Best and Worst NFL Coaches

ottawasub

New member
Mar 20, 2005
795
0
0
Since there`s a lot of NFL fans on this board, I`m curious who you guys would rate as the best and worst coaches. My picks are:

Best:

1. Bill Belichick: Is there any doubt? While I don`t think New England will repeat this season, what he`s accomplished over the last 4 years has been one of the greatest coaching feats in sports history.

2. Bill Cowher: Maybe this is the Steeler fan bias in me, but under him they rarely take bad penalties (i.e. false starts, unnecessary pass interference) and seem to have more success with trick plays than any other team. When Ben R. stepped in, Cowher and Whisenhunt adjusted offensive strategy perfectlyy to maximize his strengths and minimze his weaknesses.

3. Bill Parcells: Makes the list based on his resume, but his recent insistence on going with washed-up QBs is puzzling.

4. Herman Edwards: The Jets have made the playoffs 3 of the last 4 years; it`s not because of their talent

5. John Fox: Grossly underrated. Not sure what he has to do to get respect.

6. Marvin Lewis
7. Jeff Fisher
8. Brian Billick
9. Andy Reid
10. Jon Gruden

Since it`s more fun to make fun of people, my choices for the Dave Wannstedt Award as the NFLs worst coaches are:

1. Mike Martz: Complete moron

2. Mike Holmgren: Was he riding on Favre`s coattails in GB?

3. Norv Turner: What did he accomplish to justify his reputation ?

4. Steve Mariucci: Ditto.

5. Mike Tice: Honeymoon is over.
 
If there's a "former head coach" category, I'd nominate Marty Morningweg, who once won the toss in overtime and took the wind. His offence never got on the field, which is one reason he's a former head coach...
 
I don't know why, but Denny Green is the first that popped up in my mind...


Wannastedt is even sucking as a College coach at Pittsburgh..

Unfortunately, I would also have to elect Joe Gibbs for his coaching last year
 
I'm going to travel back in time a little:

Best coach ever: Chuck Noll
Worst coach ever: Forrest Gregg
Best coach never to win a Superbowl: Bud Grant
Most overrated coach ever: Bill Walsh

Best coach 2005: Bill Cowher
Worst coach 2005: Mike Tice
Best coach 2005 never to win a Superbowl: Tony Dungy
Most overrated coach 2005: Bill Parcells

Oh yeah, put all these guys together into one person and you get:

Vince Lombardi

Just my list (and opinion) :eek:
 
slowandeasy said:
I don't know why, but Denny Green is the first that popped up in my mind...

Wannastedt is even sucking as a College coach at Pittsburgh..

Unfortunately, I would also have to elect Joe Gibbs for his coaching last year

Even with the two fluke plays and a total choke job by the Dallas D, I agree completely with Gibbs. He WAS a great coach but it appears that the game has gone right by him. Portis is the poster boy for the ability for Denver to churn out 1,000 yard backs and nothing more.

Mariucci is definitely the most overrated coach out there. Harrington is being hung out to dry and scapegoated for Mooch's inabilities. If he is such a genius and Joey is that flawed, wouldn't you tailor the offense to what he can do? Also, if you never actually run out of a single back, spread set or never throw to Kevin Jones when he goes into motion and splits out wide what the hell are the point of either? On top of all that, Mooch stays loyal to Mr. Bend-But-Don't-Break Jauron??? Please bring back Fred Flinstone!!!

Aside from Lloyd Carr and Phillip Fulmer, Mike Martz is the greatest mismanager of talent in football.
 
the_big_E said:
at least Mike Martz won a Super Bowl!

how about Mike Shanahan, ever since Elway, TD, and Sharpe have left... :eek:

Vermeil was the head coach when St. Louis won the Super Bowl. Martz took over with basically the same personnel and went nowhere. Maybe saying he`s the worst coach is a little unfair, but the Rams are consistently losing games they should be winning because of moves that make absolutely no sense.

You`re right about Shanahan. I`m starting to think the game may have passed him by as well.
 
iluvbtca said:
Lloyd Carr

You've got that right.
It's gonna be LLLLoyd Carr this year -- at least.

But he and Fulmer will be able to dine out on their respective national championships for years to come, I fear...
 
Speedo said:
You've got that right.
It's gonna be LLLLoyd Carr this year -- at least.

But he and Fulmer will be able to dine out on their respective national championships for years to come, I fear...

I don't think there is any coach that does less with more than LLoyd (soon to be LLLoyd) Carr. This year could turn into a disaster for Michigan. I think he will get one more year before he is under a lot of internal pressure.

Going back a few years, I think one of the worst coaches in history has to be Ray Perkins. He ran teams into the ground no matter where he went.
 
iluvbtca said:
Mariucci is definitely the most overrated coach out there. Harrington is being hung out to dry and scapegoated for Mooch's inabilities. If he is such a genius and Joey is that flawed, wouldn't you tailor the offense to what he can do?

Mooch did tailor the offense to what Joey can do, short 2-3 yard passes, which he did successfully against an inept Green Bay defense. Problem is you have three thoroughbred receivers in Rogers, Williams and Williams with a QB that can't get them the ball. Joey has neither the arm strength or manuervability to be a threat as QB. So, 8 in the box with a constant spy on Kevin Jones...The Lions, with all their offensive weapons, just aren't that tough to defend because of their QB weakness. Don't forget, Joey was Matt Milen's guy, not Mooch's.

Speedo said:
You've got that right.
It's gonna be LLLLoyd Carr this year -- at least.

As long as one of those L's come next week against the Spartans, I'll be happy :)
 
spartan5782 said:
Mooch did tailor the offense to what Joey can do, short 2-3 yard passes, which he did successfully against an inept Green Bay defense. Problem is you have three thoroughbred receivers in Rogers, Williams and Williams with a QB that can't get them the ball. Joey has neither the arm strength or manuervability to be a threat as QB. So, 8 in the box with a constant spy on Kevin Jones...The Lions, with all their offensive weapons, just aren't that tough to defend because of their QB weakness. Don't forget, Joey was Matt Milen's guy, not Mooch's.

As long as one of those L's come next week against the Spartans, I'll be happy :)

It's funny but I believe Joey was more of a stretch-the-field passer coming out of Oregon. Mind you, I didn't watch many Ducks' games or really give much attention to the PAC 10. I do agree though that he does not have the NFL definition of a gun especially seeing those very scary out patterns.

As for the Joey's Millen's guy, I think that's debatable. I'm partial to the idea he was a Ford guy (both Sr and Jr). Remember, they were just moving into Ford Field at that time and a highly touted QB would be a much better media sell than probably who was Millen's guy Quentin Jammer. I still think Mike McMahon has the raw skills, gun and mobility, to be a good starter in the NFL.

Carr will only survive if he sacrifices both of his boys Hermann and Malone. Malone's never been much of a play caller in my opinion and Hermann has really sucked since the '97 season. In both cases, last year each was bailed out by great players (Braylon) or plays (Shazor vs. Purdue). I'm hoping that Lloyd's die-hard loyalty to people (Navarre should have been unplugged after his So season) will have him quit rather than fire his boys.

Mike Martz has taken to the Bobby Ross technique of retiring HOF running backs although Marshall has decided to take the Emmitt Smith approach to grasping for the end of a career. Faulk should have still put up 1,500 yards the past to seasons and if he had gotten the ball more in their last Super Bowl, there may have never been a Patriots' "dinesty".
 
spartan5782 said:
As long as one of those L's come next week against the Spartans, I'll be happy :)

By 30 points or so, I fear. I think the Spartans are scary good this year on offense, and they don't have to worry much about Michigan's offense if their two losses are any indication...

iluvbtca said:
Carr will only survive if he sacrifices both of his boys Hermann and Malone. Malone's never been much of a play caller in my opinion and Hermann has really sucked since the '97 season. In both cases, last year each was bailed out by great players (Braylon) or plays (Shazor vs. Purdue). I'm hoping that Lloyd's die-hard loyalty to people (Navarre should have been unplugged after his So season) will have him quit rather than fire his boys.

Agreed, but the loyalty motherlode at Michigan runs deep. Bo still unofficially runs the show, and won't approve anyone but a "Michigan Man." I fear Carr will be there for as long as he wants the job, and there won't be any internal push to replace him as long as there are 110+ large in the stands each week.

spartan5782 said:
Mooch did tailor the offense to what Joey can do, short 2-3 yard passes, which he did successfully against an inept Green Bay defense. Problem is you have three thoroughbred receivers in Rogers, Williams and Williams with a QB that can't get them the ball. Joey has neither the arm strength or manuervability to be a threat as QB. So, 8 in the box with a constant spy on Kevin Jones...The Lions, with all their offensive weapons, just aren't that tough to defend because of their QB weakness. Don't forget, Joey was Matt Milen's guy, not Mooch's.

SUNDAY SPECIAL Prediction: Bye Week 26 Detroit 3.
 
What does the German army and the Michigan football team have in common?

They both have great fight songs, ugly ass helmets and they can't win the big one! :p

Go Spartans!
 
Last edited:
How can you all you guys forget about what Marty Shottenheimer did with San Diego?

He is top 3 coaches in the NFL... That is the reason he won the jack adams award last year(i think this is the best coach award)

Peace
 
iluvbtca said:
As for the Joey's Millen's guy, I think that's debatable. I'm partial to the idea he was a Ford guy (both Sr and Jr). Remember, they were just moving into Ford Field at that time and a highly touted QB would be a much better media sell than probably who was Millen's guy Quentin Jammer. I still think Mike McMahon has the raw skills, gun and mobility, to be a good starter in the NFL.

I agree Millen wasn't sold on Joey...it was his then handpicked coach Marty Mornhingweg that wanted him. I guess I was just saying Millen had to give the final nod so the buck stops with him.

I was also a McMahon fan. The kid had wheels and a stronger arm than Joey. He just didn't have the balance of a $37 million contract that we'd have to eat if we tried to move Joey. Playing behind McNabb in Philly, he'll probably get a ring long before Joey :D
 
ottawasub said:
Since there`s a lot of NFL fans on this board, I`m curious who you guys would rate as the best and worst coaches. My picks are:

Best:

1. Bill Belichick: Is there any doubt? While I don`t think New England will repeat this season, what he`s accomplished over the last 4 years has been one of the greatest coaching feats in sports history.

2. Bill Cowher: Maybe this is the Steeler fan bias in me, but under him they rarely take bad penalties (i.e. false starts, unnecessary pass interference) and seem to have more success with trick plays than any other team. When Ben R. stepped in, Cowher and Whisenhunt adjusted offensive strategy perfectlyy to maximize his strengths and minimze his weaknesses.

3. Bill Parcells: Makes the list based on his resume, but his recent insistence on going with washed-up QBs is puzzling.

4. Herman Edwards: The Jets have made the playoffs 3 of the last 4 years; it`s not because of their talent

5. John Fox: Grossly underrated. Not sure what he has to do to get respect.

6. Marvin Lewis
7. Jeff Fisher
8. Brian Billick
9. Andy Reid
10. Jon Gruden

Since it`s more fun to make fun of people, my choices for the Dave Wannstedt Award as the NFLs worst coaches are:

1. Mike Martz: Complete moron

2. Mike Holmgren: Was he riding on Favre`s coattails in GB?

3. Norv Turner: What did he accomplish to justify his reputation ?

4. Steve Mariucci: Ditto.

5. Mike Tice: Honeymoon is over.
You have Andy Reid 9th and the slop you have ahead of him makes no sense.Please dont rate coaches,your not good at it......