Blue Jays 2010

Thank goodness, he is not Brian Burke. He took a bad team and made it worse.

You mean Brian Colangelo. I have no problem with Burke. He's put the Leafs on the right path after having to correct all the screw-ups committed by John Ferguson Jr. & Cliff Fletcher, who made as much damage as JF in less than a year. The Leafs now have the most solid organizational structure since the days of Conn Smyth. I'm currently reading Al Strachan's book on the Leafs & the chapters on Harold Ballard have caused me to have nightmares!

Anyways, i like the way Alex Anthopoulos has been managing the Jays. All of his decisions have been scrutinized extensively & he remains calm. He doesn't have the knack to put his foot in his mouth like his predecessor & he's slowly gaining respect all over the league, not just with fellow GMs, but with the ballplayers also. His sound management skills alone might eventually cause other free agents to want to come & play for him in Toronto in the future.
 
Gotta give Ricciardi some credit for the currently improving the Jays via two acquisitions.

Bautista and Anthopoulos.
 
JP was not too bad IMO. He did screw up some contracts like BJ Ryan and Lyle Overpaid but he did some good things as well. He drafted Ricky Romero, and put together most of our starters right now...(Marcum, Cecil, Litsch etc). Adam Lind, Travis Snider, Bautista and Hill are all JP's doings. Lets just hope that AA takes it to another level and brings some winning to town.
 
Seeing as I started this thread, it's a good bet that I've been following the team very closely.

But you never did answer the question as to whether you were sarcastic when you said that it was a good thing Snider is back because they need his power.
 
As to spending like the Yankees? Never gonna happen, until there's a hard salary cap in baseball. The Yankees make more on their local TV rights than almost every team makes from every revenue source combined. The Jays are NOT in the same league.

The Yankees can spend $220 mil on payroll and still show a profit of 20 mil at the end of the fiscal year.
If the Jays spent $220 million on payroll they would probably lose about 100 million a year.

I would like to see the Yankees rotate to the Central division every 10 years. 10 years in Central and then 10 years in East and keep rotating.
With no salary cap their presence is a real burden on other teams in the division because payroll dictates they will make the playoffs 90% of the time.

Either that or make it a balanced schedule so that teams in Central and West can't play a creampuff schedule and then grab the wildcard on the basis of being able to play a soft schedule.

In the NFL they have a rating system to rank strength of scheduled games.
If you have to play a lot of good teams the strength of schedule would be 110 say. If you are lucky and have a bunch of losing teams on your schedule the strength of schedule would be rated at 92 say.

In the AL East every year the strength of schedule is about 110 and you also need to win 96 games to have a chance to make the playoffs most years.
In the other divisions the strength of schedule is only about 92 for the teams and some years you only need to win 88 or 90 games to win your division.

So, teams in the other 2 AL divisions have got it made relative to AL East. They get to play a soft schedule and they don't need to win as many games to get into the playoffs either.
 
make it a balanced schedule so that teams in Central and West can't play a creampuff schedule and then grab the wildcard on the basis of being able to play a soft schedule. In the AL East every year the strength of schedule is about 110 and you also need to win 96 games to have a chance to make the playoffs most years.
In the other divisions the strength of schedule is only about 92 for the teams and some years you only need to win 88 or 90 games to win your division.

So, teams in the other 2 AL divisions have got it made relative to AL East. They get to play a soft schedule and they don't need to win as many games to get into the playoffs either.

I really like your idea(s). However, the Yankees & Red Sox don't really care about changing anything, and i doubt that as long as these two powerhouses aren't getting on with the plan, i doubt MLB will.
 
But you never did answer the question as to whether you were sarcastic when you said that it was a good thing Snider is back because they need his power.

Yes, I was.

Sometimes sarcasm is harder to pick up when it is written as opposed to being verbalised.
 
Either that or make it a balanced schedule so that teams in Central and West can't play a creampuff schedule and then grab the wildcard on the basis of being able to play a soft schedule.
So, teams in the other 2 AL divisions have got it made relative to AL East. They get to play a soft schedule and they don't need to win as many games to get into the playoffs either.


A.L. Wild Card Winners:

1995 New York Yankees
1996 Baltimore Orioles
1997 New York Yankees
1998 Boston Red Sox
1999 Boston Red Sox
2000 Seattle Mariners
2001 Cleveland Indians
2002 Anaheim Angels
2003 Boston Red Sox
2004 Boston Red Sox
2005 Boston Red Sox
2006 Detroit Tigers
2007 New York Yankees
2008 Boston Red Sox
2009 Boston Red Sox

Fifteen years of the Wild Card, and 11 times ( 73.33 % ) the Wild Card team has come out of the East Division.

What's that you were saying about the Central and West Divisions having it easy, and sneaking into the playoffs through the Wild Card spot ?

That being said, a relatively balanced schedule would be a good thing.
 
Last edited:
I think he misspoke. They snuck into the playoffs BY WINNING WEAK DIVISIONS, while better teams in the East couldn't even get the wildcard.
It's a stone cold fact that the West and Central have it easy.

Would you care to document that statement with some statistics, Fonzi, or should we accept your random comment as a stone cold fact ?

For instance, you could show us the West Division record vs the East Division, and the Central Division record vs the East Division, and the Central vs West for each of the past 15 seasons. That information would allow us to see accurately which division was stronger in each year.
 
How about the fact that the AL East more often than not has the best overall record in the AL, if not both leagues.

Case in point, this year.

AL East--34 games over .500
AL Central--8 games under
AL West--10 games under

NL East--12 over
NL Central--44 under
NL West--16 over

Is that stone cold enough for you george?
 
How about the fact that the AL East more often than not has the best overall record in the AL, if not both leagues.

Case in point, this year.

AL East--34 games over .500
AL Central--8 games under
AL West--10 games under

NL East--12 over
NL Central--44 under
NL West--16 over

Is that stone cold enough for you george?

No, Eddie, it's not.

How many of those wins are against other Eastern teams, and how many against teams from the other divisions ?

It's not that hard to pull up the statistics, and doesn't take much time.

I've gone to mlb.com and indeed the A.L. East is stronger vs the other two divisions this year. They only have statistics back to the 2001 season, so I'll check out the records for the past 9 years when I have just a little more time.

I'm not arguing that the A.L.E. isn't the strongest division, I'd just like to see some facts that back that up, not just random statements.
 
I'd be happy to, but I really just don't have the time.
Go back over the last ten years, and you'll see that the records of those other two divisions against the AL East is PATHETIC. Well, the Central is pathetic. The West is mediocre at best. TERRIBLE vs. the Red Sox and Yankees, the two teams we have to perennially compete with - and the crux of the problem.
Like it is this year.

Seriously, wtf?!? Anyone who thinks that Boston and New York haven't been about the best two teams in baseball running for the last decade isn't paying any attention. And if you think payroll has nothing to do with it, you're a moron. THAT'S a stone cold fact.

Fonzi, I'm not a moron, and there's really no need to launch personal attacks.

The following information took me about 8 minutes to gather, not really that much time, to be able to prove or disprove what you stated.

Records by division

2001

W vs E 109-63 .626
W vs C 99-73 .576
C vs E 81-87 .482

2002

W vs E 101-71 .587
W vs C 102-69 .596
C vs E 73-95 .435

2003

W vs E 83-89 .482
W vs C 104-68 .605
C vs E 73-95 .435

2004

W vs E 86-86 .500
W vs C 97-75 .574
C vs E 76-92 .452

2005

W vs E 77-101 .433
W vs C 101-73 .580
C vs E 89-83 .517

2006

W vs E 102-74 .591
W vs C 88-84 .512
C vs E 86-86 .500

2007

W vs E 92-84 .523
W vs C 83-91 .477
C vs E 85-101 .457

2008

W vs E 85-94 .457
W vs C 84-91 .480
C vs E 77-109 .414

2009

W vs E 95-79 .546
W vs C 96-80 .552
C vs E 76-110 .409

The 2010 season is not completed, and the results would be skewed, so, we'll look at the number from the past 9 complete seasons.

A quick glance will tell us that the Central is the weak sister of the 3 divisions in the American League.

*more to follow shortly :D
 
How about we cut to the chase, huh? You can't make the playoffs if you don't finish first or second - the whole division is somewhat meaningless.


The facts will show you, back to 2001, that the East has been the strongest division, with the West close behind, and the Central very distant. But, if you look at the performances from the best teams in those divisions, it isn't close.

Changing the rules midstream, are we, Fonzerelli ?

I could have just looked at the records of the top 2 teams in each division, that would have been easier, but, I'll go back and do it, just to show you.

Here are the facts, going back to 2001:

The A.L. West has a cumulative record of 830-741 ( .535 ) vs the A.L. East.
The A.L. West has a cumulative record of 854-704 ( .548 ) vs the A.L. Central
The A.L. East has a cumulative record of 868-716 ( .548 ) vs the A.L. Central

Total record outside their own divisions

A.L. West 1684-1445 .538
A.L East 1609-1546 .510
A.L. Central 1420-1722 .452

It would seem from these numbers that the American League West division is the strongest of the 3 divisions from 2001-2009.


Those
are Stone Cold Facts (whatever that means) .
 
How about we cut to the chase, huh? You can't make the playoffs if you don't finish first or second - the whole division is somewhat meaningless.
Here are the winning percentages of the top two teams in the AL divisions going back to 2002:

(2010: East - .632, .623; Central - .566, .551; West - .575, .500)
2009: East - .636, .586; Central - .534, .528; West - .599, .537
2008: East - .599, .586; Central - .546, .540; West - .617, .488
2007: East - .593, .580; Central - .593, .543; West - .580, .543
2006: East - .599, .537; Central - .593, .586; West - .574, .549
2005: East - .586, .586; Central - .611, .574; West - .586, .543
2004: East - .623, .605; Central - .568, .512; West - .568, .562
2003: East - .623, .586; Central - .556, .532; West - .593, .574
2002: East - .640, .574; Central - .584, .500; West - .636, .611
MEAN: East - .612, .580; Central - .573, .539; West - .594, .551

In six of those eight years, the East won the wildcard - the Central took one, the West one. In only four of those years would the Central WINNER have finished second or higher in the East.

Please tell me how those STONE COLD NUMBERS don't show that the East is consistently the hardest AL (MLB, if you wanna run the numbers yourself) division to make the playoffs.

The facts will show you, back to 2001, that the East has been the strongest division, with the West close behind, and the Central very distant. But, if you look at the performances from the best teams in those divisions, it isn't close.


So, in short, you're saying that the top 2 teams in the A.L. East are stronger than the top 2 teams in the other two divisions, year over year, right ?

Here are the records of the top 2 teams in each division (against teams from other divisions), same format as noted above, for the years 2001-2009

W vs E

64-26
51-35
46-26
48-38
40-49
55-34
51-37
47-46
53-39

455-338 .574

W vs C

58-28
62-24
57-33
55-31
55-32
48-39
44-41
46-39
48-38

473-305 .608

E vs C

39-33
48-24
48-21
39-25
40-26
41-29
52-24
44-28
51-19

402-229 .637

E vs W

27-37
35-29
37-31
44-28
47-27
35-35
35-33
44-28
36-36

340-284 .545

C vs E

35-33
33-31
38-30
35-33
39-30
38-30
38-33
28-48
25-43

309-311 .498

C vs W

31-37
34-38
33-35
35-33
34-36
36-33
39-34
36-32
41-35

319-316 .502

Again, we can easily see that the even the top teams in the A.L. Central are weak against teams from outside their division.

The top 2 teams from the West Division have a cumulative record against team from the other two divisions of 928-643 .555

The top 2 teams from the East Division have a cumulative record against teams from the other two divisions of 742-513 .591

The top 2 teams from the Central Division have a cumulative record against teams from the other two divisions of 628-627 .5003

A .555 winning percentage = 89.91 (let's say 90 wins)
A .591 winning percentage = 95.74 (let's say 96 wins)

That would seem to indicate that the average Top Two teams in the East Division are 6 wins better than the average Top Two team in the West Division.

However, if you look at the record of the West Division Top Two vs East Division teams, they have a .574 W.P. vs teams from the East, and East Division Top Two vs West Division teams have a .545 W.P. vs teams from the West.

Aren't numbers fun ?

Conclusions:

The American League Central Division is the weakest of the 3 divisions.

Depending how you look at the numbers, an argument could be made for EITHER the East OR the West Division being the strongest in the league.

It is hardly cut & dried that the A.L. East is superior, and a reasonable person could say that the A.L. West is the stronger of the two divisions, and be comfortable in that decision.
 
Last edited:
The West & East are very similar in talent levels.

To stone cold :rolleyes: state otherwise is disingenous.
 
Independent of the wild card the main question is what do you need to do to get out of your conference alive.
From 2002 to 2009 the AL Divison winners have averaged:

East: 99.14 wins
Central: 92.8 wins
West: 96.22 wins

So to survive in the East you need to win 2.92 more games than a typical Western division champ earns and 6.34 more games than a typical Central division champion earns. So, barriers to playoff entry are highest in Eastern Division.

Since re alignment in 1995 the East has won the wild card 11 times, the West 2 times and the Central 2 times.


Looking at recent World Series Champions from 1992 to present (17 years)
Teams currently in the AL Eastern Divison have won it 9 times,
Teams currently in the AL Western Division have won once,
Teams currently in the AL Central Division have won it once.

NL teams have won it 6 times.

These stats seem to indicate that in recent years the AL Western division is not equal in talent to the AL Eastern division.
 
Independent of the wild card the main question is what do you need to do to get out of your conference alive.
From 2002 to 2009 the AL Divison winners have averaged:

East: 99.14 wins
Central: 92.8 wins
West: 96.22 wins

So to survive in the East you need to win 2.92 more games than a typical Western division champ earns and 6.34 more games than a typical Central division champion earns. So, barriers to playoff entry are highest in Eastern Division.

Since re alignment in 1995 the East has won the wild card 11 times, the West 2 times and the Central 2 times.


Looking at recent World Series Champions from 1992 to present (17 years)
Teams currently in the AL Eastern Divison have won it 9 times,
Teams currently in the AL Western Division have won once,
Teams currently in the AL Central Division have won it once.

NL teams have won it 6 times.

These stats seem to indicate that in recent years the AL Western division is not equal in talent to the AL Eastern division.

K.T., where were those extra wins generated, within the division (dominating the bottom feeders), or externally, against the other 2 divisions in the league ?
 
K.T., where were those extra wins generated, within the division (dominating the bottom feeders), or externally, against the other 2 divisions in the league ?

That's an interesting question. To get completely meaningful numbers you need a balanced shedule.

Even if there was such a thing as Star Trek transporter technology where it took people 3 seconds to travel to any place on the globe making geography irrelevant, I don't think Western or Central teams would want a balanced schedule because it would reduce their chances of winning the wild card.

Moreover I don't think Oakland or Seattle or Minnesota or Cleveland would jump at the chance to switch division places with the Blue Jays if the commisioner gave them the opportunity to do so.
 
K.T., thank you for your courteous, thoughtful response.
I have no real dog in this fight, I just would like to know what the facts are.
I am a Blue Jays fan, and I'd like to see them in the playoffs more often, obviously.

I think, from the numbers that have been presented, that while the East may have a small numerical advantage, it could reasonably be argued that the West division is relatively equal to them.

I think we're all agreed that the Central sucks moose cock.

Personally, I don't want the Blue Jays to switch divisions. If you're going to be the best, you've got to beat the best.

As I noted earlier in the thread, a more balanced schedule is the only fair way to see the best teams make it the playoffs.
 
Personally, I don't want the Blue Jays to switch divisions. If you're going to be the best, you've got to beat the best.

Yea, there's something to be said for staying in the East and competing against the top teams there. Besides that, teams that survive the East seem to do better in playoffs than other teams.
Baseball lends itself to some great debates.

I would like to see Tampa Bay win the World Series this year.
They just promoted Jeremy Hellickson from triple A and he looks like he's going to be a really good pitcher.
http://web.minorleaguebaseball.com/milb/stats/stats.jsp?pos=P&sid=milb&t=p_pbp&pid=476451