Acura or Lexus

New Mercedes GLA. Starts at $38K. AMG version with 375HP starts at $51.7K. Cheaper and faster (4.5s 0-60) than the Audi SQ5 and Porsche Macan Turbo

Can't tell from the pictures if it's styled as a small SUV or tall station wagon, but it looks good. Looking forward to seeing one on the road.

mercedes-gla-concept-shanghai-000.jpg


maxresdefault.jpg
 
There's a pretty good market in Toronto for used 911s. If you are interested, I can provide you with URLs to about a half dozen exotic car sellers in the GTA, plus Lease Busters and the Porsche web site has a quite good dealer used car search engine.

If you are looking to buy, do your research. 911s definitely have bugs and they are very, very expensive to fix (I can recommend some shops in the west end). Join http://pcaucr.org/, the members are very good with information and recommendations. Excellence magazine has a review of used Porsche models each month that will provide key information for new buyers.

Thanks for the info. Exotic and luxury cars are fun but the maintenance is like a mistress :(
 
Based on as in built on the same frame in the same factory from the same line. It isn't a conceptual similarity or an architectural similarity.
Fuji, modern factories can build different platforms on the same production line. It's certainly possible there are different frames involved. I couldn't be bothered to check the part numbers just to prove you wrong yet again. You'll just argue the 3rd bolt from the left is the same. Regardless, 98%+ of the components on the 3 cars are different, therefore they are different cars.


Did you click through to the reliability section and read where it says no data?
Yes I did. Did you read Edmunds' description on how they come up with the ratings? Obviously not.

Edmunds has their own ratings on the main page and the reliability link shows 3rd party opinions (i.e Identifix or JD Power). If the Edmunds site hasn't set up the link, no data is displayed. That's why I made it easy for you and included the JD Power link.

I note you now seem focused on just the F-type instead of Jaguar line in general. I'll bet it's because the other Jag models have been rated top quality and design. Being new, the F-type has less available data.

I really wish I could ask your wife if she likes the Jag. Like many women, I'll bet the smile will say it all.
 
Subaru sold 2.5x as many outbacks this year as 2009. Are you sure that the raw number of complaints didn't just reflect there being a surge in the number of owners? Is that site averaging or is it just giving a raw total?

BTW, the very brief scan I did of that site showed that the complaints were frequently about the manual transmission, eg, excessive oil consumption. Though I didn't look in detail or collate the results.

CVT was introduced in 2010.

Also need to see what the complaints are in total. There is a JD Power survey that shows a similar story but it didn't distinguish minor problems from major ones, so it is hard to tell if it is people complaining about the crappy and outdated entertainment system, or if they were having serious mechanical issues.

Is the 2.5x sales figure only for Canada or also US? The carcomplaints website includes US complaints I think. If the 2.5 sales increase is true, then it could explain some rise in complaints in proportion as well. You can click on the year bar, details will open on. In 2015 Electrical problem cause engine not starting: http://www.carcomplaints.com/Subaru/Outback/2015/electrical/ . In 2014, it's dominated by hesitant acceleration - I read some of complaints - CVT are to blame: http://www.carcomplaints.com/Subaru/Outback/2014/engine/

Even if 2.5x increase in sales number, in 2009, there were only 8 complaints, and 2010, there are only 9 complaints. But 2013,14,15 are 31, 35, 38 respectively. It's more 4 times increase in complaints rather than 2.5 times.

Just as a comparison, Honda Civic: http://www.carcomplaints.com/Honda/Civic/ graph looks low number in recent years, and higher number in previous years, which makes sense as vehicle age, some problems start showing up. Another domestic example, Chevy Equinox: http://www.carcomplaints.com/Chevrolet/Equinox/ same predictable trend.

Luxury brands seem to do pretty well. Acura RDX, and Lexus RX, both of which use traditional automatic transmission.

Another surprise is Honda CRV also plagued with CVT problems in recent years: http://www.carcomplaints.com/Honda/CR-V/2015/

Moral of story: avoid unproven technology
 
2.5x is the increase in US sales, I believe Canada had a similar increase.

The brief look at the results showed a lot of complaints were for excessive oil consumption in the manual trim. I don't think you can blame the CVT for whatever that represents.
 
Fuji, modern factories can build different platforms on the same production line. It's certainly possible there are different frames involved. I couldn't be bothered to check the part numbers just to prove you wrong yet again. You'll just argue the 3rd bolt from the left is the same. Regardless, 98%+ of the components on the 3 cars are different, therefore they are different cars.



Yes I did. Did you read Edmunds' description on how they come up with the ratings? Obviously not.

Edmunds has their own ratings on the main page and the reliability link shows 3rd party opinions (i.e Identifix or JD Power). If the Edmunds site hasn't set up the link, no data is displayed. That's why I made it easy for you and included the JD Power link.

I note you now seem focused on just the F-type instead of Jaguar line in general. I'll bet it's because the other Jag models have been rated top quality and design. Being new, the F-type has less available data.

I really wish I could ask your wife if she likes the Jag. Like many women, I'll bet the smile will say it all.

You should only take survey sites like Edmunds or even carcomplaints or JD powers as grain of salts, as most luxury buyers either don't have time to write complaints, or don't want to bother. Rich people drive a car for only a couple of years then trade it in for something newer, and leaving problems for used car buyers who usually have lowered expectable of low reliability and prepared to either - work on the car themselves as weekend hobby or know a mechanic who are enthusiastic can get cheap aftermarket parts to do all kinds of mods, which voids the warranties anyway, so they too are not likely to post complaints either.

So it is really difficult to accurately say the long term durability of luxury brand cars like BMW, Porsche, MB, Land Rover, Jag, etc. all of them bring smile out of women face because they are status symbols and women are attracted to status. But everyone knows that a cheap Honda civic will outlast any of the European Elite cars.

More expensive means more luxury and performance. Does not necessarily mean more durable
 
Fuji, modern factories can build different platforms on the same production line. It's certainly possible there are different frames involved. I couldn't be bothered to check the part numbers just to prove you wrong yet again. You'll just argue the 3rd bolt from the left is the same. Regardless, 98%+ of the components on the 3 cars are different, therefore they are different cars.

In this case whether you admit it or not the Prado platform is explicitly used by Toyota to build tacoma, land cruiser, 4 runner, and GX. Toyota calls it the "international Prado platform" and if I have to choose between believing you or believing Toyota, I'm going to believe Toyota.
 
2.5x is the increase in US sales, I believe Canada had a similar increase.

The brief look at the results showed a lot of complaints were for excessive oil consumption in the manual trim. I don't think you can blame the CVT for whatever that represents.


Top complaint 2015 (Engine won't turn over): http://www.carcomplaints.com/Subaru/Outback/2015/electrical/engine_wont_turn_over_wont_start.shtml
I read them all, they are all automatic, or CVT
Top complaint 2014 (Hesitant when accelerating): http://www.carcomplaints.com/Subaru/Outback/2014/engine/hesitates_when_accelerating.shtml
All but one is Manual tranny. all are CVT

Oil consumption is well known bug in Subaru boxer engine, but it's ranked pretty low after recent CVT and electrical bugs showed up.
 
Engine won't turn over wouldn't be a CVT issue. Most likely a dead battery. Hesitant while accelerating is likely CVT but the question is whether it was actually hesitant or just didn't sound the same to somebody coming from a different platform.

I still don't know how to interpret that data, it seems too anecdotal. Would like to see a controlled study. JDPower did do one but it unfortunately didn't ask owners to distinguish major and minor problems or break them down, so you can't tell whether it was "wheel fell off in traffic" or "engine won't turn over" or just "entertainment system outdated".
 
In this case whether you admit it or not the Prado platform is explicitly used by Toyota to build tacoma, land cruiser, 4 runner, and GX. Toyota calls it the "international Prado platform" and if I have to choose between believing you or believing Toyota, I'm going to believe Toyota.

Correct, except not the Land Cruiser (not the NA LCJ200 anyways). The LC shares a platform with the LX and was derived (shortened) from the Tundra 2nd gen.
 
Fuji fixating on CVT again. I believe this is about the 5 th time I can recall him braying on about the wonders of a CVT transmission.

CVT is an unmitigated disaster and anyone who buys a car with a CVT is in for a world of hurt.

Audi was an early pioneer into CVT and last year,they dumped it for good. Absolute junk.
 
Fuji fixating on CVT again. I believe this is about the 5 th time I can recall him braying on about the wonders of a CVT transmission.

CVT is an unmitigated disaster and anyone who buys a car with a CVT is in for a world of hurt.

Audi was an early pioneer into CVT and last year,they dumped it for good. Absolute junk.

Yap yap yap. The data at the link I posted above absolutely and definitively proves you wrong but keep bleating.
 
I don't know why anybody would praise Subaru, it does nothing very well, be everything so, so.

It doesn't handle worth shit, because of full time AWD, so whats so great about it.

Even IF its AWD system was slightly superior, so what, big deal, there's more to driving a couple of months in snow.

FAST
 
I don't know why anybody would praise Subaru, it does nothing very well, be everything so, so.

It doesn't handle worth shit, because of full time AWD, so whats so great about it.

Even IF its AWD system was slightly superior, so what, big deal, there's more to driving a couple of months in snow.

FAST

If you ever got stuck in snow say a ramp into a highway clogged with snow and a Subie just cruises by you without any struggle you may appreciate it more. It is not for everyone but again I think a Subie is great value and underrated.
 
Fuji, where is your source for Subaru increased sales 2.5 times? My data doesn't seem to agree: http://www.goodcarbadcar.net/2011/01/subaru-outback-sales-figures.html
There is an increasing trend, but sales in 2014 total is 138792, and 2010 total is 93148, that's 50% increase
Number of power train complaints in 2014 is: 33 (http://www.carcomplaints.com/Subaru/Outback/2014/)
Number of power train complaints in 2010 is: 6
Complaints increased by 5x

From your page:

2009: 55,356
2014: 138,790

138.8/55.4 = 2.51

2010 and 2014 are both CVT. 2009 model year was the last year without a CVT. From the site I linked above reliability improved dramatically starting with 2010 models.

I will grant you that Toyota has even better reliability numbers but Subaru reliability improved dramatically from what it was when the CVT was introduced.
 
I don't know why anybody would praise Subaru, it does nothing very well, be everything so, so.

It doesn't handle worth shit, because of full time AWD, so whats so great about it.

Even IF its AWD system was slightly superior, so what, big deal, there's more to driving a couple of months in snow.

FAST

It depends where you are driving and in how much snow or whether you drive into the woods in shitty unmaintained roads.

In Toronto I agree with you, but if you go to Vermont or out to the Rockies and drive through a mountain pass road on a day when four FEET of snow has fallen the Subaru will get you through it. So will a 4Runner or a Jeep or anything else with 9 inches of clearance and 4/AWD. Your Acura ain't getting you home in that. It is going to slide off the road if it doesn't high center first, assuming you can even get it moving. When you cruise past a sign that says "All vehicles must carry chains" and then the cop who is turning everybody else back waves you through you appreciate a vehicle with real snow capability.

People buy Subaru's because the rest of the year they are still practical vehicles that suck less gas than a 4runner and are more reliable than a Jeep.

But sure in Toronto arguably you won't hardly ever deal with conditions an Acura can't handle so long as you give it good snow tires. We get cold but not deep snow and certainly not deep snow on top of ice on a steep mountain road.

Subaru has a niche market that doesn't appeal to you unless you live in a place like that or sometimes take your vehicle down a muddy logging road to a camp site.

It is an outdoors and severe weather niche that not everybody needs.
 
From your page:

2009: 55,356
2014: 138,790

138.8/55.4 = 2.51

2010 and 2014 are both CVT. 2009 model year was the last year without a CVT. From the site I linked above reliability improved dramatically starting with 2010 models.

I will grant you that Toyota has even better reliability numbers but Subaru reliability improved dramatically from what it was when the CVT was introduced.

Okay, maybe it has nothing to do with CVT, but the number of complaint increase from 2010 to 2014 by almost 5 times, is not due to increased sales. It's something else, electrical or engine. This is very concerning to a perspective buyer like myself.
 
If you ever got stuck in snow say a ramp into a highway clogged with snow and a Subie just cruises by you without any struggle you may appreciate it more. It is not for everyone but again I think a Subie is great value and underrated.

Compared to a Q50 with AWD ?

As I said, IF the Subaru full time AWD system is slightly better than my Q50, but will NOT allow the car handle like a rear drive sports sedan, for most of the year, sorry, I enjoy the handling of a sports sedan more than a possible better AWD system.

Don't get me wrong, I'm NOT saying that the Subaru is a bad car, or not worth the cost, just have to consider other aspects than AWD.

The Scion FRS uses the Subie boxer motor, which enables it to have the lowest center of gravity of ANY car on the road.

FAST