Is the USA in decline?

He wasn't charged with any crime is the correct defence. This is all internal ICC policy at this point.

You know as well as I do that "he wasn't charged with any crime" is no indication he didn't do anything.
That's the Trump defense you rightly reject when it is someone you don't like.

Do you support the charges he laid against Netanyahu and his team continuing or being dismissed because of these complaints?

Of course not, that would be ridiculous.
The fact Israel is trying to use that as an argument is pathetic.
Indeed, it is a reason to suspect the accusations have merit. If you are going to fabricate something to remove the charges, you fabricate something about him forging or suppressing evidence.

Sure, he should have resigned with the corruption charges for decency but more importantly, Israel should have turfed him from office after the ICC warrants.

He is currently being investigated in court and may be removed in elections.
What "turfing out" do you want?
Military coup? Popular uprising?
Invasion by outside forces?

You would have Khan step down because of accusations and internal policy.
Would you apply that to the Israeli government and its accusations of war crimes?

I would have Khan be removed by proper due process, which is happening.
I would have the Israeli government changed as well.

What is consistent is that despite whether or not the person can be removed, I don't think "I don't want him removed, so therefore he didn't do it" is a legitimate argument.
 
Its not a power grab, they already charged Putin (falsely IMHO) and Netanyau and I think Katz.

I think Katz is rumoured but not actually done yet.

But these are irrelevant to your proposal.
Those three were all charged under existing ICC rules.

if anyone directly attacks judges in the ICC with sanctions, and threats for work they do with the ICC they should be charged with interfering with the ICC and subject to arrest and trial IF they enter the ICC zone, and should be banned from conducing an business within the ICC or with businesses that operate within ICC nations.

This would be an expansion of ICC powers since I don't think such action has ever been done.
Now "we should be allowed to take action against people who threaten us" seems very reasonable to me, and if not explicitly in the rules, there is probably a case to be made for such action.
I think you can stretch Article 70 to cover it. https://www.public.law/world/rome_statute/article_70_offences_against_the_administration_of_justice
 
You know as well as I do that "he wasn't charged with any crime" is no indication he didn't do anything.
That's the Trump defense you rightly reject when it is someone you don't like.

But its also the metric you want to use when he's doing something you don't like.

Of course not, that would be ridiculous.
The fact Israel is trying to use that as an argument is pathetic.
Indeed, it is a reason to suspect the accusations have merit. If you are going to fabricate something to remove the charges, you fabricate something about him forging or suppressing evidence.

Good.

He is currently being investigated in court and may be removed in elections.
What "turfing out" do you want?
Military coup? Popular uprising?
Invasion by outside forces?

I guess its too much to expect a country to demand their leader step down over warrants for genocide, is it?

I would have Khan be removed by proper due process, which is happening.
I would have the Israeli government changed as well.

What is consistent is that despite whether or not the person can be removed, I don't think "I don't want him removed, so therefore he didn't do it" is a legitimate argument.

Don't you have to find out of Khan did something before you remove him?
Due process is limited in our new authoritarian world, trump and Netanyahu can shut down the courts or delay trials and even sick the courts on opponents on made up charges. It gets into a grey area here, if you think Khan should step down then so should trump and Netanyahu, if they aren't then its unreasonable to ask only their critics to be held to these standards. Which is crappy, but its the new normal.

As it is, debanking seems to be the way they are trying to shut it all down now.


 
But its also the metric you want to use when he's doing something you don't like.

I don't even know what you think this sentence means.
Try again.

I guess its too much to expect a country to demand their leader step down over warrants for genocide, is it?

Anyone can demand their leader step down at any time.
How do you want them to make him do it?

Don't you have to find out of Khan did something before you remove him?

They did.
There was an investigation.
The people who read the investigation and the legal experts assessment of what was found in the investigation voted in large numbers to remove him.

Due process is limited in our new authoritarian world, trump and Netanyahu can shut down the courts or delay trials and even sick the courts on opponents on made up charges. It gets into a grey area here, if you think Khan should step down then so should trump and Netanyahu, if they aren't then its unreasonable to ask only their critics to be held to these standards. Which is crappy, but its the new normal.

Khan didn't step down.
Khan was removed after an inquiry after due process.

Why do you keep pretending otherwise?

As it is, debanking seems to be the way they are trying to shut it all down now.



And that is some seriously fucked up shit.[/QUOTE]
 
Then why have they not sued him?

What would suing him prove?
If I recall, at least one of the women has made it clear that since he ended up trapped in legal hell for far longer than any sentence under Swedish law would have punished him, she considers any further legal action pointless.

Why did all those extra judicial abuses happen to Assange by the UK?

This has nothing to do with the accusations by the women.

Why didn't Sweden agree to not extraditing him to the USA if they were REALLY only interested in dealing with the sexual assault charges?

Because under the Swedish constitution they have no right to make that promise to him.

Why was the CIA considering assassinating him?

That has nothing to do with the women's accusations.
Do you honestly think the CIA plans assassinations of people who are accused of sexual assault?
 
US total debt: $40 trillion
US budget deficit: $2 trillion
US INTEREST payment on debt: $1.25 trillion or almost 20% of government revenue

Not sustainable! Surest sign of the decline of the US

See, now that is a specific thing.
I'm not sure what we're supposed to call debt-related decline, but you are at least pointing to something specific.
 
I don't even know what you think this sentence means.
Try again.

You argued that Khan should step down because of internal accusations.
That was enough for you.

Anyone can demand their leader step down at any time.
How do you want them to make him do it?

Pitchforks at sunset?
These are double standards, you argue that because nobody can force politicians to leave they shouldn't have to.

They did.
There was an investigation.
The people who read the investigation and the legal experts assessment of what was found in the investigation voted in large numbers to remove him.

The investigation found no proof of wrongdoing.
What qualifies as 'voted in large numbers' in that statement?
The investigators or the UN vote on a report that stated it did not prove anything?

Khan didn't step down.
Khan was removed after an inquiry after due process.

Why do you keep pretending otherwise?

I'm not pretending anything, I'm stating clear double standards.
If this standard were applied to all of those in office all of trump's government and most of Israel's would have been removed. I'd be fully supportive of this decision if that were the case.
That you would argue this one but not argue it for anyone else shows your own bias.
The case is hardly solid or the findings conclusive, as you know.

The panel of judges said that "the investigation was not conclusive enough", but as they had to make a "determination", they stated that, "The Panel is unanimously of the opinion that the factual findings by OIOS do not establish misconduct or breach of duty under the relevant framework."

And that is some seriously fucked up shit.
Which makes the Khan accusations look even worse in context.
The most serious allegation is of 'inappropriate touching while the victim pretended to be asleep', which is vague enough to mean too many things.

Given the debanking, the multitude of other attacks on Khan and the ICC, and Israel jumping on the allegations and demanding charges be dropped it doesn't sound legit.
And if this standard were applied fully, I'd be backing it, but when you argue that it only applies to the ICC, not the SCOTUS or political leaders, its a double standard.
 
What would suing him prove?
If I recall, at least one of the women has made it clear that since he ended up trapped in legal hell for far longer than any sentence under Swedish law would have punished him, she considers any further legal action pointless.



This has nothing to do with the accusations by the women.



Because under the Swedish constitution they have no right to make that promise to him.



That has nothing to do with the women's accusations.
Do you honestly think the CIA plans assassinations of people who are accused of sexual assault?

Wow you really believe that shit? A civil lawsuit would have exposed the facts of the accusation.
Of course the abuses had nothing to do with the women, it had EVERYTHING to do with the USA.
While its true the Swedes could not guarantee this, the British could guarantee it. And they refused as they knew it was all part of ruse to get him out of the embassy to Sweden where he would be handed over to the Americans.
Of course the CIA assassination had nothing to do with the rape accusation. Just like the accusations had nothing to do with rape.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: Valcazar
You argued that Khan should step down because of internal accusations.
That was enough for you.

I never argued this.
I argued that him being voted out by the organizational body with the power to vote him out after they reviewed evidence gathered in an internal investigation was completely proper and above board.
Also, that during that process, your statement "the charges were dropped" never happened.

The first of these is an opinion.
The second is a fact. '

Pitchforks at sunset?
These are double standards, you argue that because nobody can force politicians to leave they shouldn't have to.

I am arguing nothing of the kind.
I am engaging in the real world.
I am sure both of us would like to live in a world where bad people didn't do bad things and if they did they just stepped down.
That clearly isn't the case.

The investigation found no proof of wrongdoing.

This is incorrect.
The inquiry found that “evidence indicated” Khan’s conduct towards the woman had “escalated over time, resulting in him engaging in nonconsensual sexual contact with her”.
The inquiry concluded it had “identified evidence establishing a factual basis” for the alleged victim’s claims against Khan. It recommended the ASP “consider appropriate action based on the evidence”.
The judges panel - asked to decide what that means from a legal standpoint said “While the panel cannot make a definitive proclamation on the existence or absence of the alleged misconduct, given its mandate, it finds itself compelled to the conclusion that on the materials disclosed, there is insufficient evidence to support a finding of misconduct measured against the standard of proof of beyond reasonable doubt.”

What qualifies as 'voted in large numbers' in that statement?

82 out of 125

I'm not pretending anything, I'm stating clear double standards.

You keep pretending Khan wasn't voted out.

If this standard were applied to all of those in office all of trump's government and most of Israel's would have been removed.

Sadly, the due process for removing a head of state is different than that for removing an ICC prosecutor.
Funnily enough, despite Trump having not been removed by the due process of impeachment in the US, I don't pretend that it means he didn't do the things he was impeached for.

I'd be fully supportive of this decision if that were the case.

Got it.
So for you, the ICC should not have removed someone who committed serious misconduct because Trump and Netanyahu haven't been removed.
Therefore your new standard is "leave all the people committing misconduct in place"?
Or is it just "Look, if they are anti-Israel, they are obviously on the good team and so therefore couldn't have committed any wrong doing or must be forgiven all wrongdoings while they are doing good work"?

That you would argue this one but not argue it for anyone else shows your own bias.

I'm the one being consistent here, Frank.

Which makes the Khan accusations look even worse in context.
The most serious allegation is of 'inappropriate touching while the victim pretended to be asleep', which is vague enough to mean too many things.

Given the debanking, the multitude of other attacks on Khan and the ICC, and Israel jumping on the allegations and demanding charges be dropped it doesn't sound legit.
And if this standard were applied fully, I'd be backing it, but when you argue that it only applies to the ICC, not the SCOTUS or political leaders, its a double standard.

Why do you keep making up arguments you think I've made?
 
Wow you really believe that shit? A civil lawsuit would have exposed the facts of the accusation.
Of course the abuses had nothing to do with the women, it had EVERYTHING to do with the USA.
While its true the Swedes could not guarantee this, the British could guarantee it. And they refused as they knew it was all part of ruse to get him out of the embassy to Sweden where he would be handed over to the Americans.
Of course the CIA assassination had nothing to do with the rape accusation. Just like the accusations had nothing to do with rape.

So let's see if we can disentangle your flailing here.

It seems you've come around to agree with my position that the abuses by the US and other government have nothing to do with the women.
So this means you've given up on the "they were agents under the control of the government planting fake stories" now?

I like that you've just smoothly pretended that you didn't just insist the Swedish government not promising him no extradition proved it was a fake case and now hand wave away the idea that you ever even implied such a thing because "it is true that the Swedes could not guarantee this".
The UK extradition case to the US is about something completely different.
 
I never argued this.
I argued that him being voted out by the organizational body with the power to vote him out after they reviewed evidence gathered in an internal investigation was completely proper and above board.
Also, that during that process, your statement "the charges were dropped" never happened.

Hold on, the reports all said there was no real evidence, nothing proven and everything was accusations.
The first internal report said as much, the second report said as much but that he should step down anyways and then the UN voted him out.
I admit I was wrong, charges were not dropped because there were and are, no charges against Khan.
You however, are dead certain he did something wrong, despite there being no evidence to back it up.


The first of these is an opinion.
The second is a fact. '

Why is that enough for you but not enough for you to be calling for anyone else to be turfed?


I am arguing nothing of the kind.
I am engaging in the real world.
I am sure both of us would like to live in a world where bad people didn't do bad things and if they did they just stepped down.
That clearly isn't the case.

You are arguing this very thing.
Your vitriol should be just as strong towards the trump and Netanyahu teams, given the reports and evidence.
Its not about bad people stepping down as much as the system being set so that you step down until you are cleared of bad things.
Now you are dead certain that Khan committed sexual assault despite there being no proof or evidence.


This is incorrect.
The inquiry found that “evidence indicated” Khan’s conduct towards the woman had “escalated over time, resulting in him engaging in nonconsensual sexual contact with her”.
The inquiry concluded it had “identified evidence establishing a factual basis” for the alleged victim’s claims against Khan. It recommended the ASP “consider appropriate action based on the evidence”.
The judges panel - asked to decide what that means from a legal standpoint said “While the panel cannot make a definitive proclamation on the existence or absence of the alleged misconduct, given its mandate, it finds itself compelled to the conclusion that on the materials disclosed, there is insufficient evidence to support a finding of misconduct measured against the standard of proof of beyond reasonable doubt.”

There was no 'evidence', only accusations by the victims. That is a problem.
There are way more accusations against trump and Netanyahu.
So you aren't you calling for them to be removed?


82 out of 125
You keep pretending Khan wasn't voted out.

Based on a report that said it couldn't prove he did anything wrong.


Sadly, the due process for removing a head of state is different than that for removing an ICC prosecutor.
Funnily enough, despite Trump having not been removed by the due process of impeachment in the US, I don't pretend that it means he didn't do the things he was impeached for.

Double standard.
Why should Khan have to be removed without proof of wrongdoing yet trump, Netanyahu and the SCOTUS being accused of worse acts?


Got it.
So for you, the ICC should not have removed someone who committed serious misconduct because Trump and Netanyahu haven't been removed.
Therefore your new standard is "leave all the people committing misconduct in place"?
Or is it just "Look, if they are anti-Israel, they are obviously on the good team and so therefore couldn't have committed any wrong doing or must be forgiven all wrongdoings while they are doing good work"?

The reports said there is no proof he did anything wrong but somehow you are very certain he did.
What do you know that the reports couldn't find?

I'm the one being consistent here, Frank.

Its sad that you think so.

Why do you keep making up arguments you think I've made?

Straw man arguments are your territory.

This is a long discussion attacking the author of genocide charges against Israel.
It still reads like an attempt to minimize the charges.

 
So let's see if we can disentangle your flailing here.

It seems you've come around to agree with my position that the abuses by the US and other government have nothing to do with the women.
So this means you've given up on the "they were agents under the control of the government planting fake stories" now?

I like that you've just smoothly pretended that you didn't just insist the Swedish government not promising him no extradition proved it was a fake case and now hand wave away the idea that you ever even implied such a thing because "it is true that the Swedes could not guarantee this".
The UK extradition case to the US is about something completely different.

No the women and the abuses were all the same plot against Assange. The women served 2 purposes, discredit him via #metoo and get him detained so he could no flee to a safe country before US indictments were ready. The UK could have guaranteed 3rd no further extradition beyond Sweden, but they did not. Also he was not charged of ANY crime and was held in a hellhole while fighting extradition. So the Brits being US lackeys clearly were in on it. You think the Ecuadorians would protect someone from rape charges alone? The UK said they would only extradite him if they were guaranteed he would not be treated inhumanely. Then it proceeded to treat him inhumanely.
 
Hold on, the reports all said there was no real evidence, nothing proven and everything was accusations.
The first internal report said as much, the second report said as much but that he should step down anyways and then the UN voted him out.

No.
The first report (the inquiry) said the inquiry found that “evidence indicated” Khan’s conduct towards the woman had “escalated over time, resulting in him engaging in nonconsensual sexual contact with her”. The inquiry concluded it had “identified evidence establishing a factual basis” for the alleged victim’s claims against Khan. It recommended the ASP “consider appropriate action based on the evidence”.
The second report was the judge's analysis of the inquiry's findings in order to provide legal advice and said that "on the materials disclosed, there is insufficient evidence to support a finding of misconduct measured against the standard of proof of beyond reasonable doubt.”

Then the ASP bureau voted 15-4 (two abstaining) that Khan may have committed “some form of misconduct” and then (after meeting with the alleged victim and offering Khan's team a response and additional written submissions from unknown parties) upped that to potentially "serious misconduct" and
Note that that decision has to be a "qualified majority", which usually means 2/3 in the ICC, so at least 14 of the 21 members.

Then they had a the special session of the Assembly of States Parties and 82 out of 125 members of that group voted that he should be dismissed for serious conduct and a serious breach of duty

I don't know where you are getting "the reports all said there was no real evidence, nothing proven and everything was accusations".
If you aren't even going to try and read things and absorb facts when you are arguing about them, why are you bothering?

I admit I was wrong, charges were not dropped because there were and are, no charges against Khan.
You however, are dead certain he did something wrong, despite there being no evidence to back it up.

I think that multiple people looking over two years and finding evidence, discussing the evidence, and then voting on the evidence, might have a good sense of the evidence.

Why is that enough for you but not enough for you to be calling for anyone else to be turfed?

Who am I not calling to be turfed?
I support Trump being turfed (again), I support Netanyahu being turfed.

You are arguing this very thing. Your vitriol should be just as strong towards the trump and Netanyahu teams, given the reports and evidence.
Its not about bad people stepping down as much as the system being set so that you step down until you are cleared of bad things.
Now you are dead certain that Khan committed sexual assault despite there being no proof or evidence.

Why do you have so much trouble holding reality in your head?
If you're just going to make things up, what's the point?

There are way more accusations against trump and Netanyahu.
So you aren't you calling for them to be removed?

I've called for both of them to be removed.
I've also pointed out that you need a way to remove them.
The removal of Khan was a two-year process involving investigations and evidence and a body with the authority to remove them.

Double standard.
Why should Khan have to be removed without proof of wrongdoing yet trump, Netanyahu and the SCOTUS being accused of worse acts?

I don't know how many times this needs to be explained to you.

Its sad that you think so.

Facts aren't sad, Frank.

Straw man arguments are your territory.

LOL!
That's amazing coming from you.

This is a long discussion attacking the author of genocide charges against Israel.
It still reads like an attempt to minimize the charges.


What is?
The tweet thread?
That appears to be about the Nicaragua case about Germany.
Israel isn't a party to that case. (Well, that's part of what the legal argument is about.)

I know you don't mean Khan since he isn't the author of genocide charges against Israel and I already said upthread that his removal for misconduct unrelated to his charges against Netanyahu shouldn't affect those charges.
 
No.
The first report (the inquiry) said the inquiry found that “evidence indicated” Khan’s conduct towards the woman had “escalated over time, resulting in him engaging in nonconsensual sexual contact with her”. The inquiry concluded it had “identified evidence establishing a factual basis” for the alleged victim’s claims against Khan. It recommended the ASP “consider appropriate action based on the evidence”.
The second report was the judge's analysis of the inquiry's findings in order to provide legal advice and said that "on the materials disclosed, there is insufficient evidence to support a finding of misconduct measured against the standard of proof of beyond reasonable doubt.”

Then the ASP bureau voted 15-4 (two abstaining) that Khan may have committed “some form of misconduct” and then (after meeting with the alleged victim and offering Khan's team a response and additional written submissions from unknown parties) upped that to potentially "serious misconduct" and
Note that that decision has to be a "qualified majority", which usually means 2/3 in the ICC, so at least 14 of the 21 members.

Then they had a the special session of the Assembly of States Parties and 82 out of 125 members of that group voted that he should be dismissed for serious conduct and a serious breach of duty

I don't know where you are getting "the reports all said there was no real evidence, nothing proven and everything was accusations".
If you aren't even going to try and read things and absorb facts when you are arguing about them, why are you bothering?



I think that multiple people looking over two years and finding evidence, discussing the evidence, and then voting on the evidence, might have a good sense of the evidence.



Who am I not calling to be turfed?
I support Trump being turfed (again), I support Netanyahu being turfed.



Why do you have so much trouble holding reality in your head?
If you're just going to make things up, what's the point?



I've called for both of them to be removed.
I've also pointed out that you need a way to remove them.
The removal of Khan was a two-year process involving investigations and evidence and a body with the authority to remove them.



I don't know how many times this needs to be explained to you.



Facts aren't sad, Frank.



LOL!
That's amazing coming from you.



What is?
The tweet thread?
That appears to be about the Nicaragua case about Germany.
Israel isn't a party to that case. (Well, that's part of what the legal argument is about.)

I know you don't mean Khan since he isn't the author of genocide charges against Israel and I already said upthread that his removal for misconduct unrelated to his charges against Netanyahu shouldn't affect those charges.

It all depends on the details that aren't in the report. If the evidence is only victim testimony, then there is 'evidence' but its not enough to prove a case.
I'm sure they acted with more caution than they would for a legal case, but that doesn't mean that the evidence proved anything.

The Germany case is related, its over weapons sales to Israel after the ICJ warnings and ICC charges.

Bad week for AI, the xitter is banning people who get Grok to admit there is genocide, which is now harder with recent reprogramming.
And now there are 2 cases of mathematicians who claim that AI stole their notes and posted solutions from their work.
 
No the women and the abuses were all the same plot against Assange.

Well, foolish of me to hold out hope, I guess.

The women served 2 purposes, discredit him via #metoo and get him detained so he could no flee to a safe country before US indictments were ready.

And they chose that weak-ass way to do that when they could make up anything?

The UK could have guaranteed 3rd no further extradition beyond Sweden, but they did not.

I guess on some vague level they could have given that word, like a plea deal, but what government ever would sight unseen?
There is a whole extradition process, and "oh, we won't follow that, we're just gonna refuse" is pretty corrupt.

Also he was not charged of ANY crime and was held in a hellhole while fighting extradition. So the Brits being US lackeys clearly were in on it.

The Brits charged him with breaching his bail conditions.
That's a crime.

You think the Ecuadorians would protect someone from rape charges alone? The UK said they would only extradite him if they were guaranteed he would not be treated inhumanely. Then it proceeded to treat him inhumanely.

And yet none of that later behavior means the women's complaints were made up.
That's just you joining Frank with the "if they are against the US and Israel, then obviously bitchez be lyin" thing.