Bertuzzi Charged!

The Doctor said:
I'm not proposing that the NHL's current system for on-ice or supplementary discipline is adequate, <snip>

I think all avenues should be exhausted in punishing Mr. Bertuzzi fairly for this incident. That, clearly, includes criminal proceedings.
Todd will not spend *one* day in jail. He'll either spend more or less. Clearly, there's little point in a slap on the wrist. (Not that a conditional sentence is merely a slap on the wrist.)
Again, we'll see what happens.

Don't forget, pending criminal results, Mr. Moore is quite free to pursue CIVIL action against Mr. Bertuzzi. I certainly hope he does.
 
Nice snip, but it still doesn't mean you need police involvement. You perpetuate to idea that because we can sue, we should sue. I'm sure the pending criminal proceeding are the only reason why Moore hasn't filed suit already. That will be the bigger nightmare for the NHL and the NHLPA and it will set a very ugly precident that neither the league or the players want to deal with. Moore sues Bertuzzi but does it stop there? How about Crawford? The Canucks? The League? Can't leave out the Avalanche? What about the PA?
 
Why not? Why not sue them? Are they responsible in any way, shape or form for what happened?
Why sue EVER?? You yourself argue that the NHLPA and the NHL should step up and make things tougher. Why haven't they? Are they making it dangerous to play in the NHL? If so, they're culpable civilly. It's up to a judge to determine whether or not the argument holds water. That's the point of the law - you let someone impartial decide.

Anyway, look, your argument is full of holes.

Does ANYTHING NEED police involvement? If the law has been broken, the police should be involved, shouldn't they? Was what Bertuzzi did outside the realm of what's *reasonable* play in the NHL? Of course it was. Would it have been criminal if it happened outside of a game? Of course.

The point of the criminal justice system is two-fold - deterrence and punishment.

Now, that having been said, you've argued that an 18-month conditional sentence is no deterrent and that it's a waste of taxpayer money for the DA to pursue this. First, the DA doesn't determine what sentences are handed out for cases they decide to prosecute - that's up to the judge. Would they argue for harsher sentences almost universally? Sure - that's their job. Is it a waste of taxpayer money to prosecute ANYBODY for ANYTHING when the outcome is likely to be such a minor punishment? That seems to be a discussion for another thread, or do you just wish to indict the whole criminal justice system rather than defend Mr. Bertuzzi.

Sure, some cases are going to end up with light sentences. That doesn't mean you don't pursue them. Remember that the *first* job is deterrence. If Mr. Bertuzzi receives an 18-month conditional sentence, you can BET he's not going to do anything that might REMOTELY end in such a bad situation for the duration of that sentence. That's the point. If he does something after that, and ends up in court again, despite the fact that his record has been wiped clean, you can BET it's going to affect his sentence. And *that* will be punishment.

Just because the NHL should clean up its own act doesn't mean that outside authority shouldn't intervene when they feel it necessary. Mr. Moore's injuries were extremely severe, and were NOT inflicted in the normal course of play.

Surely, even YOU would draw the line *somewhere*, wouldn't you? I mean, if Bertuzzi had a knife on him, that'd be outside the pale, wouldn't it? A gun? Well, Doctor, you can kill someone very easily with a fist, as, unfortunately, almost happened. There is a legal precedent that you take the consequences of your actions - if you punch someone in the face and they die because of a heart condition they were born with, you're still culpable for their death.

You haven't presented any reasonable cause NOT to pursue legal action against Mr. Bertuzzi.
 
Yet again it is not about discussing two opposing views on a certain situation it's about you proving that your point of view is correct and exclussive. I've always believed, whether it's hockey, football, lacrosse or any other sport predicated on physical contact that once you've signed a contract that pays you some inconcievable amounts of money to play games that involve some form of physical aggression against your opponent, sometimes involving sticks, or projectiles that can cause death, you accept the fact that there are risk and the possibility that something bad might happen, whether intentional or not.

And since you choose to ignore the fact that I am stating my opinion, not arguing a case before some court, I'll offer one last point...

Bite me!
 
The Doctor said:
Yet again it is not about discussing two opposing views on a certain situation it's about you proving that your point of view is correct and exclussive. I've always believed, whether it's hockey, football, lacrosse or any other sport predicated on physical contact that once you've signed a contract that pays you some inconcievable amounts of money to play games that involve some form of physical aggression against your opponent, sometimes involving sticks, or projectiles that can cause death, you accept the fact that there are risk and the possibility that something bad might happen, whether intentional or not.

And since you choose to ignore the fact that I am stating my opinion, not arguing a case before some court, I'll offer one last point...

Bite me!

"Bite me". Nice comeback.

If you made some reasonable points, I might agree with some of them.
You don't. That's not my fault. Maybe you should elicit someone to argue your points for you.

Even the argument you just tried to make was incredibly weak - you must realize that. The fact that Steve Moore signed on to play a physical sport with some level of personal risk IN NO WAY mitigates the necessity to act in a reasonable manner. This is not a license for Todd Bertuzzi or anyone else to assault someone in such a brutal manner.

Are you on crack?
 
I don't think Doctor understands that, hdog.
Apparently, when you sign up to play hockey, you're signing away all rights to blame someone for fracturing your spine fifty feet behind the play. Maybe you should just consider your choice of occupation more carefully next time.
:rolleyes:
 
By your criteria, Goob, I'm sure he has.

As for stating an opinion, I guess it's not okay to disagree with it, or point out flaws in the reasoning behind it. Hey, it's just an opinion, right? It can't be right or wrong.

It's my opinion that you two are dipshits.
:)
 
However, feel free to argue against my opinion.
I sorta think that's the point in here ......
:rolleyes:
 
I wasn't disagreeing with you, I was inviting dissenting opinion.
I understand you're reluctant to disagree with people, however.

I'm sorry, is this a five-minute argument, or the full half-hour?
 
Don't give me that you snotty-faced heap of parrot droppings!
 
Ranger has proven in many threads in this forum that he really does not require a dissenting or opposing opinion to carry on his argument. He will continue to post responses to his own posts and other posts regardless of whether there has been any additional information put forth (see Outplaying).

Ranger68 said:
I`s my opinion that you two are dipshits.

Agreed but I`m sure you`ll still try to prove your point.

However, feel free to argue against my opinion.
I sorta think that`s the point in here ......

Actually I thought the point was the free exchange of information, opinion and sometimes even humour as it pertains to a number of different topics including, but not limited to, the adult industry, current events and sports. If your sole purpose is to come here and argue your point........you`re in the wrong skit!



And you need to get a life and stop taking yourself so seriously