Afghanistan

Thank you for a well thought through and eloquent post. it is a rarity here on Terb. Sadly, I cannot match your post in eloquence, but I will respond anyway.

I do not believe that the canadian military need realistic training in warfare, and anyway, it surely cannot be a reason for sending soldiers to fight in far away places. Canada has no need to project military power around the globe like the US has, and indeed, I believe Canada could do a better service to the world by not getting involved in wars in far away places. A "coast guard" would be my wish.

I believe that no person anywhere on the planet deserve to have his life snuffed out, but has a right to life and the pursuit of happiness. There are tribal areas in far away places, where people kill each other, but there is notyhing we can do about that, except participating in the killing and thus making the situation worse. I believe Iraq and Afghanistan are recent examples of that. It saddens me in particular, when young canadian men and women are killed in far away places, and I do not think politiciens should have the right to send young people to die, even if they have signed on the dotted line, and are paid for it.

I understand your aversion to the word "waste". Like the women who died on Mount Everest, maybe the soldiers died doing what they wanted to do. I do find the deaths unnecessary and preventable.

I'm not saying we should declare war all the time to get training, I'm saying there's a silver lining. If lessons are learned, valuable insight gained and our professional military becomes more professional, regardless of the political viewpoint, it's not really a waste. The military derives a net benefit even if the average Canadian civilian does not.

My point is that if someone says, "Why are you against us being in Afghanistan?", no valid response, IMO should mention soldiers lives. "Our men and women are dying for no reason." No, not a valid answer. Our men and women are dying because that's their job and we're engaged in military action. Debate the action, not the lives.

No net benefit to Canadians, will make no difference to the lives of the Afghan people, supporting an unjust regime that doesn't reflect the will of the local populace, there purely for corporate interests, and on and on. I don't agree with all these reasons myself, but they are some of the reasons I hear given and I accept them as valid arguments in the debate. The lives of soldiers are not. One would not look at WWII, imagine themselves living back then and say, "Well, Hitler is evil and we should fight him to rid the world of his fascist tyranny, save the lives of those under the Nazi boot, liberate people living in concentration camps, and so on.... But a lot of our soldiers will die, so maybe we shouldn't go." The lives of soldiers are irrelevant in determining whether or not military action should be undertaken.

A military action is politically justifiable or it is not. Soldiers lives are there to execute the political will in foreign theatres, not be used in arguments for or against it. The value of any political decision should never be measured against lives of soldiers unless it is a decision about military administration (ie closing military resource centres, equipment acquisition or downsizing the military).
 
My point is that if someone says, "Why are you against us being in Afghanistan?", no valid response, IMO should mention soldiers lives.

That is a ridiculous viewpoint. Of course we should consider the lives and welfare of our soldiers in making decisions. It is one if the largest costs, if not THE largest cost, of war. Every policy decision needs to be made in light of the costs versus the anticipated benefits.

In fact, this is the reason why it is so important to have civilian political oversight, because civilian leaders are better at assessing the costs to society of losing soldiers, and of having them come home with physical, mental, and emotional injuries.

Has Afghanistan been worth what it cost us in lives, trauma, and treasure is a very valid question.

Asking it is no slight against the soldiers who faithfully served their country. They chose to join the forces and did their countries bidding, and for that they should be proud, and honoured.

They did not choose to fight in Afghanistan, other than their choice to go and do what we asked. The choice to fight in Afghanistan was made by the government, and the government owes it to all Canadians to make sure that such choices are being made with due consideration to both the costs and the benefits (or sometimes the necessity) of going to war.
 
That is a ridiculous viewpoint. Of course we should consider the lives and welfare of our soldiers in making decisions. It is one if the largest costs, if not THE largest cost, of war. Every policy decision needs to be made in light of the costs versus the anticipated benefits.

In fact, this is the reason why it is so important to have civilian political oversight, because civilian leaders are better at assessing the costs to society of losing soldiers, and of having them come home with physical, mental, and emotional injuries.

Has Afghanistan been worth what it cost us in lives, trauma, and treasure is a very valid question.

Asking it is no slight against the soldiers who faithfully served their country. They chose to join the forces and did their countries bidding, and for that they should be proud, and honoured.

They did not choose to fight in Afghanistan, other than their choice to go and do what we asked. The choice to fight in Afghanistan was made by the government, and the government owes it to all Canadians to make sure that such choices are being made with due consideration to both the costs and the benefits (or sometimes the necessity) of going to war.

Exactly. And beyond what governing powers decide , one needs to consider the actual motives driving warfare...corporate multinational interests. It's all a nasty game wherein the front liners are brainwashed to believe they are fighting to defend our freedoms..it's never about our freedoms except for the most simple minded amongst us dumb enough to buy the spin
 
Exactly. And beyond what governing powers decide , one needs to consider the actual motives driving warfare...corporate multinational interests. It's all a nasty game wherein the front liners are brainwashed to believe they are fighting to defend our freedoms..it's never about our freedoms except for the most simple minded amongst us dumb enough to buy the spin

That's my point - the soldiers lives aren't the deciding factor. If you're going to war or not going to war on the basis of soldier's lives, you're missing the entire point of a military. Soldiers don't get paid overtime and field operations allowance isn't what it used to be. The bulk of the costs you wouldn't otherwise incur are all logistical - getting soldiers and equipment to and from your bases. But really, the soldiers are the cheap part. The equipment costs a fortune. Aircraft and ships can relocate themselves for the exact same costs involved in maintaining them here, it's getting tanks, ammunition and fuel that costs a lot. But no one ever argues the cost of logistics in going to war. Soldier's lives are the same. The politicians (and hopefully the nation) decides if military action can be justified on political grounds and political grounds alone.

What happens when everything is drones and guided missiles? If we make soldier's lives a big factor in determining whether military action is justified, are we just going to go everywhere for any reason once lives are no longer a factor? A military action needs to be justifiable on it's own merits. If it's not, we shouldn't go. It's that simple. The lives of the soldiers shouldn't play any factor in making that decision. Frankly, neither should economics. The question should be "Does someone need our help, is military action the only way to help, and are we sure we will do more good than harm?" If yes, we go. It's the only moral way to determine something as destructive and tragic as war. But the second you start arguing against military action because someone might die, you've missed the entire point. Military action is ideally only considered when people are already dying. No one has any right to say that Canadian soldiers are more valuable than the lives that we're considering going to protect. Lives are already being lost if we're thinking of joining in. So let's determine if we should go on the merits of our being there alone, or protest against because of the lack of merits. But don't make soldiers pawns in your politics.
 
That's my point - the soldiers lives aren't the deciding factor. If you're going to war or not going to war on the basis of soldier's lives, you're missing the entire point of a military. Soldiers don't get paid overtime and field operations allowance isn't what it used to be. The bulk of the costs you wouldn't otherwise incur are all logistical - getting soldiers and equipment to and from your bases. But really, the soldiers are the cheap part. The equipment costs a fortune. Aircraft and ships can relocate themselves for the exact same costs involved in maintaining them here, it's getting tanks, ammunition and fuel that costs a lot. But no one ever argues the cost of logistics in going to war. Soldier's lives are the same. The politicians (and hopefully the nation) decides if military action can be justified on political grounds and political grounds alone.

What happens when everything is drones and guided missiles? If we make soldier's lives a big factor in determining whether military action is justified, are we just going to go everywhere for any reason once lives are no longer a factor? A military action needs to be justifiable on it's own merits. If it's not, we shouldn't go. It's that simple. The lives of the soldiers shouldn't play any factor in making that decision. Frankly, neither should economics. The question should be "Does someone need our help, is military action the only way to help, and are we sure we will do more good than harm?" If yes, we go. It's the only moral way to determine something as destructive and tragic as war. But the second you start arguing against military action because someone might die, you've missed the entire point. Military action is ideally only considered when people are already dying. No one has any right to say that Canadian soldiers are more valuable than the lives that we're considering going to protect. Lives are already being lost if we're thinking of joining in. So let's determine if we should go on the merits of our being there alone, or protest against because of the lack of merits. But don't make soldiers pawns in your politics.

I would disagree with you on the point that I highlighted in red. Much too often, when "we" are going to save a population, "we" exterminate a large number of them. Iraq is an example of that. Saving the population from a nasty dictator has cost maybe up to half a million of the population "we" wanted to save. (that is the story anyway).
 
That's my point - the soldiers lives aren't the deciding factor. If you're going to war or not going to war on the basis of soldier's lives, you're missing the entire point of a military. Soldiers don't get paid overtime and field operations allowance isn't what it used to be. The bulk of the costs you wouldn't otherwise incur are all logistical - getting soldiers and equipment to and from your bases. But really, the soldiers are the cheap part. The equipment costs a fortune. Aircraft and ships can relocate themselves for the exact same costs involved in maintaining them here, it's getting tanks, ammunition and fuel that costs a lot. But no one ever argues the cost of logistics in going to war. Soldier's lives are the same. The politicians (and hopefully the nation) decides if military action can be justified on political grounds and political grounds alone.

What happens when everything is drones and guided missiles? If we make soldier's lives a big factor in determining whether military action is justified, are we just going to go everywhere for any reason once lives are no longer a factor? A military action needs to be justifiable on it's own merits. If it's not, we shouldn't go. It's that simple. The lives of the soldiers shouldn't play any factor in making that decision. Frankly, neither should economics. The question should be "Does someone need our help, is military action the only way to help, and are we sure we will do more good than harm?" If yes, we go. It's the only moral way to determine something as destructive and tragic as war. But the second you start arguing against military action because someone might die, you've missed the entire point. Military action is ideally only considered when people are already dying. No one has any right to say that Canadian soldiers are more valuable than the lives that we're considering going to protect. Lives are already being lost if we're thinking of joining in. So let's determine if we should go on the merits of our being there alone, or protest against because of the lack of merits. But don't make soldiers pawns in your politics.

Thank God that here in Canada we have politicians who are sensitive to the value of a soldier's lives, and do consider that before sending them into battle. They may not always make the right decisions, but they do try to.

And I would think our soldiers want to believe that too, "my country wouldn't be sending me into danger if it wasn't worth it" seems like something we need our soldiers to know.

Saying that the decision is purely political is silly. The political cost of having our guys come home in wooden boxes is certainly part of the political calculation.
 
I would disagree with you on the point that I highlighted in red. Much too often, when "we" are going to save a population, "we" exterminate a large number of them. Iraq is an example of that. Saving the population from a nasty dictator has cost maybe up to half a million of the population "we" wanted to save. (that is the story anyway).

Cost of civilians is a different factor. My rationale was: "Does someone need our help, is military action the only way to help, and are we sure we will do more good than harm?" If we kill 5 million people in a quest to save a 50,000 minority from persecution, I think it would be difficult to argue we did more good than harm.

Let me put it another way: if military action is the right thing to do, you do it. You don't back out simply because some of your own soldiers might die. We're supposed to act on principles. Our men and women in uniform WANT us to act on principles. They didn't join the military so that when it came decision time, we would say, "Well... it would be the right thing to do and we really hope someone goes to war, but we just don't want any of our own to die."

Can you name a single military action Canada has been involved in where soldiers didn't die? Heck, soldiers have died during peacekeeping in Cyprus. Anyone who witnessed peacekeepers in Cyprus knows how ridiculous that sounds because it was such a cushy tourist posting. Everyone wanted to go. And yet 3 peacekeepers have died there.

Welcome to the military, where people die in war, in military action, in peacekeeping and heck, even in training. If we stop doing things because Canadian soldiers have or might die, then it's time to follow Liechtenstein's steps and get rid of our military altogether.

So if you want to disagree with military action in Afghanistan, explain why it was the wrong thing to do. Don't run and hide behind our soldier's lives because that's not an argument - it's a byproduct. The sky is blue, water is wet and soldiers die in combat. The fact that soldiers die isn't an argument for or against anything, it's a simple fact of reality.
 
Cost of civilians is a different factor. My rationale was: "Does someone need our help, is military action the only way to help, and are we sure we will do more good than harm?" If we kill 5 million people in a quest to save a 50,000 minority from persecution, I think it would be difficult to argue we did more good than harm.

Let me put it another way: if military action is the right thing to do, you do it. You don't back out simply because some of your own soldiers might die. We're supposed to act on principles. Our men and women in uniform WANT us to act on principles. They didn't join the military so that when it came decision time, we would say, "Well... it would be the right thing to do and we really hope someone goes to war, but we just don't want any of our own to die."

Can you name a single military action Canada has been involved in where soldiers didn't die? Heck, soldiers have died during peacekeeping in Cyprus. Anyone who witnessed peacekeepers in Cyprus knows how ridiculous that sounds because it was such a cushy tourist posting. Everyone wanted to go. And yet 3 peacekeepers have died there.

Welcome to the military, where people die in war, in military action, in peacekeeping and heck, even in training. If we stop doing things because Canadian soldiers have or might die, then it's time to follow Liechtenstein's steps and get rid of our military altogether.

So if you want to disagree with military action in Afghanistan, explain why it was the wrong thing to do. Don't run and hide behind our soldier's lives because that's not an argument - it's a byproduct. The sky is blue, water is wet and soldiers die in combat. The fact that soldiers die isn't an argument for or against anything, it's a simple fact of reality.

I understand your point, and it is a valid point. I am not sure I agree with you, mainly because I do not believe in Canada going to war under any circumstance except when our landmass is attacked, which I am sure will never happen.
 
Our men and women in uniform WANT us to act on principles.

Things are not usually that simple. Some wars are, but a lot of times you can debate how much action to take and it isn't clear that one alternative is better than the other.

Sometimes there are clear red lines that are obvious to everyone. Sometimes there are threats that are truly existential. But most of the time it is a lot murkier.

Especially when the principles involved become ideological rather than existential: Going to war to impose democracy. Going to war so that no one thinks we are weak. Going to war over the domino theory. Going to war to bring peace to people in another region, rather than for ourselves.

I am not saying that these are never situations that justify going to war, but it becomes more of a political calculus, adding up all the costs in one column, and the benefits in another. In that calculus a stream of young people coming home in wooden boxes looms large.

Even when the threat is existential and the principles clear, at some point the cost in lives still becomes a consideration. Would we spend a million soldier's lives fighting over our Northern border with Russia? Or, even though we are clearly in the right, would at some point it not make more sense to give indignant UN speeches and leave it at that.

On the other hand, if a foreign tyrant ever threatened to conquer the entire country and enslave us all, it might be worth conscripting every single man, woman, and maybe even child to fight them off.

Obviously these extreme cases are just thought experiments, but they validate the principles. Real world decisions are things like "boots on the ground in Syria or only remote support".

That is a great example of how murky things get. On the one hand there are clear principles that are worth fighting for at play, like democracy, and freedom. There are national adversaries who stand to lose or gain a lot, Iran could be set back, or emerge more powerful. But there are complications: would Al Qaeda be the real winner? Would it antagonize even more Muslims?

In the face of all that uncertainty, the fact that it would cost a lot of Canadians their lives is effectively the deciding factor. We are willing to send money and weapons, but stop short of putting our guys lives on the line.

Can you name a single military action Canada has been involved in where soldiers didn't die?

Libya.
 
I understand your point, and it is a valid point. I am not sure I agree with you, mainly because I do not believe in Canada going to war under any circumstance except when our landmass is attacked, which I am sure will never happen.

And that's fine. In that case your argument is that we should have a defense force and be military isolationists. Perfectly valid argument. I disagree with it, but it's a valid argument. It allows you to determine your personal right. You also made no mention of soldier's lives, which is exactly my point - you believe something is either right or wrong, but you don't refuse to do the right thing just because soldiers might die. I never implied everyone would always have the same definition of right and wrong. That's why our elected officials represent us and determine what the national sentiment is. I don't pretend politicians are always right, but that's the system nonetheless. So they determine what the nation, as a whole, thinks the right thing to do is... And if it's the right thing to do, we do it.
 
. So they determine what the nation, as a whole, thinks the right thing to do is... And if it's the right thing to do, we do it.
Or in Canada's Case whatever the u.s. Wishes us to do, or shall I say, whatever u.s. Corporate and industrialist barons require of the peasant workforce
 
Last edited:
Or in Canada's Case whatever the u.s. Wishes us to do, or shall I say, whatever u.s. Corporate and industrialist barons require of the peasant workforce

Yeah! Exactly!

Unless, of course, you live in reality. The reality where the US tried to get us to join them in the Iraq invasion in 2003, where they tried to get us to commit to joining the coalition of the willing in Iraq again several times between then and 2009, where they tried to convince us to enlarge the size of our forces in Afghanistan so they could divert more resources to Iraq, where they tried to get us to extend the length of the mission of Afghanistan.

Lefties like to complain about Harper turning Canada into America, but the proof isn't in the pudding in this case. He still manages to say "No" on some pretty big issues.
 
And that's fine. In that case your argument is that we should have a defense force and be military isolationists.

That is indeed my argument, and it seems to be supported by the fact that the department of the government dealing with these things are called The Ministry of National Defense.
 
That is indeed my argument, and it seems to be supported by the fact that the department of the government dealing with these things are called The Ministry of National Defense.

Canadian defense policy is more mature than danmand defense policy. If we can keep the world as peaceful as possible, and keep Canadian regions of interest safe, quiet, prosperous, and friendly to our needs, then we will hopefully never be in the situation where our enemies actually arrive on our shores. Does Canada, does the West, get that right all the time? Of course not. But better to try to keep mother earth free, happy, peaceful, and keep wars away from our landmass, than to have to defend Canada IN Canada. A defense policy that sees Canada protecting its borders from within its borders (rather than from the other side of the planet) is a failure.
 
Dragging out the old rationale for military intervention, that the poor girls must go to school. What is Canada planning to do about the poor girls in our beloved friendly countries like Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Oman, Bahrain etc.???

I believe that girls can and do get schooling in those countries. I recall hearing about a female lawyer in Saudi getting some large appointment last year. They have a long way to go but they do have schooling.
 
... There are tribal areas in far away places, where people kill each other, but there is notyhing we can do about that, except participating in the killing and thus making the situation worse....

How about providing aid to the people in need? Education is another area that leads to better lives. Building infrastructure? Unfortunately, aid without oversight and protection becomes black market profit or aid workers kidnapped and education becomes a political battlefront. Very few people are willing to go in and help needy people in conflict zones without any protection so how do you figure we go about helping them?

You keep going on about less privileged people around the world yet now you post that Canada shouldn't be helping people in need. Seems like just another example of an academic playing at being moral.
 
That is a ridiculous viewpoint. Of course we should consider the lives and welfare of our soldiers in making decisions. ..

Might be different in other situations but I understand that every single Canadian soldier deployed in Afghanistan volunteered to go knowing the risks. They weren't drafted. They weren't forced to go. They felt for reasons of their own which I am sure are varied that they CHOSE to serve.

Yes, may wars are to serve the agendas of others but that doesn't take away from the free will of soldiers to act as they felt was right.
 
How about providing aid to the people in need? Education is another area that leads to better lives. Building infrastructure? Unfortunately, aid without oversight and protection becomes black market profit or aid workers kidnapped and education becomes a political battlefront. Very few people are willing to go in and help needy people in conflict zones without any protection so how do you figure we go about helping them?

You keep going on about less privileged people around the world yet now you post that Canada shouldn't be helping people in need. Seems like just another example of an academic playing at being moral.

You are now claiming that the canadian soldiers were in Afghanistan to protect the people helping the Afghan people. Is that the best you can come up with.

My problem is that "helping" the people of Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan inevitably involves killing a whole lot of them.