Thank you for a well thought through and eloquent post. it is a rarity here on Terb. Sadly, I cannot match your post in eloquence, but I will respond anyway.
I do not believe that the canadian military need realistic training in warfare, and anyway, it surely cannot be a reason for sending soldiers to fight in far away places. Canada has no need to project military power around the globe like the US has, and indeed, I believe Canada could do a better service to the world by not getting involved in wars in far away places. A "coast guard" would be my wish.
I believe that no person anywhere on the planet deserve to have his life snuffed out, but has a right to life and the pursuit of happiness. There are tribal areas in far away places, where people kill each other, but there is notyhing we can do about that, except participating in the killing and thus making the situation worse. I believe Iraq and Afghanistan are recent examples of that. It saddens me in particular, when young canadian men and women are killed in far away places, and I do not think politiciens should have the right to send young people to die, even if they have signed on the dotted line, and are paid for it.
I understand your aversion to the word "waste". Like the women who died on Mount Everest, maybe the soldiers died doing what they wanted to do. I do find the deaths unnecessary and preventable.
I'm not saying we should declare war all the time to get training, I'm saying there's a silver lining. If lessons are learned, valuable insight gained and our professional military becomes more professional, regardless of the political viewpoint, it's not really a waste. The military derives a net benefit even if the average Canadian civilian does not.
My point is that if someone says, "Why are you against us being in Afghanistan?", no valid response, IMO should mention soldiers lives. "Our men and women are dying for no reason." No, not a valid answer. Our men and women are dying because that's their job and we're engaged in military action. Debate the action, not the lives.
No net benefit to Canadians, will make no difference to the lives of the Afghan people, supporting an unjust regime that doesn't reflect the will of the local populace, there purely for corporate interests, and on and on. I don't agree with all these reasons myself, but they are some of the reasons I hear given and I accept them as valid arguments in the debate. The lives of soldiers are not. One would not look at WWII, imagine themselves living back then and say, "Well, Hitler is evil and we should fight him to rid the world of his fascist tyranny, save the lives of those under the Nazi boot, liberate people living in concentration camps, and so on.... But a lot of our soldiers will die, so maybe we shouldn't go." The lives of soldiers are irrelevant in determining whether or not military action should be undertaken.
A military action is politically justifiable or it is not. Soldiers lives are there to execute the political will in foreign theatres, not be used in arguments for or against it. The value of any political decision should never be measured against lives of soldiers unless it is a decision about military administration (ie closing military resource centres, equipment acquisition or downsizing the military).

