Are personal trainers worth it?

YYZguy

Member
Aug 19, 2001
525
6
18
29,000 feet and climbing
Fellow Terbite -

Hoping for feedback on the value of personal trainers.

I go through cycles of being reasonably fit to reasonably complacent, but lately, I have been fairly good at going to the gym.

However, I seem to have hit a plateau.

So I was wondering if anyone has used a personal trainer before and what their feedback is? And also a sense of what the cost would be?

I do have a very chaotic and unpredicatable work schedule so I'd be looking for a trainer who is extremely flexible and I could likely only commit to once a week (I go to the gym more, but at all different days and times).

Thanks - YYZGuy
 
Most PT..like a regimented schedule...but there are some who will work within your restrictions.....If you hit a plateau......take 1-2 weeks off.....no lifting whatsoever.....
when you get back to lifting.......totally change things up...if you did chest/Bi..on monday...do them on thursday..shoulders/tri's on tues....do them on Fri.
or instead of push/pull exercises on one area...try it on another.....

or spend a 4-6 week schedule doing the big 3.....bench..squat..D/L...adding 5lbs per workout...max out on reps to failure...MON/WED/FRI.......and cardio the off days...except on squat days....the last thing you'll want to do is cardio after a squat session..

good luck....hangin an bangin...
 
A Good Trainer is a Rare Find

Fellow Terbite -

However, I seem to have hit a plateau.

So I was wondering if anyone has used a personal trainer before and what their feedback is? And also a sense of what the cost would be?

Thanks - YYZGuy

I would say 95 percent of personal trainers are a complete waste of time at the big fitness chains. To see if they are worth it, look at what they have done for themselves and their clients. I had a 135 lbs kid named Kerry at Extreme Fitness with not even 13 inch arms talking like he was the God of muscle, and knowledge. Half the trainers don't look like they work out at all. The big chains pay them very little, so your more intelligent people tend to avoid the industry, or go out on their own.

You might find the rare gem, and it will cost you, but perhaps it is worth it.
 
I see a PT weekly, albeit at the same time and day every week. Cost is 60$ for an hour session. I find it helpful, although not for the same reasons you are looking for. This kid is training for bodybuilding comps, so he doesn't fit in the same category that Keanu is referring to.
 
Most PT..like a regimented schedule...but there are some who will work within your restrictions.....If you hit a plateau......take 1-2 weeks off.....no lifting whatsoever.....
when you get back to lifting.......totally change things up...if you did chest/Bi..on monday...do them on thursday..shoulders/tri's on tues....do them on Fri.
or instead of push/pull exercises on one area...try it on another.....

or spend a 4-6 week schedule doing the big 3.....bench..squat..D/L...adding 5lbs per workout...max out on reps to failure...MON/WED/FRI.......and cardio the off days...except on squat days....the last thing you'll want to do is cardio after a squat session..

good luck....hangin an bangin...


5lbs per workout is fine for more seasoned athletes. For the average individual ( I would include 99% of members) I prefer to see things go in 4 week cycles.

Take squats for example, due to the large muscle groups that you are working with you will more inclined to have your best overall gains. If an average member were to increase 5lbs per month for 12 months. Thats 60lbs per year. If your P.B. squat is 225lbs a 60lb gain takes it to 285lb, thats huge.
Here is the first cycle. Add 5lbs per week for 4 weeks, begin the second cycle with the weight you where using for week two of the previous cycle, add 5 lbs per week for 4 weeks, thats a 5 lb gain in a month. This moves so on and so forth. It's virtually impossible to burn out because each week and each month are different.

Regards cardio, I love to piggy back my cardio on to the end of a squat session. I even use squats to warm up for hockey. I finish my session and time it so that I go straight to the arena and on the ice. I find that your giddy up and go is great. Tired after though, then a rest day to deserved.

Just my 2 cents
 
Tell the training manager what your goals are and he/she should be able to find a PT that will help you. As with any service ;), there is variability in knowledge and attentiveness. I have always chosen trainers who are powerlifters because that is what I want to get better at.
 
to each his own....I max wieght every time out(power lifter in me)...so yeah 5 lbs per week is tough for the neophyte lifter.....but i also go max reps on leg press too...to failure...so when i'm done I can barely walk...let alone do cardio...
just do whats right for you....
 
Stop doing the same workout. Change it up every week so your body can't get use to the training.
 
because nobody pushes themselves as far as they can really go ... I know this because I do better workout -more reps, higher weight, longer static holds - when I'm with my trainer. I would quit ... but when he screams "three more!!" ... I do three more...

Ok, I can see that. I have a workout buddy for this purpose and it's free.
 
good point ... but my schedule is such that finding a workout buddy who can be as flexible as me is challenging ...

You should try to find a regular client who knows his way around a gym. That way you can have a workout... and then have another "workout". It's a win win. ha ha
 
If you've no knowledge of physical fitness or how to achieve your goals, it's possible to spend a lot of time/money at a gym and not get any results.
A trainer can definitely help with getting started and helping you maximize your time so you can actually see results. You don't need to put one on retainer; a few sessions can easily be enough.
 
if you got tons of money to blow, why not.. it can't be that bad if you can find a good trainer. Otherwise, just get a friend to train with you... or talk to people at the guy, make friends and you can learn a lot from them or get the to spot you once a while. if you ask nicely, most are eager to give advice and help out someone just starting out
 
Thanks all for the input -

Still haven't made my mind up yet, but all the feedback was very helpful.

I know if I do try a personal trainer that they will give me advice I don't want to hear (what my daily two pints of Guiness isn't okay? But it's a great source of iron!).

However, I should be getting a nice tax refund shortly and while I will spend some of it foolishly (you know where or how), I may try out a personal trainer for a limited time and see how it works.