Ancient Aliens

We still don't know they exist. And anyone claiming he knew black holes existed in 1900 would have rightly been called a lunatic. Why? Because knowledge is TRUE, JUSTIFIED BELIEF. You can believe black holes exist, and you may be right. But, if your reason for believing them is that an alien told you - you don't know jack. :)

I'll repeat, since you seem to be a bit thick - there is no reason for any rational human being to believe in aliens since it's an extraordinary claim and there is a distinct (total) lack of evidence. Got it?

Occam's Razor, people.

Occam's Razor is only a systematic method for choosing between two competing theories or hypotheses. It's not a method of disproving one theory or assertion.

You think extra-terrestrials or life on other worlds is an extra-ordinary claim because you choose not to believe in the evidence at hand. I'm not saying that it's 100% or that is highly likely. I'm saying that it's possible if not probable. They don't have to land on Parliament Hill to suspect that they exist here or elsewhere in the universe.
 
We still don't know they exist. And anyone claiming he knew black holes existed in 1900 would have rightly been called a lunatic. Why? Because knowledge is TRUE, JUSTIFIED BELIEF. You can believe black holes exist, and you may be right. But, if your reason for believing them is that an alien told you - you don't know jack. :)

I'll repeat, since you seem to be a bit thick - there is no reason for any rational human being to believe in aliens since it's an extraordinary claim and there is a distinct (total) lack of evidence. Got it?

Occam's Razor, people.

Did anyone made the claim they knew of black holes in 1900? No one knew for certain but considering they'd been suspected for over 100 years, likely and it's doubtful they be considered lunatic in 1900. No one here claimed the scientists of the day were told anything by aliens. You really do know how to fling shit about the barn don't you.

Evidence no, but the math tells a different story, just like geometry and astronomical observation told the Greeks in 3rd century BCE and Arab astronomers in the 9th century,that he earth was round yet it wasn't proved until much later in the 16th century with the circumnavigation of the world. The Greeks were able to estimate the circumference of the earth within a 100 miles, but it couldn't be 'prove' it until much later. They weren't wrong, but the technology wasn't there to 'prove' it. Got it?
 
5 Pieces of Evidence That Suggests Intelligent Alien Life Exists

While I wouldn't quote the 1st source as prima facie evidence, these are a start. I do recall actually hearing the radio exchange noted in this link between Apollo astronauts and Mission Control in a separate documentary.

http://www.paranormalhaze.com/5-pieces-of-evidence-that-suggests-intelligent-alien-life-exists/

Earthlike Planet Found Orbiting At Right Distance For Life

This is from astronomical evidence instead of advanced statistics, but more analytical work needs to be done.

http://news.nationalgeographic.com/...med-life-nasa-kepler-habitable-space-science/
 
There is no evidence at hand.

As for the use of Occam's Razor, you can believe something that requires a massive foundation of facts that you know nothing about - "aliens from another star system travelled thousands of light years and probed my anus" - or, you can believe the much simpler theory - "you've had too much peyote". If you are a rational human being, you should only accept extraordinary claims based upon extraordinary evidence.

And, for someone who's using the DRAKE EQUATION as "astronomical evidence" that aliens exist, your dismissal of the use of Occam's Razor in this argument is amusing.

But, finally, an admission - it's POSSIBLE. I agree. Extra-terrestrial life is possible, even probable. That says nothing about whether or not "ET" exists, can travel the stars, or has visited this planet. The existence of technologically advanced aliens is PURE CONJECTURE, and nothing but. You. Have. No. Evidence.

Your faith in Occams razor is commendable, but it's not fool proof. If you are in Canada and hear hoof beats, chance are it's not zebras, but in South Africa don't be so certain. As in my previous post, if the math says it should be this, don't insist it isn't because you can't see it. In Astronomy especially, it's not so so what you see that can be important, it's what you don't see.
 
There is no evidence at hand.

As for the use of Occam's Razor, you can believe something that requires a massive foundation of facts that you know nothing about - "aliens from another star system travelled thousands of light years and probed my anus" - or, you can believe the much simpler theory - "you've had too much peyote". If you are a rational human being, you should only accept extraordinary claims based upon extraordinary evidence.

And, for someone who's using the DRAKE EQUATION as "astronomical evidence" that aliens exist, your dismissal of the use of Occam's Razor in this argument is amusing.

But, finally, an admission - it's POSSIBLE. I agree. Extra-terrestrial life is possible, even probable. That says nothing about whether or not "ET" exists, can travel the stars, or has visited this planet. The existence of technologically advanced aliens is PURE CONJECTURE, and nothing but. You. Have. No. Evidence.

Forget about your silly examples of Occam's Razor. Why don't we apply it actual video or professional-observed eye-witness accounts of UFO's evading interception or defying gravity and not looking like any military craft that we know - the best hypothesis is that they are extra-terrestrial.

I'm not citing the Drake Equation as 'astronomical evidence', nor have I said that astronomy has proven that aliens have landed.

The evidence is in many visual sightings (not every picture, video or witness mind you) that cannot be explained as celestial or atmospheric phenomenon, or currently known military craft.

So YOU say there's no evidence because you haven't seen it personally yourself, but if Buzz Aldrin or some other Apollo astronaut says it, or pilot, or police, or airforce personnel says it, that's not good enough for you. Fine. You can keep on denying it. WTF do you think they saw and can explain better then them?
 
Like all lunatics, you keep on moving the goalposts so that you can't be pinned down. (The Greeks and Arabs used geometry and astronomy to deduce that the world was round - and this has been KNOWN for thousands of years - but you claim it wasn't "proven" until the 16th century? lol)

Anyway, there is no extraordinary evidence that aliens exist. What is your "math" that "tells a different story"? Please elaborate. Tell me what your Drake Equation factors are and what results it gives you.

No, it hasn't been known for thousands of years as the proof wasn't there until Columbus sailed to America ( irish monks and vikings aside) and Magellan sailed around the world. The math said it was and yet millions didn't believe it until the 1500s. You're the contemporary version of the millions. Can't see it taste it smell it, so it's not there. Oh sorry, it's probably there, but there's no proof that 'you' except, I'm not quite sure were you got you degree/training in Astrophysics. Likewise the math says there has to be extraterrestrial and not a goalpost in sight.

As for applyiong the Drake equation, not my strong suit much in the same way as string theory isn't, but I do have a basic understanding the Higgs Boson and dark matter, yet I gave a quick review of the numbers earlier, which I doubt you read, but feel free;

http://www.homepages.ucl.ac.uk/~ucapdki/numberofhabs.html
 
I thought you had hard astronomical and mathematical proof? All I see here is a bunch of wild speculation.
1. UFOs in ancient history
total hearsay
2. Astronauts have seen the UFOs
most of this has been debunked, but even if it hadn't, this is not hard evidence, just more hearsay
3. The Wow Signal
the very scientist responsible has admitted the incredible unlikelihood that this is evidence of extra-terrestrial life
4. The Drake Equation
mathematical gibberish - most of the factors are totally unknown - I could create a "Drake Equation" to calculate the number of presbyterians living in other galaxies, and it would be as useful
5. Seti 2003 Signal
if you can corroborate this with the scientists involved - who haven't said anything about it - that'd be great


So? See 4. above - the Drake Equation. Astronomers are providing good evidence for earthlike planets orbiting other stars. Yep, they sure are. On what percentage of those does life arise? On what percentage of planets where life arises does it develop intelligence? Then technology?
FWIW, please provide your values for the factors in the Drake Equation, and tell me what it implies about the likelihood of ET coming to visit.


See above.

You have yet to provide ANY astronomical or mathematical evidence that ET exists and has come calling.

Please proceed.


I valued the link more for its reference to the Apollo sighting. Who has debunked the sighting by those Apollo astronauts? I've heard the radio transmission.

Other examples point to the possibility. YOU know that in the vastness of the universe, that we can't be the only intelligent life, and since the age of the universe can support life more advanced than ours by even a million years, the possibility that UFO sightings, some of them so blatant, are examples of technologically-advanced ETs is likely.
 
No, ancient people KNEW the earth was round. It had nothing to do with Columbus! lol

The math - the Drake Equation - says NOTHING about the existence of extra-terrestrial life, so I don't know what you're talking about. If you want to say that "let me put this factor here, and that factor there ... and ... voila! soez many ETz!", that's one thing. But, you better back it up. The MATH says NOTHING until you make a bunch of wild suppositions. You're talking out your ass.

Show us here your proof that the ancients, not just a select group, knew the earth was round.

It' not me talking out my ass, it comes from people like Carl Sequin, Michio Kaku, Jack Horner, Steven Hawkings, Craig Venter, James Garvin, Victoria Meadows, just to name a few.

I know you accept it's probalby true but 'you' don't have proof. Others far more intelligent and experienced than you do, but apparently not you.
 
Your blurry, frequently-exposed-as-hoaxes "unexplained videos and pictures" do not constitute extraordinary evidence. I daresay that if you brought them to any court on the planet, trying to make your claims using those as your evidence, you'd lose, and be laughed at. The best explanation is that these are hoaxes, as such a large percentage of them have proven to be, over the years.

Is that what you've got? A bunch of "eyewitness accounts" and hazy videos? 'Cause, frankly, Occam's Razor doesn't seem very silly at all, when applied to all that. If that's really all you have, what your whole argument boils down to, I'm not interested in engaging. It's all hearsay.

The FACT is that all kinds of trained people have seen things they can't explain in the sky. To leap from that to visiting ETs is unjustifiable nonsense. That's really all there is to it.

Oh, BTW, Aldrin has REFUTED the arguments that he saw a "UFO". Just to keep you up to speed.

I never provided any video evidence so you're making up the 'blurry' stuff you're referring to. There have been some excellent threads on UFO sightings here on Terb in the past year, if not elsewere. I even know of someone who knows a small-craft pilot here in Ontario, who he claims is a rational, intelligent, successful person that saw a UFO flying below and to the right of his plane. He radioed it in but the control tower couldn't see it on their radar, although he visually saw it.

It was another astronaut. He's been quoted. However, I'm still waiting for the your evidence that debunks what Astronauts have seen as UFO's.

So every pilot, military personnel, police, or lucid, credible eye-witness (the fact that you use quotation marks around eye-witness means you are a complete, close-minded skeptic) who have seen craft making impossible maneouvres, accelerating at impossible speeds, or hovering has seen something else that is terrestrial, celestial or atmospheric which can be explained away?

I dare say that if there was a court that would rule on this subject matter, they could not explain it rationally as anything else.

And I note how you dismiss any eyewitness account as 'hearsay' even when it's first hand observations.
 
it would be narrow minded to think no other life exists on another planet in another galaxy or solar system.
Which while I believe as a mathematical probability it is almost a certainty, that doesn't mean that one has to "buy into" this "ancient astronauts" nonsense.
 
Since I really don't have time to properly educate you, here, from Wikipedia. (Yeah, teacher, I'll take the D for plagiarism. ;) )
"The misconception that educated Europeans at the time of Columbus believed in a flat Earth, and that his voyages refuted that belief, has been referred to as "The Myth of the Flat Earth". In 1945, it was listed by the Historical Association (of Britain) as the second of 20 in a pamphlet on common errors in history."
Russell, Jeffrey B.. "The Myth of the Flat Earth". American Scientific Affiliation. Retrieved 2007-03-14.
Members of the Historical Association (1945). Common errors in history. General Series, G.1. London: P.S. King & Staples for the Historical Association., pp.4–5. The Historical Association published a second list of 17 other common errors in 1947.

Next?

Aside from the fact that wasn't what I asked for, interesting to read. Nothing like offering a 70 year old reference to refute my point.
 
Here, from NASA:
Edwin Aldrin recently came out on in a special on the Science Channel and stated that the astronauts aboard Apollo 11 all saw unidentified objects which seemed to have been following them. He also mentions that they were briefed not to talk about what they had seen. What does NASA have to say in response to this? What were those objects they all saw?

I just talked to Buzz Aldrin on the phone, and he notes that the quotations were taken out of context and did not convey the intended meaning. After the Apollo 11 crew verified that the object they were seeing was not the SIVB upper stage, which was about 6000 miles away at that time, they concluded that they were probably seeing one of the panels from the separation of the spacecraft from the upper stage. These panels were not tracked from Earth and were likely much closer to the Apollo spacecraft. They chose not to discuss this on the open communications channel since they were concerned that their comments might be misinterpreted (as they are being now). Apparently all of this discussion about the panels was cut from the broadcast interview, thus giving the impression that they had seen a UFO. David Morrison
NAI Senior Scientist
July 26, 2006
http://astrobiology.nasa.gov/ask-an-astrobiologist/question/?id=1568
But, by all means, keep going.

The problem with almost all of these things is that, time and again, they're proven to be hoaxes, lies, things taken totally out of context. Why should anyone be surprised? You can believe that people make things up, or that aliens have visited us. Occam.

I found a video of Buzz Aldrin on Larry King explaining that it was one of the ejected panels from a rocket stage but not the larger stage booster before it which was further back. Yes, Occam's Razor explains that.

However, what about Gordon Cooper's claims? OR can only conclude one thing in light of no reasonable alternative theory - ET.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tkBhME9RCjc&feature=related (notice JFK in the background at the ticket-taper parade). There are earlier interviews of Gordon Cooper where his speech is not slurred but his account the same.
 
I believe you. I really do. I believe your friend saw something he couldn't explain.
How is that evidence of extraterrestrial beings?


I've provided hard evidence refuting your claim about Aldrin. Please provide a link for whatever you want me to refute next.


"Credible" eye-witness begs the question, so I'll just ignore that. But, really, YOU seem to be the one who is closed-minded - to reason.

But, in a word, yes. Either that, or they're mistaken. Or lying. Or stoned. Or have just seen something they couldn't explain at the time, and we don't have enough evidence to explain after the fact.


Then why have so many of these "credible eye-witness accounts" been shown to be hoaxes, or explained away, over the years?


It's hearsay unless you can provide first-hand accounts. Where are they? I'll gladly talk to these people. The supposed testimony of some "ancient" (the first "proof" in your link), recorded by some other person is just that. Hearsay. If you want to provide actual testimony, please proceed.

Or, you can just pay attention: So what? See my point above. How in the world do you get from "someone saw something in the sky they couldn't explain" to "we're being visited by ET"? All you have to do is answer that.


Simple explanation. It's alien or 'ET' because what they saw is not terrestrial.

It's not a bird. It's not another plane or known plane or man-made craft. It's not a balloon. It's not even Superman. What do you want? A certificate of authenticity?

You yourself summarily dismiss ANY AND ALL WITNESSES, even those who are trained observers. You will only believe it if it lands on your back yard and they come out and say "Earthling, take us to your leader" - maybe.
 
Show us here your proof that the ancients, not just a select group, knew the earth was round.
Further to what was posted in #68

Aristotle (384–322 BC) gave the following observational arguments supporting the idea of a spherical Earth:

There are stars seen in Egypt and . . . Cyprus which are not seen in the northerly regions.
Travelers going south see southern constellations rise higher above the horizon
The shadow of Earth on the Moon during a lunar eclipse is round. (De caelo, 297b31–298a10)

Eratosthenes circa 240 B.C. estimated Earth's circumference as 250,000 stades only about a ten percent error, by using the differing angles of the sun at the Summer Solstice in Syene and Alexandria and the distance between the two.

Strabo (c. 64 BC – 24 AD), stated that elevated lights or areas of land were visible to sailors at greater distances than those less elevated and that the hulls of ships disapeared below the horizon showed that the Earth was spherical.
 
Simple explanation. It's alien or 'ET' because what they saw is not terrestrial.
Are you aware that the vast majority of "UFO" sightings in North America can be attributed to the development stages of the U-2 and SR-71 both of which at the time had Top Secret Code Word clearances. There are plenty of interviews of pilots involved in the development of these two aircraft talking about hearing airline pilots going nuts down below with UFO sightings.
 
Precisely.
Dinosaurs ruled the planet for hundreds of millions of years. Mankind has ruled the planet with technology for a TINY fraction of that. There is no evidence that intelligent or technological life must surely arise on ANY of the planets in the universe which COULD do it. In fact, there seems to be good evidence that technology is self-limiting - that technological civilizations wipe themselves out after a short period of time. Possibly VERY short.
In any case, it's all wild supposition, based on mostly refuted anecdotal evidence, and is summarily dismissed by most reasonable experts.

,,,,,and in the last hundred years of that tiny time, they've learned/discovered more than the rest man kinds time on earth. The amount of knowledge is said to double every 16 years. No one here made the claim that any of our knowledge came from aliens. More jello on the wall again. Technology is superseded perhaps, not the societies around it. We manufacture things at a rate that could not be imagined at the start of the industrial revolution and are we not called an industrialized society.

Baby steps first. We are presently working on which planets have life first. Let's work on the technology of those worlds down the road. More jello.

As I said earlier, I'll put more credence in the views and findings of the scientist listed earlier than you, any day.
 
Are you aware that the vast majority of "UFO" sightings in North America can be attributed to the development stages of the U-2 and SR-71 both of which at the time had Top Secret Code Word clearances. There are plenty of interviews of pilots involved in the development of these two aircraft talking about hearing airline pilots going nuts down below with UFO sightings.


As far as sightings, I figure if they can get here, they can stay invisible better than the records would show.
 
The universe is not infinite. Please stop spreading your ignorance. Thanks. :)

Give him a break Fonzi. It's big enough for him to say that other life exists, even in equal or advanced forms.

P.S. I just saw a video on this topic. So there's no evidence that it is 'infinite' and that all we know is that the 'horizon' is 14 billion years based on the speed of light, and that it is expanding. I also recall watching a documentary that the universe could have started as a super-condensed black hole before the big bang, and that it's possible that the process of expansion could be followed by contraction, with this process repeating itself.