Air Canada is going down

card fees

I agree with the fact that it is a scam when they charge fees for a card that is for personal use.
But I do get extended warranties on every purchase. Loss protection, and also free medical insurance on trips. The card is for business and I need supplemental cards for an employee of mine. Also it covers rental cars ( I do have a rider on my auto insurance, but if my employee rents a car for work, she is covered through the card.)
I also get 1 point for every dollar spent, and I don't carry a balance.
also if you add up $125/year X say 5 years, that might buy you a trip to Calgary.
I have already cashed points for a trip to San Francisco (business class, 2 tickets) Montreal. Calgary, and hopefully London if they are not cancelled.
So, to each their own.
 
WhOiSyOdAdDy? said:
I think the government should open our skies and allow foreign airlines to compete in our marketplace.

first off, wouldn't it be disasterous for our other airlines if US or other airlines were given free access to Canada, but we weren't given equal access to their markets?

unlike a third world country, there is no lack of capital in this country, and we do have enough expertise and experience that we should be able to run our own airlines without needing foreigners to manage things - after all, just look at all theother airlines around the world that have also had difficulties.

most likely it would be uS carriers that would take advantage of it - and eventually as canadian companies were driven out of business then the US airlines would start to route flights via their US hubs - i.e., to fly from one canadian city to another you would have to stop in a US city to change flights - and go through customs twice!

then there is the jobs aspect - with free trade, many uS companies just closed down their canadian branch plants and moved their work to the US, where they had excess capacity and economies of scale. look at the auto industry - all the good jobs are in the US, held by americans.

there was an article in the paper the other day about appliances - the uS companies are closing their canadian operations and moving them to the US - the extra transportation costs are cheaper than keeping the canadian plants open, even with our low dollar!

whoisyourdaddy, its attitudes like yours that will see us eventually become part of the US!
 
the stock is back online today
i sold my already, just to be on the save site
and i'm gonna carefully watch how this thing go, because lost $3000 dollar in two day is not acceptable to me.

just a reminder, Canada is part of the G7 country
it's gonna be funny if we don't have our own airline
even poor third world country has them.
 
WhOiSyOdAdDy? said:
If Canadians cannot compete in prodctivity then we do not deserve to have those jobs.

And no, all the good jobs are not in the USA. With NAFTA.. many, many companies have moved production from Canada... and from the USA.. to MEXICO... not to mention all of the investment and companies that had moved and sourced production in China.

Is that so bad??... we may as well be part of the usa... One day in the not to distant future, we will be forced to merge with the usa.... to compete with the EC

canadian workers are as productive as americans, if not more so, when you factor everything in. productivity is mainly dependent on investment and technology - but that is another long and complicated debate. the thing is that american companies treat canada as part of their domestic market when it comes to sales, but as a foreign country when it comes to locating facilities - the border is still there and is a source of risk (delays, currency fluctuations, etc.) plus american managers and professionals do not want to relocate to canada.

joining the USA - ya, it would be pretty bad in some respects. the worst thing for us is the way we are headed - to lose our soveignty and ability to make our own decisions - like the way the uS is trying to change our softwood lumber industry.

remeber the US rallying cry - "no taxation without representation" - thats where we are headed in effect - to be powerless in many respects - effectively run by the uS but not having any democratic influence or say. the whole thing about how we have to join the war on iraq or else lose jobs is an indication of this. eventually this situation will get so bad that joining the US will be an improvement over the situation we find ourselves in.

frankly, canada would be better joining the EC - excpet that france doesn't want us in (france is heavily dependent on agriculture - like grain, and doesn't want us cometing in europe). ironically - the EC has signed a free trade deal with mexico, but refuse to negotiate with us!

my ideal would be for us to distance ourselves much more from the US - to regain more control over our economy and reduce our exposure to the US - the uS is not that reliable of a partner... mind you, most of the things i would do are the exact opposite of our current policies - i would see us reduce immigration, exit many multinational agreements, end many of our agreements with the US (and then renogiate some of them - leveraging things like allowing military access to our airspace, norad, etc, to get a better deal) and moving our economy away from resource-based exports, including energy.

i guesss you could call me a radical-centrist economic nationalist, for lack of a better description.
 
or

mr. x said:


i guesss you could call me a radical-centrist economic nationalist, for lack of a better description.

inefficient for short.

OTB
 
Let Air Canada die and then start another Canadian based airline service.You can pay pilots and stewardesses much less and make a profit instead of paying so much for the stewards they really dont do anything to earn their money.They are overpaid hostesses and hosts,who dont really want to do anything but get to the destination and get home.They only work about 15 days a month and get paid like they are working a full time job!
 
Air Canada

How about this...Air Canada down the tube...small Regional Carriers dominate local flights (Hamilton to Ottawa-at least Sheila gets a ride)...USA/American (not sure which one) Air Carrier takes over domestic market (ie. NAFTA)..... now America controls the skies of Canada....Not a bad move for a peacetime effort...
 
Re: or

onthebottom said:
inefficient for short.

OTB
not necessarily... but then, with our current policies, our productivity has not improved much over the last 10 years, despite the fact that free trade was supposed to boost productivity.

besides which, there are benefits to greater self-sufficiency and less reliance on exports - less risk and greater stability and more control over the economy... and the economy can become even more productive (efficient) by adding value to raw materials

in many ways the canadian economy is like that of a one-industry mining town - subject to extremes of boom and bust and at the mercy of external markets. those cycles of boom and bust, and the resulting volatility of the economy, are inefficient in a different way.
 
Last edited:
Re: Re: or

mr. x said:


besides which, there are benefits to greater self-sufficiency and less reliance on exports - less risk and greater stability and more control over the economy... and the economy can become even more productive (efficient) by adding value to raw materials


I would like to know what country has this self-sufficiency? As far as I know every country relies on others for something. Stock markets are linked, natural resources are shared. What I don't have I get from someone else and in trade I will give them more of what I have.

I don't believe that it is possible to isolate yourself (maybe poor choice of words). Like it or not we are all linked and as more countries join this relationship we loose that much more self-sufficeincy. Control over our economy can only be exersized to a point.

I do believe your theory is sound Mr. x. I just doubt the ability to execute it given today's "gobal village."
 
Re: Re: or

mr. x said:
not necessarily... but then, with our current policies, our productivity has not improved much over the last 10 years, despite the fact that free trade was supposed to boost productivity.

I don't know that free trade so much improves productivity as it does reward it. What free trade allows is countries to specialize and make the most of what they have.

mr. x said:

besides which, there are benefits to greater self-sufficiency and less reliance on exports - less risk and greater stability and more control over the economy... and the economy can become even more productive (efficient) by adding value to raw materials

You don't get more efficient by adding value to raw materials, you do however get paid for it if your'e the most efficent provider.

mr. x said:

in many ways the canadian economy is like that of a one-industry mining town - subject to extremes of boom and bust and at the mercy of external markets. those cycles of boom and bust, and the resulting volatility of the economy, are inefficient in a different way.

The whole world is subject to external markets, it's called the global economy and like gravity it's here to stay.

OTB
 
Re: Re: Re: or

Cardinal Fang said:
I would like to know what country has this self-sufficiency? As far as I know every country relies on others for something. Stock markets are linked, natural resources are shared. What I don't have I get from someone else and in trade I will give them more of what I have.

I don't believe that it is possible to isolate yourself (maybe poor choice of words). Like it or not we are all linked and as more countries join this relationship we loose that much more self-sufficeincy. Control over our economy can only be exersized to a point.

I do believe your theory is sound Mr. x. I just doubt the ability to execute it given today's "gobal village."

well, i would say that the country that came closest to my theories was japan from 1950 to 1990... japan kept out GM and ford - if they had allowed free trade in automobiles or allowed their companies to be taken over, their auto industry would never have become the dynamo it was!

now, japan has had problems since 1990 - caused by the bubble economy and the fact that since then they have been unwilling to deal with corporate/bank debt and deflation. i suggest reading paul krugman, who writes for the NY times - i think he is brilliant on economic matters. mind you, he is a supporter of free trade because of the economic theory of competitive advantage, but he admits that the benefits are often oversold, and that countries like canada often need to protect infant industries. in one book, he even described canada's national policy under mcdonald as being a successful "infant country" policy!

go to http://www.pkarchive.org/ to read some of his stuff!
 
Re: Re: Re: or

onthebottom said:
I don't know that free trade so much improves productivity as it does reward it. What free trade allows is countries to specialize and make the most of what they have.

You don't get more efficient by adding value to raw materials, you do however get paid for it if your'e the most efficent provider.

The whole world is subject to external markets, it's called the global economy and like gravity it's here to stay.

OTB

oh, i also suggest reading jane jacob's - a brilliant writer and thinker who was born in the states but lives in toronto! try "the nature of economies" or some of her other books. she talks about "import replacement" and other theories that are quite interesting.

as for global markets, i think that canada should opt out where it is in our benefit. in a world where everyone signs global agreements, it might be that canada could prosper by opting out - cheating, in effect. canada is such a small player that it is unlikely that they would put up barriers just to keep us out of their markets - and as for the uS, we should be using access to our energy as an economic lever to ensure we are treated squarely.

if you ever study game theory there is one theory that says that cheaters can survive as long as they do not reach a certain threshold - just as we don't all run around with guns even though there are a few criminals out there!
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: or

mr. x said:
well, i would say that the country that came closest to my theories was japan from 1950 to 1990... japan kept out GM and ford - if they had allowed free trade in automobiles or allowed their companies to be taken over, their auto industry would never have become the dynamo it was!

now, japan has had problems since 1990 - caused by the bubble economy and the fact that since then they have been unwilling to deal with corporate/bank debt and deflation. i suggest reading paul krugman, who writes for the NY times - i think he is brilliant on economic matters. mind you, he is a supporter of free trade because of the economic theory of competitive advantage, but he admits that the benefits are often oversold, and that countries like canada often need to protect infant industries. in one book, he even described canada's national policy under mcdonald as being a successful "infant country" policy!

go to http://www.pkarchive.org/ to read some of his stuff!

X,

Japan is a good example of your cheaters theory. They had rules that were one sided and it worked for them. Now the problem is that can't embrace a new global world and they are getting creamed. I can't say that I find the cheaters theory very nobel but then again, all fair.... Hope you wouldn't mind the US leveraging it's position it the world for more than it's share of the goodies.

OTB
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: or

onthebottom said:
X,

Japan is a good example of your cheaters theory. They had rules that were one sided and it worked for them. Now the problem is that can't embrace a new global world and they are getting creamed. I can't say that I find the cheaters theory very nobel but then again, all fair.... Hope you wouldn't mind the US leveraging it's position it the world for more than it's share of the goodies.

OTB

japan isn't getting creamed - its unemployment rate is lower than the uS, for example, but there is no growth either. on the other hand, japanese companies still dominate many industries, like autos, and have set up plants around the world to produce goods.

if you read krugman, maybe you will agree with his thesis that what japan really needs to do is to print money - their problem is a lack of inflation - a problem that might soon exist in the US as well.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: or

mr. x said:
japan isn't getting creamed - its unemployment rate is lower than the uS, for example, but there is no growth either. on the other hand, japanese companies still dominate many industries, like autos, and have set up plants around the world to produce goods.

if you read krugman, maybe you will agree with his thesis that what japan really needs to do is to print money - their problem is a lack of inflation - a problem that might soon exist in the US as well.

I will look up your links as I'm a bit of an amateur economist (aren't we all). Japan's problem is that they are completely unwilling to restructure their economy and write off bad loans. There are ridiculous regulations, subsidies to farmers, bad debts..... This is all weighing on the economy. Their export business has brought them about as far as it can.

The low unemployment is in some ways a sign of the inflexibility of their system. They are the poster child for stagnation, and they aren't doing anything about it. Amazing.

OTB
 
Age-old problem

The problem of economical globalization is too fast for keeping a balance between manufactures and consumers, from William Greider’s “One World, Ready or Not”.

There are simply endless supplies of cheaper labors around, not many developing countries are going to increases its size of middle class in fears of losing investments from developed countries. More Mr. Ford are needed in these countries, who have the ambition to increase the standards of their workforce.

It is very hard to adjust the true price of goods when governments have subsidies everything from agriculture to industrial manufactures. What is unemployment cost? Why is birth rate decreased so many years in developed countries?

Japan has criticized China for the globe deflation for sometime now. Every developing country want to become the next Japan/Germany, no one wants to become the next US, even the US does not like it in a way.

Many exporters, and not enough consumers are around the world. The chain of link has weakened.

Can cheaper oil save this economy?
 
Last edited:
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: or

onthebottom said:


The low unemployment is in some ways a sign of the inflexibility of their system. They are the poster child for stagnation, and they aren't doing anything about it. Amazing.

OTB

i am confused by how low unemployment signifies stagnation - western europe has high unemployment, but it also gets labelled as being economically stagnant.

of course, many japanese companies have policies of lifetime employment - but this only applies to big companies, and even then , nissan and some others sre moving away from this.

i agree that japan has failed to act decisieively to solve their roblems - but this is a cultural trait - just like in the war - they were fearless on the act, but never learned the stategic value of retreating when it made sense!
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: or

mr. x said:
i am confused by how low unemployment signifies stagnation - western europe has high unemployment, but it also gets labelled as being economically stagnant.

Good question.

Unemployment can be both too low and too high. If you had 0 unemployment there would be no liquidity in the job market, no companies reorganizing, shifting their labor for more efficient operations..... This has historically been the problem with Japan, companies have employment for life understandings with their employees, no one rocks the boat... Very stagnant environment.

Everyone understands the impacts of high unemployment.

From a historic perspective current Japanese unemployment is high (mid 5s) vs the 3% range it tracked in 15 years ago.

mr. x said:

of course, many japanese companies have policies of lifetime employment - but this only applies to big companies, and even then , nissan and some others sre moving away from this..

This movement away from lifetime employment, and the recession is what is causing higher unemployment rates.

mr. x said:

i agree that japan has failed to act decisively to solve their problems - but this is a cultural trait - just like in the war - they were fearless on the act, but never learned the strategic value of retreating when it made sense!

I do think this is a cultural trait, that's why it hasn't changed even with crushing recessions. I think there is a parallel to your war analogy. Incredibly efficient in production but don't know when to strategically change their business.

OTB