normally i don't enter into discussions of this nature, basically because there are too many theories and no proof of anything. I tend to be more logical about things. The earleist estimate of actually writing in the new testement is the book of James around AD40. Old testament is estimated to have been writen starting as early as 1445 BC. Both dates are according to carm.org. I realize that the discussion is centered around religon and not the bible, however since religon stems from stories of the bible i anted to point out that people inclined to be believers are basing the belief on a book whose newest stories are roughly 2000 yrs old. The believers also tend to intepret everything in the bible differently and typically refer to the inconsistancies of the book when they cannot explain something related to it.
Do you seriously think that ancient people or their ancestors were capable of making rational decisions and conducting proper research into why certain things occured? Was it not easier for them to develop the concept of a supreme being? Could the supreme being have been an alien? Maybe, or maybe not, too hard to prove it either way, however ancient people also believed in immortals, woshipped animals and were highly motivated by fear...just saying.
Organized religon is a cross between organized crime and a cult. People are conditioned to certain teachings that resonate because they are looking to fill an void and the filler might as well be an imaginary friend they can talk to. Organized religion has caused wars over the centuries all in the name of a god who is supposed to be good. It has also caused mercy killings and child abuse stemming directly from it, but I'm sure organized religon can be twisted to sound like a good thing just like the bilbe can be twisted. Organized religon may (I don't know for sure) contribute 80% of it's fundraising to charity...or it may not. Could they be cooking the books? Absolutely. are they? Who knows - not I and I very much doubt you do either. There is not one organized religon that is better than another, they all have flaws and the books that they are based upon can all be interpreted in many ways.
My point is that most people want to be good and do better but lack the ability to do so themselves so it's easier to have a bunch of other people tell them what a great job they are doing...kind of like sheep. We all want that in our jobs, our family and our lives. Organized religon does exactly that and uses the printed word as a crutch to justify it's teachings. The reality is it's a massive brainwash and quite typical of the rest of the world where a small percentage oat the top live off the sweat of the large percent on the bottom.
One of the definitions of a cult as taken from cultdefinition.com : formal religous worship. Isn't that what organized religon is? doesnt matter if you call it christian, muslim or budhist...it's formal religous worship.
I can't prove my thoughts any more than anyone else can in terms of the bible and ancient stories and ancient people, however science and history has already disproven many of the ancient theories that formalized religons have been based on...so we now call these miracles.
I'm done now.
Wow, you really saved it up didn't you?
I notice one of the definitions of cult you didn't include from your reference was #5;
5 a : great devotion to a person, idea, object, movement, or work (as a film or book); especially : such devotion regarded as a literary or intellectual fad
plus some other points;
[h=3]VARIETY OF CULTS[/h]Groups said to be ‘cults’ are not necessarily religious.
Such is the case with, for instance, political cults (e.g. Lyndon LaRouche), psycho-spiritual or self-improvement workshops (LGAT, Large Group Awareness Training), and hate groups (e.g. Ku Klux Klan, White Supremacists).
[h=3]CULTS ARE NOT ALWAYS DESTRUCTIVE[/h]
Not all groups that could in one way or another be defined, sociologically, as cults are necessarily destructive. For instance, not every high-demand group requires its members to cut off normal contact with friends and family.
A good initial check is to ask, how does this group impact a person’s health, wealth, and/or personal relationships?
The absence of written history doesn't mean the history is flawed or false. Having spent time with cultures where verbal history is the rules and not the exception, such as Inuit, Cree, and Zulu, it's been shown to be accurate, similar independent account saying the same things.
Accounts of the Coppermine River/Bloody Falls battle or massacre were found to very similar even though combatents, Innuit and Dene were relaying different sides of the story. In other words, aural history isn't automatically flawed.
As far as cooking the books, the books get reviewed by Arthur Anderson and they know. Yes, Arthur Anderson of Enron fame, but does that put every set of books they've reviewed in question for the last 100 years? I doubt it.
Most people have the ability to be good. That's why most people are law abiding citizens. Atheist or religious people don't seem have a corner on that human trait.
Organized crime? What crime are they committing?
Ancient people, although I don't know what definition of ancient you want to use, were able to use rational thought. Follow the game as they know where the food/water is and will gather in numbers making hunting easier. Follow ravens as they know where accessible food is, especially human compatible food. Why do you think the Arab mathematicians and ancient Greeks knew that the earth was round years before Columbus, and could prove it?
Ancients learned how to store/carry fire. A pretty important discovery through rational thinking and research. the discovery of fire was pretty much luck, but being able to use it and control it was through practice and observation. Pretty smart for them dumb ancients, don't you think?
Even modern cultures believe in animal spirits and the good news is most modern cultures don't believe in immortality these days.