Banning Items to Save lives

Banning which of the following would save the most lives in the US?

  • "Assault" Weapons

    Votes: 6 24.0%
  • Cigarets

    Votes: 12 48.0%
  • Alcohol

    Votes: 2 8.0%
  • Cats

    Votes: 5 20.0%

  • Total voters
    25
You also dance back and forth between arguments.

On one hand you say assault style weapons don't kill enough people to warrant a ban.. Then on the other hand you say that too many assault style weapons will still be available to make a difference.

So which is it?

I'm not sure what you are confused about but if you put together a better sentence, one that I can understand, I would be happy to clarify.

Taking a guess at what you are after, I will just say this:

Assault type rifles like the AR-15 are incredibly common, one of those most popular rifles in the United States, owned by millions of people. They are, however, hardly ever used in crime and almost no-one is killed by them. Almost all of the gun crime in the United States is committed with a handgun, not any sort of rifle. Rifles just aren't popular with criminals because they cannot easily be concealed, so despite the extreme popularity of the AR-15, you just don't find it being used in crime very often.

What has drawn attention to it are the lighting-strike rare mass shootings that make massive headlines and generate all sorts of media interest, such as the Sandy Hook shooting. Despite the amount of press these events generate, they are incredibly rare events, and you have a much better chance of winning the lottery than of ever being the victim of such a thing.
 
Fear mongering. Last year rifles of all kinds killed 323 people in the United States, less than one in a million. And that includes hunting rifles and ordinary semi-automatics. "Assault type rifles" will be a fraction of those 323 shootings, depending on how you wind up defining that term.

So objectively this is not a problem. In fact almost no-one is killed, and you are just blathering away wholly disconnected from the objective reality that lightning strikes kill more people than assault rifles do.

Your the only one disconnected from reality my friend. By the way, lightning strikes killed 28 people last year. Per my math skills 28 lightning deaths is less then 323 rifle deaths. Also not sure if you aware but lightning as been around as long as the earth and its a natural thing. Its nature. A gun isnt. Cant believe you cant grasp that concept. Thats your whole problem. You cant admit to yourself that a gun is a dangerous tool designed to kill people and the US&A have a problem treating it as so. I wonder if you could have this converstation and stance with someone who lost a family member due to someone being irresponsible with a gun, look them in the eye and tell them its ok cause lightning kills alot of people as well. Guns are a fucking man made tool to kill someone, thats a fact that isnt fear mongering.
 
Lighting strikes kill an average of 50 people a year in the US, which is a higher number than are killed in mass shootings.

I see that you are just going on with the rhetoric "guns were made to kill so they must be very very very scary things", totally ignoring that 323 people out of 350 million is lottery odds. Never mind that a lot of those were killed with hunting rifles and that if you actually did ban "assault type rifles" (whatever that means) most of those people would just have some other kind of gun. How many lives do you figure would be saved? Do you think it would save "even one life"? I am not so sure.

Just how much mileage are you expecting to be able to get out of "guns are scary" without having to provide any data to justify your claim that they are in fact scary? If they are so scary and terrifying and if people are dying left right and center just at the thought of an assault rifle--well, why aren't we seeing that in reality?

Maybe because most guns are for target shooting and for hunting, and in fact you are just wholesale making it up when you say they are for killing people? I can tell you for a fact--and the RCMP and Chief Firearms Officer of Ontario will corroborate--that I own my guns for target shooting, not for killing people.
 
Lighting strikes kill an average of 50 people a year in the US, which is a higher number than are killed in mass shootings.

I see that you are just going on with the rhetoric "guns were made to kill so they must be very very very scary things", totally ignoring that 323 people out of 350 million is lottery odds. Never mind that a lot of those were killed with hunting rifles and that if you actually did ban "assault type rifles" (whatever that means) most of those people would just have some other kind of gun. How many lives do you figure would be saved? Do you think it would save "even one life"? I am not so sure.

Just how much mileage are you expecting to be able to get out of "guns are scary" without having to provide any data to justify your claim that they are in fact scary? If they are so scary and terrifying and if people are dying left right and center just at the thought of an assault rifle--well, why aren't we seeing that in reality?

Maybe because most guns are for target shooting and for hunting, and in fact you are just wholesale making it up when you say they are for killing people? I can tell you for a fact--and the RCMP and Chief Firearms Officer of Ontario will corroborate--that I own my guns for target shooting, not for killing people.

Guns are scary....what are we 8 years old? Scary lol. No, im going with the rhetoric that guns are dangerous. They were created for killing things and shoot bullets that travel 700mph that can penetrate your skull from distance. You see to be going with the rhetoric that since YOU only use your guns for target practice that they are perectly safe. They are not toys. How many people again shot themselves on gun appriciated day being all safe with firearms? Not even playing to shoot it? 11,000 people die from gun deaths a year in the states. The states has a problem with them. If a nutso civilians that wants to flip out could get there hands so easily on something more dangerous then a type of assault weapon weapon Im sure they would. If granades were as accessable as guns im sure they would be tossing these into schools instead to cause their carnage.
 
They were created for killing things and shoot bullets that travel 700mph that can penetrate your skull from distance.

Sounds sooooo scary. These scary things must be killing hundreds of thou... oh wait. 323.

Umm.....

You see to be going with the rhetoric that since YOU only use your guns for target practice that they are perectly safe.

My guns are perfectly safe because I handle them and use them in a safe way, but primarily, because like virtually all firearms owners I am not a criminal.

Not even playing to shoot it? 11,000 people die from gun deaths a year in the states.

You are playing a shell game: Those are handgun shootings. This thread was about a ban on a particular type of rifle. There were only 323 rifle homicides last year in the United States.
 
Let me point out something you guys are missing:

"Guns were designed to kill people" <-- this is just rhetoric, fluffy words, that mean nothing

"Cars actually kill people" <-- this is objective reality, people really die

1113 people have been killed by devices designed to kill people since the Newtown slaughter.
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/crime/2012/12/gun_death_tally_every_american_gun_death_since_newtown_sandy_hook_shooting.html

Other then hunting rifles, all other guns are designed to killed people.
Cars are designed to move people.

Considering how many cars there are in the US, and how often they are in use, they are much safer then guns.
 
1113 people have been killed by devices designed to kill people since the Newtown slaughter.

And about 2660 have died in car accidents.

Your 1113 figure will mostly be handguns, almost none of them will have been killed by rifles. The topic here was this claim that banning "assault rifles" would save lives--it won't.

As for the general problem with homicides in the US--and it is a problem--it appears to be more of a social problem than a gun problem. It appears to be the result of discrimination, inequality, drug trade, lack of educational opportunities, unemployment, insufficient social safety net, and whatever other factors there are that cause people to turn to crime.
 
And about 2660 have died in car accidents.

Your 1113 figure will mostly be handguns, almost none of them will have been killed by rifles. The topic here was this claim that banning "assault rifles" would save lives--it won't.

As for the general problem with homicides in the US--and it is a problem--it appears to be more of a social problem than a gun problem. It appears to be the result of discrimination, inequality, drug trade, lack of educational opportunities, unemployment, insufficient social safety net, and whatever other factors there are that cause people to turn to crime.

According to wiki, that's at about 1 death per 100 million miles traveled by cars, which would make them remarkably safe considered how much they are used.
That's 100 million miles of useful transportation per casualty.

For guns there appears to be no net value, since crime and incarceration rates in the US are humungous compared to most other western countries.
So that's 1,113 deaths for negligible social benefit.
Even with millions of guns around, it appears that Americans are far, far less safe then any other western country.
Such a waste.
 
There are more deaths per car than per gun and more per driver than per gun owner. The reason is that legal guns and legal gun owners don't kill people.

The problem is almost entirely illegal guns in the hands of criminals.

At any rate the topic is drifting to gun control in general. The topic here was assault rifles, which at hardly ever used.

323
 
There are more deaths per car than per gun and more per driver than per gun owner. The reason is that legal guns and legal gun owners don't kill people.

The problem is almost entirely illegal guns in the hands of criminals.

At any rate the topic is drifting to gun control in general. The topic here was assault rifles, which at hardly ever used.

323

The only reason is that most people don't carry with their guns to the store, take their guns to the movies and work and to drop off their kids at school each day.
What positive benefit do guns give American society?

You cannot answer that question honestly.
 
You are playing a shell game: Those are handgun shootings. This thread was about a ban on a particular type of rifle. There were only 323 rifle homicides last year in the United States.

Actually if you look at the poll this thread was about "Assault Weapons" not Assault Rifles. At some point we all got caught up with "Assault Rifles" but the original question was about "Assault Weapons". "Assault Weapons" (based on the previous US ban on them) often included many types of handguns.
 
The topic here was this claim that banning "assault rifles" would save lives--it won't.

You're straying from your argument again. Here, I'll help you stay on track.

You're claiming that the AMOUNT of lives saved by eliminating "assault rifles" is negligible and therefore NOT worth the effort. Or do you really think that not ONE SINGLE LIFE would be spared as a result of an Assault Rifle ban. If so, then you should probably stop ending your posts with "323".
 
There are more deaths per car than per gun and more per driver than per gun owner. The reason is that legal guns and legal gun owners don't kill people.

The problem is almost entirely illegal guns in the hands of criminals.

At any rate the topic is drifting to gun control in general. The topic here was assault rifles, which at hardly ever used.

323

Fuji I can see you new best friend is straw man.
 
You're straying from your argument again. Here, I'll help you stay on track.

You're claiming that the AMOUNT of lives saved by eliminating "assault rifles" is negligible and therefore NOT worth the effort. Or do you really think that not ONE SINGLE LIFE would be spared as a result of an Assault Rifle ban. If so, then you should probably stop ending your posts with "323".

I think not one life would be saved, those who would have used an AR15 will just use a semi automatic hunting rifle as Lepine and Breivik did.

I am also pointing our that the numbers potentially in play the don't justify a national policy in the first place.

323
 
The only reason is that most people don't carry with their guns to the store, take their guns to the movies and work and to drop off their kids at school each day.
What positive benefit do guns give American society?

You cannot answer that question honestly.

Shooting is a sport and has all the benefits of any sport. If you disagree take it up with the IOC which has recognized shooting sports by including several shooting events in the Olympics.
 
Absolutely. The number of activities that we would have to ban if you went after every theoretically preventable death with a higher mortality rate is huge. Swimming kills ten times more people, so let's just ban that. People going out on public transit when they have a cough--kills more people (and kills other people). We simply flat out accept this level of mortality for commonplace activities.

You are fear mongering, failing to apply the same risk tolerances to shooting sports as you apply to other sports, and to human activity in general.

Just to put this in clearer terms, it's a death rate of 0.1 deaths per 100000 people.
When there's a shooting sports thread, I might offer my opinion about what risks we can tolerate in that sport, but so far we've had only general treads about the appropriateness of guns in society and their regulation, whether by outright prohibition as in this thread or some particular ban by distinguishing purpose or mechanical type such as the assault rifle technobabble, or simple administrative measure such as registration. And then there's the whole muddiness of Canadians and Americans with their entirely different laws and historical attitudes imagining they can discuss anything as broadly contentious as guns.

Like most folks, I'm in no way techically qualified to propose specific gun laws or regulations, nor have I done so here or in the other threads. But like any citizen I am fully qualified to have an opinion on the matter, and offer it to the judgement of others, and to judge theirs and the logioc and evidence they offer. I see no reason why the onus should not be on those who want to own and use deadly weapons to prove their qualifications, demonstrate all aspects of their safe handling, register their ownership with the authorities and prove they are continuing their responsible ownership and use of their deadly weapons.

As with Aardvark's hammers, your lightning strikes analogy is poorly chosen and misdirected. Most of the hammers in the world were never intended as weapons (I'm sure a handful were acquired for that purpose but far fewer than lightning strikes), and people all over the worrd do everything they know how to avoid lightning killing anyone. Apart from the few guns designed and built for targets—you'd know better than I why they must nonetheless use lethal ammunition instead of other accuracy-determining means like lasers—the purpose of any gun is to kill.

But no one walks into a store and says I need lightning for self-protection, or to hunt with. At that point and after we can better protect ourselves from guns than we ever can from storms. Why shouldn't we, if we choose to?

And if we ever get drowning deaths below lighting strike numbers does that mean we can do without lifeguards, swimming lessons and water safety classes?
 
I think not one life would be saved, those who would have used an AR15 will just use a semi automatic hunting rifle as Lepine and Breivik did.

I am also pointing our that the numbers potentially in play the don't justify a national policy in the first place.

323

How do you know that the semi-automatic hunting rifles that Lepine and Breivik used WON'T be banned as well? You actually don't. You're assuming they won't but so far we haven't heard exactly what sort of guns the new potential ban would ban (or how).

So NOW your argument is that the ban won't work, because you don't think the "ban" will include all the guns necessary to have any effect.

It also sounds like you agree with ME. That a proper ban WOULD save lives.

Thank you Fuji. It's nice when somebody can admit that they were wrong.
 
How do you know that the semi-automatic hunting rifles that Lepine and Breivik used WON'T be banned as well? You actually don't. You're assuming they won't but so far we haven't heard exactly what sort of guns the new potential ban would ban (or how).

So NOW your argument is that the ban won't work, because you don't think the "ban" will include all the guns necessary to have any effect.

It also sounds like you agree with ME. That a proper ban WOULD save lives.

Thank you Fuji. It's nice when somebody can admit that they were wrong.

There is no proposal to ban hunting rifles currently being considered and such a proposal would be deeply unpopular.

Even in Canada where we implemented restrictions on the AR15 the ruger mini remains a non restricted firearm.

And no I do not think there it's a any evidence gun control works, I simply pointed out that even if you thought it did assault rifle homicides are rare.