Blu-ray Versus HD DVD

Powershot said:
The Venturer (HDA3) and RCA (HDA1 IIRC) players are just rebadged Toshibas.

I would think the Venturer would be alot cheaper quality than a Toshiba or RCA.
 
The Bandit said:
I would think the Venturer would be alot cheaper quality than a Toshiba or RCA.

Powershot was right, those are just rebadged Toshibas.

I have the RCA HDV5000 myself, it is exactly as same as the Toshiba HD-A1. Made in Japan too. :D

Both the RCA and the Venturer can be updated by using the Toshiba firmware update discs.

BTW, I have the PS3 too so I'm format neutral.
 
Powershot said:
The Venturer (HDA3) and RCA (HDA1 IIRC) players are just rebadged Toshibas.

I got no problem with that if China wants to manufac. quality brands under their own label and sell them cheaper! Makes the risk of getting a useless brick lower.
 
cypherpunk said:
I'm sure HD can bring some good things to porn, but not without making things like razor burn and make up lines noticable. I have some 720p porn and it's not all that special, so just upping the resolution isn't going to do much.

As for Blu-ray, it's worth noting that there was a rumor a year ago that porn was banned on the format. The specifics of that aren't clear, but what's clear now is that it's not true. There is certainly more porn available on HD-DVD, but that's because it's cheaper.

The story I read somewhere is that Sony refuses to sell the equipment necessary for manufacturing blu-ray disks to anyone in the adult film industry. Sony doesn’t want to directly do business with the porn industry. I’m not sure if that’s a good decision or not.
There’s nothing stopping a 3rd party from reselling the equipment or producing the disks for the porn industry.

I heard that the porn industry took it as a snub and has decided to go HD-DVD. The rationale is that if we’re not good enough for you, you’re not good enough for us, kinda thing.

That decision may hurt Sony in the long run cuz the porn industry is huge and could tip the balance in the format war.

I’d love to see some HD porn. I’m not sure if I’m ready to see every little mole, freckle and bead of sweat on my fav porn star, :p but I think it’ll be cool.

I think I’m going to make the plunge after Christmas and buy myself an HD-DVD player.
 
Cinema Face said:
I’d love to see some HD porn. I’m not sure if I’m ready to see every little mole, freckle and bead of sweat on my fav porn star, :p but I think it’ll be cool.

I think I’m going to make the plunge after Christmas and buy myself an HD-DVD player.

with so many freakin' good deals on now, no need to wait!
 
Cinema Face said:
The story I read somewhere is that Sony refuses to sell the equipment necessary for manufacturing blu-ray disks to anyone in the adult film industry. Sony doesn’t want to directly do business with the porn industry. I’m not sure if that’s a good decision or not.
There’s nothing stopping a 3rd party from reselling the equipment or producing the disks for the porn industry.

The software is available for retail. The hardware costs millions and millions of dollars and requires a clean room environment and only a handful of companies have made the investment, hence the higher price of manufacturing. I'm not aware of any content producer, except Sony, that does its own disc pressing. Whatever you've read is wrong and outright crazy.
 
Decision Catalyst in the Blu-Ray vs. HD-DVD war

http://www.reghardware.co.uk/2007/12/21/blu_ray_vs_hd_dvd_price_war/

Plunging player prices to reveal Blu-ray vs HD DVD winner?
By Tony Smith
21st December 2007 13:02 GMT


A clear leader in the battle to be the top next-generation optical disc format could emerge next year as player prices plummet and take of the cost of entry out of the equation, market watcher Understanding & Solutions (U&S) has claimed.

While consumers remain confused about whether to back HD DVD or Blu-ray Disc, the high cost of players has allowed them to step back from the debate. However, falling prices have brought both technologies within reach of a greater number of consumers, paving the way for a more unequivocal choice of format - what U&S calls "format clarity".

“Blu-ray and HD DVD player prices have been falling since the Summer, culminating in Toshiba’s loss leading sub-$100 HD DVD player, available in the US last month for a limited time,” said U&S consultant Jeremy Wills.

“Price reductions in the US have continued into December, with Blu-ray players dropping below $300 for the first time, and HD DVD players below $200."

Further reductions are on the cards, said U&S senior consultant Bill Foster. "In early 2008 we’re going to see the Bill of Materials for a basic High Definition player, in either format, weighing in at less than $150, and that’s going to impact the High Street very soon, providing the consumer with a choice of low price players that allow CE companies a margin for profit.”

Buyers in Europe are going to have to wait a little longer for a wide choice of cheap hi-def players, but U&S said it reckons average player prices - as opposed to entry-level model pricing - for HD DVD and Blu-ray of $275 (£138/€192) and $475 (£239/€331), respectively.

Assuming neither format drops out of the race, by 2011, HD DVD and Blu-ray players will both retail for less that $100 (£50/€70), U&S forecast.

“As demand grows and manufacturing volumes build, we’re going to see the costs of releasing on two different formats really start to bite," said Foster.

"There may be surprises just around the corner.” ®
 
cypherpunk said:
I'm sure HD can bring some good things to porn, but not without making things like razor burn and make up lines noticable. I have some 720p porn and it's not all that special, so just upping the resolution isn't going to do much.

As for Blu-ray, it's worth noting that there was a rumor a year ago that porn was banned on the format. The specifics of that aren't clear, but what's clear now is that it's not true. There is certainly more porn available on HD-DVD, but that's because it's cheaper.


Besides, most porn content is already web-based so HD-DVD will be a small factor in sales, as sales for DVD have already peaked.
 
Why I think Blue Ray will lose the Battle
It is not the Quality of the format it is how friendly it is to the consumer and who systems can record without complications

Every format that Sony exclusively created has lost in that past
Betamax, MidiDisc, and super 8

* Even though beta was the better system they lost due to greed. Sony wanted Royalties on every beta machine sold under other brand names VHS did not.
* Mini Disc was a Great system covered like a floppy disc it would not scratch up like a CD disc would especially used in a car and smaller for portable players.
* Super 8 and Super 8 digital held on for a while but were replaced shortly by smaller formats.

Blue Ray is not backwards compatible were most HD DVD disc I have rented can flip over and play on a standard DVD player, NICE! A format that has the consumers best interests in mind not just exclusive royalties and profitability. Looking at the specs and watching both I would say the Quality was the same but even if Blue ray was better HD DVD is more consumer friendly and win on that basis .
Oh and by the way the time it takes a blue ray disc to load is unacceptable.
 
What ever happened to LaserDisc's?

Was Sony behind that cause it was no match for the DVD disc.

I remember owning a MiniDisc when it was first popular before 2000.
 
Are you talking about the 12" laserDisc's? LOL

Edifice said:
What ever happened to LaserDisc's?

Was Sony behind that cause it was no match for the DVD disc.

I remember owning a MiniDisc when it was first popular before 2000.


I somehow think Pioneer was behind the 12"LD format but not too sure.
They may have lost the race when they used DEVO to promote it

Philips was behind the DVD ,Compact Cassette ,Cd, and they stuck around
 
Robio1971 said:
Why I think Blue Ray will lose the Battle
It is not the Quality of the format it is how friendly it is to the consumer and who systems can record without complications

Every format that Sony exclusively created has lost in that past
Betamax, MidiDisc, and super 8

* Even though beta was the better system they lost due to greed. Sony wanted Royalties on every beta machine sold under other brand names VHS did not.
* Mini Disc was a Great system covered like a floppy disc it would not scratch up like a CD disc would especially used in a car and smaller for portable players.
* Super 8 and Super 8 digital held on for a while but were replaced shortly by smaller formats.

Blue Ray is not backwards compatible were most HD DVD disc I have rented can flip over and play on a standard DVD player, NICE! A format that has the consumers best interests in mind not just exclusive royalties and profitability. Looking at the specs and watching both I would say the Quality was the same but even if Blue ray was better HD DVD is more consumer friendly and win on that basis .
Oh and by the way the time it takes a blue ray disc to load is unacceptable.


Betamax lost due to Sony not wanting to have it's machine showing porn. The porn industry went with VHS and the rest is history.

Why would you want or need to have a HD DVD disc that can play on a regular dvd player?

What is an acceptable loading time? How much longer are you willing to wait for better sound and video?

x
 
This is why one would want to play an HD DVD on a DVD player

xdog said:
Betamax lost due to Sony not wanting to have it's machine showing porn. The porn industry went with VHS and the rest is history.

Why would you want or need to have a HD DVD disc that can play on a regular dvd player?

What is an acceptable loading time? How much longer are you willing to wait for better sound and video?

x

If they made it backwards compatible everyone would not need to run out and buy a new player just to watch a rented movie. With the HD DVD they could just flip it over. This may not sound like a big deal to those of us who are willing and would buy into HD picture quality format but for the higher percentage of people who are still using a VCRs and complaining that they just bought a DVD player because the local video store doesn't even have Video tapes anymore. It is not always about quality either I would watch a low quality format with good content over a high quality production with bogus content
 
Robio said:
If they made it backwards compatible everyone would not need to run out and buy a new player just to watch a rented movie. With the HD DVD they could just flip it over. This may not sound like a big deal to those of us who are willing and would buy into HD picture quality format but for the higher percentage of people who are still using a VCRs and complaining that they just bought a DVD player because the local video store doesn't even have Video tapes anymore. It is not always about quality either I would watch a low quality format with good content over a high quality production with bogus content


If it's not about quality, then why even bother buying an HD-DVD or Blu-ray?

x
 
Blu-Ray outsold HD-DVD 70/30 in 2007, I think the PS3 will tip the balance toward the BR format.

OTB
 
I would want to go HD but...

xdog said:
If it's not about quality, then why even bother buying an HD-DVD or Blu-ray?

x

A large percentage of people are sick of format changes so if they go to a HD format that was backwards compatible every one is being looked after from the person who wants the latest and greatest to the people who are sick of regular format changes.
I have even over herd people to this day say were is the video tape section at Rogers or Blockbusters. Those types of people who just breakdown bought a DVD player would not be happy if they now need to replace it again with blue ray.
 
thundarr said:
Time Warner just annouced it is going with Blu-ray which is the end of HD DVD.

If they made this move based on holiday sales, then I'd say you're right and that Universal should follow suit soon unless they're contractually obligated. A lot can happen in two quarters, but I'm ready to start taking bets.