Is the USA in decline?

I find your attempts to target Khan because of his charges against Israel to be even sadder.
You are intentionally trying to escalate internal policy matters with legal findings.

That's cute.
That's been your entire defense.
The whole reason you're defending him is because you think it is an Israeli smear.
A last minute DARVO isn't going to get you anywhere.

Posting a BBC commentary as support material is weak. The ICJ did rule that the charges of genocide were plausible.

I posted the actual decision.
That commentary was to clarify the ambiguity your opiniojuris piece is talking about.
I don't think the opinion of the person who presided over the decision and delivered it is weak, but you do you.

They declared Palestinians had a right to be protected from plausible acts of genocide. That's very different, your take is intentionally wrong.

So you know better than the person whose name is on the front page of the decision?
She's being "intentionally wrong" about her work?
Cool.

The ICJ made its ruling before UN, Amnesty, HRW and other reports stating Israel is committing genocide, yet the warning was enough that all states should have ceased aiding Israel because they could plausibly be aiding genocide. That is why Germany is on trial.


Germany is on trial because Nicaragua took it to court.
 
That's cute.
That's been your entire defense.
The whole reason you're defending him is because you think it is an Israeli smear.
A last minute DARVO isn't going to get you anywhere.

Its all within reason to consider the charges against Khan to be politically motivated and to note he was not charged with breaking laws.
Nothing to remotely dispute the charges he laid against Netanyahu and his team.

I posted the actual decision.
That commentary was to clarify the ambiguity your opiniojuris piece is talking about.
I don't think the opinion of the person who presided over the decision and delivered it is weak, but you do you.

Oh lordy, now you're starting to sound like butler, 'but there were two dissenting judges on the ruling so therefore I only believe the dissenting judges'.

She didn't make the ruling.
But if you're so certain maybe you should head out play defence for Germany at the ICJ trials.
Good luck.

So you know better than the person whose name is on the front page of the decision?
She's being "intentionally wrong" about her work?
Cool.



Germany is on trial because Nicaragua took it to court.

For sending weapons to Israel to aid its genocide after being warned that the charges of genocide were 'plausible', that the court ordered Israel to stop committing genocide, get out of Palestine and save all evidence.
 
And bam your story changes again the moment someone points out the truth, without the bat of an eye.

I accept that I am not aware of every single fact in this case, but you seem be quite sure of every single fact. Fact is Assange was never actually charged. And they refused to come to the UK to question him. If they had charged him, they would have to go through a much more complex set of procedures to then extradite him to the USA do you get that? It was all a ruse.
 
Its all within reason to consider the charges against Khan to be politically motivated and to note he was not charged with breaking laws.

It is.
It also doesn't hold up to much scrutiny.

Nothing to remotely dispute the charges he laid against Netanyahu and his team.

You're the only one who keeps bringing it up.
I get it, you are perfectly happy to defend him from any charges if you think admitting any wrongdoing might hurt his case against Netanyahu.

Oh lordy, now you're starting to sound like butler, 'but there were two dissenting judges on the ruling so therefore I only believe the dissenting judges'.

What the fuck are you talking about?
The two dissenting voices in that ruling you linked to, which isn't the ruling we're talking about, argued that no additional provisional measures should be added to the ones they already ordered.
I'm not sure what that has to do in any way with the discussion we are having.

She didn't make the ruling.

She didn't make the ruling with her name on it?
1789525975781.png

I'll accept that the ruling is - by ICJ convention - considered the work of the whole court.
But I am pretty certain the President of the court gets to explain what the court decided.

But if you're so certain maybe you should head out play defence for Germany at the ICJ trials.
Good luck.

Why would I want to defend Germany in the trial?
Also, this point isn't likely to come up in the trial, since I presume Nicaragua knows what it filed and why and has very good lawyers.

For sending weapons to Israel to aid its genocide after being warned that the charges of genocide were 'plausible', that the court ordered Israel to stop committing genocide, get out of Palestine and save all evidence.

No.
Nicaragua says Germany has violated its obligations under the 1948 Genocide Convention by providing Israel with military equipment, despite being aware of the risk that genocide could be committed in Gaza.
It has nothing to do with being warned the charges were plausible.
It has to do with Germany's own actions, not Israel's.

As I understand it, if the case depends on the court's rulings about Israel's actions, then Israel has to be part of the case, and then Nicaragua failed to bring the case properly, and it will be dismissed.
 
I accept that I am not aware of every single fact in this case, but you seem be quite sure of every single fact. Fact is Assange was never actually charged.

The fact is Sweden is not a common-law country.

And they refused to come to the UK to question him. If they had charged him, they would have to go through a much more complex set of procedures to then extradite him to the USA do you get that?

And you believe that why?
But... let's take your point there.
According to you, if they didn't charge him, they would have had an easier time extraditing him to the US.
Then why make up the accusations they weren't going to charge when they could just pick him up off the street and extradite him?

It was all a ruse.

Yes, you've made your belief that the whole thing was invented head to tail very clear.
 
The fact is Sweden is not a common-law country.



And you believe that why?
But... let's take your point there.
According to you, if they didn't charge him, they would have had an easier time extraditing him to the US.
Then why make up the accusations they weren't going to charge when they could just pick him up off the street and extradite him?



Yes, you've made your belief that the whole thing was invented head to tail very clear.


WTF the Swedes could not extradite him if they stated up front they had no intention to charge him. BUT if they did charge him, he would be embroiled in the Swedish judicial process and they could not just send him to the USA until those were dispositioned. (probably many months or even a few years). So they made up this shit so they could have cause to extradite him, then question him. Chose not to charge him and then have given time for the USA to prepare their extradition request, cut him lose in Sweden and send him to the USA. Are you really that clueless. OMG. 🤷‍♂️ As I said, their refusal to conduct their questioning in the UK is the smoking gun.

Sweden not being a common law country has nothing to do with this.
 
WTF the Swedes could not extradite him if they stated up front they had no intention to charge him.

Why not?
If the US asks Sweden to extradite someone, Sweden doesn't have to charge him with something first.
That's not how it works.

The US can just ask Sweden to extradite him. (Obviously, the US would have to charge him with something.)

BUT if they did charge him, he would be embroiled in the Swedish judicial process and they could not just send him to the USA until those were dispositioned. (probably many months or even a few years). So they made up this shit so they could have cause to extradite him, then question him. Chose not to charge him and then have given time for the USA to prepare their extradition request, cut him lose in Sweden and send him to the USA. Are you really that clueless. OMG. 🤷‍♂️ As I said, their refusal to conduct their questioning in the UK is the smoking gun.

So the plan was to fake an accusation, question him in Sweden, then let him go to the UK, then wait for him to refuse to go back to Sweden, so they could try to force him to be sent back to Sweden, so the US could then demand he be extradited.
But instead they faked an accusation, questioned him in Sweden, let him go to the UK, then had him refuse to go back to Sweden, then detain him in the UK, from which he got extradited to the US in a way that had nothing to do with Sweden whatsoever?

Sweden not being a common law country has nothing to do with this.

It does since you seem very hung up on them not charging him.
 
It is.
It also doesn't hold up to much scrutiny.

According to you.


You're the only one who keeps bringing it up.
I get it, you are perfectly happy to defend him from any charges if you think admitting any wrongdoing might hurt his case against Netanyahu.

You are the one that keeps harping on this claim, not me.

What the fuck are you talking about?
The two dissenting voices in that ruling you linked to, which isn't the ruling we're talking about, argued that no additional provisional measures should be added to the ones they already ordered.
I'm not sure what that has to do in any way with the discussion we are having.

Arguing that the president's opinion is the only one that counts is similar.



She didn't make the ruling with her name on it?
View attachment 648417

I'll accept that the ruling is - by ICJ convention - considered the work of the whole court.
But I am pretty certain the President of the court gets to explain what the court decided.

She was present, she did not write the ruling.




No.
Nicaragua says Germany has violated its obligations under the 1948 Genocide Convention by providing Israel with military equipment, despite being aware of the risk that genocide could be committed in Gaza.
It has nothing to do with being warned the charges were plausible.
It has to do with Germany's own actions, not Israel's.

As I understand it, if the case depends on the court's rulings about Israel's actions, then Israel has to be part of the case, and then Nicaragua failed to bring the case properly, and it will be dismissed.

We will see how the court rules.
Eventually.
 
You are the one that keeps harping on this claim, not me.

You are the only one who keeps bringing it up.
I said from the beginning his removal for this should not diminish the case against Netanyahu at all since there is no connection between these things.

Arguing that the president's opinion is the only one that counts is similar.

No.
The President clarified what the court actually found and wrote in their ruling.
Has one of the other judges come forward and said "No, she's wrong, when we wrote that we actually meant something else"?

Also, my position that the President explaining the ruling matters is in no way similar to you posting an entirely different ruling and saying I am claiming the two judges in dissent in that ruling are the only people I believe.

She was present, she did not write the ruling.

So you think the staffer or legal person who wrote the text needs to come forward?
Or do you now think she wasn't one of the judges who came to the consensus conclusion?
 
I find your attempts to target Khan because of his charges against Israel to be even sadder.
You are intentionally trying to escalate internal policy matters with legal findings.



Posting a BBC commentary as support material is weak. The ICJ did rule that the charges of genocide were plausible.



They declared Palestinians had a right to be protected from plausible acts of genocide. That's very different, your take is intentionally wrong.
The ICJ made its ruling before UN, Amnesty, HRW and other reports stating Israel is committing genocide, yet the warning was enough that all states should have ceased aiding Israel because they could plausibly be aiding genocide. That is why Germany is on trial.


She wasn't president during the vote, or present on the decision.

INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE
YEAR 2024
2024
24 May
General List
No. 192
24 May 2024
APPLICATION OF THE CONVENTION ON THE PREVENTION AND PUNISHMENT OF THE CRIME OF GENOCIDE IN THE GAZA STRIP
(SOUTH AFRICA v. ISRAEL)
REQUEST FOR THE MODIFICATION OF THE ORDER OF 28 MARCH 2024
ORDER
Present: President SALAM; Vice-President SEBUTINDE; Judges ABRAHAM, YUSUF, XUE, BHANDARI, IWASAWA, NOLTE, CHARLESWORTH, BRANT, GÓMEZ ROBLEDO, CLEVELAND, AURESCU, TLADI; Judge ad hoc BARAK; Registrar GAUTIER.
The International Court of Justice,
Composed as above,
After deliberation,
Having regard to Article 41 of the Statute of the Court and Article 76 of the Rules of Court,
Makes the following Order:


 
  • Haha
Reactions: Valcazar

Oh my god.
Dude.

OK.

Let's go slow.

We've been discussing this case -- this one in the NPR news article here: https://www.npr.org/2024/01/26/1227078791/icj-israel-genocide-gaza-palestinians-south-africa

Do you see the big headline?
You've posted this link here and in other threads repeatedly.
1789792992726.png


Do see right there under the headline?
It's a date.

What is the date, Franky? (You can do it.)

That's right... it's January 26, 2024.

That's when the ICJ order on this case came out: https://www.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/case-related/192/192-20240126-ord-01-00-en.pdf
Case 192. South Africa vs Israel.

As you can see from that page, the January 26 order is the first order in the case.
It's also the one that got those headlines saying "plausible".
It's the one we've been talking about.


Now, for the second time (and after I corrected you the first time), you've posted this link: https://www.icj-cij.org/node/204091

You even posted text from it!

The first time you said I was implying that since two judges dissented, I was pretending only the dissent happened.
This time, you said it shows I'm completely wrong and Judge Donoghue wasn't even there, let alone President for the case.

Now... look carefully at what you posted - either the link, the first document in the link, or even your post since I quoted the text.
Do you see that right under "192"?

It's a date.
What is the date, Franky? (You can do it.)

That's right... it's May 24, 2024.

As I told you last time. That's not the decision we've been discussing.
It's a follow-up decision - as it says on the ICJ page, it's a
Request for the modification of the Order of 28 March 2024 indicating provisional measures
(The March 28 order is a request for a modification of the January 26 order.)

See how the dates are different?
That means they took place at different times.
 
The Mooch was too smart to work for The King of Kings. This is probably the most honest description of Canada I've read from an American.

 
I remember visiting my uncle in San Fran in 2012 when an elderly couple asked if I spoke English. The fact that they don’t think non-whites are capable of speaking English shows how racist America was in the years leading up to Trump’s first term. No wonder they elected him

Seems like they never really got over slavery, all they did was make the racism more subtle and systematic.