Assemble your ALL-TIME Maple Leafs team

[MyHobbyist]

Who would be on your all-time Maple Leafs team?

- select 3 forwards, 2 defense, & 1 goalie
- you can pick any players who at least played 1 game for the Leafs (dead or alive)
- assume all players are in their prime (even if their prime years were not with the Leafs)

Would a team with your 6 players win a Stanley Cup today?


MINE:

Forwards: Sundin, Gilmour, Mahovlich
Defense: Tim Horton, Phaneuf
Goalie: CUJO

 

[Celticman]

Forwards: Teeder Kennedy, Sittler, Mahovlich
Defense: Tim Horton, Borje Salming
Goalie: Turk Broda

 

[shack]

Forwards: Teeder Kennedy, Sittler, Mahovlich
Defense: Tim Horton, Borje Salming
Goalie: Turk Broda

That's not bad. I'd have to make Keon one of the forwards.

 

[alwayslooking]

Boy it doesn't say much for the Leafs if Phaneuf is one of the top 2 defenseman in team history. I don't think he'd be top 2 in Flames history.

 

[GPIDEAL]

That's not bad. I'd have to make Keon one of the forwards.

Absolutely!!!!!! One of my all-time favourite Leafs and hockey players is Davey Keon!

 

[dirkd101]

D; Todd Gill, Brad Marsh
G; Vesa Toskala
F; Kris King, Kent Manderville, Tie Domi

 

[bullitt]

D; Todd Gill, Brad Marsh
G; Vesa Toskala
F; Kris King, Kent Manderville, Tie Domi

you forgot mike pelyk.

 

[Rockslinger]

I think there are more Leafs in the HOF than from any other team.

 

[wigglee]

F: Luca Caputi, John Kordic, Edward Shack
D: Ian Turnbull, Mike Komisarek
G: Jiri Crha

 

[rags]

clark sundin big m horton salming bower

 

[Ironhead]

D; Todd Gill, Brad Marsh
G; Vesa Toskala
F; Kris King, Kent Manderville, Tie Domi

F: Luca Caputi, John Kordic, Edward Shack
D: Ian Turnbull, Mike Komisarek
G: Jiri Crha

You two are trying hard .... not to win.





My all time Leaf team.
Gilmour, Kessel, Sittler
Horton, Carlyle
Cheevers


Kessel, would like to see him with a good center.
I considered Fs Roberts and Henderson, D Salming

 

[shack]

F: Luca Caputi, John Kordic, Edward Shack
D: Ian Turnbull, Mike Komisarek
G: Jiri Crha

Shack and Turnbull were the 2 NHL caliber players out of that group.

 

[Rockslinger]

This is before your time but allow me to tell you about Harvey "Busher" Jackson, the greatest Maple Leaf ever.

 

[MyHobbyist]

This is before your time but allow me to tell you about Harvey "Busher" Jackson, the greatest Maple Leaf ever.

I think way before my time

 

[gcostanza]

Alex Mogilny
Dave Keon
Mats Sundin

Brian Leetch
Borje Salming

Bernie Parent

 

[revolver]

Sittler, Sundin, Mahovlich
Salming, Turnbull
Potvin

 

[wigglee]

ok...here is my real list

Big M, Sundin, Ullman
Salming , Leetch
Sawchuk

 

[dirkd101]

Why hasn't Aki Berg been picked by anyone?

New D, Aki Berg, Bryan McCabe

 

[nondescriptive]

Goalie-Bernie Parent

Defense-Borje Salming, Ian Turnbull

RW-Lanny MacDonald

C-Darryl Sittler

LW-Frank Mahovlich

 

[rags]

does anyone know when cheevers played for the leafs?