Begging in Tim Hortons...........

lookingforitallthetime said:
danmand, I have to say I'm surprised you're calling yourself a Conservative. It appears Lancs has had a positive affect on you.

In an earlier thread you offered your definition of the many types of conservatism. As a matter of fact, you critisized me for labelling myself a Conservative so loosly. Now, here you are proclaiming your Conservatism.

Is it safe to classify you as a socialist conservative?

I am a fiscal conservative, I believe in government being efficient and optimizing production and growth. It is clearly inefficient to have an uneducated and unproductive population. The greatest ressource of any country even a country like Canada rich in natural ressources, are its people. Some of the smallest countries in Europe, void of natural ressources, have the highest living standards in the world.

lookingforitallthetime said:
When its -20, the privacy issue should be less important.

Why don't we give them a cell phone, car, middle management job and the services of an SP once a month?

The funny thing is, if you gave them all these things, I'd be willing to bet a large majority would be back on the street panhandling within 24 hours.

The experience from countries that have a much more agressive employment strategy, like the scandinavian countries, are that almost everybody wants to have a job and be productive members of society, just like you. Nobody grows up dreaming about becoming a panhandler or petty thief.

lookingforitallthetime said:
I hear its because Denmark exports it's unproductive members of society to Canada.

I refuse to comment on that statement, as I might incriminate myself.:o
 
I think there is good points on both sides of this issue. I think we as a society are responsible for taking care of people who CAN'T take care of themselves. However I don't think we owe anything to a person who can take care of themselves but WON'T.
I think what puts a lot of our young people and older people on the streets is they refuse or are unable to follow the rules of society. Unfortunately or fortunately, depending on how you look at it, there has to be some rules for society to continue. You can be your own person or do your own thing and still not be a drag on society; you may not necessarily contribute to society a lot but you can still survive within societies rules.
A lot of the unfortunate people on the streets have not been able to follow any rules and eventually they end up the only place that accepts that....on the street. The real kicker for them is the help that is available for them has a set of rules attached,( ie if you stay at a shelter you have to be up and out fairly early in the morning, have to eat meals at certain times etc), which excludes a lot of the people they were meant to help.
You may say in understandable ignorance, "They are up early in the morning on the street anyways so why dont they just go in to the shelter last thing and then get up early and hit the streets". However, then they are following somebody else's rules instead of just waking up whenever on the subway grate.
In essence, this is a extended explanation of "If they won't help themselves, they can't be helped".

Having said all that, I have bought street people a coffee or something to eat at times and it may seem strange but I just do it when I feel led to help a particular person. I know there are a lot of scammers out there but if you let your heart lead you you'll be surprised how many of the right people you will help. I can pass a hundred people and it not bother me too much but I dare not pass the person who touches my heart. If you do you risk developing a hard heart and that will hurt you in the long run more than anything.

I'll get off my soapbox now.
traveler196
 
danmand said:
The system has obviously failed him.

And bugger of, will you, we do not need americans to advise us on social policy.

PLEASE SPARE ME THE BULLSHIT.

The so called "Homeless" budget in Toronto is 220 million a year.

http://www.torontosun.com/News/Columnists/Levy_Sue-Ann/2006/04/25/1549465-sun.html

That's more than the budget to fix every bridge in Toronto. (The bridge budget being around 50 million.)

Something is out of whack with those numbers don't you think.
 
Look if you want to help out with the homeless, then donate money to the charities or organizations that operate the shelters, off the street programs, youth on the streets, drug and alcohal rehab programs, and pretty much all the other issues and challenges the homeless face. I mean that bum that lives on the corner of the block that you drive past everyday is not the only image you should have of people that are "on the streets", so to speak. If it is then your image is not entirely complete. There are so many people out there that are homeless, but still struggling to get back on their feet. I am sure you know, or know someone that knows one of those people that move around from friend's place to friend's place on an ongoing bases. These people are also considered homeless. I guess my point is that if you feel the need to help, or give a shit about the homeless then donate to those places, let the homeless go and get it where it is set up so it is systematic and insured to go to the right intentions, instead of handing over a twoonie which he just used to go into buying crack for his addiction. Sure the occassional twoonie here and there are ok, because we are after all human, but for the most part, let's try to solve the bigger picture instead of a few seconds of sympathy.
 
PHNINE said:
Look if you want to help out with the homeless, then donate money to the charities or organizations that operate the shelters, off the street programs, youth on the streets, drug and alcohal rehab programs, and pretty much all the other issues and challenges the homeless face. I mean that bum that lives on the corner of the block that you drive past everyday is not the only image you should have of people that are "on the streets", so to speak. If it is then your image is not entirely complete. There are so many people out there that are homeless, but still struggling to get back on their feet. I am sure you know, or know someone that knows one of those people that move around from friend's place to friend's place on an ongoing bases. These people are also considered homeless. I guess my point is that if you feel the need to help, or give a shit about the homeless then donate to those places, let the homeless go and get it where it is set up so it is systematic and insured to go to the right intentions, instead of handing over a twoonie which he just used to go into buying crack for his addiction. Sure the occassional twoonie here and there are ok, because we are after all human, but for the most part, let's try to solve the bigger picture instead of a few seconds of sympathy.

Well put.

BTW were you able to sell that coffee and bagel back??
 
PHNINE said:
Look if you want to help out with the homeless, then donate money to the charities or organizations that operate the shelters, off the street programs, youth on the streets, drug and alcohal rehab programs, and pretty much all the other issues and challenges the homeless face. I mean that bum that lives on the corner of the block that you drive past everyday is not the only image you should have of people that are "on the streets", so to speak. If it is then your image is not entirely complete. There are so many people out there that are homeless, but still struggling to get back on their feet. I am sure you know, or know someone that knows one of those people that move around from friend's place to friend's place on an ongoing bases. These people are also considered homeless. I guess my point is that if you feel the need to help, or give a shit about the homeless then donate to those places, let the homeless go and get it where it is set up so it is systematic and insured to go to the right intentions, instead of handing over a twoonie which he just used to go into buying crack for his addiction. Sure the occassional twoonie here and there are ok, because we are after all human, but for the most part, let's try to solve the bigger picture instead of a few seconds of sympathy.

Yeah, but the problem has to be solved on a much greater scale than that. It is not a job for NGO agencies, charities and churches. The problem has to be addressed by society as a whole, i.e. government. It would require changes in attitude towards education, health care, drug usage, work, unemployment, general welfare, etc. and that is of course utopian in Canada, at least during our lifetimes.

But it would be very cost effective, with a generous ROI.
 
This problem isn't going to be solved by ideology. "Conservative", "liberal" are empty constructs. Ideology at that level is just an attempt to gloss over the gang of ugly facts that murdered your favourite political theory.

Government should base its policies in sound project management techniques. If spending money on a social program is likely to return a net profit to society then spend the money no matter what anyone's "conservative" ideology says. If spending it will not earn any value for society then don't spend the money, no matter how harsh and uncaring your "liberal" ideology says that is.
 
just my two cents... never give out money to a homeless... donate your time and monies to shelters, churches and organizations that will better offer the help the homeless needs.. .if you give out money you are in most likely hood fueling drug habits and or drinking habbits...
 
Fabulous said:
20 years ago you saw the odd beggar/homeless person on Toronto streets. Now it seems like everybody is a beggar or homeless, you can barely walk 2 blocks downtown without being approached by somebody looking for a handout from a stranger.

Part of this was caused by the shift in policy years back that mental patients are better off in the real world instead of being institutionalized. So they let all these people out without any formal socialization nor follow-up and now we are starting to see the results. Thank you, bleeding hearts. :rolleyes:
 
The Daulfin said:
Part of this was caused by the shift in policy years back that mental patients are better off in the real world instead of being institutionalized. So they let all these people out without any formal socialization nor follow-up and now we are starting to see the results. Thank you, bleeding hearts.

Bleeding heart? bleeding arse rather:eek:

That was a policy invented by Reagan in the US and copied by Harris. Bleding arses.
 
danmand said:
Bleeding heart? bleeding arse rather:eek:

That was a policy invented by Reagan in the US and copied by Harris. Bleding arses.
ya know what, it was and still is a piss-poor idea.
 
danmand said:
My understanding is that most of the shelters are something like big rooms with 20 cots, no privacy, people screaming all night, no security etc.

I think the city should convert some buildings into extremely small rooms, with room for a cot and a desk, that would be more humane accomodation, and would likely not require any more square footage.

Well the next poster has a point about enabling drug abuse with private rooms, so why not split the diference? Convert spaces into 4 person dwelling groups and give slightly more privacy without falling into the problems with total privacy. When I visited Vancouver when I was younger, I ended up in a hostel where I shared a room with only 2 bunkbeds and four lockers with 3 other guys and I never had any problems with sleep or security. If I had to pay a small fee for such accomodation, then a homeless person should have nothing to bitch about with such a set-up. Hell, you could even charge hostelling rates to help offset the costs when the beds are not full like they would be in the winters.
 
Nikki2 said:
Aw,come on :( lay off us bleeding hearts Without us you'd be paying a lot more taxes *lol* We do all the volunteer work in this Country.

Actully, it's because of bleeding hearts that we pay more taxes in this country. Like has already been pointed out, Toronto has a grosteque budget for homelessness and the problem is getting worse and not better. Without the bleeding hearts, that budget would be probably more in the 10-30 million range. No amount of volunterism offsets the tax costs that the same philosophy incurs.
 
Terbevore said:
I just had to share this. I’m in the Tim Hortons at Carlton and Jarvis yesterday in the early afternoon. A beggar comes in and starts bugging people for change. No one gives him any. The girl working the counter tells him to leave. A lady beside me laments that she feels sorry for him. I mention to her that there are several shelters in the area where he can get food and a place to sleep.

Five minutes go by and he’s back. The girl behind the counter again tells him to get out but he protests saying someone is buying him something. He orders a hot chocolate and a bagel and a gentleman pays for it. Then, both the beggar and the good samaritan leave, going in different directions. Once the good samaritan is out of sight, the beggar is back in the store demanding that the counter-girl exchange his bagel and hot chocolate for money. The girl tells him to forget it and he then goes to every customer in the store trying to sell them the bagel and the cup of hot chocolate. The counter-girl orders him out of the store and he was last seen standing outside on the sidewalk asking everyone passing by if they wanted to buy a bagel and a hot chocolate. The lady sitting beside me stated that she had just received some basic education with respect to the people wandering the streets.

This I swear is a true story.

All this discussion about helping the homeless. Who cares!

Answer the question we all wanna know...Did you win Roll Up the Rim?
 
I won a coffee today, big deal. Who wins the damn cars anyway???

Yeah, I won muffins, donuts and maybe the occasional coffee.

Seems the people who win the cars, tv's and bikes are in Western Canada at least that's what someone told me.

BTW, is the car officially yours or is it one of those stupid lease to own for one year.
 
Edifice said:
Yeah, I won muffins, donuts and maybe the occasional coffee.

Seems the people who win the cars, tv's and bikes are in Western Canada at least that's what someone told me.

BTW, is the car officially yours or is it one of those stupid lease to own for one year.


It is yours outright according to some signs they had in a Timmies I was in. With so many of those scam lease for a year deals it seems that if you actually are giving clear title you need to be very specific. We are a jaded lot.
 
LancsLad said:
It is yours outright according to some signs they had in a Timmies I was in. With so many of those scam lease for a year deals it seems that if you actually are giving clear title you need to be very specific. We are a jaded lot.

Are you sure? I thought it was one of those lease for a year deals.
 
Edifice said:
Yeah, I won muffins, donuts and maybe the occasional coffee.

Seems the people who win the cars, tv's and bikes are in Western Canada at least that's what someone told me.

BTW, is the car officially yours or is it one of those stupid lease to own for one year.

I rolled up my first rim today. Free coffee. :D