American Sniper

All in all, I think it was a good movie taken from one soldier's point of view. So it was not meant to delve into the broader political context of the war. I'm now quite sure how a movie can accurately capture how someone deals with PTSD, but the movie did a reasonable job with scenes before he takes the shot, and scenes at home with his family. Real life is very nuanced so I don't think it would translate well to the screen.
Which would be fine, if that's all that the movie did. But it isn't. The movie also framed the context of the entire war in a big pile of historical revisionist nonsense. It ham-handedly juxtaposes 9/11 over the invasion of Iraq, conveniently ignoring the fact that Afghanistan and nearly 2 years happened first. Even sillier, it depicts American troops fighting against Al Qaeda in Iraq in 2003. What. The. Fuck? NEVER fucking happened. Might as well have them fighting Count Dooku 's army of clone warriors. But hey, why face the uncomfortable truth that it was a local insurgency they were fighting when you can make it look like foreign Al Qaeda boogeymen* were behind it all? If this were just another stupid movie glorifying soldiers doing manly soldier things that would be fine. But it is also designed to lie to America and make Americans feel better about their shitty past. And those who forget their past, are doomed to continue being global belligerents under the mistaken impression of doing good and/or protecting anything other than their most unscrupulous interests. (or summin like that)


*Spoiler alert: The American war in Iraq was fought against local insurgents and led to the forming of flavour-of-the-month evil crazy motherfuckers we must stop at nothing to eliminate, ISIS. By pretending that Al Qadea was in the theatre from the start, we can put a layer of culpability between us and ISIS. But of course, even this bit of fiction ignores the very real fact that thanks to CIA training and funding of rebels in Afghanistan back in the "Soviets were the boogeyman" days, America was also directly responsible for creating the Taliban and other precursors to Al Qaeda. So even if you accept the lies of this flick but peel the onion a bit further, you can still see where the problem truly sits.
 
Last edited:
Hey explorerzip....... You're so righ. Michael Moore, Bill maher, Oliver stone, they're all fake. That's y they keep making the same type of movie and never try a new theme. . That's y they take death threats and need body guards at all times. But people like YOU... You I'm sure really care. People like you restore my faith in catastrophic asteroids and nuclear war.
 
Hey explorerzip....... You're so righ. Michael Moore, Bill maher, Oliver stone, they're all fake. That's y they keep making the same type of movie and never try a new theme. . That's y they take death threats and need body guards at all times. But people like YOU... You I'm sure really care. People like you restore my faith in catastrophic asteroids and nuclear war.

That escalated quickly. :confused:
 
The movie also framed the context of the entire war in a big pile of historical revisionist nonsense. It ham-handedly juxtaposes 9/11 over the invasion of Iraq, conveniently ignoring the fact that Afghanistan and nearly 2 years happened first. Even sillier, it depicts American troops fighting against Al Qaeda in Iraq in 2003. What. The. Fuck? NEVER fucking happened. Might as well have them fighting Count Dooku 's army of clone warriors. But hey, why face the uncomfortable truth that it was a local insurgency they were fighting when you can make it look like foreign Al Qaeda boogeymen* were behind it all? If this were just another stupid movie glorifying soldiers doing manly soldier things that would be fine. But it is also designed to lie to America and make Americans feel better about their shitty past. And those who forget their past, are doomed to continue being global belligerents under the mistaken impression of doing good and/or protecting anything other than their most unscrupulous interests. (or summin like that)

I think that's precisely what the movie and book were trying to do. It's an autobiography of Chris Kyle's life so he only chose to tell his viewpoint, regardless of how right or wrong it is and did not cover the broader historical context. I haven't read the book myself so it is likely that Eastwood added the 9/11 imagery to "lie to America" as you put it.
 
It's an autobiography of Chris Kyle's life so he only chose to tell his viewpoint, regardless of how right or wrong it is..

I loved the movie. BTW: Zarqawi was al-Qaeda and came in from Afghanistan just to fight the US in Iraq. I took the viewpoints of Chris Kyle as his viewpoint not an historical accurate rewrite. I also don't expect WW-II films to portray German soldiers with an anti-Hitler attitude.

If you take this film to be a soldier's story from his viewpoint - I'd highly recommend it.
 
A story of one man's war. He was just really good at it. I don't get why people are getting so bend out of shape over it. I read his book, just a regular soldier. Not much different from the guys I served with when I was a kid.

i think its the fact people watch it and claim him to be a "hero"..he's not..just a soldier
 
The Hollywood left (Michael Moore, Bill Maher et al) are pissed that American Sniper is such a huge box office success. Any day now expect the Hollywood lefties to release a movie titled "ISIS Beheader" where the hero wears a mask and cut off kidnapped people's heads.


Wow, do you think? As we enter the theatre they couple give us masks so we could feel part of the raping and murder. And save the last row for the real kinks.

Oh, oh I'm getting a chubby.
 
BTW: Zarqawi was al-Qaeda and came in from Afghanistan just to fight the US in Iraq
bin Laden complained that Zarqawi killed many more Muslims than American soldiers. Got so bad that the Iraqi Sunnis teamed up with the Americans to get rid of AQ in Iraq,
 
i think its the fact people watch it and claim him to be a "hero"..he's not..just a soldier
To be perfectly blunt, guys who were on the receiving end don't really give a shit what civilians think. There's no common ground. How do you explain you pissed your pants first time you were mortared? So, nobody says it nor considers themselves heros.
 
To be perfectly blunt, guys who were on the receiving end don't really give a shit what civilians think. There's no common ground. How do you explain you pissed your pants first time you were mortared? So, nobody says it nor considers themselves heros.

no i'm talking about the avg. american...not his fellow soldiers.. feels too hollow to put a man on a pedastal for sniping people who were just defending their own country.. from ILLEGAL INVADERS ... so should look back on Vietnam and look for some heroes who napalmed hundreds if not thousands of VIetnamese people?
 
no i'm talking about the avg. american...not his fellow soldiers.. feels too hollow to put a man on a pedastal for sniping people who were just defending their own country.. from ILLEGAL INVADERS ... so should look back on Vietnam and look for some heroes who napalmed hundreds if not thousands of VIetnamese people?

Carling who you sniping at now?
 
Which would be fine, if that's all that the movie did. But it isn't. The movie also framed the context of the entire war in a big pile of historical revisionist nonsense. It ham-handedly juxtaposes 9/11 over the invasion of Iraq, conveniently ignoring the fact that Afghanistan and nearly 2 years happened first. Even sillier, it depicts American troops fighting against Al Qaeda in Iraq in 2003. What. The. Fuck? NEVER fucking happened. Might as well have them fighting Count Dooku 's army of clone warriors. But hey, why face the uncomfortable truth that it was a local insurgency they were fighting when you can make it look like foreign Al Qaeda boogeymen* were behind it all? If this were just another stupid movie glorifying soldiers doing manly soldier things that would be fine. But it is also designed to lie to America and make Americans feel better about their shitty past. And those who forget their past, are doomed to continue being global belligerents under the mistaken impression of doing good and/or protecting anything other than their most unscrupulous interests. (or summin like that)


*Spoiler alert: The American war in Iraq was fought against local insurgents and led to the forming of flavour-of-the-month evil crazy motherfuckers we must stop at nothing to eliminate, ISIS. By pretending that Al Qadea was in the theatre from the start, we can put a layer of culpability between us and ISIS. But of course, even this bit of fiction ignores the very real fact that thanks to CIA training and funding of rebels in Afghanistan back in the "Soviets were the boogeyman" days, America was also directly responsible for creating the Taliban and other precursors to Al Qaeda. So even if you accept the lies of this flick but peel the onion a bit further, you can still see where the problem truly sits.

Generally I agree with everything you say, but to say that America is directly responsible for creating the Taliban is nuts. Deals are made with the devil you know or lesser evil, but alliances change. The Taliban don't care about the values entailed in the American Constitution.

P.S. This will be the next movie I see.
 
I hate how the trailer on the radio talks about most dangerous sniper......sounds too much like an action movie.

I can't watch war movies anymore the idea of people profiting from The misery of others for my entertainment is something i don't support.

I hate how Eastwood picked and chose what to present about kyle. He should not be viewed as a hero.

Flat out it is propaganda that some people will confuse as the truth.
 
no i'm talking about the avg. american...not his fellow soldiers.. feels too hollow to put a man on a pedastal for sniping people who were just defending their own country.. from ILLEGAL INVADERS ... so should look back on Vietnam and look for some heroes who napalmed hundreds if not thousands of VIetnamese people?
Kyle was a professional soldier. The politics of the conflict were not his business. The civilian authority decided to send him there. He did his job. Did he hate his enemies? Sure. Every soldier does. They're trying to kill you, after all. I don't know about pedestals, he was an outstanding operator who fulfilled his duty to his country that decided to send him there. He certainly is a role model for others in the military.
 
Haven't read the book or seen the movie, I'll get to it when I can watch it at home probably.

But perhaps I can this little definition of a Hero I heard once will cover a lot.

"Someone who is too tired, cold, hungry, and scared to give a shit anymore". I think this has resulted in more hero's than any other reason in history.
 
Generally I agree with everything you say, but to say that America is directly responsible for creating the Taliban is nuts.
Jesus GP, even I wouldn't admit to agreeing with everything I say! Still, yeah. Apologies, I may have not chosen my words carefully enough (there's a 233,311th time for everything!). I did not mean to imply that the US were solely responsible for creating the Taliban. That would indeed be nutty. But it is an unassailable fact that they did fund and train the mujahideen, and a lot of those same bad boys went on to start the Taliban. So yes, there is a direct line to the US, but they are by no means solely responsible for creating them. That better?
 
Kyle was a professional soldier. The politics of the conflict were not his business. The civilian authority decided to send him there. He did his job. Did he hate his enemies? Sure. Every soldier does. They're trying to kill you, after all. I don't know about pedestals, he was an outstanding operator who fulfilled his duty to his country that decided to send him there. He certainly is a role model for others in the military.
If I were Chris, I would also do everything in my power to protect the men (and women) who serve with me (and not give a damn about what some fat guy in Hollywood thinks).