Costanza, you are really great with numbers, please explain to us how Happ cannot be an all-star with the stats he's put up with this season please??!
Well AK, thank you for the sincere compliment.
I can offer an explanation, it's worth what you're paying to read it, but there's a certain amount of logic/sense to it.
There are a limited number of All Star roster spots, 34 per league.
Every team must be represented.
The Toronto Blue Jays are 1 of 15 teams in the A.L. (6.66% of the league).
With the active all stars they had this year (look below), they had 4 of 34 spots, (11.76% of the players).
Which player, from what team, do you drop, in order to include J. A. Happ?
Marco Estrada (D.L.), Aaron Sanchez (as a replacement), Michael Saunders, Edwin Encarnacion & Josh Donaldson are Blue Jays already named to the team.
In short, the All Star game is not a representation of the 34 best players in each league, as there has to be a rep from each team, a participation ribbon, if you will.
The N.H.L. mid-season All Star game is set up much the same way.
J. A. Happ is having a terrific season, don't be blinded by wins though.
As has been discussed in the past, wins are a very misleading statistic as to the value of a starting pitcher.
I haven't looked recently, but I believe both Aaron Sanchez & Marco Estrada have better underlying numbers.