Blu-ray Versus HD DVD

Anynym said:
Well, sorry, but no. HD DVD is only single layer. Anything based on HD DVD which is multiple layer is, simply, not HD DVD, and won't play in HD DVD players. And there really isn't anybody talking seriously about multi-layer HD DVD (although I'm sure their marketing department would love to confuse the marketplace, as they have clearly confused some consumers). Blu-ray, by contrast, is designed as multi-layer, and although todays equipment is limited, those extensions are very much part of Blu-ray.

HD DVD marketers really don't want anyone to notice that Blu-ray discs have outsold their competition by a ratio of about 3:1 over the past year. Blu-ray marketers don't really want anyone to notice that even with that ratio, just about any single popular movie on DVD has outsold the total of both hi-def formats for all movies over the past year.

Weird, man. Not to get into any heated debate or anything, but your info seems to be at least a year out of date. Multi layer HD-DVDs are HD-DVD (as much as BLuRay supporters would like to ignore them). Here are some links to update your info on the upcoming triple layers:

http://hometheater.about.com/b/a/169684.htm
http://www.hometheatermag.com/news/051105toshiba/
http://www.reghardware.co.uk/2007/09/11/hd_dvd_51gb_approved/
http://www.afterdawn.com/news/archive/7922.cfm
http://www.engadget.com/2006/09/11/toshibas-triple-layer-hd-dvd-dvd-discs/
http://www.physorg.com/news4052.html

Further, double layer HD-DVD BURNERS for computers are even available on the market. Not bad for something you claim to not even exist, huh?

http://www.cdrinfo.com/Sections/News/Details.aspx?NewsId=21740

No doubt, Bluray had the great start but the 3:1 ratio has largely been debunked now and pretty much everyone agrees that HD-DVD has a lot of momentum (which of course, is not determinative of who will win in the end). The Xbox 360 and HALO3, Transformers HD-DVD, Dreamworks (Shrek, Harry Potter movies, etc) going exclusive HD-DVD all show strong movement on the HD-DVD camp. I cant even remember the last big announcement in favour of BLuRay. They havent even been able to get ANY player into the $250 price range for Xmas, which market watchers was predicting as the magic number.

Also, Walmart will be hard pushing HD-DVD this Christmas. In fact , they had a special sale yesterday in US where A2 HD-DVD players were being sold at $98!!!! Best Buy and Circuit City have also moved their prices down as well which will mean a big Christmas push on HD-DVD. Further, K-Mart has apparently decided to drop BLuRay players from its line up due to its costs and go with HD-DVD. A lot of troubling signs if your a BluRay guy.
 
newguy27 said:
Weird, man. Not to get into any heated debate or anything, but your info seems to be at least a year out of date. Multi layer HD-DVDs are HD-DVD (as much as BLuRay supporters would like to ignore them). ... Further, double layer HD-DVD BURNERS for computers are even available on the market. Not bad for something you claim to not even exist, huh?

http://www.cdrinfo.com/Sections/News/Details.aspx?NewsId=21740
Well, I prefer actual facts, myself, from independent and objective third party experts who study such questions, rather than citations which apparently fail to differentiate between READ and WRITE capabilities.

http://arstechnica.com/journals/hardware.ars/2007/10/10/sony-launches-4x-internal-blu-ray-burner
http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20070906-battle-between-blu-ray-and-hd-dvd-fizzles-as-consumers-watch-and-wait.html

Perhaps of most interest to yourself should be the dates of the articles: less than two months ago.

Again, yes, I acknowledge once again that HD-DVD has put more marketing dollars into their format. And that includes loss-leader marketing of various HD DVD players. But as anyone familiar with the technologies will know, there are no inherent long-term cost differences between the two formats: neither laser is more expensive to manufacture than the other. (Although there may be some short-term manufacturing cost advantages for HD DVD, they are in the process used to create the media, not the players.) The fact that some players are cheaper today is more a sign of desperation from some marketers than a sign of technological edge. For those differentiators, you need to look deeper.
 
newguy27 said:
The Xbox 360 and HALO3, Transformers HD-DVD, Dreamworks (Shrek, Harry Potter movies, etc) going exclusive HD-DVD all show strong movement on the HD-DVD camp.

I'm confused, what's this about the 360 and Halo 3 and HD DVD? If you think that Halo 3 is going to drive 360 adoption to the point that the HD DVD add on becomes a major factor, you're delusional. Add ons don't sell well, never have, and probably never will. As for Dreamworks, just a few months ago they were expressing doubt in both HD DVD and Blu-ray. Paramount and its subsidiaries are small enough to turn on a dime when it comes to format choice, so it's not like they're committed to anything long term.

Anyone who has a strong opinion on this is flying blind.
 
newguy27 said:
Also, Walmart will be hard pushing HD-DVD this Christmas. In fact , they had a special sale yesterday in US where A2 HD-DVD players were being sold at $98!!!!

Best Buy and Circuit City have also moved their prices down as well which will mean a big Christmas push on HD-DVD.

True, a friend alerted me on that a couple days ago. I believe it was a Toshiba.

As much as I appreciate 1080P I don't think I'll be jumping on either format until the players reach below 200 loon per unit on average, hi res DVD's become more avilable in terms of titles for rental which I guestimate would take a couple more years at least.

As for which format will win ? Only time will tell IMHO.
 
The current issue of Business Week discusses the current state of the battle between HD-DVD and Blu-Ray, for those who are interested.

In summary, the article suggests that while Warner studios could choose to align with HD-DVD (splitting the DVD market share approximately in half on hi-def alignment, and possibly dooming both formats) or with Blu-Ray (which would give that form a dominating 70% (approx) DVD market share).

Coupling that with the number of devices dedicated to playing HD-DVDs (US, 578 000) versus Blu-Ray (US, 370 000) and entertainment consoles capable of it (HD-DVD: X-Box, 300 000; Blu-Ray: PS3, 2 300 000), the authors give the edge to Blu-Ray.
 
Funny a salesman at a store told me not to buy into it yet until the dust settles. I said how about I buy one of each HD DVD and blue ray. So he showed me how long it took for a blue ray disc to load which seems excessively long but the quality was better then HD DVD but not by much . HD DVD may be the winner here Beta was supposed to be better then VHS but VHS was the winning format. This was recent and I am not sure if all blue rays take so long to load but this one was unacceptable. The salesman was right but ironically lost the sales
 
Anynym said:
Well, I prefer actual facts, myself, from independent and objective third party experts who study such questions, rather than citations which apparently fail to differentiate between READ and WRITE capabilities.

Ummm..you seemed to ignored the point of my post entirely. You said:

"Well, sorry, but no. HD DVD is only single layer. Anything based on HD DVD which is multiple layer is, simply, not HD DVD, and won't play in HD DVD players. And there really isn't anybody talking seriously about multi-layer HD DVD..."

which, as you can appreciate seeing that you claim to prefer actual facts, is simply an outright lie. Duo-layer HD-DVDs seem to be all over the place, which is my point.

Also, while HD-DVD burners have been slow to come to market (hopefully not in a heavy-handed attempt to prevent pirating of movies), there are HD-DVD burners in the Toshiba laptops. Places like Circuit City and Amazon.com are selling them right now...or do you not believe those companies exist?

http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/Tosh...sem/rpsm/oid/185947/rpem/ccd/productDetail.do
http://www.toshibadirect.com/td/b2c/pdet.to?seg=HHO&poid=383406
http://www.amazon.com/Toshiba-G45-A...?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1197427060&sr=8-34
 
newguy27 said:
Also, while HD-DVD burners have been slow to come to market (hopefully not in a heavy-handed attempt to prevent pirating of movies), there are HD-DVD burners in the Toshiba laptops. Places like Circuit City and Amazon.com are selling them right now...or do you not believe those companies exist?

http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/Tosh...sem/rpsm/oid/185947/rpem/ccd/productDetail.do
http://www.toshibadirect.com/td/b2c/pdet.to?seg=HHO&poid=383406
http://www.amazon.com/Toshiba-G45-A...?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1197427060&sr=8-34

I'm pretty sure he was talking about stand-alone HD-DVD burners, and I'm also pretty sure those don't exist. $3,000 is a little steep for HD-DVD burning, laptop or not. The point is that the availability of (cheap) burners translates to adoption by enthusiasts (not that $450 for a Blu-ray burner is cheap).
 
After buying a DVD player the first year they came out and spending a fortune on it, I told myself I would wait until things settled down in the HD war. That didn't quite happen. I didn't buy a stand alone player right away but bought the Xbox 360 add-on the day it was released. The only reason was the price of $200. Even still, I am taking it easy with my movie purchases only buying my favorite movies. I will not buy a BD player until they reach $200. I won't buy a PS3 as a BD player with the benefit of gaming because it offers me nothing that my Xbox 360 can't do which is to simply put a game in and play. I don't care about it's other functions. Therefore the PS3 just becomes another expensive BD player. I support HD DVD not because I'm a fanboy but because I despise Sony.
 
Anynym said:
The current issue of Business Week discusses the current state of the battle between HD-DVD and Blu-Ray, for those who are interested.

.

Good article. Basically it is saying that Warner is the wild card. If they decide to go Blu-ray, then they will dominate, if they decide to go HD DVD then the market will be split.

This format battle is different than the classic Beta vs VHS because the many movie studios have alligned themselves according to format, splitting the market.

If no clear winner emerges soon, then the best bet would be to buy a player that does both, unless you want to limit yourself to only watching certain studio movies in HD.

I was wondering, why is that only Toshiba makes HD-DVD while all the rest seem to make Blu-ray? Does anyone else make HD-DVD players?

I'm surprised that nobody has mentioned the porn industry. I heard that the adult movie studios have gone HD DVD. I haven't seen any HD content in adult video rental stores yet, but if you go online and shop for high def dvd's, it seems to be mostly HD-DVD.

The porn industry is huge business and it will certainly play a role in driving the technology.
 
Found this on Digital Home:

http://www.digitalhome.ca/forum/showthread.php?t=75974

"Our position hasn’t changed and certainly any comments that were published in the US were not intended to suggest that we had changed our stance. We support both formats and we have not made any decision towards that policy and nor are any such announcements planned or in the pipeline.

"In terms of the short-term scenarios around the Q4 sales results, Warner Brothers are always reviewing our strategies and we can’t say what might happen in five or ten years, but for now, there’s been no decision made to change course."

If this is true, then it could be some time before we have a clear winner in the format war. :(
 
Guys ... I got this one. Blu-ray is here to stay. It may not be in the immediate present but it is absolutely the future. Aside from the PS 3 .. Here's why.

How did dvds get so popular ?? Pirating right?? .. millions and millions of people pirate/copy movies and put them on blank dvds. There are ways to pirate/copy PS3 games and Blu-ray movies. This creates demand for the blank media and hardware. Eventually the price drops for both these key ingredients because of the demand and leads to market domination. Production costs decrease too because the raw materials can be purchased in larger quantities.

The technology to copy-protect is there .. ever wonder why they have not integrated it in the hardware ?? This is why they will win the war. HD-DVD will not be able to compete simply due to ecomomies of scale once BR hits mass production levels. There isn't even an HD-DVD burner on the market. They are way too far behind.
 
Last edited:
Cinema Face said:
Good article. ...
Always nice to see that someone has taken the time to read the third-party information which has been contributed.
 
Cinema Face said:
I was wondering, why is that only Toshiba makes HD-DVD while all the rest seem to make Blu-ray? Does anyone else make HD-DVD players?

I'm surprised that nobody has mentioned the porn industry. I heard that the adult movie studios have gone HD DVD. I haven't seen any HD content in adult video rental stores yet, but if you go online and shop for high def dvd's, it seems to be mostly HD-DVD.

The porn industry is huge business and it will certainly play a role in driving the technology.

I've seen the porn HD-DVDs around already for rent...curious to see how one might look on the big screen in high def. Haven't heard of a Bluray porn dvd...not sure if there are any.

As for Toshiba, they certainly bore the brunt of the player market for HD-DVD, but RCA has at least one out too. The big news on that front is that Chinese Venturer HD-DVD players are now for sale at Wal-Mart, who is pushing HD-DVD this entire holiday season. When the Chinese manufacturing plants get behind something, it's usually a good sign that there will be a strong market push.

As for the other post about pirating...i agree it can have a big impact but im not sure which way it will go. Rumours are that HD-DVD burners are slow to market maybe because to prevent pirating of disks, which they only need to do long enough to convince more movie studios to join their side in fear of BLuray already being pirated en mass. This will be quite a battle for sure.

I hope the LG players come down in price fast so no one is caught on the losing side in the end.
 
newguy27 said:
I've seen the porn HD-DVDs around already for rent...curious to see how one might look on the big screen in high def. Haven't heard of a Bluray porn dvd...not sure if there are any.
.


Where did you see them?
 
newguy27 said:
I've seen the porn HD-DVDs around already for rent...curious to see how one might look on the big screen in high def. Haven't heard of a Bluray porn dvd...not sure if there are any.

I'm sure HD can bring some good things to porn, but not without making things like razor burn and make up lines noticable. I have some 720p porn and it's not all that special, so just upping the resolution isn't going to do much.

As for Blu-ray, it's worth noting that there was a rumor a year ago that porn was banned on the format. The specifics of that aren't clear, but what's clear now is that it's not true. There is certainly more porn available on HD-DVD, but that's because it's cheaper.