Another Ex-Bush Advisor "Sorry"

Mcluhan said:
your conceit is showing again...

Everyone who gets drunk says stupid things, and i'm sure you're no exception as you do it when sober.

A more relevent train of thought to examine is why you equate criticizing Israel with antisemitism. Are they pushing that in the church pamphlets these days? Inquiring minds wish to know.

Don't know, haven't been to church in quite a while - but you do like to paint with a broad brush don't you. Keep wiggling though, it's entertaining. We're you drunk when you made the racist statement, or just racist?

And in the spirit of full disclosure I have said many a stupid thing while under the influence.

OTB
 
It’s the usual tactic to neutralize critics of Israel by smearing them with the charge of "anti-Semitism", just ask Jimmy Carter so there's nothing new here in your approach to this argument. Since you avoid the question (again) by deferring to more name calling I'll spell it out for you (again): the Israelis, who are threatening to plunge the Middle East into the throes of a nuclear Armageddon are backed and spurred on by the extreme religious right in America AND your criminals in Washington, a pack of liars and thieves of which Wolfowitz is the archetype; therefore (yes) I see no reason NOT to paint them all with the same brush, the broader the better.

Your show of a little humility is politely acknowledged anyway. Now, if you would only reduce down your signature by say 5 lines, I'd even be grateful.
 
The vast majority of the lunatic fringe ultra-right absolutely despises Israel and adores the imperial, anti-progressive Arab view. All one has to do is to check their sites, one of which Mcluhan used to bolster his idiotic claim that the Mossad killed Mr. Hariri. One can easily see what true "anti-Zionism" is by checking out the sites of the Aryan Nations, David Duke, Ernst Zundel, Jewwatch, etc. etc.
 
LurkerDave said:
The vast majority of the lunatic fringe ultra-right absolutely despises Israel and adores the imperial, anti-progressive Arab view. All one has to do is to check their sites, one of which Mcluhan used to bolster his idiotic claim that the Mossad killed Mr. Hariri. One can easily see what true "anti-Zionism" is by checking out the sites of the Aryan Nations, David Duke, Ernst Zundel, Jewwatch, etc. etc.

You can add the Current Pope, the previous Pope, and Jimmy Carter to the view that the Palestinian situation is living under a policy of apartheid. This is not to be confused with Aryan Nations, David Duke etc. And yes, I have my opinion that the Mossad took out Haririr. Please explain why that is an 'idiotic' opinion? Just because some anti-Zionist site also thinks so?
 
Only a complete fool would believe that Israel played a role in the murder of Hariri. To this day, pro-Syrian politicians in Lebanon like Nabi B'erri of Amal are doing all they can to thwart any investigation into that assassination. If there was any belief whatsover that Israel was behind the killing, the pro-Syrians in the Beirut government would press forward, rather than attempting to stop a legitimate investigation into the matter.
 
LurkerDave said:
Only a complete fool would believe that Israel played a role in the murder of Hariri. To this day, pro-Syrian politicians in Lebanon like Nabi B'erri of Amal are doing all they can to thwart any investigation into that assassination. If there was any belief whatsover that Israel was behind the killing, the pro-Syrians in the Beirut government would press forward, rather than attempting to stop a legitimate investigation into the matter.

I just love the "only complete fool argument", it says so much, really.

Look, there are two schools of thought on the matter (clearly). There is the pro-Israeli/US camp and then there is the other camp which is cynical. It includes the albeit unsubstantiated report leaked by a French intelligence member and many other non-main stream news sources. Read this one for an alternate view (and there are many):

http://www.wsws.org/articles/2005/feb2005/hari-f17.shtml

If its a put-up job, then of course they are obligated to thwart the framing.

The question is, who had the most to gain, and the answer is clearly, US/Israeli side. BTW,..who was it that went to war with Lebanon recently? Syria? Opps... no..Israel. Certainly this would not have occurred with Hariri at the helm. (true or false, pick one)

The reason I referenced that site, FYI, was because of the amazing photography, not because of its clearly anti-Zionist slant, which I also took note of.
 
I find this this quote from the Washington Post interesting also:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A29296-2005Feb16?language=printer


" Yesterday, the Israeli daily reported that while most analysts "agreed that Syria was the obvious culprit because of Hariri's calls for its withdrawal, killing him does more harm than good for Syria.

"It's totally illogical that Syria would do it," said Prof. Eyal Zisser, a Syria expert at the Dayan Institute for Middle East Studies at Tel Aviv University. "It would be such a stupid move on their part. Everyone is watching them and they don't want to destabilize Lebanon."
 
Mcluhan said:
It’s the usual tactic to neutralize critics of Israel by smearing them with the charge of "anti-Semitism", just ask Jimmy Carter so there's nothing new here in your approach to this argument. Since you avoid the question (again) by deferring to more name calling I'll spell it out for you (again): the Israelis, who are threatening to plunge the Middle East into the throes of a nuclear Armageddon are backed and spurred on by the extreme religious right in America AND your criminals in Washington, a pack of liars and thieves of which Wolfowitz is the archetype; therefore (yes) I see no reason NOT to paint them all with the same brush, the broader the better.

Your show of a little humility is politely acknowledged anyway. Now, if you would only reduce down your signature by say 5 lines, I'd even be grateful.

No, I'm quite critical of Israel, it's the usual tactic of calling people for being racist when they take racist positions... like assuming Jews are money grubbing..... sad really that you're not man enough to admit it.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
No, I'm quite critical of Israel, it's the usual tactic of calling people for being racist when they take racist positions... like assuming Jews are money grubbing..... sad really that you're not man enough to admit it.

OTB

Your really starting to piss me off. The comment was directed at Wolfowitz 'and his band of liars and thieves". Who does that normally conjure up in this minds of 99% of all people, Jews? or your farking lying criminal administration? Stop trying to paint me as antisemitic over YOUR twist of the reference; which is wrong. In other words politely fuck off.
 
Mcluhan said:
...
The question is, who had the most to gain, and the answer is clearly, US/Israeli side. BTW,..who was it that went to war with Lebanon recently? Syria? Opps... no..Israel. Certainly this would not have occurred with Hariri at the helm. (true or false, pick one)


I think that the assassinations (yes, plural) were for Syria what Iraq was for the US. They though they had a good idea to consolidate power but it didn't work out the way that they though.

The reason I referenced that site, FYI, was because of the amazing photography, not because of its clearly anti-Zionist slant, which I also took note of.
Right.
 
Mcluhan said:
It’s the usual tactic to neutralize critics of Israel by smearing them with the charge of "anti-Semitism", ...
This is the usual claim of those without any argument to make. Their proof? The Jewish conspiracy keeps the proof hidden but everyone knows how Jews are.

If you want to criticize Israeli policy, go ahead. It leans towards bias when you blindly criticize without basis and while ignoring comparable flaws of nations who are Israel's enemies. It also leans towards racism when you assume that any person who might be Jewish is a part of a conspiracy.

Why would otb thing you are anti-semitic with your comment? How many of your posts talk about the way that Jews dominate the US, international politics, control elaborate plots....?
 
basketcase said:
If you want to criticize Israeli policy, go ahead. It leans towards bias when you blindly criticize without basis and while ignoring comparable flaws of nations who are Israel's enemies. It also leans towards racism when you assume that any person who might be Jewish is a part of a conspiracy.

I did not blindly criticize. The attack was on Wofowitz, and his ilk (the cabal) being in bed with Israel (one more time).

As you know, I routinely criticize Israel and the administration in that vane. I could be a lot harder on Israel's right wing if that was my dogged purpose, but it is not. I resent being called a racist over it, and that a common tactic, and you know it. Just ask Jimmy carter. I also believe that Israel's extremists being in bed with Wolfowitz et al is a giant mistake. And the AIPAC should be registered. There is a long list of things that i see going on that I don't like. I don't rattle on here about each and every one either.

As for Hariri, you know what I think. Its a free world, so I can say what 'I think'. I don't support political assassinations under any circumstances. Do you?

I also think Israel should be FORCED to sign the NPT. Don't you?

Anyway, this discussion does not belong in this thread. And yet here we are...
 
Should Iran be forced to follow it? What about North Korea, India, Pakistan?

Again, your focus is too narrow.
 
basketcase said:
Should Iran be forced to follow it? What about North Korea, India, Pakistan?

Again, your focus is too narrow.

Yes, of course. Only a crazy person would argue otherwise. But starting a nuclear war over the issue which is 10 years away is not the right measure of force.

A good start would be to take Israel's nukes away. Then it becomes a non-issue for everyone.
 
Mcluhan said:
Your really starting to piss me off. The comment was directed at Wolfowitz 'and his band of liars and thieves". Who does that normally conjure up in this minds of 99% of all people, Jews? or your farking lying criminal administration? Stop trying to paint me as antisemitic over YOUR twist of the reference; which is wrong. In other words politely fuck off.

Then why was it funny that she was an Arab........

OTB
 
Mcluhan said:
A good start would be to take Israel's nukes away. Then it becomes a non-issue for everyone.
Again you ignore other examples that I've already mentioned.

India has had nukes for a while. So does Pakistan and some of their technology has been exported to places such as Libya. North Korea also claims to have nukes.

Why would you focus on Israel? They have never had publicized tests to intimidate their neighbours like India and Pakistan have. They have not advertised tests and launched trials of nuclear ready missiles like North Korea has. In fact, Israel has only recently even insinuated that they have nukes and has never threatened anyone with them.

The other nuclear powers don't deserve to have them either. The US is seen as evil imperialists. Russia is said to be run by organized crime. China has a very low record on human rights and has effectively occupied 3 (arguably) non-Chinese regions.

Your sole focus on Israel shows clearly where you're coming from.
 
basketcase said:
Again you ignore other examples that I've already mentioned.

India has had nukes for a while. So does Pakistan and some of their technology has been exported to places such as Libya. North Korea also claims to have nukes.

Why would you focus on Israel? They have never had publicized tests to intimidate their neighbours like India and Pakistan have. They have not advertised tests and launched trials of nuclear ready missiles like North Korea has. In fact, Israel has only recently even insinuated that they have nukes and has never threatened anyone with them.

The other nuclear powers don't deserve to have them either. The US is seen as evil imperialists. Russia is said to be run by organized crime. China has a very low record on human rights and has effectively occupied 3 (arguably) non-Chinese regions.

Your sole focus on Israel shows clearly where you're coming from.

I thought we were discussing Israel. Perhaps not...

sure, I can multi-task, lets go for it.
 
Mcluhan said:
I also think Israel should be FORCED to sign the NPT. Don't you?

Anyway, this discussion does not belong in this thread. And yet here we are...

OK, good, back to policy.

How do you propose forcing Israel to sign the NPT......

OTB
 
basketcase said:
You're always discussing Israel. (I think that's my point).

No, I am always discussing the war in the middle east. Israel, is a little hard to ignore, in case you haven't noticed I stay out of the Palestinian/Israeli issue, because I haven't been there and seen the matter for my own eyes, which in this case, I rather think is necessary, and I have no doubt you could assign the responsibility 49/51 depending on the day.