Acquital for Zimmerman

True but that;s not what you originally stated. re "who" started fight.

What I said is blatantly obvious to anyone who paid attention in highschool civics class:

Finding a reasonable doubt that Zimmerman was guilty did not prove his innocence and did not prove Martin guilty.
 
What I said is blatantly obvious to anyone who paid attention in highschool civics class:

Finding a reasonable doubt that Zimmerman was guilty did not prove his innocence and did not prove Martin guilty.

im pretty sure Zimmerman thinks he is innocent!
 
Finding a reasonable doubt that Zimmerman was guilty did not prove his innocence and did not prove Martin guilty.
What you can't get through your head is that GZ is presumed innocent and remains innocent unless and until a jury is satisfied beyond reasonable doubt.

There is no need to prove GZ innocent and to say so merely shows that you were not paying too much attention in class... to say nothing of your ignorance of the law!

And TM was not charged with anything so your comment about proving his guilt [or innocence] is plainly absurd.

Perry
 
What you can't get through your head is that GZ is presumed innocent and remains innocent unless and until a jury is satisfied beyond reasonable doubt.

There is no need to prove GZ innocent and to say so merely shows that you were not paying too much attention in class... to say nothing of your ignorance of the law!

And TM was not charged with anything so your comment about proving his guilt [or innocence] is plainly absurd.

Perry

Zimmerman did not do anything unlawful so says the court. But that does not mean he didnt do anything wrong.
 
What you can't get through your head is that GZ is presumed innocent and remains innocent unless and until a jury is satisfied beyond reasonable doubt.

There is no need to prove GZ innocent and to say so merely shows that you were not paying too much attention in class... to say nothing of your ignorance of the law!

And TM was not charged with anything so your comment about proving his guilt [or innocence] is plainly absurd.

Perry

Presumed innocent is not the same thing as proved innocent. You should know that.

My comments were directed at several people above in the thread who seem to think that the defence proved its version of events true and who are now treating that version as if it were proved fact.

In reality the defence only raised a reasonable doubt, that their version might be the truth even if it probably isn't.

That is as it should be from the perspective of what should happen to Zimmerman. He should not go to jail and not get a criminal record. We demand a high standard before taking away a persons freedom.

However from the perspective of Martin and comments here on him it does not mean that people here should conclude he was at fault. That was not proved. In fact it may be that Zimmerman is most likely at fault.
 
Presumed innocent is not the same thing as proved innocent. You should know that.

My comments were directed at several people above in the thread who seem to think that the defence proved its version of events true and who are now treating that version as if it were proved fact.

In reality the defence only raised a reasonable doubt, that their version might be the truth even if it probably isn't.

That is as it should be from the perspective of what should happen to Zimmerman. He should not go to jail and not get a criminal record. We demand a high standard before taking away a persons freedom.

However from the perspective of Martin and comments here on him it does not mean that people here should conclude he was at fault. That was not proved. In fact it may be that Zimmerman is most likely at fault.
I have to agree for the most part with fuji here.................with the exception of his personal bias highlighted above.
 
IF he knew his chances were nil as you suggested then he should not have gotten out of his car. Are you suggesting that he was dumb enough to think that a confrontation was going to end in a friendly manner?

I agree with you on the get out of dodge or call the cops. Calling cops would be too slow. Running is an option. Do you agree that in that situation panic sets in and it's fight or flight?

BTW even if a person had a criminal past (unknown to the wannabe cop) they should be able to walk down the street and not be acosted by the wannabe cop. Since GZ knew nothing about hte person and had no way of knowing what their past was.... that's why I suggest it should be ignored. Secondly, no matter what your past is in that creepy situation any person will do the fight or flight. And their past probably doesn't make them lean one way or the other. I could just as easily see someone with a criminal past using flight as their first option.


This whole trial is B.S Zimmerman killed an unarmed teenager. The only person with a criminal past is Zimmerman. Zimmerman has had 2 priors before this of Assaulting a police officer and domestic violence. Zimmerman is the thug here, not Trayvon Martin. Check your facts.

In 2005, Zimmerman was arrested and charged with "resisting officer with violence" and "battery of law enforcement officer." Both these felonies are considered third-degree. Due to his desperate attempts, the charges were reduced to "resisting officer without violence" and then the only remaining charge was also completely waived off when he entered an alcohol education program.

In the same year (2005), Zimmerman's ex-fiance, Veronica Zuazo, filed a civil motion for a restraining order, alleging domestic violence. In retaliation, Zimmerman filed for a retraining order against Zuazo and both these claims were resolved with both restraining orders granted.

As I stated only one of these people had a criminal record. And it was the shooter and murder George Zimmerman.
 
This whole trial is B.S Zimmerman killed an unarmed teenager. The only person with a criminal past is Zimmerman. Zimmerman has had 2 priors before this of Assaulting a police officer and domestic violence. Zimmerman is the thug here, not Trayvon Martin. Check your facts.

In 2005, Zimmerman was arrested and charged with "resisting officer with violence" and "battery of law enforcement officer." Both these felonies are considered third-degree. Due to his desperate attempts, the charges were reduced to "resisting officer without violence" and then the only remaining charge was also completely waived off when he entered an alcohol education program.

In the same year (2005), Zimmerman's ex-fiance, Veronica Zuazo, filed a civil motion for a restraining order, alleging domestic violence. In retaliation, Zimmerman filed for a retraining order against Zuazo and both these claims were resolved with both restraining orders granted.

As I stated only one of these people had a criminal record. And it was the shooter and murder George Zimmerman.
Completely irrelevant to this case.
 
Interesting, it was a split decision, 3 for and 3 against in the jury room. I guess a tie goes to the defendant.
 
I would take TM walking as suspiscious...YES. DEFINELTY.

His age, the rain, the GATED COMMUNITY, his stopping and looking oddly at houses (maybe cars), and no purpose...Yes I take it as suspiscious. If Im the Neighbourhood watch guy, I too would take notice.

I get that you may FC walk and stop and look at the starry nights...... and that sometimes you may get wet doing it.....but on those wet nights...you ARE NOT looking at the constellations, or the houses...as it is cloudy and you likely are getting home. I am doubtful, as a man of your age, that you stop to look dreamily at a house for sale in the pouring rain.

But maybe you do! Which, too, would be suspiscious!!


Last time I checked a neighborhood watch person is not a policeman. The only thing I know that neighborhood watch people do is call the police. They don't carry guns and pretend to be cops. They aren't trained to know what is suspicious or what's not suspicious. A cop tells this dummy to not follow this kid then listen to the cop. It's not hard, and it's funny that the guy doing the following after the cops told him not to did the killing. This case is simple, it's not hard. How anybody can keep trying to make a case for Zimmerman is crazy. Cause at this point nobody knows what really happened when the altercation happened. But what we do know is that Zimmerman was stalking and unarmed kid that had done nothing wrong, and if cops would have got there they wouldn't have charged Trayvon Martin with anything either because he wasn't doing anything wrong. Cops probably would have asked him what you doin if he was still there when the cops arrived. And Martin would have said i'm just on my way home, and cops would have said where's home? And the kid points to where he lives and it's raining, and the cops probably give him a ride home to get him out the rain. End of story...

But nooooo..... We got Vigilante wanna be neighborhood watchman following and stalking people through a neighborhood. Packing a gun no-less, this is crazy. And scary at the same time. Can you people imagine that's you in this situation with some strange man following you through a neighborhood? A person that's not a cop? At that point Martin was standing his ground, and was defending himself from some crazy guy with a gun.
 
Completely irrelevant to this case.

How is it irrelevant to this case if a person has priors of violence and this same guy just killed somebody with a gun? Are you crazy? How is it not relevant when the defense said that Martin has marijuana in his system as part of their defense? That sure was relevant, but Zimmerman having priors is not relevant to saying that this guy is a violent man which has been documented? ha ha...
 
My comments were directed at several people above in the thread who seem to think that the defence proved its version of events true and who are now treating that version as if it were proved fact.
You are as entitled to believe that G.Z. was stalking T.M. as others are to believe that O.J. Simpson actually murdered his ex-wife and Ron Goldman.

That doesn't change the fact that legally the proven facts are that neither one of them did what they were charged with doing.
 
Interesting, it was a split decision, 3 for and 3 against in the jury room. I guess a tie goes to the defendant.
Criminal Jury verdicts must be unanimous, perhaps the first vote was a tie, but the final vote must have been unanimous or they all lied in open court when they told the Judge it was.
 
How is it irrelevant to this case if a person has priors of violence and this same guy just killed somebody with a gun?
Because you are falling into one of the holes of hearsay - to whit: because Bob is a bad person, hence therefore Bob must have committed this crime.
 
Criminal Jury verdicts must be unanimous, perhaps the first vote was a tie, but the final vote must have been unanimous
Yes.

The juror who went public on Anderson Cooper is planning to write a book with her attorney husband about her experience in this trial.
 
OK ... Am I missing something ... The evidence shows that this kid started beating in Zimmerman ... THEN he shot him. Why the fuck is there a problem. Granted the approach may have be race based but if he was in a place where he wasn't know and someone asks "who are you" the responsible answer is "I'm so and so ... I was vising my friend at ..." This response keeps you alive and shows you to be a fine upstanding citizen regardless of color, race or creed.

He was shot because of the way he acted ... not his color. Should Zimmerman have a gun ... no! But its south Florida ... he'd be the only one unarmed! The circus created by political agendas is sickening. Al Sharpton ... go away and keep race out of it. Unless you are willing to acknowledge that the young mans reaction was part to blame ... just shut up! Avoiding the harsh reality that the main issue is gun control and making it about race just shows how media has a grip on us all.