A Very Serious Question

fuji said:
First some harsh question, sorry just please recognize that there are always two sides to every story and we are only getting your side. Also worth your sitting down and giving some hard thought to as well just in case it never really crossed your mind:

Do you come with the package? Is it possible that your wife is refusing to see YOU, and not the daughter? Are you using your daughter to get to your ex-wife somehow? Could your daughter spend the week with your ex-wife, but without you?

Assuming you have offered to let your ex-wife spend time alone with her daughter...

If she really is that sick, if she really honestly can't stand the daughter, and it has nothing to do with you, then you are almost better off telling your daughter that her mom is dead.

Almost.

In reality that would be used against you severely if the mother ever changed her mind, and some day the daughter will get angry at you when she learns the truth--so ultimately I agree with the other posters, tell your daughter the truth.

Do make it the truth.

If the truth is it's because your ex-wife can't stand YOU and thinks any time spent with the daughter will mean having to put up with YOU, then tell the daughter that.

If the truth is she just can't stand being a mother, then find some way to tell your daughter that too.

Next....

Is there a grandmother around on the mothers side? At least she could have some connection to that side of her family through a grandmother, aunt, or some such. Are they speaking with you? What's their advice? It's THEIR daughter so the mom might have spoken more openly/honestly with them about it, and THEIR grand-daughter...

These are fair questions.
My original post, was brief, as I don't want to reveal too many personal details. But, although I have full custody, unsupervised visits are approved. Her last stay over at my ex's was 18 months ago, I get a call at 1am "She threw up, I don't know what to do, come get her."

Additionally, my visit to the UK will be supervised, I'm not going to another country without knowing where my daughter is at ALL times.

We are in constant contact with my ex-inLaws, VERY good relationship with both myself and my daughter, and they still keep apologizing for their daughter's behavior. In fact, I'm in NYC for work this weekend, my daughter wanted to come with me (she loves museums), of course I couldn't leave her alone in a hotel or bring her to a photo shoot, so I invited my ex-mother in-law to come along. So the relationship is pretty strong there.

I am now going to meet the both of them for dinner now. This is going to be a tough conversation...
 
shoeguy said:
We are in constant contact with my ex-inLaws, VERY good relationship with both myself and my daughter, and they still keep apologizing for their daughter's behavior.

This is excellent, and at the risk of offending them, after this trip to Europe, I suggest asking them for help explaining to your daughter who her mother really is. 7 might be to early, but if she's getting these questions from her friends, she needs (and deserves) to have an answer. And as you explain it her grandparents can make this much more effective, because she wont be able to go straight to "dad's lying to me about mom" the way kids of divorces tend to (I speak as one there)
 
Honestly dude, the best thing is to be truthful. Not brutally, as your daughter is only six, but truthful in an age appropriate way. The issue will continue to come up for many years, and if you continue using her age as a guide on what to say, and how, at the appropriate time she will fully understand the situation without feeling left out (by telling a string of half-truths along the way and then dropping a bomb) or being over burdened by it (by being to frank for her age). I was the victim of the first transgression. In the meantime, if your ex ever wants to see her, leave the onus on her to arrange it without leaving yourself in a vulnerable position. You're fine.
 
shoeguy said:
Additionally, my visit to the UK will be supervised, I'm not going to another country without knowing where my daughter is at ALL times.

So reading between the lines...

Is there a conflict here between your wife not wanting to see you, and you wanting to know where your daughter is "at ALL times"?

I can imagine your wife reacting to this as though you are trying to use your daughter to force yourself back into her life; while you perceive it as simply a prudent step given that it is a "foreign country".

Would a reasonable compromise be that you drop your daughter off every morning at your ex-wife's home, and come by every evening after dinner to pick her up? Make it clear that she need not interact with you other than for a minute or so when you pickup or drop-off your daughter.

You could rent a cellphone in the UK and tell your ex-wife that if at any time she feels unsure of what to do that she can call you and you will arrive to do whatever is needed--take the daughter home, resolve any problem, etc.
 
I really do thing you can sit down with your daughter and speak with about it. Help her, a long the way as she gets older. From my own experience speaking with her and being there to answer in a positive way is the best way to handle it.

No need to be harsh with her just answer, the question as she asked them and be honest. Their always a nice…This is a hard subject to deal with on this board, or any where else for matter sakes.

Really this stuff happens and she does have her grand parents let them assist you as the question come up. As I know myself they will come up every now and then. Just be there to speak with her and be supportive.

No offence here but opinions are like assholes...we all got them and this situation is delicate to begin with.....:)
 
Some people just aren't cut out to be parents. And this includes women.

I think society is far less understanding when a woman does this then when a man does it.

Your daughter is lucky she has you.
 
Some people just aren't cut out to be parents. And this includes women.

I think society is far less understanding when a woman does this then when a man does it.

Your daughter is lucky she has you.

Now this I agree wit 100%
 
Shoeguy, with the additional information. Might I suggest that you talk with your ex-in-laws and agree on what you are going to say. I would suggest that, however, you phrase it, that you state that it is sad that mommy has something wrong with her - and that she can't help it. . . and emphasize (even if we don't know the mechanics) that this just something that sometimes happens and that there is no reason why this would happen to her.

If you know anyone who is a "friendly" psychologist, or pastoral counselor doubtless they would have some really good and useful advice.

Sorry to hear all this, and I hope you and your daughter both have a really fun time in the U.K.
 
Fuji,

Perhaps, although I don't practice much of it (Thank GOD!), I've been around too much Family Law.

Shoeguy's actions including supervised visitation seem perfectly prudent to me given his ex-wife's condition and the fact that he has sole custody, and the visitation is overseas.

You may be correct, however, from what we've been presented I don't see it.
 
I think you cannot expect much from your ex in the mothering department.

I recall watching a Dr.Phil show about this issue and I thought his advice was excellent. He attempted to empower the child by suggesting that in the absence of their parent , they have to be a parent to themselves.

Encourage your daughter to empower herself to accept things for what they are and move on.

I wish you well...
 
Does this skank pay child support?
 
Well, that was the most difficult thing I have ever had to do thus far. I chose door number 1 "Honesty is the best policy".

*Anyone who has kids will see the heart blistering pain in this*
I had to bring it down to a second grader's level, but, what I told her is that when we get on the plane this week to go on vacation, we're not going to be able to see mum, (why?), well, mum is not ready to be a mommy yet. (When will she be ready?) I'm sorry hun, but I don't know when she will be ready, but when she is ready, we will fly her home or we can see her. (Even during school?) Yes, even during school. (How come mommy's not a mommy but you're a daddy) Because I love you very much. (How come mommy doesn't love us?) *UGH!* That hit me like a ton of bricks. My ex Mother in-Law took over from there as the room was spinning for me. *sigh* We all shed a few tears, good thing the restaurant was almost empty.

And just like Daddy's little girl she asks (Can we go surfing instead?) *You see, I have surfing pictures from when I was a teenager living on the West Coast, and for the past year, she has wanted me to teach her to surf* We can get an instructor to teach you to surf, but yes, we can go surfing.

My ex Mother in-Law bought me this: http://www.amazon.com/Just-Two-Us-Will-Smith/dp/0439087929

For those who don't know, it's about the relationship between father and son, but she told me this still applies. I cried. Yeah I said it.

Thanks for everyones helpful suggestions. I really hope this hasn't messed her up.
 
You sound like a really great father. That had to be as hard as anything can be but you did the right thing. It will be hard for all of you and you have all my sympathy, but you've got this on the best course a person can put it on from the brief glimpse I can see.
 
This will probably sound overally alarmist, but needs to be said anyway:
DO NOT GO TO ENGLAND (OR EUROPE).

If you are dealing with anyone even slightly mentally ill, stay on ground where you at least know your legal footing. If she wants to visit her daughter, she can come to Canada.

If you go to England, and she even mentions custody to any of the judges or child protection officers, then you will not be allowed out of the country with your daughter. Keep in mind, you could be accused of all sorts of crap that isn't even slightly true. The authorities will not let you leave with your daughter until they are 100% convinced none of it is true, and you will have a very difficult time proving your innocence.

The local papers just recently covered a story of a single mother who just moved to Canada from the United States. A neighbour said the daughter "might be" a kidnap victim. Children's aid took custody of the daughter, the cop runnig the case didn't believe any of the story, and it took one week and a judges order to get the child released. The judge threw it out on lack of evidence, before DNA results cleared the mother. CAS was really off-base on the case.

Granted England is probably the best country in the world for a Canadian to have a custody dispute in. However, from any legal point of view, I would strongly suggest encouraging the mother to come to Canada. If you want to do something nice, pay the airfare for her Mom to come to Canada.

Don't take your daughter somewhere where a Mom with chronic mental illness could make your life hell. Don't put your fate and your daughter's fate in the hands of someone that doesn't trust herself with your daughter.

Additionally, if your daughter wanted to see her Mom, your vacation is ruined now anyways. It just won't be fun for your daughter or for you.

Cancel the vacation. Don't go. It is a really bad idea on so many different levels.
 
My advice would have been to cut this woman completely out your daughter's life for good since you have full custody. Forget supervised visits because she has proven that she does not take any interest in this child which is unfortunate. The only problem is your ex-in-laws are still in your daughter's life which is a good thing.

I would take your daughter to couselling and also be honest with her. While the truth may hurt for a while, kids are resiliant and can adapt to these types of situations with the proper guidance. It is a good thing she has one parent to lean on. Most importantly, do not bad mouth her biological mother. She will ask questions later on and by maintaining a diplomatic view about her mother's absence in her life, she is less likely to be bitter about the whole situation.
 
I think that what you told her was not just a good way to put it, but it was very honest and true. Just as some Dads simply walk away, so do some women. Although it is more rare, it still does happen. For a child it is unfathomable because the one person who is supposed to love and protect them simply doesn't want to be in the picture. Your daughter will eventually find her own way to cope with this but, just in my opinion, if you can keep her Mom somehow in her life, at least she may one day have the opportunity to reconcile. Otherwise she will go her whole life wondering why her Mom abandoned her. Counselling will help but eventually your daughter will come to her own decision on how to deal with this and probably decide on her own that she doesn't want to see her Mom anyway. Until that day keeping at least the opportunity open for reconcillation is all that you can do.
 
First, my deepest condolences. Any, my sincere congratulations to you, for being such a stand-up father. Well done; you should be very proud of your commitment to your daughter.

To deal with Fuji's points - if you are that concerned/worried, have you considered offering to let your ex mother and/or father-in-law accompany you? That keeps you daughter under the watch of people you trust, and removes any concerns your ex may have, about your involvement in the visit.

If you don't want that or can't make it work, then I suggest you lie to the little girl (for now) and take her somewhere fun. Enjoy Europe for a week then go to some place a kid her age would love. Euro disney or the real one or whatever. If there is a way she can bring a little friend along, at least for the second week, that would help distract her from the lack of her mother's company. Fuck the money, spend it on the kid, now, to help hide this trauma. It will come up eventually, and it will be a nightmare, but for now, just keep her happy.

Good luck.
 
Hey Shoeguy...

Cherish this relationship and time with your daughter. (Which I'm sure you already do...) Sounds like you made an effort to include the Ex and she slammed the door at every opportunity... too bad for her. Move on. Yes it is sad that your daughter will not have that relationship with her mother, tragic even, but your daughter has you. And by the sounds of things, that is absolutely great!

There is NOTHING MORE SACRED and SPECIAL than a Father/ Daughter relationship!
I Know... I have 2... and they are the lights of my life! :)