Bautista is Now HOF Eligible

I doubt he gets the 5% needed to stay on the ballot.

His career numbers fall way short. And while his peak numbers are good, his 5 year peak numbers still fall short of the peaks of most hall of famers.
 
I dunno the bat throw is still shown and talked about. Maybe that'll get him some points. He did kind of start that trend, no?
 
Mark Buerhle is also on ballot.
Bautista will not get in, late bloomer , short power hitting season span, 5 years only, never won WS.

Buerhle has a better chance of getting in, maybe not on first balloting.
Won WS
Perfect game
no hitter
4 time gold glove winner
5 time all star
 
Mark Buerhle is also on ballot.
Bautista will not get in, late bloomer , short power hitting season span, 5 years only, never won WS.

Buerhle has a better chance of getting in, maybe not on first balloting.
Won WS
Perfect game
no hitter
4 time gold glove winner
5 time all star

Buerle will likely get the 5% to stay on the ballot I think. But I would be surprised if he ever got to 20% at any time. Which is well below the 75% that is needed.

He does have solid career numbers for starters of his era - 214Wins and 59.1 ERA -- but they are not HOF worthy career numbers without great peak performance (i.e CY Youngs / dominant season). And he doesn't have that.

Its a decent list of accomplishments above for a solid baseball player. But those are very modest for a Hall of Famer.

Maybe 15 years from now he gets on the Veterans Committee ballot and they were drinking and drunk like the day they voted in Harold Baines.
 
As much as Jose was amazing in Toronto, he just doesn't have the numbers or resume for the HOF. Baseball is the toughest one to get into. I think Buehrle has a legit shot thanks to that list of accomplishments @unassuming posted. Still, hard sledding. He has 214 wins, which is pretty damn good for this era.
 
Loved watching Jose and his metamorphosis with the Jays. Don't know if he made some adjustments or took advantage of a better look given to him by an organization.

Not a hall of famer in my estimation but a hall of very good that is for sure.

As a Yankee fan we always look at ex Yankees like Ron Guidry. Lifetime record of 170-91 with a 3.29 ERA.

3 time 20 game winner. 4 time all star. 5 times gold glove winner. 1 Cy Young. 2 time World Series winner. Lifetime 5-2 with a 3.02 postseason record.

Guidry never made in past 9% in balloting....
 
Last edited:
Loved watching Jose and his metamorphosis with the Jays. Don't know if he made some adjustments or took advantage of a better look given to him by an organization.

Not a hall of famer in my estimation but a hall of very good that is for sure.

As a Yankee fan we always look at ex Yankees like Ron Guidry. Life record of 170-91 with a 3.29 ERA.

3 time 20 game winner. 4 time all star. 5 times gold glove winner. 1 Cy Young. 2 time World Series winner. Lifetime 5-2 with a 3.02 postseason record.

Guidry never made in past 9% in balloting....
Ron Guidry like Jose Bautista had a couple HOF seasons but not HOF careers.
 
Mark Buerhle is also on ballot.
Bautista will not get in, late bloomer , short power hitting season span, 5 years only, never won WS.

Buerhle has a better chance of getting in, maybe not on first balloting.
Won WS
Perfect game
no hitter
4 time gold glove winner
5 time all star
And 14 straight seasons with over 200 innings pitched.
 
Mark Buerhle is also on ballot.
Bautista will not get in, late bloomer , short power hitting season span, 5 years only, never won WS.

Buerhle has a better chance of getting in, maybe not on first balloting.
Won WS
Perfect game
no hitter
4 time gold glove winner
5 time all star
A good pitcher for sure, but not a HOFer.
 
No White Sox...

I remember when Gibby tried like hell to leave him in for his last start with the Jays, to get 200 innings in for the year.

Gibby was awesome...
That was ugly. He only needed to pitch 2 innings, and then they were going to take him out. Tampa Bay just kept getting on base and they finally had to take him out before the first inning was over. He gave up 8 runs, none of them earned. Sad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
HOF ain’t happening, but I’d love to see Bautista coaching in Toronto. He would be perfect for it. I can think of a number of Blue Jays that struggle with their hands in proper position, timing and turning on the ball. Jose became a student of these mechanics in order to experience any success.

Guerrero is an absolute disaster with his stride and timing.

Philip
 
Jose Bautista's long time friend David Ortiz fixed his swing. It may have been called fraternizing with the enemy, Ortiz didn't care, he'd just won his second WS with the Red Sox. Two years later Joey Boom Bats hit 54 home runs.

The current Jays could use someone with Joey's attitude, Josh Donaldson said he's retiring after this season.


Robinson Cano fixed Edwin Encarnacion's timing.
 
Last edited:
Vladdy has to start serving cold cuts when a pitchers try to punk him. Remember the back pitch to Bautista?

 
Jose Bautista's long time friend David Ortiz fixed his swing. It may have been called fraternizing with the enemy, Ortiz didn't care, he'd just won his second WS with the Red Sox. Two years later Joey Boom Bats hit 54 home runs.

The current Jays could use someone with Joey's attitude, Josh Donaldson said he's retiring after this season.


Robinson Cano fixed Edwin Encarnacion's timing.
I seem to recall in the past Cito Gaston and Dwayne Murphy were credited with helping Jose change his swing, which led to his success.
 
He can make the Toronto Sports HOF.

lol or the Front street walk of fame (which doesn’t even exist).

Philip