The Israel Lobby

That's a ban on anyone lobbying for ISRAEL.
You think everyone else is going to agree that they should be banned as well just to stop AIPAC?
Who cares? Ban them all. The same rules apply to everyone. Remember we are talking about foreign policy. I dont think the AARP or NRA lobby on this topic.
 
Who cares? Ban them all. The same rules apply to everyone. Remember we are talking about foreign policy. I dont think the AARP or NRA lobby on this topic.

The NRA does.
(Pretty sure the AARP does not.)
 
They lobby about treaties that would affect small arms ownership in the US,
Exactly how would a treaty with a foreign government affect small arms ownership in the US? The right to bear arms is in the US constitution.
 
Exactly how would a treaty with a foreign government affect small arms ownership in the US? The right to bear arms is in the US constitution.

Interpreting the Constitution is an open thing.
Remember the Supreme Court making up a new rule about owning guns and the history involved a few years ago?
But also, treaties are in the Constitution as well.
When something in two places in the Constitution come in conflict, it needs to get settled. The NRA usually wants to prevent that conflict from even happening, by preventing treaties that put restrictions they worry might get into conflict.
 
Interpreting the Constitution is an open thing.
Remember the Supreme Court making up a new rule about owning guns and the history involved a few years ago?
But also, treaties are in the Constitution as well.
When something in two places in the Constitution come in conflict, it needs to get settled. The NRA usually wants to prevent that conflict from even happening, by preventing treaties that put restrictions they worry might get into conflict.
Not quite the same as bribing politicians to hand over billions of dollars from your fellow taxpayers to a foreign country. But sure, if you want to get bogged down in minutiae, ban the NRA too 😆
 
Not quite the same as bribing politicians to hand over billions of dollars from your fellow taxpayers to a foreign country. But sure, if you want to get bogged down in minutiae, ban the NRA too 😆

It's still foreign policy.
The channelling money to a foreign government part was more indirect than AIPAC, sure.