Ban Cinelli Yes or No

basketcase said:
Until he comes out directly saying "Jews are (insert racial epithet)" or something of the like, there is no legal recourse, just an appeal to the opinions of the mods.


I was waiting for someone to suggest this. If anyone posts material on the board that is anti Jewish or Israel, lets prosecute them. Great idea Basketcase! So much for the open exchange of differing views. Fortunately we have a board here that allows everyone to express their opinion.
 
It seems that you have no problem with a statement like that I mentioned.

You also seem fixated on this as no one here has suggested criticism of Israeli politics is wrong. Cinelli goes beyond that with his attacks.

What could be prosecuted is if he is seen as inciting racial hatred. That would get him in deep, regardless of whether it was targeting Jews, Muslims, Blacks, Whites, or whoever. If that were to happen, the board's ownership would also be liable so I assume they would act at that point if not before.

Basically you are allowed to express your agreement with cinelli's opinion and be as up front as he is.
 
Oh, and by the way Assoholic, your handle is perfect.

..oh and by the way you sound like a little fag,
because you do not have
enough knowledge to debate him you want to ban him.
Well before I did not care what you thought because you have not
been here long enough.
Now I could care less because you sound like a little bitch,
an ignorant stupid little bitch.
 
basketcase said:
It seems that you have no problem with a statement like that I mentioned.

You also seem fixated on this as no one here has suggested criticism of Israeli politics is wrong. Cinelli goes beyond that with his attacks.


I am fixated?? Anytime Cinelli submits a post, you feverishly jump on it in a pathetic attempt to discredit his view. Cinelli taunts you the way a cat plays with a wounded mouse. If you think Cinelli's posts are so outrageous and unbelievable, why don't you simply ignore him?



basketcase said:
What could be prosecuted is if he is seen as inciting racial hatred. That would get him in deep, regardless of whether it was targeting Jews, Muslims, Blacks, Whites, or whoever. If that were to happen, the board's ownership would also be liable so I assume they would act at that point if not before.

Please provide me with specific examples of where he promotes racial hatred.


basketcase said:
Basically you are allowed to express your agreement with cinelli's opinion and be as up front as he is.

How can we express our agreement with Cinelli's opinions if we ban him as you and your obsequious cohorts suggest?
 
Dev0 said:
basketcase said:
You also seem fixated on this as no one here has suggested criticism of Israeli politics is wrong.
I am fixated?? Anytime Cinelli submits a post, you feverishly jump on it in a pathetic attempt to discredit his view. Cinelli taunts you the way a cat plays with a wounded mouse. If you think Cinelli's posts are so outrageous and unbelievable, why don't you simply ignore him?
You are the one who claims someone here is saying criticism of Israel is wrong. I seem to have missed that post.




Dev0 said:
Please provide me with specific examples of where he promotes racial hatred.
Re-read what I wrote. I'll highlight the relevant information.
basketcase said:
What could be prosecuted is if he is seen as inciting racial hatred.
Is that clear enough?

Dev0 said:
How can we express our agreement with Cinelli's opinions if we ban him as you and your obsequious cohorts suggest?
Please show me where I said we should ban him.

You are as sad as cinelli in your attempts to mislead people.
 
assoholic said:
Oh, and by the way Assoholic, your handle is perfect.

..oh and by the way you sound like a little fag,
because you do not have
enough knowledge to debate him you want to ban him.
Well before I did not care what you thought because you have not
been here long enough.
Now I could care less because you sound like a little bitch,
an ignorant stupid little bitch.
You sound pretty sad needing to insult the guy instead of debating him.

Come back when you have more posts.
 
Naw, that would show him too much attention...

OTB
 
basketcase said:
You sound pretty sad needing to insult the guy instead of debating him.

Come back when you have more posts.

.what debate, tinkerbell shows up and decides
who should be banned.
And you are one to talk.
Any criticism of anything to do with Isreal
and you scream "anti-semite"
 
Honestly, I don’t know if Cinelli should be banned or not because I’ve never actually read any of his posts.

I don’t read them because judging by the titles, they are nothing more than the evil Zionist conspiracy theory crap and I don’t need to waste my time reading such drivel. There are other member’s posts that I don’t read either for similar reasons. I think they’re single demensional and foolish but that doesn’t mean that they should be banned.

We still have free speech in this country and that gives people the right to express any ideas that they want. It also gives the rest of us the right to hear those ideas and make up our own minds.

Free speech does not give anyone the right to make abusive, insulting comments about individuals or groups of individuals. It does not give anyone the right to tell anyone else to abuse anyone either.

If Cinelli or anyone on this board focuses on criticizing ideas and behavior then I think that’s fair game. If he attacks the people personally, then that’s wrong.

So, if all Cinelli says is, “Jews do bad things” then he shouldn’t be banned.

If Cinelli says, “Jews ARE bad.” Then he should be warned and if he still persists then he should be banned.

If Cinelli says, “I hate Jews.” Then he is expressing an opinion, albeit a repulsive one.

If Cinelli says, “I hate Jews. You should too.” Then he is inciting hatred and that’s unacceptable.


Having free speech means that sometimes you’re going to read and hear things that you don’t agree with. I recommend that you do what I do: Just ignore them.
 
DonQuixote said:
...and require thoughtful responses.

You're expecting too much.
 
basketcase said:
You are the one who claims someone here is saying criticism of Israel is wrong. I seem to have missed that post.





Re-read what I wrote. I'll highlight the relevant information.

Is that clear enough?


Please show me where I said we should ban him.

You are as sad as cinelli in your attempts to mislead people.

Basketcase it appears that we have some common ground. To summarize your post we both agree that fair criticism of Jews-Israel is acceptable, that Cinelli's posts do not promote racial hatred, and that Cinelli should not be banned.
 
How can some of you be such fucking idiots ????

It is a privately owned board -there is no fucking free speech rights for godsake.

The only issue is if the mods are rational enough and if the owner has any sense of right and wrong as this Cinelli is obviously spreading hate literature on this board.

IF the board was mine ( which thank god it ain't ) I would erase his posts and him ( Cinelli ) because it proves the thought process of the mods and the owners is quite irrational imo ,as they allow him to post.
 
Hank Reardon said:
How can some of you be such fucking idiots ????

It is a privately owned board -there is no fucking free speech rights for godsake.

The only issue is if the mods are rational enough and if the owner has any sense of right and wrong as this Cinelli is obviously spreading hate literature on this board.

IF the board was mine ( which thank god it ain't ) I would erase his posts and him ( Cinelli ) because it proves the thought process of the mods and the owners is quite irrational imoas they allow him to post.



You must agree then with the Censorship methods employed by Chapters/Indigo. That is sad.:confused:
 
Hank Reardon said:
Sorry, what do you mean please ?



As a stauch ADL/ JDF'er heather and her minions do not allow Mein Kamf to be sold in their stores.

Heather's picks, My ass.


hey thats funny:D
 
Oh for heaven's sake.

Open up your own book store and sell whatever you want.

We can give all the advise to the ownership and moderators here, but the decision belongs to them. What books Indigo sells is entirely up to their leadership too - the case isn't any different. Feel free to petition them on it - but it's their decision to make.

And jeezus, it's not like Mein Kampf will be flying off their shelves if there. Indigo is a business hoping to be profitable (duh).

The issues here are pretty simple.
 
TQM said:
Open up your own book store and sell whatever you want.

We can give all the advise to the ownership and moderators here, but the decision belongs to them. What books Indigo sells is entirely up to their leadership too - the case isn't any different. Feel free to petition them on it - but it's their decision to make.

And jeezus, it's not like Mein Kampf will be flying off their shelves if there. Indigo is a business hoping to be profitable (duh).

The issues here are pretty simple.


The issues here are not simple, but some of the posters are, you might reflect on that point awhile.:D

I have no desire to own a bookstore.

my point is that the self-righteous over the top pontification on "rights" by the ADL/JDF supporters is all the more precious as its so one sided.
 
Jews have always supported other causes, not only Jewish issues.

Martin Luther King ( god rest his soul) would attest to this.