Bush on Auschwitz

Since when is Wikpedia a reliable source - and the Gustav Line refers to German defences along the Emilia - Rommagna Ridge in Northern Italy, not the Liri Valley. And I was referring to Marrochini, not Marrochinate. TQM, I realize that you must win an argument at all cost so fire away with your evidence. It wont change anything. Oh I almost forgot, unless it's a fabrication, there was no Hitler line in Italy.

I do recommend Vittorio De Sica's La Ciociara, starring Sofia Loren and Jean Paul Belmondo. The violence has been drastically toned down but it is accurate.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0054749/
 
Yeah bad of me to

cite corroborating support. (slapping my own hands...)

1. http://members.iinet.net.au/~gduncan/massacres_axis.html#Italy - see 90% of the way down.

2. http://www.sdreader.com/php/cityshow.php?id=C021998

But why should I do the work for you?

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rls=com.microsoft%3Aen-US&q=marocchinate&btnG=Search

Please note (for others): Gurkhas are Nepalese and had nothing to do with the mass rapes in the villages around Cassino.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brigade_of_Gurkhas
 
Kinder, gentler?

No.

We've managed to see here someone take a real genuine horrific tragic attrocity and completely blame the wrong people (Gurkhas - which he misspelled too - and the British).

But I'm used to being criticized for providing supporting evidence.

Still I'm fully aware of my uniqueness - I seem to be the only one horrified that a group could be blamed for an attrocity that had nothing to do with it.

(as if the term 'marrochinate' doesn't give this one away...).

You, jwm, just don't see the dignity in my anger.

Anyway, I'm reminded of Plato's lesson in Meno, that a little knowledge can be a dangerous thing.
 
TQM said:
No.

We've managed to see here someone take a real genuine horrific tragic attrocity and completely blame the wrong people (Gurkhas - which he misspelled too - and the British).

But I'm used to being criticized for providing supporting evidence.

Still I'm fully aware of my uniqueness - I seem to be the only one horrified that a group could be blamed for an attrocity that had nothing to do with it.

(as if the term 'marrochinate' doesn't give this one away...).

You, jwm, just don't see the dignity in my anger.

Anyway, I'm reminded of Plato's lesson in Meno, that a little knowledge can be a dangerous thing.

Well, you're not calling people names. I think that's a nice switch. I hope you keep it up.

jwm
 
you're wrong, jwm.

You didn't see any typed words, true. But the conclusions one should be drawing from what I've said here are far, far worse, than any name calling.

That's really what I don't get about you all. You totally mystify me. Insidious commits an offence beyond compare (falsely blaming people for mass rape; falsely blaming people for turning their gaze away to allow this mass rape), but your concern is of the etiquette in how I discuss it. There's simply no name calling that could offend as greatly, even if Insidious means well with what he's said.

Honestly, you seem like a decent sort, but you are utterly alien to me.
 
TQM arrogance is no substitute for intelligence.

I do have information about "The English Marrochini" but it is not something I'm prepared to discuss in a public forum. Eventually I'll come across the information you ask for even if it takes until my September trip to do it.

If that doesn't satify you it's not my concern. If you still take such great exception pm me. And there was no Hitler line.
 
TQM said:
You didn't see any typed words, true. But the conclusions one should be drawing from what I've said here are far, far worse, than any name calling.

That's really what I don't get about you all. You totally mystify me. Insidious commits an offence beyond compare (falsely blaming people for mass rape; falsely blaming people for turning their gaze away to allow this mass rape), but your concern is of the etiquette in how I discuss it. There's simply no name calling that could offend as greatly, even if Insidious means well with what he's said.

Honestly, you seem like a decent sort, but you are utterly alien to me.

It's the transference! :p

jwm
 
TQM

I was reading the final link that you considered minor. Although it doesn't give the full story it does give me the information I need. What you term The Hitler Line was known as The Caesar Line to us. Anyway read this excerpt and make of it what you will:

After crossing the Melfa River, 6 Armoured Division of 13 Corps drove up Route 6 on 26 May until halted at the Providero defile, about two miles from Arce. Troops of 1 Parachute Division, who occupied the steep and wooded hills on each side of the highway, thwarted for two days the British attempts to burst through to Arce. To outflank this rearguard Kirkman ordered 8 Indian Division into the hills north of the defile, and at the same time directed 78 Division across country to Ceprano where (as has been mentioned) the Canadians were bridging the Liri.

The 8th Indian Division, with 18 NZ Armoured Regiment still under command, had not yet crossed the Melfa River. In the morning of the 26th a column consisting of a squadron of 6 Lancers' armoured cars, a troop of B Squadron's tanks, and a company of infantry was sent up the narrow gorge through which the Melfa flowed into the Liri valley. The column overcame a German rearguard, but could not prevent the enemy from blowing the bridge half-way through the gorge (Ponte la Valle), so therefore returned to Roccasecca.

A ford below the gorge was negotiable to all types of vehicles, and a bridge built by the Germans farther downstream was still intact, but as these were considered inadequate, 8 Indian Division constructed a Bailey bridge near the ford. When this was ready, 17 Indian Infantry Brigade, with a squadron of 18 Armoured Regiment in support of each of its three battalions, was to cross the Melfa and advance over the hills north of Route 6 towards Arce. This country, although marked on the map as ‘impassable to tracked vehicles’.1 did not deter the New Zealand tank crews, who ‘were prepared to go anywhere and undertake any task. They took their tanks to seemingly impossible places, up steep mountain sides strewn with boulders and down again.’2

B Squadron (in support of 1 Royal Fusiliers) and A Squadron (supporting 1/12 Frontier Force Regiment) crossed the Melfa in the afternoon of 27 May and advanced up a shallow valley between two steep ridges. While the infantry clambered up to the higher ground, the tanks moved in single file along rocky farm tracks on the lower slopes. The Fusiliers met only scattered resistance and in the late afternoon reached their objective, Monte Orio,
 
TQM my good friend, can I just say....BINGO!

overlooking Route 6 about two miles from the river. The Frontiersmen, advancing without opposition from hill to hill on the northern side of the valley, were on their objective, Monte Clavello, in the evening, by which time 1/5 Royal Gurkha Rifles and C Squadron had crossed the Melfa and begun their attack on Frajoli, a little village on a saddle between Orio and Clavello.

When two companies of Gurkhas and a troop of tanks closed in on Frajoli in the failing light, the Germans brought down machine-gun and mortar fire from the village and the nearby hillsides. The tanks replied with their 75-millimetre guns and Brownings; the artillery fired in support, and part of B Squadron crossed a ravine to lend a hand. By 9.30 p.m. all resistance in and around Frajoli had ceased. Some Germans were dead and over 40 were prisoners. The New Zealand casualties were slight: an officer wounded and one tank damaged.
 
TQM, as Frank Zappa would say, did you what some more, well here's some more.

Now that 8 Indian Division had secured the hills on the northern side of the Providero defile, 6 Armoured Division renewed the attack on the southern side, and gained the top of two prominent hills during the night. Fierce fighting continued next day.

On 28 May the Frontiersmen and B Squadron advanced beyond Monte Clavello to Monte Favone, the highest peak in the locality. On the far side of Favone was the town of Santo Padre, from which a road led northwards through Arpino to Sora, on Route 82 in the upper Liri valley. The leading tanks skirted around Favone until they were looking across a ravine at Santo Padre. ‘The town was swarming with Germans, evidently hurrying to evacuate the place, for trucks and cars were pulling out as fast as they could along a road that wound away to the north. Our infantry was nowhere in sight, but down from Favone towards Santo Padre streamed figures in khaki, unrecognisable at that distance.’1 Not knowing that these were Germans, the New Zealanders left them alone and concentrated on the transport which came into view at a road bend a mile away. Several vehicles were knocked out, but the rest vanished down the road.
 
TQM I would like to fill in what the New Zealand account leaves out, but like I said it's personal and not for public consumption. I know you take great pride in your fierce intellect but, in the future, try not to lead with your asshole.
 
jwmorrice said:
The emergence of a kinder, gentler TQM? I like it.

jwm

He's been declawed.
 
What can I say?

Insidious provides not one shred of information to suggests it was Gurkhas, rather than Morrocans, etc., who committed this atrocity. I don't recall saying Gurkhas weren't involved in WW2.

The Gurkhas were a fairly elite force, not untamed, wild monsters. Unfortunately, the Morrocans were. Just google it, for heaven sake.

Next: Asterix - you'r a fucking idiot. Just out of curiousity, when't the last time you think you actually contributed something to a conversation? Eh, little one?
 
TQM said:
Next: Asterix - you'r a fucking idiot. Just out of curiousity, when't the last time you think you actually contributed something to a conversation? Eh, little one?

Temper, temper. Remember you have to watch your blood pressure.
 
Lmao!

TQM you are priceless.

An elite fighting force when confronted with prolonged warfare and the constant threat of death, breaks down. In this Gurkhas are not different from Morrocans, French,English...

If you are willing to accept that rapes occurred in Stuttgart then why do you deny that they occurred in the Frosinone sector?
 
This should raise TQM's blood preassure.

On Rememberance Day, TLN broadcast an Italian film about El Alamien.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0329042/

It's a very depressing movie that details the hardships faced not only by Italian forces but the British forces that opposed them. There is one item of the film that stands out:

Since the Mussolini government was incapable of provisioning it's forces, dysentry ran rife among the Italian troops. It was when they were squatting down, crapping their empty guts out, that British snipers struck. This fact was confirmed not only by my late father, all Italian North Africa War Veterans as well. But there is no mention of this in English history books.

TQM here is another link for you...and I don't mind doing all the work. lol

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0084422/
 
Insidious

I don't know what more to say to you. I've shown you to be an idiot. I don't know why you are providing links to films. You made a mistake of numbing grossness and either you are hoping no one has noticed or you're too much of an imbecile to comprehend your mistake.

I've pointed it out, in detail, enough times to retire from this conversation.

Asterix - I didn't say I have to watch my blood pressure. I did imply that imbeciles like Insidious impact it. Frankly, you don't have the ability to impact it.