Ancient Aliens

I never disagreed with the POSSIBILITY of other life in the universe. I never even debated it.
I await refutation of my initial statements. Anything?


Still trying to making it your claim.

As said earlier the research is incomplete, so the proof is yet to come, by how much, I certainly don't know, but neither do you.
 
He felt he could reach India by setting out to sea westward from Spain, because he believed that the Earth was found.

I'm not normally a grammar nazi, but it really confuses the discussion when there are so many typos from posters :)
 
Our faith was written/interpreted/reinterpreted by men who believed the world was flat with a blade to their throats and told what to write.

I stand by my original point. Restated: It is a reasonable position to take that there is no empirical evidence for either faith in UFO's or faith in religious figures like Jesus so treating one as laughable and one as reasonable is, well, unreasonable. Your comment doesn't deal with my premise at all.
 
Indeed, nor are the scientists the ones "coming up with any equations". I've told you about the Drake Equation. That's the one we're talking about.

But, your logic fails in the last sentence. Yes, the odds are that there is life in the universe other than ours. To extrapolate from that to anything resembling "there are other advanced technological civilizations out there" or "we've been visited already" is no supported by any mathematical or scientific evidence. To do so is SUPPOSITION, pure and simple.

Is it a possibility? Sure. Is there ANY scientific or mathematical evidence? No.

I never claimed that an equation proved that they are so advanced that they can travel.

I making my own supposition based on the possibility of life elswhere, the age of the universe and the myriad of credible, unexplained UFO sightings here.
 
'Likely' and 'possible' is very, very different from 'proof' or 'certainty' - this is the core issue of this part of this thread, which may have cause some misunderstanding.

Understood but it's my personal opinion that we've been visited based on the many UFO sightings and reports that HAVEN'T been explained away. Therefore, you can't use Occam Razor in the absence of an alternate explanation. There are scientists that will say 'maybe', or 'possible'. That's all I want people to concede.
 
Right. "Making my own supposition" is not proof.
Done here?
To summarize: there is neither mathematical nor astronomical evidence to prove what you believe.

Somebody might think you were done some time ago, but hey. Somebody might also say that the proof is there, but we just haven't found it.
 
You do know what the word "proof" means, right? If you "haven't found the proof", you haven't proven anything.
LOL Too much.
Once again: there is no mathematical or astronomical evidence to back up your claims.
QED

Gee, I thought you were done, apparently not.

To quote one of your favourite sources, not that you wanted us to know;

"Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence!"-- Carl Sagan, Astronomer

I know you didn't say they didn't exist, just that there was no proof. A mugwump stance if I ever heard one.
 
GPIDEAL: "I assume these astrophysicists know what they're talking about. I'm not the one coming up with any equations."
Wrong again. Getting tiresome.

With respect to what? That not all astrophysicists know what they're talking about, or only the ones that you disagree with?
 
I have no interest. You're free to believe that eyewitness accounts prove the existence of flying saucers and ET. There is no scientific evidence for your belief.


Any of those would be good - to start with. Then, I would have to believe I wasn't being Punked. ;) Better yet, to have a trusted body of scientists - the only ones who could truly pronounce on the veracity of such claims - announce the knowledge of the existence of those things.


Yeah, because no ex-astronaut, pilot, clergyman, or politician (!) could possibly lie about ANYTHING.
BTW, again, you're believing in accounts that, hilariously, HAVE ALREADY BEEN DISPROVEN.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Carter_UFO_incident
The Reagan sighting is entirely anecdotal, with no first-hand evidence - as, undoubtedly, are many of the stories you now blindly accept.

I have stated my standard of belief. It involves scientific proof, not just a bunch of hearsay.

Fair enough. You're a scientific purist but you mention hearsay, although you wouldn't believe it even if Chuck Yeager told you himself that he saw a flying disc that he pursued which can only be of intelligent, alien origin, and that's not hearsay.

Can the scientific method rely on credible observations alone?
 
Can the scientific method rely on credible observations alone?

The scientific method HAS to rely on testable hypotheses generating reproducible evidence. It's the only way to be reasonably sure of the claims made. And, to be a good claim, anyone should be able to repeat the test, and come up with similar (preferably identical) evidence.

And the weirder the claim, the more important that the method and evidence be highly reproducible.
 
The scientific method HAS to rely on testable hypotheses generating reproducible evidence. It's the only way to be reasonably sure of the claims made. And, to be a good claim, anyone should be able to repeat the test, and come up with similar (preferably identical) evidence.

And the weirder the claim, the more important that the method and evidence be highly reproducible.

How does it apply to the confirmation of ET visitng here? Are they going to let you test them? I mean, what if we have more sightings, and you and Fonzi see them whizzing by the Toronto skyline or up north at the cottage. What would you say to that?
 
If Chuck Yeager told me himself, that would not be hearsay. That, in and of itself, would not be enough for me to believe in flying saucers, no, and that should be the position of any rational human being - even though it would no longer be hearsay.

Chuck Yeager has not done so, yet. So - hearsay.

The scientific method tells us that we should come up with a theory and then see what the evidence says - test.
Theory a: that flying saucers have visited our planet. Does the evidence fit this theory? There is no evidence, other than stories. Can we test this theory? Sure - provide hard physical evidence. Since that evidence has yet to be found, it seems pretty weak.
Theory b: that people have made up stories or been mistaken. Does the evidence fit this theory? Yes, many stories have proven false or been explained. Have all of them? No, you wouldn't expect to be able to disprove EVERY story.

Which theory works better?

I only mentioned Chuck Yeager as an example of a famous and credible fighter pilot, not that he's reported UFOs.

So you are saying that you can't conclude their existence even with genuine video footage that is clear and resolute? You must touch and examine too?

Belief in some UFOs as real ETs doesn't necessarily make one irrational (like that pilot who spoke in confidence to my cousin's husband - he used to be in politics, and wouldn't dare admit it for fear of being ridiculed). Perhaps not a pure scientist.
 
How does it apply to the confirmation of ET visitng here? Are they going to let you test them? I mean, what if we have more sightings, and you and Fonzi see them whizzing by the Toronto skyline or up north at the cottage. What would you say to that?

An interesting question (i.e. what would it take to make ME 'believe in aliens')

Due to my background, my standard of proof is extremely (excessively?) high when it comes to what I classify as 'paranormal' phenomena (e.g. ghosts, fairies, alien abduction, ESP, etc).

In short, I'd probably need to be abducted personally :)

Just trying to be honest.

One interesting thing though, is that with the increasing availability of high-def cameras in cell phones/smart phones, we'll come to a point where nearly everyone on earth will have a decent recording device at hand, and if aliens/ghosts/fairies do exist (and are visible to the normal light spectrum) we should have lots of pictures of them posted on Facebook/Twitter soon enough...
 
What if Superman fell to earth in a meteorite and came up and shook my hand? What would I say to THAT?!

UFOs are not just out of comic books. Humour me with my question:

What would you say if you saw something that didn't look terrestrial hovering above the lake at the cottage, with a 'washing machine' sound, and which zipped away at incredible speed without a sonic boom upon the arrival of a few figher jets. What would you conclude?
 
An interesting question (i.e. what would it take to make ME 'believe in aliens')

Due to my background, my standard of proof is extremely (excessively?) high when it comes to what I classify as 'paranormal' phenomena (e.g. ghosts, fairies, alien abduction, ESP, etc).

In short, I'd probably need to be abducted personally :)

Just trying to be honest.

One interesting thing though, is that with the increasing availability of high-def cameras in cell phones/smart phones, we'll come to a point where nearly everyone on earth will have a decent recording device at hand, and if aliens/ghosts/fairies do exist (and are visible to the normal light spectrum) we should have lots of pictures of them posted on Facebook/Twitter soon enough...

Fair enough. Thanks for your honesty. There are already many such shots but usually they're taken hastily and aren't very good.

It's also been postulated that ETs hide themselves by not being in the visible light spectrum (Dan Akroyd YT video showed some International Space Station footage of a giant donut that was not visible in the usual light spectrum - I don't know if it's true but sure seemed interseting).