I concur (mostly). I guess the only part I can't wrap my head around is "a proper investment professional" as I’m pretty sure they don’t exist. It’s not his money and never will be… he just wants his salary, MER and commissions and everything else he charges people to manage their money (not his) so he has no reason to work, he can just sit back and take your money for doing nothing. If he does work hard and make a lot of money, it is your money, not his so why would he even bother? No one cares about your money more than you do and anyone managing your money for you is going to have lousy returns.
I’d hate to see money wasted in a GIC as well given today’s interest rates don’t beat inflation you are in effect paying the bank to hold your money for you as it doesn't even keep up with inflation. I’m a trader and not an investor. That said, I have to park excess capital somewhere and I usually put it in a high dividend yielding asset (like 14% or so, now that’s better than a GIC isn't it?) and put a zero cost collar (sometimes called a Protected Buy-Write) on it so there is no risk. I mitigate the risk of being long the market for free and get a much better rate of return than a GIC.
While such a strategy won’t have the returns I get actively trading it doesn't take a lot of knowledge to do it either and gives a better yield.