Since there`s a lot of NFL fans on this board, I`m curious who you guys would rate as the best and worst coaches. My picks are:
Best:
1. Bill Belichick: Is there any doubt? While I don`t think New England will repeat this season, what he`s accomplished over the last 4 years has been one of the greatest coaching feats in sports history.
2. Bill Cowher: Maybe this is the Steeler fan bias in me, but under him they rarely take bad penalties (i.e. false starts, unnecessary pass interference) and seem to have more success with trick plays than any other team. When Ben R. stepped in, Cowher and Whisenhunt adjusted offensive strategy perfectlyy to maximize his strengths and minimze his weaknesses.
3. Bill Parcells: Makes the list based on his resume, but his recent insistence on going with washed-up QBs is puzzling.
4. Herman Edwards: The Jets have made the playoffs 3 of the last 4 years; it`s not because of their talent
5. John Fox: Grossly underrated. Not sure what he has to do to get respect.
6. Marvin Lewis
7. Jeff Fisher
8. Brian Billick
9. Andy Reid
10. Jon Gruden
Since it`s more fun to make fun of people, my choices for the Dave Wannstedt Award as the NFLs worst coaches are:
1. Mike Martz: Complete moron
2. Mike Holmgren: Was he riding on Favre`s coattails in GB?
3. Norv Turner: What did he accomplish to justify his reputation ?
4. Steve Mariucci: Ditto.
5. Mike Tice: Honeymoon is over.
Best:
1. Bill Belichick: Is there any doubt? While I don`t think New England will repeat this season, what he`s accomplished over the last 4 years has been one of the greatest coaching feats in sports history.
2. Bill Cowher: Maybe this is the Steeler fan bias in me, but under him they rarely take bad penalties (i.e. false starts, unnecessary pass interference) and seem to have more success with trick plays than any other team. When Ben R. stepped in, Cowher and Whisenhunt adjusted offensive strategy perfectlyy to maximize his strengths and minimze his weaknesses.
3. Bill Parcells: Makes the list based on his resume, but his recent insistence on going with washed-up QBs is puzzling.
4. Herman Edwards: The Jets have made the playoffs 3 of the last 4 years; it`s not because of their talent
5. John Fox: Grossly underrated. Not sure what he has to do to get respect.
6. Marvin Lewis
7. Jeff Fisher
8. Brian Billick
9. Andy Reid
10. Jon Gruden
Since it`s more fun to make fun of people, my choices for the Dave Wannstedt Award as the NFLs worst coaches are:
1. Mike Martz: Complete moron
2. Mike Holmgren: Was he riding on Favre`s coattails in GB?
3. Norv Turner: What did he accomplish to justify his reputation ?
4. Steve Mariucci: Ditto.
5. Mike Tice: Honeymoon is over.

