Blue Jays: 2016 Edition

Stroman should absolutely be in the starting rotation, of course, but not as the ace. That should still be Dickey.

Stro has never pitched a full season. He's never thrown north of 200 innings. You can't throw him into the deep end, expect him to go the full season and win the WS.

Stro should be the #2 starter with a few games off here and there when a gap in the schedule allows.
 
lets assume Stroman averages 7 or more innings a start. If he starts 30 games that's 210 innings. However, if he pitches in turn throughout the season, he would start 33 games...so now you are pushing over 230 innings for a guy who has not pitched a full season. You have to find spots to give him a break and you cant push him every 5 days. Estrada is now supposed to start in game 7 (irony), but would probably be ready to pitch the home opener 2 days earlier and you get the rotation as suggested by butler.

The other solution is to use the Royals method and go to the bullpen in the seventh, and starters are only expected to go 6 innings. So do you pull Stroman or Sanchez when they are throwing zeros?
 
I have heard nothing at all re: talks with EE. Anybody have any updates. Today is Wed and he will stop negotiating once the season starts on Sunday.
 
With Floyd and Chavez in the bullpen and Hutchison in Buffalo there are plenty of opportunities to give Stro and Sanchez days off during the season to keep them fresh and strong...

At least, in theory!

Perry
 
I have heard nothing at all re: talks with EE. Anybody have any updates. Today is Wed and he will stop negotiating once the season starts on Sunday.

I am with the management here if they decided to give the current roster a last shot of the WS. Jays are out of it at the trade deadline they might get late draft picks or anything for JB&EE.
 
I am with the management here if they decided to give the current roster a last shot of the WS. Jays are out of it at the trade deadline they might get late draft picks or anything for JB&EE.
Thanks for your opinion. I asked if anybody had any updates on discussions.
 
We are 5th favourite to win the WS this year:

http://www.oddsshark.com/mlb/mlb-odds-world-series-futures

Chicago Cubs +400
San Francisco Giants +800
New York Mets +1100
Los Angeles Dodgers +1100
Toronto Blue Jays +1400
Boston Red Sox +1400
Kansas City Royals +1400
Washington Nationals +1600
Houston Astros +1600
St. Louis Cardinals +1800
Pittsburgh Pirates +2000
Detroit Tigers +2000
Cleveland Indians +2000
Texas Rangers +2200
New York Yankees +2500
Arizona Diamondbacks +2500
Chicago White Sox +3300
Seattle Mariners +4000
Los Angeles Angels +4000
Baltimore Orioles +4000
Tampa Bay Rays +4000
Minnesota Twins +5000
Miami Marlins +5000
Oakland Athletics +7500
San Diego Padres +10000
Milwaukee Brewers +12500
Cincinnati Reds +12500
Philadelphia Phillies +15000
Atlanta Braves +15000
Colorado Rockies +15000
 
I think they should limit Sanchez to 28 starts during the season this year by skipping his turn in the rotation 3 or 4 times, then keep him going in the playoffs till his arm falls off.
Sanchez has the potential to compete for a Cy Young award over the next 5 years and be the ace of this staff and be a Roy Halladay or Dave Steib like impact pitcher.

As for the other starters, they'll need to skip Stroman's turn a couple of times too because he has innings issues too.
Estrada looks like solid number 3, Dickey number 4 and Happ number 5.
Dickey I picture as a reliable number 4 pitcher who can give you a 4.15 era or so during the season and pitch 200 innings. He has an overall ERA of about 3.94 or so during his 3 seasons in Toronto and I would expect some decline since he's 41 years old now and you never know when older players are just going to suddenly completely lose it,

I hope Happ can retain what pitching coach Ray Searage down in Pittsburg taught him to clean up his delivery.
That Searage has a magic touch since he's turned around a lot of arms who had limited success with other organizations.
 
I have no idea considering how messed up the Dodgers are right now how they can be that high on the list.

And I think the Cubs may have starter issues this year. Call it a hunch.....
 
Jon Heyman said it is believed that Jose Bautista would accept a 4 year 120 million dollar extension from the Blue Jays.

Even if the Jays had a big budget for players I don't think it makes sense to keep both Encarnacion and Bautista long term though because Bautista has declined significantly as an outfielder over the past couple of years.
According to Fangraphs he's now a below average defensive outfielder and it's not surprising because a lot of balls sailing out to him lately have turned into awkward wild west adventures whereas 3 or 4 years ago he was always so smooth and effortless and fluid out there.

That means he needs to get transitioned into a DH relatively soon and what can you do with two older veteran guys on the team like Bautista and Encarnacion who can both mash it but only play DH.
On a side note I wonder how it is that the Red Sox always seem to have David Ortiz on 1 or 2 year contract extensions for the past 6 years; but, the Blue Jays need to make a really long term commitment to Bautista. It would be more convenient if Bautista thought the same way as Ortiz.

Personally, I expect both Bautista and Encarnacion to be gone next season; so, the Jays really need to make this year count because the wind won't be on their backs nearly as much in 2017.
 
Jon Heyman said it is believed that Jose Bautista would accept a 4 year 120 million dollar extension from the Blue Jays.
Hey, the guy is good. He knows it and he flaunts it, which is OK with me.

But I think success may have gone to his head... 4@120 is fucking crazy, of course he would take it! But 3@80 (maybe with a club option for a 4th) and it's probably a deal and he retires a BJ.

But I agree with you. Unless the BJ's make it to the WS and, preferably, win it, I don't think either will be back. The BJ's will get 2 draft picks and reorganize around Donaldson, Tulo, Travis, Martin, Colabello, Saunders, Pillar, Smoak and one big bat to replace JB and EE.

It will be interesting to see how it plays out and if either or both of them have really great years... it could make for one beautiful mess! :D

Let's hope they win it all!

Perry
 
I really hope Smoak learned how to hit the curveball this spring training
 
JB had a poor dWAR last year cuz he wrenched his shoulder against the O's after they threw at him after his HR. I think he led MLB in total OF assists over the previous 5-6 years. He threw side arm for most of last season and only threw out runners by end of season. He's lost a step but I predict he will have a positive dWAR if healthy.
 
Last edited:
I am with the management here if they decided to give the current roster a last shot of the WS. Jays are out of it at the trade deadline they might get late draft picks or anything for JB&EE.

Non action says volumes. Shapiro wants JB and EE playing for their contracts which in turn gives the Jays the best chance at winning, which in turns gets Rogers the most revenue, which in turn gives them the best chance at signing one of them.

IMHO they won't sign either.