Jerry Seinfeld On Palestine

Yes, but everyone knows that very basic fact.
There is no need to put that qualifier on posts on a pooner board politics forum.

No.
They really don't.
All you have to do is talk to people and they make it very clear they don't understand it.
Worse still, people constantly talk about it as if you are voting for the Prime Minister directly.

It's become more and more common and it shapes how people think about their vote and about the results.

No, it wasn't a 'dumb comment' about the electoral system, it was a common usage of support for party/leader as most normal Canadians do. You can say you are voting Carney or liberals and everyone knows what that means. Its an idiotic claim to say that phrase shows ignorance of the political system.

I know it is common.
Just because something wrong is a common belief doesn't mean it isn't wrong.
 
But they'll never form government.
If Palestinian rights are your priority, shouldn't the question be which vote is most likely to influence actual government policy rather than which party most closely matches your views on paper?
A party with no realistic path to power can't implement any of the policies you're voting for, even if they support them.

It's a bit more complicated than that in a parliamentary system, though.

"Who forms the government" isn't a question of simple popular vote, and the option of minority and coalition governments exist.
All of that is separate from "who is running in my riding and who has the chance to win here".

"The NDP will never form a government" isn't really a good universal measure of whether or not someone should vote NDP.
 
No.
They really don't.
All you have to do is talk to people and they make it very clear they don't understand it.
Worse still, people constantly talk about it as if you are voting for the Prime Minister directly.

It's become more and more common and it shapes how people think about their vote and about the results.



I know it is common.
Just because something wrong is a common belief doesn't mean it isn't wrong.

What next, do you call out people for not wanting an honest answer when they ask 'how are you today'?
Why waste bandwidth on a pedantic post, is it just the only attack you could think of at the time?
 
It's a bit more complicated than that in a parliamentary system, though.

"Who forms the government" isn't a question of simple popular vote, and the option of minority and coalition governments exist.
All of that is separate from "who is running in my riding and who has the chance to win here".

"The NDP will never form a government" isn't really a good universal measure of whether or not someone should vote NDP.

Not when we had a few years of very effective lib/NDP minority very recently.

At this point it really looks like you are more offended by me using shorthand of Lewis for NDP than Israel's genocide and intentional targeting of children.
That merits no comment.

 
But they'll never form government.
If Palestinian rights are your priority, shouldn't the question be which vote is most likely to influence actual government policy rather than which party most closely matches your views on paper?
A party with no realistic path to power can't implement any of the policies you're voting for, even if they support them.

We have dental and daycare courtesy of the last liberal/NDP minority government.
That is a realistic, practical and effective option.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
What next, do you call out people for not wanting an honest answer when they ask 'how are you today'?
Why waste bandwidth on a pedantic post, is it just the only attack you could think of at the time?

I think spreading a false idea about the electoral system is a bit more important than retreating to social pleasantries in answer to "how are you today".
I post on this because I actually think voting and how people vote matters.

I know we disagree about the importance of voting.
 
Not when we had a few years of very effective lib/NDP minority very recently.

An option that doesn't exist in a Presidential system.

At this point it really looks like you are more offended by me using shorthand of Lewis for NDP than Israel's genocide and intentional targeting of children.
That merits no comment.

And yet you commented anyway. :rolleyes:

One day you might learn that you can't measure what people find important via posts on an escort board, but it will mean you need to become less extremely online.
 
I think spreading a false idea about the electoral system is a bit more important than retreating to social pleasantries in answer to "how are you today".
I post on this because I actually think voting and how people vote matters.

I know we disagree about the importance of voting.

OMG!

Now I was 'spreading false ideas about the electoral system'!
By saying I was voting Lewis instead of saying I will vote for the Lewis NDP, which in conversation would sound stupid.

What we disagree on is the importance of not voting for war criminals because its 'pragmatic' in that Wilhoit kind of way.
Just as we disagree about how evil it is to target and kill children.

 
An option that doesn't exist in a Presidential system.

Irrelevant to talking about voting Lewis/NDP.

And yet you commented anyway. :rolleyes:

One day you might learn that you can't measure what people find important via posts on an escort board, but it will mean you need to become less extremely online.

One day you will learn that what you refuse to say is just as important as what you do say over and over again.

 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu and Valcazar
OMG!

Now I was 'spreading false ideas about the electoral system'!

No, not really.
We were discussing how that position is propagated in general in society.
This isn't some nefarious scheme you are engaged in.

What we disagree on is the importance of not voting for war criminals because its 'pragmatic' in that Wilhoit kind of way.

I am never going to stop finding it funny how you can't grasp the Wilhoit quote.
And we disagree on a lot more than "voting for war criminals" when it comes to voting.
That's barely even relevant to the disagreement.

Just as we disagree about how evil it is to target and kill children.

When have we disagreed about it being evil to target and kill children?
 
No, not really.
We were discussing how that position is propagated in general in society.
This isn't some nefarious scheme you are engaged in.

You said this:
I think spreading a false idea about the electoral system is a bit more important than retreating to social pleasantries in answer to "how are you today".


I am never going to stop finding it funny how you can't grasp the Wilhoit quote.
And we disagree on a lot more than "voting for war criminals" when it comes to voting.
That's barely even relevant to the disagreement.

Its depressing that you can't see the Palestinian settler colonial issue in that framework.
But that kind of willful blindness is part of backing really sick shite, isn't it?

When have we disagreed about it being evil to target and kill children?

Over the last few days, where it was very clear that you are more upset about electoral language than genocide targeting children.
What is important to you is very clear.

 
Its depressing that you can't see the Palestinian settler colonial issue in that framework.

But that's not how you use it when you are attacking me.
You use it to claim my vote is an example of it.

"The Israeli government acts as if the law protects them but doesn't bind them and the law binds others but does not protect them" is textbook Wilhoit and I wouldn't remotely disagree about that.

Over the last few days, where it was very clear that you are more upset about electoral language than genocide targeting children.
What is important to you is very clear.


I'm not the new york times, Frank.
You really need to get offline sometimes.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: MaverickPunter
But that's not how you use it when you are attacking me.
You use it to claim my vote is an example of it.

"The Israeli government acts as if the law protects them but doesn't bind them and the law binds others but does not protect them" is textbook Wilhoit and I wouldn't remotely disagree about that.

And that extrapolates into 'The american government acts as if the law protects them but doesn't bind them as they fund and provide support for Israeli genocide'. As they show with their attacks on the ICC and those who criticize Israel. Your vote for Harris fit this pattern.

Which is exactly how I've been using it.

I'm not the new york times, Frank.
You really need to get offline sometimes.

Thanks for pointing that out, I really had you pegged as an american newspaper.
 
And that extrapolates into 'The american government acts as if the law protects them but doesn't bind them as they fund and provide support for Israeli genocide'. As they show with their attacks on the ICC and those who criticize Israel.

This is true.

Your vote for Harris fit this pattern.

This is false.

Which is exactly how I've been using it.

I know.
It's why I keep making fun of you for it.

Thanks for pointing that out, I really had you pegged as an american newspaper.

I'm here to help Frank.
Everyone knows your problems with critical thinking.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: MaverickPunter
This is true.
This is false.
I know.
It's why I keep making fun of you for it.
I'm here to help Frank.
Everyone knows your problems with critical thinking.

You practice Wilhoit conservatism.
You explained how your views backed this but then just said it doesn't apply to you with Harris.
That's just sad.

The US is directly involved in this clear application of Wilhoit conservatism.


 
  • Haha
Reactions: Valcazar
One day you'll manage it.
I'm sure.
I haven't given up on you yet.

I'm amused that you were willing to accept that supporting Israel is Wilhoit conservatism but that when its applied to the dems you instantly just get dismissive and refuse to explain yourself. As debating tactics go, its quite the failure.

Meanwhile, american democrat support continues to bind Palestinians while clearly not protecting them.

 
And as long as you keep saying nonsense like this, I will continue to point out you don't understand the Wilhoit quote.

Its quite amusing that you think pretending it doesn't apply after you said it applies is a good argument.
Just as its amazing that you are here to practice arguments in defence of genocide for public use and think this is a good line.