Blue Jays: 2016 Edition

That is as ridiculous an idea as I have ever read in this thread! :yo:

Perry

Why?

Having an Ace in the pen is as valuable as an ace starter in the playoffs as a reliever plays more games and those appearances are in crucial situations

1 Jays need only 4 starters in playoffs so someone from the starting 5 is not needed

2 That starter cannot be Dicky as he takes an inning to find his knuckle ball (stats show his worse inning is the first by far) and he gives up too many homers

3 Dicky has pitched well with Martin as catcher (pitched shutout last time in playoffs)

3 Either Dicky sits or another starter goes to pen and becomes a crucial part of the playoff team as the reliever that gets the ball to Osuna

4 Dicky can be the fourth starter meaning he perhaps gets only 1 or 2 starts if Jays go to the Series

Having one of the big four go to the pen makes sense as fourth starter may see only one or two starts but pitch several times as reliever

I throw HAPPS NAME OUT THERE BECAUSE HE IS THE QUALITY LEFTY THAT THE PEN DEPSERATLY NEEDS


What do you think should happen to the starting rotation in the playoffs if my idea is so dumb?
 
Sanchez, Estrada, Happ, & Stroman will be the Jays' starters in the playoffs, assuming they're healthy. Dickey will watch from the bench, and Liriano will be the lefty in the pen.
 
Are you seriously suggesting a guy in the running for they cy young should get moved to the bull-pen???

Beyond idiotic.
Sanchez is the number one starter not Happ and Estrada is as good as Happ although last two starts have been bad as he is injured

Another quality arm in the pen is just as important as a fourth quality arm as a starter IMHO



I am suggesting someone should be considered as they have 4 quality starters and only need 3 with Dicky as the fourth starter

You do not think a star reliever is as important as a star starter in the playoffs??? and they have 4 star starters so one can go to the pen

Another star arm to compliment Osuna would be lights out


Stroman seems a better choice as he seems to be the number four starter but he is not a lefty and Happ is a lefty and we have none in the pen

At the very least it is an idea to be considered

If not then Dicky is useless and he pitched very well in last playoffs and is looking stronger and you can not put Dickey in the pen because he takes an inning to find his knuckleball so, having Dickey as the fourth starter and sending someone to the pen thereby creating a high quality pen does make sense
 
Sanchez, Estrada, Happ, & Stroman will be the Jays' starters in the playoffs, assuming they're healthy. Dickey will watch from the bench, and Liriano will be the lefty in the pen.

that is my guess

I am throwing out the idea of one of the big four going to the pen for discussion
 
I am suggesting someone should be considered as they have 4 quality starters and only need 3 with Dicky as the fourth starter

You do not think a star reliever is as important as a star reliever in the playoffs??? and they have 4 star starters so one can go to the pen

Another star arm to compliment Osuna would be lights out

Sanchez is the number one starter not Happ and Estrada is as good as Happ although last two starts have been bad as he is injured

Another quality arm in the pen is just as important as a fourth quality arm as a starter IMHO

Stroman seems a better choice but he is not a lefty and Happ is a lefty and we have none in the pen

At the very least it is an idea to be considered

If not then Dicky is useless and he pitched very well in last playoffs and is looking stronger

Liriano is a lefty. Seeing you don't have him anywhere on your playoff why not put him in the bullpen? Make more sense than Happ!
 
Liriano is a lefty. Seeing you don't have him anywhere on your playoff why not put him in the bullpen? Make more sense than Happ!

Liriano for sure will not be starter but he is not the quality mid reliever that the pen needs against the quality hitters of the playoffs

As it stands it is the Jays weak link and in the playoffs the games often becomes a contest between pens and we will lose those games more than win them as things stand

Everyone seems to be missing this point

We need a quality pen more than four quality starters in the playoffs so sending one of our big four starters to the pen seems an idea to be considered and it cannot be Sanchez as he is number one so that leaves the other three
 
We get your point. We just don't agree with it :) We'll have Osuna, Grilli, Biagini and Liriano for high-leverage relief. That's plenty. The way the playoff schedule shakes out, you'll need a 4th starter at least a couple times. That can't be Dickey.
 
They were talking about the pitching rotation today and I agree with moving Liriano to the bullpen as a lefty specialist and going back to 5-man rotation with Sanchez. I realize they want to save his arm so rotate him in and out occasionally but don't mess with the whole frikken rotation.
 
We get your point. We just don't agree with it :) We'll have Osuna, Grilli, Biagini and Liriano for high-leverage relief. That's plenty. The way the playoff schedule shakes out, you'll need a 4th starter at least a couple times. That can't be Dickey.

ok

understood and I am not saying my idea is solid but it is an idea worth consideration and not an idiotic suggestion

1 I do not agree that said relievers of Grilli, Biagini and Liriano and Benoit are high-leverage relief in getting ball to Osuna when facing the quality hitters of the playoffs

2 fourth starter will not pitch that many games maybe only 1 or 2

3 Dicky pitches better with Martin and either he is a starter or he will see no action as he takes an inning to find his knuckler

3 having the fourth starter (Stroman?) pitch only 1 or 2 games seems like a waste as he would be more valuable in the pen when Dicky could pitch those 1 or 2 games
 
Just noticed Sox-KC game is live on Sportsnet as well
 
The Jays always seem to make things difficult. We needed Uptons inside the park (or whatever that was) in the 8th to come from behind.
Thankfully the awful AAA Twins OF chose to dive for the liner which was clearly the wrong decision. Then they booted it around.

We seemed to be chipping back in the game 5-3 but Gibby in his infinite wisdom puts Schultz out there to extend the Twins lead back to 4.

We need to sweep those Twins.
 
Anyone have the number of quality starts since we went to 6 man rotation? I seem to recall 3-4 starts.
 
Anyone have the number of quality starts since we went to 6 man rotation? I seem to recall 3-4 starts.
I'd be more inclined to go by their won-loss record in that span as opposed to quality starts. That is the most important stat.