Ancient Aliens

That's nothing but a circular argument.


You don't know any of those things - that it's not a bird, plane, man-made craft, balloon, or Superman. You've chosen to leap from (a) we don't know what it is, to (b) it must be a flying saucer. This is not supported by the facts, or logic.


I haven't dismissed anybody. I've provided reasonable explanations for ALL of them. Once again, here are the choices:
they're lying;
they're permanently crazy;
they're temporarily crazy / drunk / stoned;
they saw something that we can't explain because we weren't there, but that falls within the realm of things we already know exist;
they saw a flying saucer;
they say something else totally unknown to us, that's not a flying saucer - a ghost, an angel, Superman, a celestial teapot, etc.

For some reason, you've made the leap to the second last conclusion. You are free to. I cannot disprove it. Understand that many of the accounts you believe have already been disproven or will be in the future, but nevertheless - accept that people will think you are being very irrational.

In any case, there is NO scientific proof for your belief. Just accept and admit that and move on with your life.

You'd have to provide me evidence that even the good videos, photos, or credible eye-witness sources are all wrong. You have to provide evidence to impeach the credibiltiy of all of these people.

You call it a leap but in reality, even if it looks like a flying saucer or cigar-shaped craft that can defy the laws of gravity, you still call it a leap to claim that it's an ET or probably extra-terrestrial in origin.

I can't see how I'm making a circular argument when one can only come to the only, remaining conclusion (if it walks and quacks like a duck, it is a duck).

You are simply a non-believer, no matter what, unless you yourself are a scientist and HAVE to subscribe to some code of conduct lest you be ridiculed.

Let me ask you this. What would make you believe that a UFO is extra-terrestrial? Touch it? Examine the material it's made from? Ride in it? Meet the extra-terrestrial beings? Give them a phyiscal or a DNA test? What? Obviously, ex-astronauts, pilots, clergymen, Jimmy Carter (yes, he saw one, and so did Ronald Reagan), policemen, scientists who claim they have seen one, is not good enough for you. What is your standard of belief?
 
Again, you have no proof of that.
And, not only is there "no proof the universe is infinite", there is plenty of proof that the universe is, in fact, finite - which is kinda the opposite of what he said.

So what you're saying is that we are the only ones in this universe? This is what the Bible implies too no?

Plenty of proof that it's finite? Please show me that proof because I just saw a video of a physics professor give a brief lecture on this point that says that we only know the 'horizon', but not necessarily the limit of space itself.
 
Bro, aliens could be one million years more advanced than we are. How can you conclude that there's no way for them to travel here or visit us based on your limited (or our civilization's) knowledge of science?

It may be true that our technology will continue to advance for many centuries.
Yet it is pretty clear to science that all of the fundamental laws of nature underlying
the whole of chemistry and a large part of physics have already been discovered by
the early 20th century. Even without the technological advantage of those aliens
one million years ahead of us I think it should be possible for us to at least
contemplate the possibility/impossibility of space travel to distant star system.
Present understanding of the laws of nature doesn't seem to indicate interstellar
space to be theoretically possible. You will not likely find any explanation
of the science underlying the gravity simulation system, the propulsion system and
faster-than-light speed of the Enterprise in star trek that doesn't contradict the laws of
physics. Space travel to star system hundreds of light years away is better left to
the entertainment business.
 
You would prove entirely unable to do so, as is painfully obvious. Seriously, blackrock, just stop. You're embarrassing yourself.
You STILL have yet to provide any scientific evidence.

You're asking to be spoon fed a course or three of astro physics and bio chemistry that scientists researchers than I will ever be have written volumes about, some of whom I listed earlier. You want me to glean through these volumes just for you. You've shown you already didn't read what you've been given earlier about the the Drake equation, the numbers involved, and how it was applied, so why would I spend time giving you more of the same. As there hasn't been any alien life discovered there is no hard evidence which 'you' would accept. You seem to accept there 'may' be life, but then you move your famous goal posts and ask how do we know the life form has the technology to travel here, which wasn't the original discussion at all.
 
It may be true that our technology will continue to advance for many centuries.
Yet it is pretty clear to science that all of the fundamental laws of nature underlying
the whole of chemistry and a large part of physics have already been discovered by
the early 20th century. Even without the technological advantage of those aliens
one million years ahead of us I think it should be possible for us to at least
contemplate the possibility/impossibility of space travel to distant star system.
Present understanding of the laws of nature doesn't seem to indicate interstellar
space to be theoretically possible. You will not likely find any explanation
of the science underlying the gravity simulation system, the propulsion system and
faster-than-light speed of the Enterprise in star trek that doesn't contradict the laws of
physics. Space travel to star system hundreds of light years away is better left to
the entertainment business.

It's been written by some that we've learn more in the last 100 years than mankind learned in all the previous time that man's been on earth and that our knowledge base doubles every sixteen years. It's impossible to say how much there is out there to discover.
 
You didn't even know what the Drake Equation was until I told you. ROTFL

Why did you put 'you' in quotes? ROTFL

Please reread my first posts in the thread. MY goalposts haven't changed. The statements stand:
extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence; there is no astronomical or mathematical proof for the belief that advanced alien life exists or has visited this planet.

I await ANY refutation of ANY of this by you.

BTW, your grammar is becoming increasingly erratic - it's actually becoming quite hard to follow what you're saying. For instance your first sentence (I'm not even sure it IS a sentence) - well, I really truly have no idea what it means. Perhaps you should take some courses in english composition rather than another astrophysics course. ;)

How do you know I didn't know about the Drake Equation? Proof you don't know what you think you know.

When all else fails, you've reverted to the grammar nazi role, well done. It reads fine by me. Does anyone else have Arthurs problem?
 
I await any refutation of my initial statements by you, blackrock.
And the fact that *I* first mentioned the Drake Equation, after you'd talked around it for a few posts, pretty much says it all.
Anything else? Seriously, anything?
And "grammar nazi"? Please reread your first sentence in that post and tell me what it means. I honestly have no idea, other than that I guess you were trying to insult me? Something about other researcher scientists? Try to formulate your thoughts before you start typing next time. It's hard to argue with someone speaking a different language. ;)

I didn't talk around anything.

I was introduced to the equation during my first university lectures in the late 60's and Carl Sagan mentioned it many times in his discussions. Not one of your better claims, but keep swinging.
 
When all else fails, you've reverted to the grammar nazi role, well done. It reads fine by me. Does anyone else have Arthurs problem?

That first sentence of yours IS a little tough to parse - if you read it slowly, you might see that you've missed a word or two:

You're asking to be spoon fed a course or three of astro physics and bio chemistry

so far so good

that scientists researchers than I will ever be have written volumes about,

This part is the problem - not to put words in your mouth, but my suspicion is that you've left out the word 'and' as well as 'smarter'.

some of whom I listed earlier.

This part is fine too.


Anyways - carry on with this discussion where you feel that arthur MUST acquiesce to the POSSIBILITY of alien life in the universe, and where he feels that there isn't enough EXTRAORDINARY EVIDENCE to convincingly prove the EXTRAORDINARY CLAIM that aliens have actually visited earth...even though those are completely different arguments...so you both better decend into the standard ad hominem attacks...:thumb:
 
Occam's Razor my ass! It proves that people supporting the ET hypothesis make things up. It was clear that he was misquoted and taken out of context by people trying to prove just that. Reasonable people used OR to choose NOT to make the incredible leap of faith required to go from what Aldrin reported seeing to proving the existence of ET. Since it was then proven totally false, the only thing required is that you accept that SOME people are making things up about the existence of ET, and will lie about it. You still don't have to accept OR as a good way to go about life. ;)

But, no, you're just going to keep this up all night. I'm sure there are THOUSANDS of stories from people who saw UFOs. But there's really no point in analyzing every crackpot claim / hoax / lie / misrepresentation / unexplained phenomenon (take your pick - I assume, for whatever reasons, you'll assume they're ALL not only unexplained, but inexplicable, except as proof of flying saucers). And there's no reason to believe that just because something MIGHT BE unexplained that it points to ET.

I came on this thread to refute the claim that there is astronomical or mathematical evidence to support your claims, and I have done so. I have proven other claims you've made false as well (Aldrin, the WOW signal). I have no desire to debate the merits of every story you can dig up.

You are free to believe these stories prove that ET has visited. Rational people will use Occam's Razor and the belief that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, look at some stories that, for whatever reason, we can't disprove, and laugh at you.

I have a reasonable alternative theory about Cooper. Very reasonable. He is lying, or perhaps crazy. Or, do you really think that people don't lie / aren't crazy? It's MUCH simpler.

I've never stated that an equation can prove advanced life on other planets - just the probability of life elsewhere. I don't know if Drake's equation can comment on the probability of advanced life forms, but does one really need to figure that out when the age of the universe is what, 14 (I've heard even 20) billion years old? If life could exist elsewhere, so can advanced life.

You only rebutted Buzz Aldrin's claim, but the additional information was required, not just with OR alone.

So, OR only worked upon the revelation of further information. Not as an automatic dismissal. In the absence of an alternate hyposesis, you can't even use OR. OR is not evidence. But you think it can apply to every UFO sighting. There are hundreds if not thousands of UFO sightings that are just that - unexplained - many sightings or radar observations specifically refer to bright objects in the sky that got away at an incredible rate of speed, without rocket propulsion or any noise - while scientifically one can't conclude that it's ET visiting from Alpha Centauri, one can allow the possibility that it is of extra-terrestrial origin.

You insist on incontrovertible evidence, but you easily dismiss Gordon Cooper as a crackpot without any evidence that he's lying. Why would he put his reputation on line? I think you would do the same even if he took his own picture or showed you a report signed by more than one pilot. He's not the only one, but military personnel are ordered not to talk about it.
 
the_drake_equation.png
 
Are you aware that the vast majority of "UFO" sightings in North America can be attributed to the development stages of the U-2 and SR-71 both of which at the time had Top Secret Code Word clearances. There are plenty of interviews of pilots involved in the development of these two aircraft talking about hearing airline pilots going nuts down below with UFO sightings.

Absolutely, and the stealth bomber and fighter aircraft.

Yes, there are tons of hoaxes, many of which are very laughable, and some are from weather phenomenon like ball thunder, or disc-shaped cloud formations, but then there are many that cannot be explained as anything terrestrial, celestial or atmospheric that is naturaly occurring or man-made like Skunkwork projects and weather balloons or orbiting artificial satellites.
 
That first sentence of yours IS a little tough to parse - if you read it slowly, you might see that you've missed a word or two:

so far so good

This part is the problem - not to put words in your mouth, but my suspicion is that you've left out the word 'and' as well as 'smarter'.

This part is fine too.

Anyways - carry on with this discussion where you feel that arthur MUST acquiesce to the POSSIBILITY of alien life in the universe, and where he feels that there isn't enough EXTRAORDINARY EVIDENCE to convincingly prove the EXTRAORDINARY CLAIM that aliens have actually visited earth...even though those are completely different arguments...so you both better decend into the standard ad hominem attacks...:thumb:

Tough yes, fair enough, especially after dropping the word 'smarter',which was there originally but got deleted on rewrite.

It's an ad hominem attack when it true, but hey.

Arthur already agreed to the possibility in an earlier, but demands proof from the presently unfinished research.
 
The Drake Equation does not prove the probability of life elsewhere. I can use DE to show that there is NO life in the universe other than ours, if I so choose.
I came on to let you know that your statements about mathematical and astronomical proof of the existence of ET were false.
I have done so.

If not the Drake Equation, what about other mathematical or statistical conclusions about the probability of life elsewhere in this universe? Even Basketcase alluded to those.
 
Further to what was posted in #68

Aristotle (384–322 BC) gave the following observational arguments supporting the idea of a spherical Earth:

There are stars seen in Egypt and . . . Cyprus which are not seen in the northerly regions.
Travelers going south see southern constellations rise higher above the horizon
The shadow of Earth on the Moon during a lunar eclipse is round. (De caelo, 297b31–298a10)

Eratosthenes circa 240 B.C. estimated Earth's circumference as 250,000 stades only about a ten percent error, by using the differing angles of the sun at the Summer Solstice in Syene and Alexandria and the distance between the two.

Strabo (c. 64 BC – 24 AD), stated that elevated lights or areas of land were visible to sailors at greater distances than those less elevated and that the hulls of ships disapeared below the horizon showed that the Earth was spherical.

Ya for sure. Did they know the earth was round around Galileo's times? I know that Christopher Columbus felt that it was round and wanted to prove it with an around-the-world voyage.
 
Let's hear them. What's the "improved" Drake Equation?
Don't you realize - it's all based on supposition? Seriously, after all this, you haven't even grasped that point, yet?

Not simple supposition.

I took statistics in university - they can make statements with a certain amount of statistical precision based on extrapolation of a small sample. I assume these astrophysicists know what they're talking about. I'm not the one coming up with any equations.

Isn't there general acceptance by the astronomical community that the odds of life elsewhere in the universe is likely? While that in of itself is not proof of ET-life, it suggests the possibility if not likelihood of ET life.
 
Isn't there general acceptance by the astronomical community that the odds of life elsewhere in the universe is likely? While that in of itself is not proof of ET-life, it suggests the possibility if not likelihood of ET life.

'Likely' and 'possible' is very, very different from 'proof' or 'certainty' - this is the core issue of this part of this thread, which may have cause some misunderstanding.