Acura or Lexus

I think only a mechanic could love a jag, a car you may spend more time fixing than driving.

I practically pee myself when I see a Series 1 or 1.5 E type on the road.

They are the pinnacle of automotive engineering and styling. And really easy to repair. And the don't depreciate at all. Mind you, they are a fun car, but so what. You only live once.
 
I practically pee myself when I see a Series 1 or 1.5 E type on the road.

They are the pinnacle of automotive engineering and styling. And really easy to repair. And the don't depreciate at all. Mind you, they are a fun car, but so what. You only live once.

I'm unclear how they can be a pinnacle of engineering when they break down so often. Lexus is a pinnacle of ACTUAL engineering. The kind that results in tight tolerances with incredible reliability.

You are confusing engineering with loud.
 
I'm unclear how they can be a pinnacle of engineering when they break down so often. Lexus is a pinnacle of ACTUAL engineering. The kind that results in tight tolerances with incredible reliability.

You are confusing engineering with loud.

I doubt I could explain it to you.

E types are not loud, they purr. They are everything that is right about the art of automotive engineering. There isn't a Japanese car that has ever been built that is a classic. Not a single one. This is a fact and not emotion talking. They are reliable enough I admit, but they don't produce an emotional response in any way shape or form. An E type can make a grown man weep with pleasure. A Japanese car will just make you look for your keys.
 
After extensive research, Audi are unreliable, and depreciates after than either Acura or Lexus. If you have money to burn, buy Audi Bmw Mercedes, but they depreciates after than Japanese due to long term reliability issues.
Oh, Audi is also the least safe luxury brand.


On my 4th Audi, 2 sedans, 1 sport coupe and 1 SUV. Have loved the past and love the currently owned. Never an issue with reliability. Not sure where the extensive research of unreliability comes from but Consumer Reports lists them as near the top of the list of reliable. Lexus leads the pack, but I am not fond of the Darth Vader looking front end.

80-consumer_reports_reliability_list_1_1e1c8af50ee6465c44faa736b1bb35a37385aad3.jpg
 
I doubt I could explain it to you.

E types are not loud, they purr.

I doubt you can explain it either. On anything that you would call excellence in engineering they are substandard. Reliability is the hallmark of engineering excellence, along with safety, efficiency, and performance. For any of those factors I can name a greatly superior car at a lower price. If you aren't leading in ANY of those categories you aren't talking about engineering excellence and you certainly aren't the pinnacle of it.

What jags lead in is anachronism.
 
Some on-line comparisons. I couldn't find any from big-name reviewers:
http://www.thecarconnection.com/car-compare-results/acura_rdx_2015-vs-lexus_rx-350_2015
http://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2015/06/2016-acura-rdx-awd-review-video/
" Perhaps a better question: is the Lexus RX worth $10,000-$15,000 more? The RDX is more nimble, more engaging, faster, has a hair more leg room and is significantly less expensive. The only real downside to the RDX is the loss of 15 cubic feet of cargo space."


The current RDX has basically the same engine as a Honda Odyssey, but requires premium for some reason.
Because the engines are tuned to make power and torque in different parts of the RPM range. RDX is rated 279 hp @ 6200 rpm, 252 lb.-ft. @ 4900 rpm. Odyssey is rated 248 @ 5700 rpm, 250 @ 4800. The RDX timing is more aggressive. I believe the two engines also use different cams (the part numbers are different, but I couldn't find the specs to confirm they are indeed different) and VCM programming. In order to take advantage of these power creating enhancements that you need to use higher octane fuel. Allot of people on AcuraZine run both 87 and 89 octane in their RDXs and although the car runs fine, most see lower gas mileage and less peppiness.
 
I doubt I could explain it to you.

E types are not loud, they purr. They are everything that is right about the art of automotive engineering. There isn't a Japanese car that has ever been built that is a classic. Not a single one. This is a fact and not emotion talking. They are reliable enough I admit, but they don't produce an emotional response in any way shape or form. An E type can make a grown man weep with pleasure. A Japanese car will just make you look for your keys.

LOL, why bother. Fuji is ..... Fuji. He'll argue anything with anybody, truth and facts be damned. It's not that you can't explain, it's that he could never understand.

My dad had a V12 E-type Series 3. What a car! The ride, the engine, the interior, the feel, the sound .... all perfect. Still one of the most sought-after collector cars. Pop the hood and people will crowd around. The machinery was ..... beautiful. Women will willingly throw their panties at a Jag, can an RX owner claim the same?

Did you ever drive a Datsun 240Z? Although no E-type, that was an awesome car and probably the closest the Japanese came to a vintage iconic vehicle. I'd love to get one as a toy car. In the Mississauga car club that meets at Applewood mall during the summer on Wednesdays (Thursday?) one member has a beautifulfully restored 240Z (260Z?).
 
LOL, why bother. Fuji is ..... Fuji. He'll argue anything with anybody, truth and facts be damned. It's not that you can't explain, it's that he could never understand.

My dad had a V12 E-type Series 3. What a car! The ride, the engine, the interior, the feel, the sound .... all perfect. Still one of the most sought-after collector cars. Pop the hood and people will crowd around. The machinery was ..... beautiful. Women will willingly throw their panties at a Jag, can an RX owner claim the same?

You can call jaguars whatever you like, just don't call them pinnacles of engineering. In an engineering sense they are an inferior car in every way. If you want to say you like the look and the interior fine.
 
Glad to see all this good dialogue from car enthusiasts.

My Infiniti was a G35, and despite the badge it felt cheap on the inside. Towards the end, it was falling apart and cost me a tonne in repairs.

The G37 was a disaster, and Nissan couldn't wait to replace it with the Q50. The Q50 is a nice car but the ride was harsh and the interior was too gimmicky, so I went with a Lexus.

I currently drive a GS, and I love it.

Not crazy about the aggressive appearance of the new NX & RSX though. Mine has the new signature spindle grill, but these 2016's have taken it to a new level.

As for Acura.....The only ones I see on the road are MDXs & RDXs. Forget their flagship RLX, I barely see any TLXs & ILXs out there!

Their golden era was the 99-03 TL. That was my dream car growing up. Still see some around today.
 
Last edited:
Interesting.. Now I may give Subaru another try. They are among the safest cars in crash tests. It's just the cheap interior that turns me off, but I guess it's an acceptable sacrifice given their price points.

I feel Subaru is undeservingly underrated in Ontario given its harsh winters. True it doesn't have the glamour, zip and star appeal like Lexus and the other German cars. It also lack acceleration, if it matters. But it feels "Germanic" in terms of its sturdiness vs the other popular Jap brands and it is a workhorse.
 
I feel Subaru is undeservingly underrated in Ontario given its harsh winters. True it doesn't have the glamour, zip and star appeal like Lexus and the other German cars. It also lack acceleration, if it matters. But it feels "Germanic" in terms of its sturdiness vs the other popular Jap brands and it is a workhorse.

Ontario gets the cold but not the snow. If you visit places that get a ton of snow, especially mountainous areas, when you walk through the parking lot at the grocery store and look at ten cars parked in the lot it'll be subaru, subaru, 4runner, subaru, jeep, pickup truck, subaru, subaru, another truck, and a subaru. In the more affluent areas there'll be a few Lexus RX's in the mix (basically luxury 4runners).
 
Ontario gets the cold but not the snow. If you visit places that get a ton of snow, especially mountainous areas, when you walk through the parking lot at the grocery store and look at ten cars parked in the lot it'll be subaru, subaru, 4runner, subaru, jeep, pickup truck, subaru, subaru, another truck, and a subaru. In the more affluent areas there'll be a few Lexus RX's in the mix (basically luxury 4runners).

I read some years ago, there is a snowy town (or maybe it is a small city) in the USA, I think that is nicknamed Subaru Town because most drive a Subaru!
 
I'm just having fun with you. I actually really respect your opinion and enjoy your stories, but I like poking at you for some reason. :p


The G was rebranded "Q" when Infiniti wanted to reinnervate their branding. I think the early G coupes are one of the most beautiful "normal priced" cars ever built.


Umm - no. Different engine tuning and internal components . Different transmission. Different brakes, Different suspension tuning and components. Should I go on?


Soccer moms - LOL - nicely done. Almost all manufacturers are seeing an increase of truck/SUV sales over car sales in North America, so your statement is misleading. What is Infiniti doing wrong?


Umm - no. In the US, Acura sales are 30% higher: http://www.autonews.com/section/ussales ...... and thus as a result, North America.


Aren't Lexus for old men ..... old man?


We agree. I like the S5 for sport and S6 for practicality. Most Audi owners I speak to bitch about service costs and insurance rates although they love their cars.
Me - I'm a Porsche man. 911 Turbo for fun and Macan for daily driver ..... unfortunately only in my dreams. Currently I'm trying to swing an Audi SQ5, but my insurance agent has other opinions, insurance is 2X my work RDX.

I'm also a jag fan. The British know how to design a chassis for looks and performance.

I like the Lexus GS. For a daily driver. It would be the only high end Jap Scrap I would consider purchasing at the given time. Recently redesigned, it's still understated, but it's not as "old man" as the ES or worse, the LS. The IS is just a wee bit too small for me.

As far as the 911 goes, I love the 356 actually.

You might find this interesting:

http://www.topgear.com/car-news/classic/porsche-911-40-singer-greatest-car-you-can-buy-today#1

It's an interesting choice of which 911 is the greatest ever made. (According to my Teutonic car friends, the best 911s are the earlier models. The more mechanical models. Much much easier to work on and mechanical as opposed to electronic.
 
I recently went to "Jap Scrap". It's funny how owning exciting, but fundamentally poorly designed crap, cars can make you appreciate boring reliable cars. Fortunately, Porsche and Mercedes have stepped up their game. They may not be Lexus reliable, but the S-class and Panamera are viable alternatives to the LS. Sadly, for the OP, the Cayenne, X5 and GLE are not quite there yet.
 
You can call jaguars whatever you like, just don't call them pinnacles of engineering. In an engineering sense they are an inferior car in every way. If you want to say you like the look and the interior fine.

Inferior? An E? You clearly know not of what you speak.

First off, no production car is the pinnacle of engineering.

But the E type Jaguar is indeed as close as it ever came. It was born out of the C-type and the D-type. (Interestingly enough, designed by the same Engineer who designed the E-type, who tragically died at the age of 53. He was the Michel Angelo of the automotive world, a mathematician, engineer, and an artist. He was a Renaissance Man. He designed everything by hand using a slide rule and his god given mathematical ability.

You seem fixated on your perception of "reliability" as the benchmark to which the moniker of "best" can be applied. My definition of the pinnacle of automotive engineering takes into account a far broader spectrum than just reliability. Sure, reliable is great and all, but a boring car is a boring car no matter how reliable it is. To most people, a car is just a means to an end. A to B and they, like you, look for that which accomplishes A to B as sensibly as possible. (Hence why we have so many eggs on the road these days.) That's not me.

I look at the old E type and I see a complete package in one car that you just don't find in too many cars. (Ok, the 59 Ferrari California would be a complete wet dream for me.) And speaking of Ferrari, Enzo Ferrari himself called the E-type the most beautiful car ever made. High praise indeed.

You judge a car by its reliability and its practicality. That works for you I understand. But to me, a car, the right car, is a work of art.


Artcurial_Retromobile_2012_04pop.jpg


1959 Ferrari California.

Absolutely stunning car and if you have 5.6 million pounds, you could buy one.
 
Lexus...and it's not even close. WTH happened to Acura??? Such a cool brand 20 years ago. Now no one seems to give a fuck.

I happen to love the Acura brand. They just don't market it properly. They've been able to have success with their SUV's but not their cars for some reason. Their best selling car of all time I think was the Integra (I owned one it was fun to drive)
I test drove the TLX and the RDX was impressed with both.
 
I love how this thread started out with Acura vs Lexus and ends up in Jaguar debate with resident know-it-all fuji of course chiming in. :)
 
@Captain...sorry to hear you have had no joy with the G. My M is indeed a 7 speed but the lag you mention is non-existent. It's a 2011 btw, and I have kept it mint with only 42K KM's on it. It looks and drives as new and I have not had a single maintenance issue. One recall on the rear auto-sunshade because it "might" develop a rattle...I have deployed the thing only once to see how it functioned. I shall be keeping the M as it is also outstanding in the snow with dedicated winter rubber. On another note I am currently in the market for a drop-top and pricing is understandably excellent @ this time of year. On the list (2009-2013) SL55/63; 2012-13 650ix; MAYBE 2016 Stang GT (gives me manual and 2+2). Also Lexus looks like it may have finally gotten its act together for 2016/17 with the new SC which looks amazing and has very respectable HP and Torque specs (467/390). Auto only of course...Was not impressed with the S5 Cab which was my initial go-to. Maybe time to dump the G and treat yourself? G/L
 
I happen to love the Acura brand. They just don't market it properly. They've been able to have success with their SUV's but not their cars for some reason. Their best selling car of all time I think was the Integra (I owned one it was fun to drive)
I test drove the TLX and the RDX was impressed with both.

I simply cannot buy a car that markets "Super Handling All Wheel Drive" unless it's a toy for my 8 year old nephew...Acura really should lose that even if it is ummm..."Super..."
 
The exact same thing can be said about Infiniti. What manufacturer doesn't share components between their various brands? Regardless, any shared component is "tuned" for the new application. Since Acura outsells Infiniti 2 to 1, most buyers who spend disagree with you.

Infiniti SUVs exteriors reminds me of a over-bloated land barges with tacky chrome bits tacked on. Interiors are beautiful. Only good looking G was the first generation G35 coupes - they were works of automotive art. The modern G37s and all 4 door G are ugly, ugly, ugly.



LOL! What is it with the old-timer posters here on TERB? As is well known in racing circles, mechanics make the worse drivers. Wrench turning is a science. Driving well is an art. BTW, I also am a mechanic. Reality sucks!

@Captain...sorry to hear you have had no joy with the G. My M is indeed a 7 speed but the lag you mention is non-existent. It's a 2011 btw, and I have kept it mint with only 42K KM's on it. It looks and drives as new and I have not had a single maintenance issue. One recall on the rear auto-sunshade because it "might" develop a rattle...I have deployed the thing only once to see how it functioned. I shall be keeping the M as it is also outstanding in the snow with dedicated winter rubber. On another note I am currently in the market for a drop-top and pricing is understandably excellent @ this time of year. On the list (2009-2013) SL55/63; 2012-13 650ix; MAYBE 2016 Stang GT (gives me manual and 2+2). Also Lexus looks like it may have finally gotten its act together for 2016/17 with the new SC which looks amazing and has very respectable HP and Torque specs (467/390). Auto only of course...Was not impressed with the S5 Cab which was my initial go-to. Maybe time to dump the G and treat yourself? G/L

So you would buy a crappy F type because of why? My original comments were in response to your twice posting about the F type, which is a box of crap on wheels. Yeah maybe fifty years ago Jaguar had one car that was a performer in its day. Not since.

The 2015 Indian car brand named Jaguar is not a pinnacle of anything, they specialize in anachronism not in engineering.