Acquital for Zimmerman

Because you are falling into one of the holes of hearsay - to whit: because Bob is a bad person, therefore Bob must have committed this crime.

Are you kidding us? Half of the posts in this thread reads like: "tM was a bad person, so he must have attacked GZ"
 
OK ... Am I missing something ... The evidence shows that this kid started beating in Zimmerman ... THEN he shot him. Why the fuck is there a problem. Granted the approach may have be race based but if he was in a place where he wasn't know and someone asks "who are you" the responsible answer is "I'm so and so ... I was vising my friend at ..." This response keeps you alive and shows you to be a fine upstanding citizen regardless of color, race or creed.

He was shot because of the way he acted ... not his color. Should Zimmerman have a gun ... no! But its south Florida ... he'd be the only one unarmed! The circus created by political agendas is sickening. Al Sharpton ... go away and keep race out of it. Unless you are willing to acknowledge that the young mans reaction was part to blame ... just shut up! Avoiding the harsh reality that the main issue is gun control and making it about race just shows how media has a grip on us all.

Wait a minute lets back up a little here, who confronted martin with a 9mm? And you believe martin was the aggressor?
 
Because you are falling into one of the holes of hearsay - to whit: because Bob is a bad person, hence therefore Bob must have committed this crime.

That is not hearsay, lol. And no it doesn't mean they committed this crime, but it does mean that this person has a violent and aggressive past. And means that this type of behavior is not out of the realm of possibility. This plays on Zimmerman's character. Anyways, Zimmerman will get his. Something weird will happen to this Vigilante crazy mofo, and justice will prevail one way or the other.
 
Wait a minute lets back up a little here, who confronted martin with a 9mm? And you believe martin was the aggressor?



That's what i'm sayin. Only one of these people had a gun, and only one of these people is a Stalker. You follow me strapped with a gun and i'm doing nothing wrong and somehow i'm the aggressor? LMFAO!!! Also your not a police officer so why are you following me and then trying to ask me questions? For all Martin knew this was just some crazy mofo following him.
 
You are as entitled to believe that G.Z. was stalking T.M. as others are to believe that O.J. Simpson actually murdered his ex-wife and Ron Goldman.

That doesn't change the fact that legally the proven facts are that neither one of them did what they were charged with doing.

I don't "believe" anything but you are embarrassingly wrong in stating that the defence proved that Zimmerman is innocent.

It is very very basic to our legal system that the defence only needs to raise a reasonable doubt. They do not, and are not required to, prove their client innocent.

The difference is subtle and if you consider only Zimmerman the difference is irrelevant, but that difference is extremely relevant if you start trying to use the verdict to make claims about what Martin did.

A reasonable doubt is enough to have Z presumed (not proved) innocent but it gives NO INFORMATION on whether M was even remotely culpable.

You should be ashamed for not knowing this.

In any case you are entirely wrong to say that either OJ or Z was legally proved innocent. They are presumed innocent which is very very different.
 
Are you kidding us? Half of the posts in this thread reads like: "tM was a bad person, so he must have attacked GZ"
With extremely limited exceptions you cannot introduce evidence at trial which shows prior bad acts. The reason for this rule is as stated above "Bob is a bad person, hence Bob must have committed this crime."
 
The Defence didn't prove that, the jury held that.

The jury proved nothing. The jury returned a not guilty verdict. The jury did not return a verdict of innocent, there is no such thing. That implies that they had at least a reasonable doubt as to his guilt, and it implies nothing more than that. He is therefore presumed (not proved) innocent and is set free, not jailed, not given a criminal record.

It is a well known and well accepted fact that many people receive not guilty verdicts when in fact they have really committed the crime. We prefer a system that errs on the side of not removing freedoms for a variety of philosophical reasons that I fully support. "Better ten guilty men go free than one innocent man go to prison" and all that.

At any rate the point you are furiously trying to avoid is this: A reasonable doubt that Zimmerman is guilty does not prove that Martin is guilty!!!
 
Last edited:
What it does explain is that it is quite possible that Travon was in a drug induced state and this may have added to his violence. His drug induced state may have lead to his own problems and getting blown away.

That is why the history of Travon in THIS CASE, may have been important evidence to explanation the ENTIRE events.
True.

More importantly, it was established through the "911" call that Zimmerman suspected that (Martin) might be "high or something". This makes relevant whether Martin was on drugs at the time, as well as whether he had a history of drug use and ingredients for drugs he was known (through his cellphone records) to use.

That's why there was an evidentiary hearing on this point, at which the Judge apparently found that while presumably relevant, it was incidental to the facts of the case (again, I presume because the level of drugs in Martin's system at the time was very low), inflammatory, and excluded from the trial.


As for Juror B37's interview with Anderson Cooper, she indicated that the initial vote was 3 for acquittal, 2 for guilty on manslaughter, and 1 for guilty on second degree murder. They proceeded to organize and review all of the evidence, and while at least one or two jurors seemed to want to convict Zimmerman of "something", they looked closely at the law and the evidence, and found that there was simply nothing in the law to convict him of, and all six jurors agreed that Zimmerman should be found Not Guilty.

They agreed that Zimmerman feared for his life at the time of the gunshot: whether this was because of the beating Martin was inflicting on Zimmerman, or because Martin was reaching for Zimmerman's gun, or both, is less certain.
 
The jury proved nothing. The jury returned a not guilty verdict. The jury did not return a verdict of innocent, there is no such thing. That implies that they had at least a reasonable doubt as to his guilt, and it implies nothing more than that. He is therefore presumed (not proved) innocent and is set free, not jailed, not given a criminal record.

It is a well known and well accepted fact that many people receive not guilty verdicts when in fact they have really committed the crime. We prefer a system that errs on the side of not removing freedoms for a variety of philosophical reasons that I fully support. "Better ten guilty men go free than one innocent man go to prison" and all that.

At any rate the point you are furiously trying to avoid is this: A reasonable doubt that Zimmerman is guilty does not prove that Martin is guilty!!!

You almost have it there Fuji. The trial is only one part of it.

The law says Zimmerman is ALWAYS INNOCENT, until proven guilty.

He WAS, and still is, INNOCENT.

in the end, the trial did not change his status.
 
With extremely limited exceptions you cannot introduce evidence at trial which shows prior bad acts. The reason for this rule is as stated above "Bob is a bad person, hence Bob must have committed this crime."

You mis read Danmand's post. While you are barred from introducing evidence of the ACCUSED'S prior bad acts, the prior bad acts of the alleged vic can be introduced where relevant and especially so in when a defence of self-defence is raised. As such, the defence could have argued TM's bad character if it was relevant to the defence. Relevance would include drug use, propensity to break the law and propensity to violence - or its symbols such as firearms. These all suggest that TM might potentially be a person who would attack and do violence to GZ.
 
Geez, oagre, I don't know what is going on here... you and I are on the same page in these matters!!!!:D

Perry
 
I didn't mention Gz's past till now.

But to answer the question of would I want him in my neighbourhood?

No

He assaulted a police officer (was supposed to take anger management classes), he and his girlfirend have mutual restraining orders for domestic violence, he made a huge number of 911 calls ranging from unruly kids at the pool to suspicious people. He carries a concealed handgun. This to me paints a picture of an unstable and unreasonable person armed with deadly force.

Has anyone here called 911 for unruly kids at the pool?

Now TM is no prize either suspended from school three times for skipping, having a pot pipe, and graffitti.

I wouldn't want either living in my hood if I had the choice.
 
I read a timeline of the events down to the second and the 3 or 4 minutes of missing time is what still puzzles me.

What's more likely

1) the two have a verbal exchange that turns violent (this scenario disregards who started it but if you want separate this into two options 1a) verbal exchange and GZ starts and 1b) verbal exchange and TM starts

2) TM attacks GZ unprovoked?

To me it's likely 1a or 1b which suggests to me that GZ played a role in escalating this.

I'll close with the sentiment that is most important to me..... no one had to die that night
 
BTW instead of arguing with fuji over the word innocent.... I see what he is saying. Which is that the court did not have enough evidence to erase reasonable doubt in the minds of the jury that GZ was innocent. But that doesn't mean that GZ was not responsible (just that the court couldn't prove it past the necessary point)

I found it interesting readin the interview with one of the jury members. There's seems to be a difference between their gut feeling and what's right vs the law.
 
Bottom line:

What this case and the reactions from the media, public, legal profession, etc. since the time the events happened until now paints a sad picture of what many people call "America the Ugly."

What will it take for the U.S. of A. to turn the corner and redeem itself?

Perry
 
Bottom line:

What this case and the reactions from the media, public, legal profession, etc. since the time the events happened until now paints a sad picture of what many people call "America the Ugly."

What will it take for the U.S. of A. to turn the corner and redeem itself?

Perry

I'm not so sure that if this happened in Canada that it would be any prettier.

But yes I agree the case brought out the worst in a lot of people. Too bad one family is now missing a son,
 
BTW instead of arguing with fuji over the word innocent....
But the problem is that the words "innocent" and "guilty" are legal terms.

For myself, I have no doubt that GZ bears at least some responsibility for what happened. I agree with the juror that GZ started something which escalated beyond GZ's ability to handle it.

Nevertheless, that is a long way from the racial profiling argument that provokes so much anger without any reliable evidence to support it.

"Over and out."

Perry