Nerve, Blood and Blister. Nerve agents include GA,GB, GD, GF, and VX. Blood agents include AC, and CK (not to be confused with CK1). Blister agents (most commonly known - mustard) are H, HD, L, and CX. Pulomonary agents (choking) include CG, PFIB and HC. Then of course, everyone's favorite and commonly found in the hands of LE, Riot Control Agents such as CS and CN. Only weapons holding these agents are deemed to be "Chemical weapons".

So, in summary, TOV did in fact claim that WP was a banned weapon through the quotes he used. The law of armed conflict does not prohibit the use of WP. So exactly what is your issue here, I don't understand. Is it the fact that the US used WP? Yeah, it's nasty. Yeah some civ died for sure, too bad they didn't leave the city when warned of the impending action, perhaps they felt they didn't need to who knows, I feel for them, it would be a horrible way to go.

But what is the cental point of debate here? I took it as the use of, as TOV quoted, "the use of chemical weapons and poisonous gases." This is completely false and I have not seen you or anyone else prove otherwise.

You seem to want proof, well I think I have given it to you. Now, you please prove to me the allegations TOV is embracing, specifically the use of chemical weapons at Falluja. These allegations are to me, unfounded terrorist propaganda what you have whole-heartedly bought into.

PS You might ask what my experience in this field is, well, not to get into specific details; I have decontaminated vehicles covered in mustard and have handled various nerve agents. I have had extensive training in this field and will welcome any friendly banter on the subject.
 
rogerstaubach said:
Very true lange. It is also not a a banned substance. The majority of militaries have white phosphorus in their arsenals. White phosphorus shells are used as an illuminating agent and as shroud cover.

Apparently the US military tactically employed white phosphorus for the specific purpose of their intent: Namely to expose and feret out insurgents in specific locations in Fallujah.

Actually RS, not be be a dink, but WP is not commonly used for illum rnds, it's mainly used for smoke...concealment.

The illumination charge then activates and a parachute opens, creating a bright light that lasts for about 2 minutes as the parachute drifts to the ground. The pyrotechnic charge is made up mostly of sodium nitrate and magnesium powder which provides the bright light.
http://www.epa.gov/ttn/chief/ap42/ch15/final/c15s04.pdf#search='illumination%20round'

WP is a nasty wpn used to burn, it burns only when in contact with air. If you got a bit on yourself the only way to stop it from burning into your flesh would be to make it anaerobic...cover it with oil, butter? (as claimed by grandma) or anything that would prevent the WP from being exposed to air. This is nearly impossible. If you are able to manage this, how on earth will it be removed without further exposure to air?? Very nasty...and effective in psyops as a wpn.

What is white phosphorus?
White phosphorus is a colorless, white, or yellow waxy solid with a garlic-like odor. It does not occur naturally, but is manufactured from phosphate rocks.

White phosphorus reacts rapidly with oxygen, easily catching fire at temperatures 10 to 15 degrees above room temperature.

http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/tfacts103.html

White phosphorus is used by the military in various types of ammunition, and to produce smoke for concealing troop movements and identifying targets.

White phosphorus has been used commonly by the military as an incendiary agent or as an igniter for munitions. It commonly is found in hand grenades, mortar and artillery rounds, and smoke bombs.

Munitions-quality white phosphorus commonly is found in solid form. When exposed to air, it spontaneously ignites and is oxidized rapidly to phosphorus pentoxide. Such heat is produced by this reaction that the element bursts into a yellow flame and produces a dense white smoke. Phosphorus also becomes luminous in the dark, and this property is conveyed to "tracer bullets." This chemical reaction continues until either all the material is consumed or the element is deprived of oxygen.

http://www.emedicine.com/emerg/topic918.htm
 
harleycharley said:
thanks for doing the research pronto..... it shows that you just dont attack those who you disagree with, you actually provide evidence and debate the issues rather than insluting the messenger. my point was that roger countered everything with an attack and putting word's in the mouths of those he disagreed with without ever providing proof of anything.

now i dont agree that calling WP chemical weapons is calling them "banned weapons." and it was the pentagon itself that said they used WP as a weapon.....

check out this article from BBC, hardly a source of terrorist propaganda......

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/4442156.stm

note these paragrahps....
You really should retire from this thread Harley. It is obvious that there are those posters here who will jump blindfolded into the pit of "look see, there is some sort of info on the internet that says something bad about the American war on terror and I'm going to half-ass believe it because it fits into my pre-conceived ideas. Then I'm going to communicate this info as truth and defend it no matter what."

This was the intent of this thread and you HC defended this tactic and the misrepresentation of facts that this tactic was based on. When confronted with the realities of WP and it's use in Fallujah by me and other posters you delved into dodging facts, putting up smokescreens and casting blame.

pronto you did a fantastic job of providing detailed facts.
 
These right wingers are all the same. No accountability. Excuses for everything. If you are not with us you are the enemy mentality. They support free speech so long as your speech is what they agree with. Just a bunch of GWB clones.

I yearn for the day when I can meet an honest, upfront right winger who is not ashamed to admit he/she may have been wrong on somethings once in a while. In other words just admitting they are human. How wonderful that would be. Is that too much to ask?
 
..Saddam had WMD
..Saddam was trying to get Uranium
..they would be greeted as liberators
..mission accomplished
..the insurgency is in its last throes
..they were not using phosphorous
..they are using phosphorous , just not against civilians
...care to fill in the next blank

...some of you guys are idiots
 
More on the use of WP in Fallujah ... http://news.independent.co.uk/world/americas/article327926.ece

US Army rules say: 'Don't use WP against people'
By Andrew Buncombe in Washington
Published: 19 November 2005


The debate over the use of white phosphorus in the battle of Fallujah took a new twist when it emerged the US Army teaches senior officers it is against the "laws of war" to fire the incendiary weapon at human targets.

A section from an instruction manual used by the US Army Command and General Staff School (CGSC) at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, makes clear that white phosphorus (WP) can be used to produce a smoke screen. But it adds: "It is against the law of land warfare to employ WP against personnel targets."

The row has raged since last year when US troops cleared the insurgent stronghold of Fallujah during a two-week operation that resulted in the deaths of 50 US Marines and more than 1,200 insurgents. Though the US at first denied it had used WP, the Pentagon has admitted using the weapon against insurgent targets. It insists the use of incendiary weapons against military targets is permitted.

But military specialists said the "laws of land warfare" taught at the CGSC are the guidelines that the US Army teaches as general principles. The GCSC generally teaches officers of senior rank such as major and colonel. John Pike, of the military studies group GlobalSecurity.Org, said: "These are the general principles about proportionality, doctrine and so on and so forth."

The Pentagon said it could not account for the discrepancy between its admission that WP was used at Fallujah and the guidance in the teaching manual. A Pentagon spokesman, Lt-Col Barry Venable, said: "For starters, the handbook doesn't say it's banned ... It's also important to remember that WP was used in Fallujah to help dislodge insurgent fighters from prepared defensive positions so that they could then be targeted with high-explosives ammunition."

He also quoted the Army Field Manual, which states: "The use of weapons which employ fire ... is not violative of international law. They should not, however, be employed in such a way as to cause unnecessary suffering to individuals."

The 1980 UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons prohibits use of incendiaries against civilians and demands that forces using them against military targets take all available steps to avoid civilian casualties.

Daryl Kimball, the executive director of the Arms Control Association, said: "The evidence available suggests that that may not have been done."
 
Well Pronto and Roger-dodger ... what have you to say about this?

From a US government document, decribing the use of White Phosphorus as a CHEMICAL WEAPON by Saddam against the Kurds.

http://www.gulflink.osd.mil/declassdocs/dia/19950901/950901_22431050_91r.html

IRAQ HAS POSSIBLY EMPLOYED PHOSPHOROUS CHEMICAL WEAPONS AGAINST THE KURDISH POPULATION IN AREAS ALONG THE IRAQI-TURKISH-IRANIAN BORDERS. [...]

IN LATE FEBRUARY 1991, FOLLOWING THE COALITION FORCES' OVERWHELMING VICTORY OVER IRAQ, KURDISH REBELS STEPPED UP THEIR STRUGGLE AGAINST IRAQI FORCES IN NORTHERN IRAQ. DURING THE BRUTAL CRACKDOWN THAT FOLLOWED THE KURDISH UPRISING, IRAQI FORCES LOYAL TO PRESIDENT SADDAM ((HUSSEIN)) MAY HAVE POSSIBLY USED WHITE PHOSPHOROUS (WP) CHEMICAL WEAPONS AGAINST KURDISH REBELS AND THE POPULACE IN ERBIL (GEOCOORD:3412N/04401E) (VICINITY OF IRANIAN BORDER) AND DOHUK (GEOCOORD:3652N/04301E) (VICINITY OF IRAQI BORDER) PROVINCES, IRAQ.

Yup. that's right. Saddam used WP as a chemical weapon. The US uses it and you cry, "It's not a chemical weapon."

Saddam tortures people. The US and the Iraqi government torture prisoners at Abu Ghraib, Guantanamo, former Soviet prisons, and Interior Ministry offices and you cry, "We don't torture people."

Your lame excuses continue to be exposed as absolute and utter BS.

Bring it on, roger. What BS will you now reach into your ass to serve up to us?
 
pronto91 said:
These allegations are to me, unfounded terrorist propaganda what you have whole-heartedly bought into.

Despite what you think these allegations are, the US has admitted to using WP against enemy combatants and indiscrimately against what seems to be civilian populations.

"Do you believe in fairies? Clap your hands" seems to be your modus operandus.
 
TOVisitor said:
Well Pronto and Roger-dodger ... what have you to say about this?

From a US government document, decribing the use of White Phosphorus as a CHEMICAL WEAPON by Saddam against the Kurds.

http://www.gulflink.osd.mil/declassdocs/dia/19950901/950901_22431050_91r.html



Yup. that's right. Saddam used WP as a chemical weapon. The US uses it and you cry, "It's not a chemical weapon."

Saddam tortures people. The US and the Iraqi government torture prisoners at Abu Ghraib, Guantanamo, former Soviet prisons, and Interior Ministry offices and you cry, "We don't torture people."

Your lame excuses continue to be exposed as absolute and utter BS.

Bring it on, roger. What BS will you now reach into your ass to serve up to us?
I see you're still excreting insults, misinformation and blame TOV. But, that's what you do when confronted and exposed, isn't TOV.

CWC states that white phosphorus is not a chemical. CWC states that WP is not a banned substance. CWC states that WP can legitimately be employed if it is targeted against an enemy.

But you already know this TOV, but you still excrete.
 
Is acid a WMD?

Can I pour some on your face rogerstaubach?

We'll have a beer after and celebrate good times.

It'll be kewl, you'll say:

"Hey, remember when I killed your brother and decimated your house"

I'll laugh and say:

"Ya, I don't even know where my brother and mother are, that's hilarious. I live with reletives now. NO, you can't come over for football"
 
blitz said:
Is acid a WMD?

Can I pour some on your face rogerstaubach?

We'll have a beer after and celebrate good times.

It'll be kewl, you'll say:

"Hey, remember when I killed your brother and decimated your house"

I'll laugh and say:

"Ya, I don't even know where my brother and mother are, that's hilarious. I live with reletives now. NO, you can't come over for football"
What's the matter blitz? Are the facts clouding your mind.

I call a dead terrorist/insurgent a dead terrorist/insurgent. You want us to believe he is an innocent civilian.
 
rogerstaubach said:
I see you're still excreting insults, misinformation and blame TOV. But, that's what you do when confronted and exposed, isn't TOV.

CWC states that white phosphorus is not a chemical. CWC states that WP is not a banned substance. CWC states that WP can legitimately be employed if it is targeted against an enemy.

But you already know this TOV, but you still excrete.

Misinformation, asshat? By quoting a US military site on the Internet? Who's over-reaching now, jagoff?

Go back and have the cranial-rectal inversion operation reversed. You're a pathetic loser.

And if you still want to kill those terrorists, why don't you go over a volunteer? Whassamatta? Too warm and cozy at your place with those orange-stained fingers from drinking Diet Coke and eating Cheetos.

C'mon boy. Where's the courage of those brave words of yours? Volunteer.
 
TOVisitor said:
Misinformation, asshat? By quoting a US military site on the Internet? Who's over-reaching now, jagoff?
Man-o-man is your excretement ever dense there TOV. Maybe you should wipe and re-focus on CWC as to the facts about WP.
 
rogie, rogie ... all you do is complain and mouth-off about those RIFTs.

Why not go fight them yourself? Do you have other priorities, like Dick Cheney?

Are you just full of big words and lots of bluster, but in the end signifying nothing?

What is it, rog?

Put those orange-stained fingers to the keyboard and tell us what is going on in that midget mind of yours.
 
..ya they lied about it because according to their own manuals they would be scum bags to use it. Hey as silly as it sounds they still take things like that seriously. If it were me and it were Stalingrad II , I would use whatever I had. This is not Stalingrad this is some immoral little men using the US army is a disgraceful and disgusting manner to attack a weak tiny little country.
Oh by the way hate to say I told you so again, but the Insurgency is as strong as it ever was , and short of genocide, it aint going anywhere.

...dumbasses
 
assoholic said:
..ya they lied about it because according to their own manuals they would be scum bags to use it. Hey as silly as it sounds they still take things like that seriously. If it were me and it were Stalingrad II , I would use whatever I had. This is not Stalingrad this is some immoral little men using the US army is a disgraceful and disgusting manner to attack a weak tiny little country.
Oh by the way hate to say I told you so again, but the Insurgency is as strong as it ever was , and short of genocide, it aint going anywhere.

...dumbasses
A new classmate for harley and max at the Ramadi Preschool for the Mentally challenged.

A serious post deserves an equally serious reply.