Ban Firearms and. . . .

firearm-OECD-UN-data3.jpg

Notice the fine print on there, the chart excludes Mexico. If it included more countries the data would be rather skewed and not paint the picture some what it to show. It's a non argument that places with guns will have more gun homicides. Now go find the same data for violent crime per 100K people. Picking out a single factoid and not looking at whole picture is misleading at best and down right deceptive at worst.

Does this data distinguish suicide from homicide? It's reported that some 80% of gun deaths are the result of suicide.
 
Notice the fine print on there, the chart excludes Mexico. If it included more countries the data would be rather skewed and not paint the picture some what it to show. It's a non argument that places with guns will have more gun homicides. Now go find the same data for violent crime per 100K people. Picking out a single factoid and not looking at whole picture is misleading at best and down right deceptive at worst.

Does this data distinguish suicide from homicide? It's reported that some 80% of gun deaths are the result of suicide.

The author of the article mention why Mexico wasn't included. Sounds like a good reason to me.

I did not include Mexico, which has about triple the U.S. rate due in large part to the ongoing drug war.

As for your suicide question, homicide is not suicide, so suicide is not included in the chart.
 
In Canada that is probably true but how many mass rampage knifings have you heard about around the world?

So in 2011 in the US there were 323 people killed with rifles of all types and 1,694 killed with knives, and over twice as many people were killed with fists as with rifles. Yes, it's very sensational headline grabbing news when somebody goes on a mass killing spree, but you have better odds of winning a lottery jackpot than being a victim of something like that. Now handguns are a different story--you're much more likely to be taken out by a handgun than win the lottery. And again, you are twice as likely to die in a fist fight, than be killed by a rifle.

Oh, and assault rilfles would only be a fraction of those 323 rifle deaths, but since there is no consistent definition of "assault rifle" it is hard to say how many of the 323 would count as "assault rifles" versus "hunting rifles". If assault rifle means fully automatic military service rifle it's probably a fraction of a percent, but if it means any semi-automatic huntingrifle then maybe most of them. Nobody seems to be able to decide exactly what an assault rifle is--but the upper limit is 323 deaths for ALL types of rifles.

http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/uc....-2011/tables/expanded-homicide-data-table-11

The general reason why rifles are not often used as a murder weapon is that they are big and bulky and cannot be concealed. Walking down Yonge street with an AK-47 slung over your shoulder tends to attract a lot of attention, so murderers tend to use concealable weapons--handguns or knives, not rifles or swords.
 
Oldjones, since you want to discuss constructive points let us go to the realm of the practical.

Given the number of firearms in the U.S. even the ones that Senator Feinstein proposes to confiscate at the death of the owner, how realistic are proposals such as you mention? One need only look at the history of prohibition in Canada and particularly the U.S.A. to see how such matters actually play out: widespread disrespect for and disregard of the law, a huge rise in organized criminality, significant enforcement costs with very little real result and the honest possibility of insurrection were the government to actively move in this direction (During the life of the Volstead Law, existing stocks of privately owned liquor were grandfathered) there were not ATF (at the time Bureau of Prohibition) agents running around trying to confiscate privately owned property when the previous owner died as the Senator has proposed.

The U.S. is not the U.K., further as the article shows, even in the U.K. it is merely the method of murder that has shifted. As to your point about mass murders although every murder is a tragedy, mass shootings are statistically infinitesimal.

As already posted in one of these threads, universal background checks are likely to be made law, something about mental health issues unfortunately less likely due to costs to states ("the unfunded mandate thing"). I rather doubt that Magazine limits or even cosmetic lists of firearms can make it out of the Senate let alone the House of Representatives.
 
So in 2011 in the US there were 323 people killed with rifles of all types and 1,694 killed with knives, and over twice as many people were killed with fists as with rifles. Yes, it's very sensational headline grabbing news when somebody goes on a mass killing spree, but you have better odds of winning the lottery than being a victim of something like that. Now handguns are a different story--you're much more likely to be taken out by a handgun than win the lottery.

Oh, and assault rilfles would only be a fraction of those 323 rifle deaths, but since there is no consistent definition of "assault rifle" it is hard to say how many of the 323 would count as "assault rifles" versus "hunting rifles".

http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/uc....-2011/tables/expanded-homicide-data-table-11
And of course that last distinction is only part of the debate because of the resistance of the gun fanatics to any regulation. If they can't stop the debate, they can derail it arguing over technicalities of gunsmithery. What distinguishes an assault rifle is that it was designed and perfected as an assault weapon. Crap like whther that means it must have flash-suppressors and pistol grips is the kind of detail necessary for legal drafting of statutes, but as the Supreme Court Judge said of pornography, we ordinary folk may not be able to define it, but we know what it is when we see it. No one 'needs' an assault rifle in any ordinary, civilized society.
 
And of course that last distinction is only part of the debate because of the resistance of the gun fanatics to any regulation. If they can't stop the debate, they can derail it arguing over technicalities of gunsmithery. What distinguishes an assault rifle is that it was designed and perfected as an assault weapon. Crap like whther that means it must have flash-suppressors and pistol grips is the kind of detail necessary for legal drafting of statutes, but as the Supreme Court Judge said of pornography, we ordinary folk may not be able to define it, but we know what it is when we see it. No one 'needs' an assault rifle in any ordinary, civilized society.

It's too bad this is an anonymous forum because I have a rifle that I would otherwise show you. The physical rifle is essentially a pipe with a trigger mechanism and magazine system at one end, and that fits into a stock. All the "I know it when I see it" stuff you are talking about is a feature of the stock, not the rifle. I can put that metal tube into a nice walnut stock in traditional hunting style and it will look like a hunting rifle. I can take the same rifle and put it into a black fibreglass stock with a pistol grip, mounting rails, and attachment points for military style slings and you will say "OMG assault rifle!"

But it is in fact the same rifle. Once you have a semi-automatic rifle with a box magazine you can shoot the same number of the same rounds in the same time, no matter whether you dress it up in a nice wooden hunting stock, or put it in a fibreglass military style stock.

So you may reply that you want to ban all semi-automatic rifles, and some jurisdictions have tried that--but they are incredibly popular hunting rifles, routinely dressed up in wood, and nobody thinks of them as an "assault rifle" and nobody is proposing to ban any of those things.

So really, you are talking about a ban on the types of plastic, wood, or fibreglass that a rifle can be put into, and really nothing whatsoever to do with the capability of the rifle itself.

At the end of the day unless you are talking about restricting the types of actions that can be used, you aren't really limiting the functionality of the rifle. Fully automatic, semi-automatic, bolt action, lever action, pump action, revolving action, or muzzle-loaded musket. That is basically the playing field, and everything else is just about how you dress it up.

Let's say you ban semi-automatics. Would you also go after cowboy style lever action rifles? With a day's practice you can learn to work that lever really fast. Ditto a pump action shotgun, once you practice a few times, you can cycle that action quickly and get off fairly rapid shots. Revolvers also, most commonly pistols but potentially can be made as rifles, also allow fairly rapid repeat fire. Even a bolt action can be fired pretty quickly with a good bolt and some practice--soldiers in WW1 and WW2 were able to sustain pretty high rates of fire from their Lee-Enfield bolt action rifles.
 
And of course that last distinction is only part of the debate because of the resistance of the gun fanatics to any regulation. If they can't stop the debate, they can derail it arguing over technicalities of gunsmithery. What distinguishes an assault rifle is that it was designed and perfected as an assault weapon. Crap like whther that means it must have flash-suppressors and pistol grips is the kind of detail necessary for legal drafting of statutes, but as the Supreme Court Judge said of pornography, we ordinary folk may not be able to define it, but we know what it is when we see it. No one 'needs' an assault rifle in any ordinary, civilized society.
If I have a 25 round box magazine and a flash suppressor on my deer rifle does that make it "an assault rifle?" If I have a fiberglass stock and a pistol grip but no flash suppressor and a eight round magazine on an AR-15 does that make it look any less like an AR-15?

__________

I see that Fuji put this even better above!
 
It's too bad this is an anonymous forum because I have a rifle that I would otherwise show you. The physical rifle is essentially a pipe with a trigger mechanism and magazine system at one end, and that fits into a stock. All the "I know it when I see it" stuff you are talking about is a feature of the stock, not the rifle. I can put that metal tube into a nice walnut stock in traditional hunting style and it will look like a hunting rifle. I can take the same rifle and put it into a black fibreglass stock with a pistol grip, mounting rails, and attachment points for military style slings and you will say "OMG assault rifle!"

But it is in fact the same rifle. Once you have a semi-automatic rifle with a box magazine you can shoot the same number of the same rounds in the same time, no matter whether you dress it up in a nice wooden hunting stock, or put it in a fibreglass military style stock.

So you may reply that you want to ban all semi-automatic rifles, and some jurisdictions have tried that--but they are incredibly popular hunting rifles, routinely dressed up in wood, and nobody thinks of them as an "assault rifle" and nobody is proposing to ban any of those things.

So really, you are talking about a ban on the types of plastic, wood, or fibreglass that a rifle can be put into, and really nothing whatsoever to do with the capability of the rifle itself.

At the end of the day unless you are talking about restricting the types of actions that can be used, you aren't really limiting the functionality of the rifle. Fully automatic, semi-automatic, bolt action, lever action, pump action, revolving action, or muzzle-loaded musket. That is basically the playing field, and everything else is just about how you dress it up.
All well and good, but I am not talking about banning assault rifles or any particular weapon.I have examined with enough guns and chatted enough with the armorers supplying them that I didn't need you telling me the action matters more then the appearance. As I said above, the distinction is a phoney distraction raised by gun-fanatics to derail debate in thickets of technical detail. They are the ones doing most of the talk about bans. The rest of the population just wants good sense to play a larger role in who buys what.

Asked for my opinion, I'd say that the onus should be on the gun-owner to prove fitness to own and lawful and appropriate purpose for owning every and any gun. Essentially they'd all be treated as we treat restricted weapons. That bar of proof could be set at varying levels depending on the specific weapon—unlike jurisdictions hampered by a Second Amendment, we can make such determinations administratively and technically—and on the owner and their circumstances. So an actual hunter buying a deer rifle, and a guy buying an AK-47 would have to meet different criteria, just as we already do if someone wants to buy pistols.
 
If I have a 25 round box magazine and a flash suppressor on my deer rifle does that make it "an assault rifle?" If I have a fiberglass stock and a pistol grip but no flash suppressor and a eight round magazine on an AR-15 does that make it look any less like an AR-15?

If your 'deer rifle' is a semi automatic, in my mind, it could be. How easy it it to convert to full auto? Can a bayonet be mounted on it? I've met plenty of very successful hunters, professional or otherwise, that have no need for a 25 round clip. They are obviously better shots than the rest.
 
If I have a 25 round box magazine and a flash suppressor on my deer rifle does that make it "an assault rifle?" If I have a fiberglass stock and a pistol grip but no flash suppressor and a eight round magazine on an AR-15 does that make it look any less like an AR-15?

__________

I see that Fuji put this even better above!
As if any of that mattered. What does matter is whether you bought all that stuff to legally shoot your allotted deer in season. What matters is that you didn't let your sixteen-year old take it down to the kindergarten to see what it would do when he shot children.

What would certainly help would be making you—that'd be the fictional you who imagines tarting up a deer rifle to play Rambo is sensible—think laonger and harder before buying such weaponry in the first place. What did Mrs. Lanza imagine she was gonna do with her two pistols and the Bushmaster? Whoever bothered to ask her? Why wasn't she concerned enough about her safety—if not from her son, then the ATF, the Staties, the local Sherrif, or someone responsible—and others to store the damn things properly? Those are the issues, not some stupidity about what shape makes something a pistol-grip.
 
The answer on my submission to the RCMP as to why I needed an "assault type rifle" (it's not called that) was "target practice" though I equally could have put down "collector" as I would meet the criteria of a collector (a demonstrated interest in the history of that type of firearm etc.)

Extending that sort of regime to all rifles was essentially what the long gun registry went after, and the primary reason why it failed was that it's just not relevant or useful. So few crimes are committed with rifles that there's no point in spending all the money and engaging all the police resources required to keep track of them. Having police review and approve transfers is not for free, much less engaging investigative resources sufficient to keep people honest--taxpayers pay for it, and when there isn't any value there, taxpayers get grumpy.

It is worth pointing out that it was primarily taxpayer lobby groups that killed the gun registry, the actual gun lobby groups themselves did not bring nearly as much in the way of resources to that fight as the Canadian Taxpayers Federation etc. did
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Assault_Weapons_Ban

Quote:

"The Federal Assault Weapons Ban expired on September 13, 2004, as part of the law's sunset provision. There have been multiple attempts to renew the ban,[SUP][2][/SUP] but no bill has reached the House floor for a vote"

That still doesn;t allow you to go get a fully automatic assault weapon as some would believe. The "assault weapon ban" you are speaking of was enacted in 1994 and expired in 2004. It was based on appearance, didn't truly ban "assault weapons" as they were already pretty much banned. If you bothered to scroll half way down the page you would have found this out yourself. You would have also known this had you actually had real interest in the topic, and not just looking for "facts" to back up your point of view.

"The term, assault weapon, when used in the context of assault weapon laws refers primarily (but not exclusively) to semi-automatic firearms that possess the cosmetic features of an assault rifle that is fully automatic."

This is a perfect example of politicians "appearing" to be doing something, when in reality its just a show.


Are you guys starting to see the stupidity of all these laws yet?
 
That's exactly what I was referring to, cosmetic is included in that ban and I agree with it, some don't. It appears the appearance of these semi-automatic rifles, ie. AR 15, is the weapon of choice for young, mentally ill males, so I'm ok with banning them, plus the fact they can be converted.

Unlike others on this board, I like to back it up with facts and not just blow rhetorical comments based on beliefs.
 
That's exactly what I was referring to, cosmetic is included in that ban and I agree with it, some don't. It appears the appearance of these semi-automatic rifles, ie. AR 15, is the weapon of choice for young, mentally ill males, so I'm ok with banning them, plus the fact they can be converted.

Unlike others on this board, I like to back it up with facts and not just blow rhetorical comments based on beliefs.

They can be converted the same way a honda civic can be converted to a ferrari.

So do you think making it less "appealing" is the goal here? If thats what you're saying than i can kind of see your argument here, doesn't change the fact that you can cause just as much damage with a semi auto rifle that looks like a hunting rifle though
 
That's exactly what I was referring to, cosmetic is included in that ban and I agree with it, some don't. It appears the appearance of these semi-automatic rifles, ie. AR 15, is the weapon of choice for young, mentally ill males, so I'm ok with banning them, plus the fact they can be converted.

Unlike others on this board, I like to back it up with facts and not just blow rhetorical comments based on beliefs.

Its not "included" as you said, its the whole basis of the ban.

And everything ive said i backed up with facts, so i dunno who you're referring to
 
That's exactly what I was referring to, cosmetic is included in that ban and I agree with it, some don't. It appears the appearance of these semi-automatic rifles, ie. AR 15, is the weapon of choice for young, mentally ill males, so I'm ok with banning them, plus the fact they can be converted.

Unlike others on this board, I like to back it up with facts and not just blow rhetorical comments based on beliefs.

Since you like to back it up with facts, can I see your facts for "is the weapon of choice for young, mentally ill males".

Breivik and Lepine used semi-automatic rifles that were in hunting rifle form. Virginia Tech and Columbine mass shooters used pistols. Despite all the hoopla after the Montreal Massacre and the reclassification of "assault type rifles" as restricted in the aftermath of that shooting the actual rifle used by Lepine is still a non-restricted hunting rifle and not a restricted weapon.

There doesn't really seem to be much justification for your view other than the two most recent shooters happened to use the AR-15. Meanwhile there are a few million lawful owners of the AR-15 who have never shot anybody.
 
I get the thinking behind gun control...I know you think it will make things better. But even if you ban guns, they won't disappear. The people who commit mass killings and other crimes are going to find the weapons they want no matter what. It's easy to make bombs with some very simple ingredients, arson probably could kill a bunch of folks too, airplanes have been used as well. Guns aren't the only way to kill lots of people.

But when you try to use laws to make people behave...it's not going to work. The only people who would give up their guns if they were banned would be the law-abiding citizens. The criminals would probably hang on to theirs.
 
I get the thinking behind gun control...I know you think it will make things better. But even if you ban guns, they won't disappear. The people who commit mass killings and other crimes are going to find the weapons they want no matter what. It's easy to make bombs with some very simple ingredients, arson probably could kill a bunch of folks too, airplanes have been used as well. Guns aren't the only way to kill lots of people.

But when you try to use laws to make people behave...it's not going to work. The only people who would give up their guns if they were banned would be the law-abiding citizens. The criminals would probably hang on to theirs.

god damn, somebody who gets it!