AF447 wreckage has been found

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
27,817
5,495
113
Quite an amazing feat but they have found the wreckage:

http://www.flightglobal.com/articles/2011/04/07/355305/af447-wreck-found-after-672-days.html

I have to admit, this crash was quite shocking. I have always felt the cruise portion of a flight was very save and only felt a bit of anxiety during takeoff and landing... when this state of the art plane plunged out of the sky in the middle of a long flight with no real explanation. It was quite disturbing. I hope the data on the recorders is still good.
 
It really is amazing that they found it. The ocean is a big place.

There is a very likely "real explanation" already known.

The pilots decided to fly through an area of severe thunderstorms.

There is nothing that will take you down faster than a thunderstorm that reaches up 50,000'. NO matter how big or strong theplane, nothing can beat Mother Nature every time.

This is one of the few real problems with airline pilots. They get used to success penetrating areas of thunderstorms, until it is too late. Pilots are taught to fly well clear of thunderstorms, yet some get too close and some penetrate them.

The Air France jet that ran off the runway at Pearson a few years ago did so because the pilots made the decision to land in the immediate proximity of a Level SIX thunderstorm. Level SIX is the highest level there is. We may see a dozen of these in Ontario all year. The outflow winds, microbursts and associated windshear can overwhelm the most capable aircraft.

But the Airlines and pilots all want to find mechanical reasons to excuse what come down to bad decision making.

I am not sure if the storm itself was the reason. After all, it is believed the plane was intact when it hit the water...probably trying desperately to recover from a dive or stall. The theories I have seen that seem most credible include loss of situational awareness by the pilots that were thrown a curveball by malfunctioning speed indicators. In either case I hope we find out definitively. It was quite a shocker as 330 is state of the art and very popular I can't count the number of times I have flown on one.
 
It is odd that they think the plane hit the water belly first, and the oxygen masks were not deployed.

If they were in a storm at night they could perhaps have been caught in the mother of all downdrafts that pushed them straight down into the ocean. Would such force not rip the wings off the plane though?

If they lost situational awareness at 36,000 ft, how do they get to 0 ft without noticing? The plane is pressurized - descending to sea level would result in ear pop wouldn't it? Mine pop when descending for landing as the pressurization in the plane adjusts. If they flew gradually down to 0 ft would not ground proximity alarms go off alerting "Terrain!...Terrian!"?
 
It is odd that they think the plane hit the water belly first, and the oxygen masks were not deployed.

If they were in a storm at night they could perhaps have been caught in the mother of all downdrafts that pushed them straight down into the ocean. Would such force not rip the wings off the plane though?

If they lost situational awareness at 36,000 ft, how do they get to 0 ft without noticing? The plane is pressurized - descending to sea level would result in ear pop wouldn't it? Mine pop when descending for landing as the pressurization in the plane adjusts. If they flew gradually down to 0 ft would not ground proximity alarms go off alerting "Terrain!...Terrian!"?

It may have been very gradual, as they focused on the speed issue....before you know it they were in a death spiral. It is also possible the engine flamed out after they stalled. In either case, if they did stall, they would have been falling for over 10 mins before they hit the water...how horrible. No masks indicates the plane did not depressurize
 
It may have been very gradual, as they focused on the speed issue....before you know it they were in a death spiral. It is also possible the engine flamed out after they stalled. In either case, if they did stall, they would have been falling for over 10 mins before they hit the water...how horrible. No masks indicates the plane did not depressurize

If the engines flamed out would they not have had time to radio in a distress call though and let ATC know they were in trouble and what the trouble was? During the 10 minutes they were falling before they hit the water.