The Israel Lobby

Straw man. I said anything that helps restrict the Israel Lobby.

It's Israel's lobby, but if the phrasing bothered you, not a problem.

The point of the question was to figure out if you want restrictions on foreign lobbying or restrictions on Israel's foreign lobbying.
 
It's Israel's lobby, but if the phrasing bothered you, not a problem.

The point of the question was to figure out if you want restrictions on foreign lobbying or restrictions on Israel's foreign lobbying.

Nobody is arguing for rules only on lobbying by Israel, just Israel being held to the same laws (FARA) and rules being tightened on all foreign lobbying.

Should be an easy sell now.

 
The point of the question was to figure out if you want restrictions on foreign lobbying or restrictions on Israel's foreign lobbying.
No, the point of the question was to obfuscate. I've already explained, at great length, how the Israel lobby is not subject to the same restrictions as other foreign lobbies.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Nobody is arguing for rules only on lobbying by Israel, just Israel being held to the same laws (FARA) and rules being tightened on all foreign lobbying.

Israel is held to FARA.
AIPAC is not.

Tighter rules on lobbying in general (and money in politics in general) is how TrackAIPAC frames the issue and something I agree with as you know.

No, the point of the question was to obfuscate. I've already explained, at great length, how the Israel lobby is not subject to the same restrictions as other foreign lobbies.

Yes, it is.
AIPAC is not.

The question is whether or not AIPAC should be considered FARA and if it should, what does that mean for all the other groups that work similarly to AIPAC but at a smaller scale.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: southpaw
Israel is held to FARA.
AIPAC is not.

Tighter rules on lobbying in general (and money in politics in general) is how TrackAIPAC frames the issue and something I agree with as you know.

AIPAC lobbies for Israel, which is the point.
 
The question is whether or not AIPAC should be considered FARA and if it should, what does that mean for all the other groups that work similarly to AIPAC but at a smaller scale.
What other foreign lobby groups are currently not under FARA? Do tell.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
What other foreign lobby groups are currently not under FARA? Do tell.

Well, given the war, the obvious one to point to is NIAC
Then there is USINPAC and PAKPAC

Are any of these as powerful or as established as AIPAC?
Of course not.
But the model is used by other groups.
After all, if something is successful, why wouldn't you copy it?
 
Okay, make them all register under FARA. No argument there. Just include AIPAC, and whatever entity they morph into after.

So what would the rule be?
Any ethnic group that lobbies the government is automatically considered foreign and must be registered under FARA?
Any group of any kind that lobbies about foreign policy?
Only ethnic AND foreign policy?
 
Any group of any kind that lobbies about foreign policy?
Sure go with that. Look at Franks list of foreign lobbies. They can't donate to US political campaigns.
 
How about you can lobby but you can't give money to politicians.

That's the whole "fix campaign finance reform".

And yes, I think we should absolutely do that.
But if you remember, AIPAC didn't have a pac or donate to politicians campaigns before 2020 and I'm pretty sure you objected to everything it was doing then as well.

Sure go with that. Look at Franks list of foreign lobbies. They can't donate to US political campaigns.

A straight up ban on any lobby group spending money on a campaign if they have an opinion on foreign policy is an interesting one, but I don't see how it flies with the American public.
People have a POV on foreign policy, they are going to want to support candidates who agree with their position.
 
That's the whole "fix campaign finance reform".

And yes, I think we should absolutely do that.
But if you remember, AIPAC didn't have a pac or donate to politicians campaigns before 2020 and I'm pretty sure you objected to everything it was doing then as well.

And kill Citizens United while you are there in magical unicorn land.
 
  • Like
Reactions: southpaw
And kill Citizens United while you are there in magical unicorn land.

Killing Citizens United is absolutely part of the finance reform needed.
Even that would be necessary, but not sufficient.

The problem is that it is a Supreme Court ruling, so much harder to get rid of.

When I mentioned TrackAIPAC didn't think FARA was enough, I didn't call it out, but killing Citizens United is also part of what they think needs to be done.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
A straight up ban on any lobby group spending money on a campaign if they have an opinion on foreign policy is an interesting one, but I don't see how it flies with the American public.
Considering Israel's current popularity with the American public, it will do just fine. If AIPAC is prevented from making campaign contributions that will severely restrict the impact they can have.
 
Considering Israel's current popularity with the American public, it will do just fine. If AIPAC is prevented from making campaign contributions that will severely restrict the impact they can have.

That's a ban on anyone lobbying for ISRAEL.
You think everyone else is going to agree that they should be banned as well just to stop AIPAC?