Basement Insulation

Ref

Committee Member
Oct 29, 2002
5,143
1,077
113
web.archive.org
I am planning to finish the basement. I completed one many years ago that was partially finished.

There is a lot of information on the net but unfortunately one person's method is anothers "How not to do it" method.

As per the Ontario building code, it seems to change as often as the seasons.

Situation: Poured basement; 7 years old; no leaks; builders half wall blanket of plastic & insulation on all walls - Which I will remove completely.

Method # 1: My first preference. Build stud walls 2.5" from concrete wall (use sill plate underneath). Going with wood because I prefer to work with it as opposed to steel framing. Once studding is complete, seal it with the DIY foam spray kits and spray behind studs. Headers & top half of wall will be at least 2.5" thick and the bottom half will be about 1 - 1.5" thick.

The spray foam at 1.5 - 2" acts as a water and air vapour barrier and an insulator (7 - 14 R). No other insulation is required.

Method # 2: Per the big box store guy...6 mm of plastic on bare concrete walls. Run it up to the headers and seal it with acoustic seal, acoustic seal it to the floor at the base of the wall and have it run under the sill plates beneath the studs by about a foot. Build stud wall 2.5 " away from plastic and insulate it with Roxul batting.

The plastic is your water and air vapour barrier, the Roxul is a good form of insulation and if any internal vapour goes through the drywall and roxul, it will evaporate in the 2.5" air gap (which also acts as an insulator)

Method # 3" Attach 2" foam boards to the wall with strapping, tape the joints and seal at the floor with spray foam from the can. Build stud wall 1" from the foam boards and insulate with pink fiberglass.

The foam boards act as a vapour barrier.

The spray foam DIY method is the most expensive, but not by very much (less than $500 when all is said and done).

Has anyone had any experience using the spray foam kits?

Any experience finishing your own basement?
 
Why do most Ontario houses have basements?

I remember talking to a civil engineer once who worked on high rises & he told me you can only use pilings for high rises. And using pilings for houses would be a much cheaper and stronger construction method than the full basement plus concrete slab foundation. also, not encasing some of the plumbing in concrete makes repairs a lot easier and cheaper in the long run.

A lot of times when foundations are damaged they dig under the concrete slab and put pilings under the slab.

http://www.handycanadian.com/articles-foundation-repair.asp

In parts of the world built on clay basements are rare. But they still use lots of concrete slabs, and repair and stabilize the slabs that get damaged by using pilings under the slabs. Weird, when starting from the pilings would be cheaper from the start.

Dig the pilings 8 feet deep and you're immune from frost heaving, and even immune from higher wind loading than the basement houses.

Is it just inertia in the building trades? tradition? does the law require slab foundations in Ontario?

Long time renter, just curious about this housing stuff.
 
Monty gives good advice.

I think we build basements for increased space and the ease of HVAC, plumbing and electrical installation.

For a typical poured concrete foundation, one has to put the footings below the frost line (36" or more in this area). The incremental extra cost to dig out the remainder of the house foot print is small, plus all the extra benefits of more space, access to utilities, etc.

Cheers
 
I am sure Rubby will agree with me that the last thing you need to do is to take advice on the internet from a loud mouth, blowhard that is giving you his amateurish mealy mouthed advice. Go to:

http://www.cmhc-schl.gc.ca/en/index.cfm
 
For a typical poured concrete foundation, one has to put the footings below the frost line (36" or more in this area). The incremental extra cost to dig out the remainder of the house foot print is small, plus all the extra benefits of more space, access to utilities, etc.

Cheers

If you look at the majority of basements, they allow 3' to 4' feet above the surface for basement windows, and for the rule that the wood must be a certain distance above grade. Footings must be at least 3' below grade, and many people aim for 4' below grade. Take the 3' to 4' above, add it to the 3' to 4' below, and you have a 6' to 8' basement.

Additionally, the builders will sell the topsoil from under and around the house and sell the topsoil for money. The dirt from under the house is used to replace the missing topsoil around the house. Eventually, new homeowners decide they want flower beds, and purchase the topsoil, not realizing that the builder swindled them.

All told, adding a basement to a new home saves the builder money.
 
First: Seal all out side air leaks; you're in the process of hiding them away, all pies, vents penetrations and cracks, and where the wooden sill plate sits atop the concrete. This is your last chance.

Your enemy in the basement is the water that will eventually make it's way thru the concrete, either slowly by permeating as thru a sponge or more rapidly thru cracks. But it will get there; concrete (at least the residential stuff) is porous. Your hope is to be long gone by the time it does, but do what you can to slow it down, best from the outside (messy and expensive, most folks hope the builder did it, so they don't have to. If you do, insulate from the outside at the same time) and/or not so effectively from the inside (wall coatings, paint-on, or insulating foams)

Trouble is, the wet eventually is just being held back by that skin. When the water gets thru, you need to give it a place to go, otherwise it will never leave and more water will come. Sealed poly next to the concrete will make a lovely, invisible water feature, until the water patiently overcomes the seal. But instead of being the odd drop or two after a downpour, you've collected a few years worth that shows up all at once. The old-fashioned and still effective approach is to layer tarpaper shingle fashion next to the concrete to shed water downwards while allowing air to circulate and—hopefully—dry it away. So the tarpaper would wrap under the sill which should be primered, and not sealed to the floor. All that is meant to protect the studs and insulation, and by drying, deter mould. If it doesn't work, there will be mould in the damp darkness, rust that will eat away steel studs in just a few years and rot that will destroy the wood in a few more. Absolutely filling the spaces with a non-absorbant insulator like sprayfoam sounds good, but you have to remember that such approaches are new, and have yet to prove how effective they are over time. All things fail.

But once you have an outside water barrier you believe in, You need to keep in-house moisture from doing the same evil things, because it will turn to water when it hits that cold foundation. Or maybe in somewhere in the insulation, whenever it gets to the layer that's cold enough. That's what you get for trying to keep all the heat in; everywhere else gets cold; think of a fluffy warm sweater turning into a sodden sponge. That's why you seal your side, the warm side, with vapour barrier so no vapour gets thru to condense inside. The non-permeable foams are their own vapour-barrier, but batts need a layer of poly on the warm face with attention to sealing at any joins or penetrations. After the drywall or whatever is on, the paint will add more vapour protection, and sealing those penetrations again will help too. I like to bring the poly out over the floor a few inches, keep the drywall 1/2" above the concrete to ensure it stays dry, and let that bottom seam stay free, but seal everywhere else. Then the baseboard can hug the foor. The colder air down there's carrying less moisture anyway, and would have a tough journey to get where it can do harm, but any liquid stuff can still get out.

The best thing for in-house moisture is to make it leave by routes you pick: sealed modern houses need planned ventilation systems. If all you have is a forced air furnace and batroom and kitchen exhausts, at least make sure you use those and that the basement 's air get's circulated too. Figure out how to get fresh, dry air in by routes, and at times you choose, to do its good work, not rob you of heat little by little.

But we should all remember, coming out of the caves to live, was supposed to be progress; whatever we do to it a basement is still a cave. We left them because they leaked, were cold, dark and hard to heat. Don't kid yourself that we've solved those problems. Nature always wins; we're just temporary.
 
Spray foam all the way...."Tiger Foam" http://www.tigerfoam.ca/

If you do have any moisture problems on the walls or floors, fix those first!

I removed every piece of insulation in my home a few years ago and spray foamed the entire place during a major renovation. Keep the tanks warm, only spray it about 2" thick, which is plenty, this will eliminate any cracks of air getting into the house and you don't have to worry vapor barriers plastic, tuck tape, staples and tons of unnecessary labour of measuring & cutting etc etc. Yes the cost is a bit more upfront but you'll see the saving in the first year. I haven't had to run my air conditioner in the past 4 years during the summer, it keeps the house remarkable cool in the summer and extremely warm and comfortable in the winter. My gas furnace is barely used these day and even that it is high efficiency, two stage motor. We did the government audit before and after, my home was 70% efficient, after the renovation, they came back and did their test and we got a score of 96%. Meaning every dollar into the home on utilities was $0.70 and $0.30 up the chimney, now only $0.04 is up the chimney. You DON'T want to make your home a sealed unit though, air needs to move in and out of your home, which is will with the dryer, bathroom vent, & kitchen vent.

You'll save yourself a lot of headaches. If you do go with Spray foam you DO NOT need 6mm vapor barrier anywhere. Just spray it on the walls as described in the video, cover it with your drywall and your done. If you over spray, which you will in some spots as you may fell the need to get carried away with the stuff as it is fun applying, simply let it dry and cut off the excess material.

I having been flipping homes for years and my SO does all the labour with his crew! When we sell the properties and our buyers see the before and after pictures, it adds major value to the home also.
 
So much information and so much of it is incorrect.

1. The frost depth in Toronto is 4' (not 36")

2. Piling a basement would be hugely expensive. MASSIVE EXPENSIVE. Spread footings are always cheaper. (And keep in mind that a piled foundation needs what is called a "Pile cap" which is basically a reinforced concrete beam that spans between the piles on which you build your foundation wall. More cost.

3. You can not build on a slab on grade in Toronto (well you could, but it would be really stupid)

4. I agree that foam is the best insulation, however, it does cost and there are different types of foam on market. The one that everyone is very familiar with is the BASF walltight that Holmes uses. (Commonly called "2 lb" foam) The walltight is without a doubt the best insulator going. HOWEVER, it is a lethal chemical cocktail that requires you to move out of your house for 24 hours. It will in fact continue to off-gas for quite some time in trace quantities. (I'm not interested in that stuff because it's not safe from a health point of view (IMHO).) The Icynene system is much healthier for you, but it is not as good an insulator as BASF Walltight. I'd go with it simply for health reasons. But the Icynene does need a vapour barrier.

The best thing about foam is that it prevents air infiltration (drafts). Batt insulation does not prevent drafts.

5. You need the best waterproofing going for a poured concrete wall. That black shit in a can is just that - shit in a can. You want a membrane that can span across a crack. (Try Rub R Wall)

6. I'm not too sure about putting tar paper inside a house frankly. Again, not a nice product. I think I'd be more likely to use a tyvek material.

7. I do not recommend making your house "as tight as a drum". The old houses are drafty, but I swear they are healthier. All the new air tight homes seem to be suffering from a lot of mold problems - things you never saw with older homes because of the air leaks. It may cost you 2 or 3 hundred, or even 5 hundred a year more to heat, but you're healhier for it.

8. 75 percent of heat loss is right out the roof. Keep that in mind. You're better off spending money to insulate an attic than a basement.

9. The first R12 of insulation does more to insulate a house than the next R40. It's not a linear relationship between R vs. Heatloss.

10. Do not use SM on the exterior of foundation walls - or at least ensure that it terminates below the ring joists because Termites love the stuff. They will tunnel right through the SM, right into the ring joist and presto, they are in your house. I've seen many improper SM installations where the contractor overlaps the ring joist. Wrong wrong wrong.
 
Lastly, here is a website that I consider to be the 7 Series of Websites as far as Residential Design is concerned.

It is an American site, but you can just look up a northern state as they are further north than T.O.

http://www.buildingscience.com/

They really go in depth and even consider such things as venting off soil gas and the like.
 
…

6. I'm not too sure about putting tar paper inside a house frankly. Again, not a nice product. I think I'd be more likely to use a tyvek material.

…
Thanks for the caution. It is a product we've been using in residences for generations without outcry or controversy, outside as rainshield and inside in custom showers and basements to do the same job. But I could have made a similar case for lead pipes up until the a few decades ago. It's good to be cautious.

On that line I tend to be suspicious of anything—like sprayed foam—that's too new to have had much use history. Lab tests and such are all fine, but they can only approximate what twenty or so years will do. And whatever the real merits of UFFI, thousands of folks have been inconvenienced or put to expense because of the difference between what the lab said early on and what the people, labs and authories found in real life. Just as a f'rinstance.

In all this stuff: it's your money putting it in; it'll be your money taking it out or fixing it. Research the hell out of it, but in the end it's what you decide. Nothing is plain black and white in life.
 
I've done a couple of basements back in the early 90's with Tar Paper, but not any more. Tyvek.

To tell you the truth, the best thing you can do is a really good waterproofing system on the outside of the foundation wall.

Tar paper is just that - paper that's been dunked in tar. As we all know, tar is not something you want around.

I don't have any problem with Tar paper under shingles, but I would prefer to see Ice and Watershield at the eaves at the least. Some guys put Tar paper on the entire surface area of the roof sheathing, others do not. I'm not convinced it's really needed, but I have no serious objections about on a roof because it's an exterior installation.

But an interior wall in a basement? Tar? Inside your house? No thanks.

As far as UFFI goes, well, the whole thing may have been overdone. Who knows. But I agree, foam technology is new and is not proven.

I prefer the Icynene insulation over walltight because it is not toxic (so they say) whereas walltight is highly toxic. (But walltight is a better insulator.)

But as previously stated, I'm not that horny about living in a house that's sealed up like a drum. A few drafts can be a very good thing for your health.
 
The Icynene is basically the same as fibreglass batt in terms of its insulating properties. It still needs a vapour barrier, and yes, wires get encapsulated, however, no different than fibreglass (batt or blown in) ditto it sucking up water - no different than batt. Any spray foam will hit the wires. That is permitted by code. As to its toxicity, it is "supposed to be" non toxic and water based (at least according to the propaganda out there).

To be honest, I think I'd use foam in the basement only to seal the ring joists were you get a lot of air infiltration. After that, just use Roxul in the walls as others have said. This is where foam is king - in sealing out air infiltration. Fibreglass or Roxul simply will not seal out air infiltration and vapour barriers are too spotty to be sucessful at sealing against air infiltration also.

I'm also not sold on using either tyvek or tar paper as frankly, the wall needs to be dry on the inside - which to me means you need a damn good waterproofing system on the outside. If I had to pick between Tar Paper and Tyvek though - it would be Tyvek in an instant.

PS, read you this link you posted:

http://www.thoughts.com/IcyneneDangers/icynene-dangers-and-problems

I'm very suspicious of the Original Poster. Sounds almost like a rival posting shit to scare customers away to be honest.

I can't understand how a leak could not be taken care of with the proper work required to take care of any leak. If you have a leak in a pipe, you pull down the drywall, rip away the insulation (it's very easy to pull apart, fix the pipe and repair the ceiling.

Also, his simple leak seems to have damaged the entire house, carpets, 2 bathrooms, killed his kid, etc.

I'm calling BS on that one.
 
I would go with spray-foam 100%. Instant air and vapour barrier which is nigh impossible to do as good a job using any other medium w/o a lot of time and effort. Had guys come and do part of my basement. Fumes were negligible although I did leave the windows open for the day (had it done in summer).

One caution... for some reason building inspectors in Mississauga expect to find a plastic vapour barrier on top of the spray-foam.

If you are making your house super-air-tight you will want to invest in some form of Heat Recovery Ventilator to exchange the air in your house. There was a previous comment that the stove, dryer and bath exhausts will do this. This is only true if your house has air leaks. If there's no way for fresh air to get in, the vents won't do anything. It would be a good idea to stub the vents for the HRV in before you spray foam.
 
If you look at the wikipedia link (where the quote was taken from), you will see that icynene is not benign either. As for the covered wires, wouldn't you agree that it's much easier to deal with batts than foam? Anyway, no reason to argue about anything here.

As for your idea to go with foam on headers and do the walls with batts - that was my preferred option, to be honest with you! I even had quotes for that scope. LOL But, since I was running out of time and had the crew already on site, I decided to go with foam and take my chances as for toxicity. We eat toxic, genetically modified food already, high in mercury and dioxin, breathe toxic air, drink toxic water and deal with toxic people on all levels. From what I see, I will not live long enough to be killed by the foam. :)

Not arguing at all.

I was just thinking about insulating my attic with foam too. I have an old house that has ice dam problems on the south face of the hip roof.

I have installed R44 Batt insulation in the attic myself (R12, R20 at 90 degrees, R12 again at 90 degrees).

The problem is that I cannot squeeze full batt insulation right to the top plate of the interior walls due to the lack of space between the top of the ceiling and the underside of the roof. So I was thinking of foaming it (my attic).

But then I was tinking, well, if I used Icynene, and the roof leaked, the water would soak right into the Icynene. That would not be good.

Then I was thinking, well, if I used Walltight, the water (from a roof leak) would not soak into the walltight, but it would sit right on top of it - what then?

Neither scenario is particularly appealing.
 
HomeDepot offers home reno courses on weekends. Actually this past weekend they had a basement reno course. They'll recommend what products work best. It's actually a really good way to go about it. Personally I'm waiting for the bathroom reno course. I'd like to redo my bathroom with tiled walls.
You can also check youtube for techniques on how to. You'd be surprised how much shit is on there.
 
HomeDepot offers home reno courses on weekends. Actually this past weekend they had a basement reno course. They'll recommend what products work best. It's actually a really good way to go about it. Personally I'm waiting for the bathroom reno course. I'd like to redo my bathroom with tiled walls.
You can also check youtube for techniques on how to. You'd be surprised how much shit is on there.

Just make sure you check with some real builders in regards to what they suggest. Home Depot doesn't hire knowledge like they used to when they first opened. I've heard one of their electrical "experts" referring to stove wire as "red-positive, black-negative, white-ground and the bare wire is just to help strengthen the cable". :)
 
If I understand the picture your words describe, you're not supposed to insulate that gap at the top of the exterior wall and below the roof deck at the eave.

I found a link from Alaska on how to deal with Ice-Dams. They recommended insulating the attic solid. After that, I vented the attic from the top, in such a way to gain appropriate airflow over the insulation. Worked like a charm on an 80 year old house.

Depending on the house construction, venting the attic through the eaves can be a really bad idea, and can cause severe problems. Same as adding insulation to a brick basement wall (as opposed to concrete). Older houses were designed to work a particular way. Techniques for new construction don't universally retrofit well.

Also, check out JTK's link: http://www.buildingscience.com/ It makes a great deal of engineering sense.
 
If you don't go with spray foam of some sort and you DO go with roxul or fiberglass, there is NO need nor benefit to tar paper or tyvek paper on the inside. None. It does nothing to seal and it is just another surface to collect moisture on.

If you really think you might have problems with moisture or water, then use Drylok paint. It soaks into the pores of the concrete, crystallizes and expands to seal up the pores. It is waterproof. It could seal your poured concrete basement into a swimming pool! Be aware that it soaks up into the concrete like you would NOT believe and you will use a 45 gallon drum of it! LOL!…
If you think you have problems with moisture/water do not rely on tarpaper, Tyvek™ or paint, or anything on the inside; problems mean 'dig you must'. The inside stuff is for natural, unstoppable processes that come short of being problems.

Starting with the paint (Disclosure: I painted my brick foundation, because I wanted it bright, not to keep it dry. For that I dug). If water's coming in the wall and the paint stops it, it doesn't go away. More water comes—they call the result pressure. Eventually the pressure finds the weakest point in the paint and as much of the water as can will try to obey the Law of Gravity and find it's way out there. You actually find water-filled blisters on painted basement walls—like mine, at least until the sodden bricks dried out—where that's happening. If the foundation is concrete block with the cores open, they'll potentially fill up with water.

Still that'll buy you a few more peaceful years than sealing a plastic bag to the wall to slowly fill up with whatever water has made it all the way thru (Bad Method). If you think plastic's a good idea, use it to protect the back side of the insulation, encapsulating it all nice and dry and keeping you warm during any floods. Seal it there, not to the wall.

On to the better Sheet Good Method: The theory of the housewrap, whether Tyvek™ or tarpaper is that it's vapour-permeable, but water shedding. Back behind the insulation vapour will condense into water (but thanks to the barrier on the warm side under the drywall, the vapour should only be arriving thru the concrete) Hopefully there's so little that it evaporates before it runs all the way down and out under your carpet. But at least there's no stored up backlog showing up after the dam burst. The paint and sheetgoods encourage the moisture not to hang around.

If one is determined to finish a basement, remember water always wins in the end. Make sure your chosen method can cope with whatever goes on behind all that expensive construction and decorating. At least until you're beyond any possibility of being the one to fix it. It'll be a success when it's only discovered as part of the next reno. And that's when you can praise the paint job.

But try to use ceramic tile and area rugs on the floor. Just in case. Can you say "Floor Drains" or "Sewer Backup"?
 
The OP said he wants to finish a basement and made NO mention of any water problems.

He said : Situation: Poured basement; 7 years old; no leaks; builders half wall blanket of plastic & insulation on all walls

Basements are big holes, and water flows downhill. Unless, you are on top of a hill, and are certain that your basement will not flood, don't every say the "no leaks" word.

One of the biggest mistakes in basements is assuming no previous leaks means no leaks for the life of the basement. Whatever you do, design the basement under the assumptions that:
1. The basement will get wet,
2. The water will need to drain, and
3. Water needs a safe place to drain.
If in a rural area, allow for the provision of a secondary pump, with a gas fired generator for backup power.