Which would be fine, if that's all that the movie did. But it isn't. The movie also framed the context of the entire war in a big pile of historical revisionist nonsense. It ham-handedly juxtaposes 9/11 over the invasion of Iraq, conveniently ignoring the fact that Afghanistan and nearly 2 years happened first. Even sillier, it depicts American troops fighting against Al Qaeda in Iraq in 2003. What. The. Fuck? NEVER fucking happened. Might as well have them fighting Count Dooku 's army of clone warriors. But hey, why face the uncomfortable truth that it was a local insurgency they were fighting when you can make it look like foreign Al Qaeda boogeymen* were behind it all? If this were just another stupid movie glorifying soldiers doing manly soldier things that would be fine. But it is also designed to lie to America and make Americans feel better about their shitty past. And those who forget their past, are doomed to continue being global belligerents under the mistaken impression of doing good and/or protecting anything other than their most unscrupulous interests. (or summin like that)All in all, I think it was a good movie taken from one soldier's point of view. So it was not meant to delve into the broader political context of the war. I'm now quite sure how a movie can accurately capture how someone deals with PTSD, but the movie did a reasonable job with scenes before he takes the shot, and scenes at home with his family. Real life is very nuanced so I don't think it would translate well to the screen.
*Spoiler alert: The American war in Iraq was fought against local insurgents and led to the forming of flavour-of-the-month evil crazy motherfuckers we must stop at nothing to eliminate, ISIS. By pretending that Al Qadea was in the theatre from the start, we can put a layer of culpability between us and ISIS. But of course, even this bit of fiction ignores the very real fact that thanks to CIA training and funding of rebels in Afghanistan back in the "Soviets were the boogeyman" days, America was also directly responsible for creating the Taliban and other precursors to Al Qaeda. So even if you accept the lies of this flick but peel the onion a bit further, you can still see where the problem truly sits.
Last edited:

