A real step towards peace

basketcase

Well-known member
Dec 29, 2005
62,466
6,990
113
Abbas's 'moderate' party has made a massive step towards peace with Israel today.

http://www.thestar.com/News/World/article/300212
Suicide bomber kills woman in Israel

eb 04, 2008 08:07 AM
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip – A Palestinian militant group says the two suicide bombers who attacked the Israeli town of Dimona today entered Israel from Egypt.

One Israeli, a woman, was killed in the attack, but the second bomber was shot dead before he could detonate his explosives.

Abu Fouad, a spokesman for the Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigade, says the operation had been planned for a month but only became possible after Gaza militants knocked down most of a border barrier with Egypt on Jan. 23.

The border remained open for a week before it was finally resealed on Sunday.

Israel has been on high alert since the border breach, fearing militants from Gaza might sneak into Israel through Egypt's porous border.

Fouad said the group initially said the attackers were from the West Bank as a diversionary tactic because they didn't know if the second attacker was still alive. Once they confirmed he was dead, they announced that they were from Gaza.
 
I must be missing something. I didn't read anything to indicate there was any move towards peace, let alone a massive one.
 
Abbas has about much control of the Al Aqsa Martyr's Brigade as I do over the weather, the Palestinians just like anyone else arent this monolithic single entity that speaks with one voice or movement.
 
scouser1 said:
Abbas has about much control of the Al Aqsa Martyr's Brigade as I do over the weather, the Palestinians just like anyone else arent this monolithic single entity that speaks with one voice or movement.

Is there anyone for the Israeli's to negotiate with?

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
Does the Israeli government really care?

They survive by the force of fear and insecurity.

Total Nonsense, DQ... this is beneath you...

While I don't believe that the Israelis are blameless by any means, what are their options? What do you propose that they do?

There have been many many attempts at peace talks... what usually happens?
Some obscure group sabotages it.. and this continues until there is a retaliation by the Israelis!!!!

FEAR AND INSECURITY!!! Israelis are guilty.. definitely..
Do you also hold the various Palestinian groups (gangs, terrorists etc..) to the same standard? What do you think motivates 12 year old boys to blow themselves up? FEAR is what various Palestinian "bosses" use to get rich off their ignorant countrymen... And once those bastards are rich, they will do anything to keep rolling in the dough...

You want to blame Israel.. fine... but the REAL CRIME is what the leaders of various factions are doing to their own people...

SHAMEFUL
 
Apology DQ

DQ, I completely misread your post. Thanks for not sending out the hit squad to rectify the situation.

RE: 12 year old... I was just looking at a picture of the boys who are responsible for the suicide bombing the other day...they looked 12..
 
DonQuixote said:
There was a young man in these parts about 2,000
years ago that preached peace and acceptance.

He was a martyr to His cause, as I recall.
....and at that time those that were only to happy to have Him nailed to a cross said in effect,
"Let his death be on us and our children."
Some should have been careful what they wished for.....:(
 
WoodPeckr said:
....and at that time those that were only to happy to have Him nailed to a cross said in effect,
"Let his death be on us and our children."
Some should have been careful what they wished for.....:(

Well at least I understand you a bit better after that post. 2000 years ago we let the Romans kill one of our own (one who was not accepted as anything other than a very minor rabblerouser), then YOU decide to accept him as your god, savour, messiah, we have to pay for it for 1500 years, then YOU decide that we deserved it the whole time.

Go find your own god! (Personally I think it's just insecurity since you probably know that you were wrong about Jeshu.)
 
PS, regarding 12 year old suicide bombers:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_suicide_bombers_in_the_Israeli-Palestinian_conflict

"According to the Palestinian Human Rights Monitoring Group, in the al-Aqsa Intifada, Palestinian militant groups have used children as "messengers and couriers, and in some cases as fighters and suicide bombers in attacks on Israeli soldiers and civilians." Fatah, Hamas, Islamic Jihad and the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) have all been implicated in involving children in this way. The issue was first brought to world attention after a widely televised incident in which a mentally handicapped Palestinian teenager, Hussam Abdo, was disarmed at an Israeli checkpoint.[4]"
 
I have no hope in either the Israeli or Palestinian
leadership.

They're all followings the mandates of extremists
within their organizations.

The Israelis have, sadly, killed more innocent
Palestinians than have had their own citizens
killed by terrorists/freedom fighters (your pic). so it's a simple competition, if more if my guys die than yours, I win. Have you ever considered INTENTION?

The Israeli blockade of goods and resources
from the Palestinians is creating a tragedy
within the occupied lands of the Palestinians.There's no blockade of the West Bank. Please propose your solution to the rocket attacks on Israel. What would you do if they started lobbing rockets at Oakville from some native reserve? Leave Oakville?

The entire situation is depressing and I put
the blame equally on both sides.Blame is besides the point. Stop the violence. I was watching Gandhi the other night, what if Arafat had followed Gandhi instead of hijacking planes?

This situation should have been settled decades
ago. That's why both sides are at fault. That makes no sense.

And the citizenry of both groups pay the price.

PS: Your statement of 12 year old suicide
bombers is unsubstantiated. Its pure hype. See my other post.

DON I'M FRUSTRATED TOO, FOR ME IT'S PERSONAL BUT I CAN IMAGINE THAT NORTH AMERICANS ARE GETTING TIRED OF HEARING ABOUT THIS INTRACTABLE CONFLICT, BUT THAT DOESN'T MEAN THAT BOTH SIDES ARE EQUALLY WRONG.
 
DATYdude said:
The Israelis have, sadly, killed more innocent
Palestinians than have had their own citizens
killed by terrorists/freedom fighters (your pic). so it's a simple competition, if more if my guys die than yours, I win. Have you ever considered INTENTION?


DON I'M FRUSTRATED TOO, FOR ME IT'S PERSONAL BUT I CAN IMAGINE THAT NORTH AMERICANS ARE GETTING TIRED OF HEARING ABOUT THIS INTRACTABLE CONFLICT, BUT THAT DOESN'T MEAN THAT BOTH SIDES ARE EQUALLY WRONG.

DATY, i don't know how I would feel in your situation, as I don't have the personal involvement you might have.

You say it's not 50/50... So what do you propose as the %age of wrongness for each side? 60/40? 70/30? How do we measure this?

You casually dismiss the only thing that might be REAL in this whole damn thing... the cold (pun intended) hard numbers... When I first started paying attention to the ME, I was appalled by these suicide bombers... The press coverage was pretty much one sided... They showed the terrible and sensational aftermath of the terrorist attacks... the suffering of the wounded and the pain of the relatives of the dead... then they mentioned something about a military campaign and that a rocket attack took out a militant leader. As I paid more attention, it seemed pretty simple... these terrorist bastards are/were nothing but cowards, slaughtering these poor defenseless Israelis.

I think it was the Star (although i find it really hard to believe that it was the Star) once showed the number of dead on each side... I think that they even divided the Palestinian numbers into "militants" and civilians. That only lasted one day, and it was never seen again.

INTENT or not... a dead body is still dead. I do believe that for the most part, Israels army does attempt to minimize the civilian casualty. It is fact that Israel regularly retaliates by sending a rocket(s) into a building or a car, or whatever. They take out their target, but how many "civilians" are injured or killed?

I don't know what the answer is, given the complexity of relationships in that part of the world.

My personal opinion is that Israel is between a rock and a hard place... However, that does not make them blameless in this human tragedy...

So give us a number... how much blame do you put on Israel???
 
shack said:
I must be missing something. I didn't read anything to indicate there was any move towards peace, let alone a massive one.

Aardvark154 said:
A suicide bombing is a step towards peace? :confused:

Sarcasm anyone?




slowandeasy said:
... The press coverage was pretty much one sided... They showed the terrible and sensational aftermath of the terrorist attacks... the suffering of the wounded and the pain of the relatives of the dead... then they mentioned something about a military campaign and that a rocket attack took out a militant leader. ...
This idea was in the star's coverage today that the Palestinians launched a bunch of rockets towards a civilian target in response for a targeted killing of a guy who was actively involved in attacks against Israel. Despite the inequity of the equipment used, I see a massive moral inequity between the killing of an admitted active combatant and the attempted killing of anyone who might happen to be wherever the rocket lands.

There should be a difference in the coverage of combatant deaths and the coverage of people who's crime was being in the wrong place.
 
slowandeasy said:
...

INTENT or not...
To me intent is a big part of the issues.

The Israelis intend to kill combatants, the Palestinian attacks mainly are intended to kill civilians. I would have less to say about attacks aimed at the IDF but that rarely occurs.

The terror apologists will say that it would be stupid for unequipped Palestinians to attack the high tech Israeli army. This doesn't make sense in terms of suicide bombers who intend to die anyways.

If the Israelis are just too powerful for the Palestinians to attack militarily they might be left with the inconceivable concept of NEGOTIATING a peace with an enemy who has already agreed to give you pretty much everything you could reasonably want except their own existence.
 
basketcase said:
To me intent is a big part of the issues.

The Israelis intend to kill combatants, the Palestinian attacks mainly are intended to kill civilians. I would have less to say about attacks aimed at the IDF but that rarely occurs.

The terror apologists will say that it would be stupid for unequipped Palestinians to attack the high tech Israeli army. This doesn't make sense in terms of suicide bombers who intend to die anyways.

If the Israelis are just too powerful for the Palestinians to attack militarily they might be left with the inconceivable concept of NEGOTIATING a peace with an enemy who has already agreed to give you pretty much everything you could reasonably want except their own existence.
This post just makes too much sense.
 
slowandeasy said:
Total Nonsense, DQ... this is beneath you...

........

Your expectations are too high......

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
Does the Israeli government really care?
......

I do think they care, why don't the Palestinians......

OTB
 
basketcase said:
This idea was in the star's coverage today that the Palestinians launched a bunch of rockets towards a civilian target in response for a targeted killing of a guy who was actively involved in attacks against Israel. Despite the inequity of the equipment used, I see a massive moral inequity between the killing of an admitted active combatant and the attempted killing of anyone who might happen to be wherever the rocket lands.

There should be a difference in the coverage of combatant deaths and the coverage of people who's crime was being in the wrong place.

Funny thing about this... I had forgotten to mention that in Israels military targeted killing of Palestinian leaders, they also happened to kill many civilians... Palestinian civilians. I remember one rocket attack that Israel launched, they destroyed a building and killed a couple of children as well as a number of other civilians.

Once again, I have to point out how easy it is to dismiss those Palestinian deaths but have sympathy for others in the exact situation....
 
basketcase said:
To me intent is a big part of the issues.

The Israelis intend to kill combatants, the Palestinian attacks mainly are intended to kill civilians. I would have less to say about attacks aimed at the IDF but that rarely occurs.
.

I think I have been down this road already... Deja Vu anyone?

Again... intent or not.... there are often civilian deaths when Israel launches one of it's "targeted" attacks. I have read many accounts of Israel's military strikes killing civilians, sometimes children. I have seen video of the launches at a car in the middle of a road that gets hit by missles. Or buildings levelled by rocket fire... Do the math... how many of Israel's executions have actually hit their target, and how much colateral damage?

Let me break it down simply... We know that Israel kills more Palestinians than the reverse... How many of those Pals killed are actual militants? How many are civilians... So from your point of view its alright for Israel to kill 1, 2, 3, 4, 5...10, 15, 20 civilians for each militant? Starting to look familiar?

The words "state sponsored terrorism" starting to hurt???