Are "Indys." less reliable/flaky?

My $US.02 - In theory I would prefer indy's. I used more years ago in Victoria B.C., Hamilton and Niagara where also became personal real friends with a few not a client, after first meeting them as a client. But that isn't my expectation.

However, for frugal me most of the better reviewed indy's are simply out of my price tolerance and agencies offer incalls and I do less than a full hour since I skip some of the usual stuff guys want.

To Jessie's good comments, as an self employed business person myself I value the indy model. Many of the agencies are women owned so not men controlled (although some good agencies are men owned/run). Agencies have drivers so have some accountability (like that more than "control.)

Having a "booker" makes it easier to schedule since can be setting up while she is with a client etc. Sadly in the U.S. this would be a criminal enterprise felony and most agencies are not as good about not selling GFE etc., rather than just time. In the U.S. risk serious prison time so only works well in Canada.

Agencies often have zillions of choices with pictures and basic info. A good booker can discuss who might best meet your needs.

On the other hand as Jessie pointed, out agency companions are on a stricter time factor (especially if outcall with driver) vs Indy's can be more flexible if they wish.

Once long ago in Phoenix I had a 2 hour appt with great gal from now deceased well known Madam Rose at her incall. By gals choice we went over 2 hours, she had no other appt's and Madam Rose said she thought it was great since she knew she was in good hands. It just happened to be before an industry party which I was late to and as I walked in another gal who knew my Canadian interests starting signing "Oh Canada" to welcome me! She had great voice too.

For me I also am looking for more down to earth gals, perhaps not the perfect model and smaller natural breasts is kind of my fetish :) However, as Conway pointed out not into playing "Backpage Roulette."

My situation may be abnormal also since I am just here for 10 days sometimes only once a year vs old days often 3 times. Finances are now more limited so have to be more choosey.

On zefroggy's good point about relationship building I am not sure you build the relationship on just a quick phone call to set up an appointment with an Indy vs. the booker with an agency. Some guys have good relationships with bookers who help to direct them to which companions might best meet their desires. For example a few days ago with 4 possble choices I selected from my spreadsheet, the booker eliminated 2 when I told her my interests were more sensual and intimate not wild or porn starish sp?
 
Generally speaking, there are fewer things that are likely to go wrong with an agency vs an indy as there is a built-in quality control process at agencies. Agencies will not hire unattractive ladies in the first place and will eventually fire ladies who are flaky, disorganized, or otherwise provide poor service. Many (not all) indies are sp's who for one reason or another could not cut it at an agency.

Guess you have had totally different experiences than I have with the agencies and indies you've known... perhaps things in TO are different than in Ottawa and Montreal where the opposite is true.


First of a girl working for an agency gets paid a LOT less. Usually a girl who goes indie it isn't because she 'cant cut it' but because she is sick of handing over a cut for a client who is seeing her for the 10th time and books 3hrs each time. Once a girl has a rep there is absolutely no reason to stay with an agency unless she cant handle her own website, own ads, own screening, own booking etc which is the case with some. Furthermore, the agencies I started out with were always good at first and deteriorated in quality. They'd hire absolutely anybody and reserve those girls for when the good ones get over-booked so they don't lose money. Trust me, I and the SPs I know could hire any agency to represent us (although agencies tend to forget the meaning of the word agent and ignore the fact that WE pay THEM for their services) yet even so, even knowing I (and other idies) see it that way, they will still line up to hire us if we wanted to...like for instance, going to a new city. Some girls will use the help of an agent. So... I don't know where you got this knowledge of the inner workings of how agencies and SPs interact... as I said, maybe its different in TO...but as an indie whos worked for agencies and knows many girls who LEFT not were "fired' if you want to use that term, I have to say that's not what I saw and I don't know how a hobbyist would know this better than those who have worked within the agencies. I'm guessing the only way would be that that's what the agency told you? Anyway, I'm not trying to argue or anything, just share that that is the complete opposite of my knowledge of the inner workings of this industry. Have a good one! xo
 
I've had more issues with agencies than indies. (with the exclusion of Cupids as Jillian runs a tight ship and could give lessons to any business leaders) I may be biased now, since I haven't contacted an agency in over 2 years.

The difference with indies is that you need to build a connection before meeting. And if you just want to order your ladies then the likelyhood of a bad experience is higher. Introduce yourself like you would to any beautiful woman in a bar. Once you have this relationship, then you can experience true GFE.


Very true. It makes a huge difference to the experience for the reasons you listed and also to the SP. Believe me, a woman is much more comfortable knowing who is behind the door and even excited to meet this charming or funny guy who was so pleasant in conversation and she knows is cool cuz she screened him herself. As opposed to being with an agency where I have NO CLUE who is behind the door. My guard is up, I'm nervous. Not only because most agencies don't bother screening except for their own blacklist of time wasters and even with that an agency girl can expect a good 3 no shows a day..the one thing they do screen for still befalls them more than indies... but in terms of if he is drunk or potentially dangerous... they don't care (in my experience)...but not only that, even if the guy is great...we don't know that until you are alone with us in a room. The comfort level between the two scenarios can not be more gapped. Because I am relaxed as an indie, I have more fun and when I have more fun and don't have nervous or unsure energy about me...the hobbyist has a hell lot more fun too. Hence the TRUE gfe experience u are talking about. U hit it dead-on. ;-)
 
Absolutely not.

I deal only with indies, the prospect of a third party taking advantage of agency girls just doesn't sit well with me. So far my batting average is .800, I have no reason to complain.
 
^^^^ This...+1

We have our reputation to answer to which is even more detrimental. A girl can start over in a new agency... an indie can never start over.. some have tried but it never works. Again, I think some here are failing to look at the full picture and are making simplified assumptions that simply don't jive with truth. You see the agency as a brand and a boss but fail to see the indie as a business owner who can make or break herself. My reputation is everything. If I had a slew of bad reviews here, I think you guys will all agree that nothing I say in my ads or website would make you see me... and I'm done.
Id also like to add that no agency has ever been a "boss" to me. Its an agency. I pay them. I paid them a percentage of my earnings just as an actress, model or singer would her agent... agencies are paid to take photos, handle advertising and marketing for me (which they often did horribly causing the wrong clients to be drawn to me and clients who were right for me were deterred because the agency had a narrow minded view on what sells (ie bait and switch which infuriated me) handle the calls etc... In return I keep in mind that I am representing their company and its reputation... but they are in no way my 'boss'. Yes, they all try to be, but Ive always made the difference clear. And if u let them, these bosses will be pressuring you to work when you aren't up to it and worse. Any SP with half a brain who is indie guards her reputation with utmost care... so I don't understand where these ideas come from... We don't need someone cracking a whip to get us to be ready for a client, and the thought of that happening doesn't sit well with me. Some of us have a built in whip called integrity, work ethic and business sense and well, just not being a slob who makes an eager client waste his time at a moment that should be fun for both of us. Also in my experience, when agencies do things like purposely double book a girl to see which guy shows up or in hope they can get her to finish the first one quickly etc.. Ive never known an agency to offer a discount to make up for it. Just excuses to justify the screw up. Whereas an indie will surely.. well.. here I cant speak for others as I have no personal knowledge but I imagine they are just as concerned as I am to be fair and offer either a discount or extra time to compensate the gent if say... I don't know...the hotel fire alarm went off so I have to postpone. So, ya I don't know..Im surprised at these assumptions which are presented as fact by people who haven't seen the inner workings of this industry. I really don't want to make enemies here by contradicting (I have a reputation to worry about after all :-P )..joking aside, I don't like arguments, drama, conflict, I'm all about being happy and sharing happiness so please know none of this is personal. I'm just stating that whats being said here isn't what I know. I enjoy a free flowing exchange of ideas and opinions and I'm hoping we can do so amicably. Have a great day! xoxo

Edit note: Obviously I replied to the wrong post. I meant the post that peepingtom (lol great name teehee) was one plussing. Sorry about that.
 
However, for frugal me most of the better reviewed indy's are simply out of my price tolerance and agencies offer incalls....
To Jessie's good comments, as an self employed business person myself I value the indy model. Many of the agencies are women owned so not men controlled (although some good agencies are men owned/run). Agencies have drivers so have some accountability (like that more than "control.)

Having a "booker" makes it easier to schedule since can be setting up while she is with a client etc. Sadly in the U.S. this would be a criminal enterprise felony and most agencies are not as good about not selling GFE etc., rather than just time. In the U.S. risk serious prison time so only works well in Canada.

Agencies often have zillions of choices with pictures and basic info. A good booker can discuss who might best meet your needs.


On zefroggy's good point about relationship building I am not sure you build the relationship on just a quick phone call to set up an appointment with an Indy vs. the booker with an agency. Some guys have good relationships with bookers who help to direct them to which companions might best meet their desires. For example a few days ago with 4 possble choices I selected from my spreadsheet, the booker eliminated 2 when I told her my interests were more sensual and intimate not wild or porn starish sp?

*wondering to self if my purple lettering will work this time :-P*
Hi Dave, Thank you for the compliment to my post, I hope you don't mind if I respond? If you do, sorry.

My reply will be in point form to the quotes I kept above..
- Do indy girls not usually do incalls in TO? In Ottawa (I don't know about Mtl) the vast majority of indies do incalls. I haven't been to TO much but the time I went and all future plans, I will have a hotel as always. Actually I don't offer outcalls in TO at all and Ottawa I strictly stay within downtown, not only for avoiding pranksters but its also time consuming to do outcalls. So I'm surprised by this. Is it the norm in TO for an indie to not have an incall?

- As to the sex of the owner of an agency, I don't think that has much to do with how they treat the SPs, contrary to popular belief. Some of the WORST human traffickers are madams and some of the best good agencies are run by men. As far as Ive heard its the same with strip joints. So either can be equally good or bad from my knowledge.

- Indies who do outcalls usually have their own driver that they stick with, some drive themselves. The difference is that when an SP calls an agency driver to say she's done, he'll often not show up for a long time as he has a car load of other girls getting picked up and dropped off which is also very indiscreet. Also, the fact that when doing a multi-hour visit, the agency driver takes off driving other girls around while the SP still has to pay him an hourly rate for not being their and the agency still gets their cut. As a result I put my foot down when I was with an agency and said Id make my own way to appointments. This didn't sit well with them but too bad. I'm not paying for hours that he is driving other girls around and is no where to be found when I'm standing on the street freezing. So.. I hired my own and finally adopted a downtown only policy for outcalls. The times I have used my own driver, they have always been there within a few minutes of my needing him and I pay for the ride there and the ride back ONLY just like any other actual driver. Ive been late to many agency outcalls, often not even knowing I was late until the client informed me I should've been there a half hour ago and asked if I found my cellphone charger (meaning the tardiness was put on me)... since going indie Ive never been late to an outcall so...

- In terms of a booker making it easier, I disagree. You can refer to one of my other posts concerning booking problems with giving clients inaccurate info, double booking, booking back to back (which I don't do) and more... In terms of when I'm busy, the msg is there, waiting for me. I have no trouble with this. If I miss out on a booking, its because I was busy, but usually when I reply, the gent is happy to hear from me and 9 times out of 10, will then book. Only occasionally do I not reach him in time and we both understand that that's life. There's also issues such as over-booking where as I know my limits and respect them. Having someone else decide how many I will see for how many hours just isn't for me. I like the ability to say, 'I'm actually booked up tomorrow, hows the day after looking for you?' if I need to and I know that the clients appreciate that I only do what I can enjoy as opposed to having a spent robot (not saying agency girls are this, just that most agencies will encourage girls to do this, many SPs like me just refuse, others give in and complain but allow it none-the-less.) What you say about having a good booker is true. I had one once and she knew exactly who to send to me... once she got to know me that is, which took time. And I'm sure she was just as knowledgeable about the other SPs. However, she was totally lost when it came to special requests... so shed often be the middle person forwarding the gent's questions or desires to me and forward my replies to him. But most don't do that and will just say whatever. There is no one who can pre-discuss a booking with me better than myself. Especially when it comes to things like BDSM or certain fetishes the booker may have no clue about. So, the only way in which I could see a booker being better than talking to the SP herself is the offer of variety as you said. S/he can tell you a little bit about each girl but not really specifics. There is nothing she can say about me that I cant say myself, same for each girl she books. But yes, it would save you a lot of time to just get a recommendation from a booker as opposed to reading through a zillion ads and reviews.

-Please everyone, correct me if I'm wrong but the way I heard C-36 being interpreted (and in my own interpretation after reading it, although its debated), it seems pretty clear that this is now also an offense in Canada. I cant recall the exact wording but its along the lines of 'discussing for purposes of' is illegal. Although, unlike the States, I don't think anyone is really enforcing that here the way they do in the States. (wow that sentence was so bad, I have to keep it there. Looks like it was written by a dyslexic 3 year old. "Unlike the States... like they do in the States *facepalm*)

Ok byebye xoxo

-Finally, (god I hope I'm not irritating the crap out of you by now :sorry: ) your doubt as to how well an SP and hobbyist can know each other via initial contact. My first point is, the same can be said about the booker who usually (in an agency that wants to avoid risk of jail time) has never even met the girl. The only communication between myself and the booker on the phone was via text msgs and the odd quick call. And when we do talk, its certainly not about what we are like, are into etc... So I would argue that this third party you are going through to find out about someone has less information on who the girl is than you would yourself using the same manner of communication. My other point is, there is a lot that can be said within texts and emails... texts and emails that a booker just doesn't have time to indulge and will run through quickly and whos answers vary depending on who is available that day. Not only is there a load of articulated information passing between us, there is a load of unspoken information that speaks volumes about who the person is. An SP is paying close attention to this, a booker doesn't because they aren't anticipating meeting this person...ever. I don't want to sound like I'm bashing agencies. Its not my intention... agencies are a great way to start out. I'm just submitting my experiences and knowledge and they are what they are. I didn't select them, its just what Ive seen.

Sorry for putting a disclaimer after every post. I'm just nervous to make someone angry as its really not what I want.

OMG Not trying to lighten the mood here but I just got a sign from the universe that I need to STFU. As I was typing,, I heard my cat doing something as he purred and I ignored it, busy typing and when I looked over he had about 6inches of my hair right down his throat, struggling to swallow it all up... I pulled it out and am now sitting here with a disgusting, cat-slobber-soaked strand of hair dripping on to my lap... ewww... gotta go. Everyone have a great day... Great post Dave! Again, thanks for the compliment! I always enjoy your posts btw.
 
Jessy: I am quite sure that you are an excellent Indy SP who takes your job seriously and provides great service. Unfortunately, not all of your Indy colleagues share your work ethic. You would probably be appalled to hear about some of the things that go on.

So...please don't take the following comments personally as they are in no way directed at you nor all Indy SP's. However, ask yourself the following questions:

Where is a guy more likely to get robbed? Indy or agency?

Where is a guy more likely to find an SP's pimp/friend hiding in the bathroom? Indy or agency?

Where is a guy more likely to find a filthy room that stinks of weed with a dirty mattress on the floor? Indy or agency?

Where is a guy more likely to get hassled by the police entering or leaving an incall? Indy or agency?

Who is more likely to use fake pics? Indy or agency?


The answer is Indy...Sorry, hun. I'm sure none of these concerns apply to you or anyone in your circle of SP friends...but these are realities of this biz that all guys need to be mindful of.

Again, as I said earlier, most of these problems can be avoided by a guy's doing his homework and reading reviews. However, if a guy is too lazy or too horny or too whatever to do his homework then his safest bet is to call up a reputable agency.
 
...

OMG Not trying to lighten the mood here but I just got a sign from the universe that I need to STFU. As I was typing,, I heard my cat doing something as he purred and I ignored it, busy typing and when I looked over he had about 6inches of my hair right down his throat, struggling to swallow it all up... I pulled it out and am now sitting here with a disgusting, cat-slobber-soaked strand of hair dripping on to my lap... ewww... gotta go. Everyone have a great day... Great post Dave! Again, thanks for the compliment! I always enjoy your posts btw.

I'm impressed that you were able to keep typing whilst simultaneously dealing with your cat's hairball issue. If it was me the cat woulda had to wait until I finished writing my post...Guess it's a good thing I don't own a cat...LOL!

:D
 
Jessie - While I am certainly not an expert on Toronto agencies since only a visitor week or so at a time for over 10 years and haven't done outcall's for a few years - but read a lot. I also have a close friend here that knows many of the agency owners and has a very favorable view of many . We have discussed a lot about the different agencies. So his views are far more informed than mine, but seems a good source of info related to Toronto.

I agree sex of owner/manager isn't really that important. I have heard podcast's of a few that I thought were very positive looking out for their "assets" (the gals).

It would seem if a companion wants to be very busy (not all do), or want more free time to yourself for other life's activities, it is much more time efficient to have an agency or at least a booker. You save time not having to do ads, answer phones and to the extent the agency screens that all would seem to save you a lot of time.

When I did do outcall's from various agencies there was always a driver that stayed in the area unless had another "delivery or pick up near by.

In those days driver always called 5-10 minutes as a time is almost up warning (which can be distracting but understand reason). Maybe in 10 experiences driver was always there to pick up lady when done and incoming most were within 5-10 minutes of stated arrival time. We often have a huge traffic mess on main highway 401 even off hours.

I use to know the typical split of agencies which was far better than in the U.S. for the gal. In the U.S. split is usually 50% but rare to have a driver. Popular Madam Rose was unusual since she paid the gals 60% and attracted a lot of visiting lady's. The pay structure as I understand is far better in Canada.

I agree would be more nervous with total unknown and have to rely on booker screening. However, as I mentioned if just set up a "date" hard to learn much about the new customer. Some escorts I am friends with in Phoenix do talk a lot to them on the phone to kind a better "feel" of them - not slurred drunk speech etc. In the U.S., because of the extreme legal risk, most companions require a reference of another provider they have seen and try to contact the reference. That of course also helps, but you don't need or seem to have that kind of system in Canada.

Many of the larger Toronto agencies monitor review boards and respond to any problems. That way they get to know the reaction of guys to various gals. Many bookers know about reviews and can help direct a guy to might be a good fit. I have had that happen many times for my odd interests (now with incalls). For special things like B/D that may require more direct discussion with the gal, I agree. Also on a podcast a gal called lots of agencies while on the air asking if they had any bi gals that she could book. Only a few of maybe 7 she called on the air, had any idea and would have to get back to her. A few said they don't provide services of women for women, a few had to check with the boss or gals and a few (maybe 1) said yes and made recommendations.

On C36, most major city PD's including a long press release from Toronto PD, most say no changes in enforcement but will follow the harm reduction model. Not interesting in going after consenting adults (customers only at risk), but concentrate on under age or forced pimping. Montreal, Victoria, B.C., Vancouver and a few other cities I have read similar reports. A few Alberta I believe cities and one North of Toronto I understand may be more aggressive. Reverdy here has a great tread with over 100 pages keeping up on C36 busts around Canada and maybe 90% are related to under aged or forced pimping. The exceptions have been some street stings - which adds the public nuisance factor.

On your good points about how much info booker can discuss under C36, most seem rather open but there are way you can phrase things without being asking directly about sex. However, what she might enjoy seems not to relate to breaking the law by "paying for sex acts". Pre C36 agencies have the same problem not "living of the avails". Seemed never a problem again since sell time not sex.

Customers of Indy's would seem to have a higher risk when the companion lists on websites illegal acts related to GFE, etc. They agencies have changed their wording to avoid that. In the U.S., just having GFE or worse in ads or reviews can be very risky since ads are solicitation and reviews are often used in probable cause statements for grand jury indictments. So far none of those issues in Canada going after customers. In Arizona it is also a crime to not list escort license number in your ad. Same mandatory 15 days in jail on first offense as for solicitation. I have never yet seen an ad in compliance since requires a log of all activities, positive ID of each customers in the record etc., and of course can not do anything sexual. Scottsdale has been especially active arresting escorts simply for not having a escort license and number in ads.

Like you trying not to bash agencies same with me for Indy's. I do have some Indy's on my spreadsheets but just seems easier from the customer view to use agencies, often less costly, easy to set up etc. Since I am so picky physically and looking for less wild, not looking for porn stars etc reviews and personal incites from my friend who sees many gals is valuable.

While you got interrupted by your cat... I had cleaning lady come.... I guess to protect them they want the person to leave the room for 10-15 minutes while clean. I said was too busy to do so and she gave in and cleaned around me. I was not at all attracted to her but maybe they try and protect the cleaning lady that way.
--
Conway's comments are especially true with Backpage ads and even more so in the U.S. We have cash and dash, robberies, not to mention undercover police stings set up on backpage to entrap.
 
We have our reputation to answer to which is even more detrimental. A girl can start over in a new agency... an indie can never start over..
And an agency owner cares just as much about the agency's reputation. And that reputation affects a whole roster of girls that the agency needs to keep busy. And the lifespan of the average agency will be much longer than the average SP.

Many SPs start over with different names. If it doesn't work out it is usually because they are unreliable under any name.

Sorry, your points are without merit.
 
I believe finding a reliable and quality indy is the pinnacle of success in this hobby. That is why when you have found one, you will probably become a regular for years, even decades. Problem is, finding that gem and building that relationship can also take years of frustration to achieve.