Jerry Seinfeld On Palestine

First off, this thread had nothing to do with Israel and Palestine. I've told you before that it's nearly impossible to have a rational discussion with you on that subject because you have a habit of dragging it into conversations where it isn't relevant.

My original point was about the absurdity of trying to paint Jewish men as pedophiles by claiming that Jerry Seinfeld is a pedophile because he dated a 17-year-old. That's a serious accusation, and in my view it's both inaccurate and slanderous.

As for Palestine, since you've brought it up yet again, I do believe Palestinians have a right to their own state and to live with dignity and security. I also believe Hamas should be destroyed as a political and military force and never be allowed to hold power again.

For the sake of consistency, I'm also not a fan of Bibi. I think he has been a disaster for the prospects of long-term peace, and I'd be perfectly happy to see him removed from power through the democratic process as well.

The problem is that you seem to assume that anyone who opposes Hamas must therefore oppose Palestinian rights, and that anyone who supports Israel's right to exist must support everything Netanyahu does. The world isn't that binary. It is entirely possible to support Palestinian statehood, oppose Hamas, support Israel's right to exist, and believe Netanyahu should no longer be leading Israel.

I disagree, its all part of the larger debates about MAGA, race, fascism and human rights.

Why should Hamas be destroyed but not the state of Israel, give that Israel has now committed way worse acts of terrorism, including rape, torture and genocide?
That appears to me as racial double standards.

I was at a Palestinian/Israeli peace event over the weekend and the Palestinian view of Oct 7 is that of a jail break, not terrorism.
War crimes were committed but nothing of the scale of Israel every day since Oct 7.
 
I'm just so used to Frankie attempting to turn every thread into a Palestinian vs Israel thread. It's annoying AF.

It is a thread with the word Palestine in the title, squeezer.
Its the entire reason this thread is here.

I think the fact that there is a 2.5 year genocide that people still defend is more than annoying as fuck, its like living with nazis in the hood.
The fact that its expanded into the war on Iran that is threatening a global recession is even more annoying than fuck.

As is the fact that you are totally unable to empathize even remotely with Palestinians, who are clearly the victims.
 
It is a thread with the word Palestine in the title, squeezer.
Its the entire reason this thread is here.

I think the fact that there is a 2.5 year genocide that people still defend is more than annoying as fuck, its like living with nazis in the hood.
The fact that its expanded into the war on Iran that is threatening a global recession is even more annoying than fuck.

As is the fact that you are totally unable to empathize even remotely with Palestinians, who are clearly the victims.


I'm not unable to empathize with Palestinians. What I find difficult is empathizing with your approach to this issue because you are relentlessly one-sided, and frankly, it's exhausting and annoying as fuck.

I've stated repeatedly that I'm not a fan of Bibi and that I believe Israel has gone too far in many respects. Yet every discussion seems to end up in the same place with you, regardless of what was actually said.

The irony is that your constant black-and-white framing probably pushes some people toward defending Israel more than they otherwise would. When every disagreement is met with accusations of supporting genocide or denying Palestinians basic rights, it becomes impossible to have a nuanced conversation.

You seem to assume that anyone who doesn't share your exact view lacks empathy for Palestinians. That's simply not true. It is entirely possible to support Palestinian rights, oppose Hamas, criticize Netanyahu, and still disagree with your characterization of the conflict.

If you're as passionate about the issue as you claim, perhaps your energy would be better spent supporting humanitarian efforts or advocacy organizations that help Palestinians rather than accusing everyone who disagrees with you of being morally equivalent to Nazis and pushing them towards cheering for Israel.
 
I'm not unable to empathize with Palestinians. What I find difficult is empathizing with your approach to this issue because you are relentlessly one-sided, and frankly, it's exhausting and annoying as fuck.

I've stated repeatedly that I'm not a fan of Bibi and that I believe Israel has gone too far in many respects. Yet every discussion seems to end up in the same place with you, regardless of what was actually said.

The irony is that your constant black-and-white framing probably pushes some people toward defending Israel more than they otherwise would. When every disagreement is met with accusations of supporting genocide or denying Palestinians basic rights, it becomes impossible to have a nuanced conversation.

You seem to assume that anyone who doesn't share your exact view lacks empathy for Palestinians. That's simply not true. It is entirely possible to support Palestinian rights, oppose Hamas, criticize Netanyahu, and still disagree with your characterization of the conflict.

If you're as passionate about the issue as you claim, perhaps your energy would be better spent supporting humanitarian efforts or advocacy organizations that help Palestinians rather than accusing everyone who disagrees with you of being morally equivalent to Nazis and pushing them towards cheering for Israel.

Did you copy that verbatim from the liberal Zio playbook? How oily and duplicitous can someone get? If you are exhausted, come to grips with your obsession with one member.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: squeezer
Did you copy that verbatim from the liberal Zio playbook? How oily and duplicitous can someone get? If you are exhausted, come to grips with your obsession with one member.


The so-called member, whom I have a hunch I'm still chatting with under a different account, is the one who continually engages on this topic.

If someone repeatedly inserts themselves into the discussion accusing folks of standing for genocide, and steers conversations back to the same subject, it's hardly surprising that people end up replying to them. Zios are loved in Italy; ask @Insidious Von . Do you have issues against Zias too??

I have a tear cup for you and Franky too....I suspect you will only need one cup. ;)

1781473283161.png
 
I'm not unable to empathize with Palestinians. What I find difficult is empathizing with your approach to this issue because you are relentlessly one-sided, and frankly, it's exhausting and annoying as fuck.

I've stated repeatedly that I'm not a fan of Bibi and that I believe Israel has gone too far in many respects. Yet every discussion seems to end up in the same place with you, regardless of what was actually said.

The irony is that your constant black-and-white framing probably pushes some people toward defending Israel more than they otherwise would. When every disagreement is met with accusations of supporting genocide or denying Palestinians basic rights, it becomes impossible to have a nuanced conversation.

You seem to assume that anyone who doesn't share your exact view lacks empathy for Palestinians. That's simply not true. It is entirely possible to support Palestinian rights, oppose Hamas, criticize Netanyahu, and still disagree with your characterization of the conflict.

If you're as passionate about the issue as you claim, perhaps your energy would be better spent supporting humanitarian efforts or advocacy organizations that help Palestinians rather than accusing everyone who disagrees with you of being morally equivalent to Nazis and pushing them towards cheering for Israel.

Except you have not once supported Palestinian rights on any matter, or shown any empathy.

For instance, starting with the basics. Ukraine has a right to self defence against Russian occupation yet you do not support Palestinian right to self defence of their own occupied land. As I stated earlier, at a Israeli/Palestinian peace event recently I heard someone say Palestinians consider Oct 7 to have been a jail break. Could you ever accept that Palestinians have a right to self defence, including Hamas?
 
Except you have not once supported Palestinian rights on any matter, or shown any empathy.

For instance, starting with the basics. Ukraine has a right to self defence against Russian occupation yet you do not support Palestinian right to self defence of their own occupied land. As I stated earlier, at a Israeli/Palestinian peace event recently I heard someone say Palestinians consider Oct 7 to have been a jail break. Could you ever accept that Palestinians have a right to self defence, including Hamas?


The Ukraine comparison falls apart the moment you look at what actually happened and illustrates how fanatical you really are. .

Ukraine did not cross into Russia on Zelensky's orders, massacre civilians, kidnap women and children, and then parade hostages back across the border. Had Ukraine done something comparable, I wouldn't have been surprised if Russia responded militarily and have supported the Russians' cause.

Ukraine also wasn't firing thousands of rockets into Russian population centers for years prior to the invasion, nor was it sending suicide bombers into civilian areas. That's why your attempt to draw a direct parallel between Ukraine and Hamas doesn't hold up.

None of this means Palestinians don't have rights or legitimate grievances. I've already said I support a Palestinian state and believe Palestinians deserve dignity, security, and self-determination. What I do not accept is the idea that deliberately targeting civilians, taking hostages, and committing atrocities on October 7th constitutes legitimate self-defense.

You keep trying to force everything into a simplistic oppressor-versus-oppressed narrative where any action taken by Hamas is automatically justified because of the broader conflict. I reject that completely.

At some point, you need to acknowledge that supporting Palestinian rights and condemning Hamas are not mutually exclusive positions.

I have also said many, many times that I do not support BIBI and believe he is hurting Israel's reputation on the global stage.
 
The Ukraine comparison falls apart the moment you look at what actually happened and illustrates how fanatical you really are. .

Ukraine did not cross into Russia on Zelensky's orders, massacre civilians, kidnap women and children, and then parade hostages back across the border. Had Ukraine done something comparable, I wouldn't have been surprised if Russia responded militarily and have supported the Russians' cause.

Ukraine also wasn't firing thousands of rockets into Russian population centers for years prior to the invasion, nor was it sending suicide bombers into civilian areas. That's why your attempt to draw a direct parallel between Ukraine and Hamas doesn't hold up.

None of this means Palestinians don't have rights or legitimate grievances. I've already said I support a Palestinian state and believe Palestinians deserve dignity, security, and self-determination. What I do not accept is the idea that deliberately targeting civilians, taking hostages, and committing atrocities on October 7th constitutes legitimate self-defense.

You keep trying to force everything into a simplistic oppressor-versus-oppressed narrative where any action taken by Hamas is automatically justified because of the broader conflict. I reject that completely.

At some point, you need to acknowledge that supporting Palestinian rights and condemning Hamas are not mutually exclusive positions.

I have also said many, many times that I do not support BIBI and believe he is hurting Israel's reputation on the global stage.

We are 78 years into the Ukraine/Russia comparison, squeezer, 78 years of Israel taking more and more parts of Palestine.
At the time that Hamas broke out of the Gaza open air prison Israel was holding more about 5,000 Palestinian hostages under 'administrative detention'. Israel repeatedly crossed into Gaza and the West Bank and took civilians back. Israel is the only country in the world with a prison for child hostages. By every metric, Israel was already far more evil than Russia.

Ukraine fired rockets at Russian occupiers.
Hamas fired rockets at Israeli occupiers.

Russia is trying to take over all of Ukraine.
Israel is trying and has now wiped Palestine off the maps.

Russia isn't even guilty of apartheid, rape or genocide the way that Israel is.

You have declared Hamas should be disbanded for one day of war crimes on Oct 7 but excuse 78 years of occupation, blockade, apartheid and now genocide.
Its Israel that needs to be dismantled the way nazi Germany was dismantled for the crime of genocide



 
We are 78 years into the Ukraine/Russia comparison, squeezer, 78 years of Israel taking more and more parts of Palestine.
At the time that Hamas broke out of the Gaza open air prison Israel was holding more about 5,000 Palestinian hostages under 'administrative detention'. Israel repeatedly crossed into Gaza and the West Bank and took civilians back. Israel is the only country in the world with a prison for child hostages. By every metric, Israel was already far more evil than Russia.

Ukraine fired rockets at Russian occupiers.
Hamas fired rockets at Israeli occupiers.

Russia is trying to take over all of Ukraine.
Israel is trying and has now wiped Palestine off the maps.

Russia isn't even guilty of apartheid, rape or genocide the way that Israel is.

You have declared Hamas should be disbanded for one day of war crimes on Oct 7 but excuse 78 years of occupation, blockade, apartheid and now genocide.
Its Israel that needs to be dismantled the way nazi Germany was dismantled for the crime of genocide


You're presenting a very one-sided version of events and then treating it as settled fact because you're becoming a MAGA Pali version.

First, Israel has not "wiped Palestine off the map." There are millions of Palestinians living in Gaza, the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and elsewhere. You can argue about borders, settlements, occupation, and statehood, but claiming Palestine has literally been erased is rhetoric, not fact.

Second, your Ukraine comparison continues to ignore a crucial distinction. Ukraine primarily targets Russian military forces and military infrastructure. Hamas deliberately targeted civilians on October 7th, murdering families in their homes, attacking a music festival, and taking civilian hostages, including children and the elderly. Those actions are not comparable to conventional military operations.

Third, you keep referring to October 7th as "one day of war crimes," as though it were some minor event. It was the deadliest attack against Jews since World War II. Any serious discussion has to acknowledge that reality rather than minimizing it.

Fourth, I have never excused everything Israel has done. In fact, I've repeatedly said that I oppose Netanyahu, that I believe Israel has gone too far in many respects, and that Palestinians deserve their own state and basic rights. The problem is that you seem incapable of recognizing any wrongdoing by Hamas while assigning virtually all blame to Israel.

Finally, comparing Israel to Nazi Germany is exactly the kind of hyperbole that makes productive discussion impossible. Once every conflict becomes "Nazis," every opponent becomes genocidal, and every disagreement becomes proof of evil, you've abandoned analysis in favor of slogans. In other words, debating you is like I accuse the righties of chasing their tail.

You can support Palestinian rights without defending Hamas. You can criticize Israeli policy without calling for the dismantling of Israel. Most people understand that. You seem determined not to. YOU are an antisemitic racist!!!!
 
1781477967003.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
You're presenting a very one-sided version of events and then treating it as settled fact because you're becoming a MAGA Pali version.

First, Israel has not "wiped Palestine off the map." There are millions of Palestinians living in Gaza, the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and elsewhere. You can argue about borders, settlements, occupation, and statehood, but claiming Palestine has literally been erased is rhetoric, not fact.

Second, your Ukraine comparison continues to ignore a crucial distinction. Ukraine primarily targets Russian military forces and military infrastructure. Hamas deliberately targeted civilians on October 7th, murdering families in their homes, attacking a music festival, and taking civilian hostages, including children and the elderly. Those actions are not comparable to conventional military operations.

Third, you keep referring to October 7th as "one day of war crimes," as though it were some minor event. It was the deadliest attack against Jews since World War II. Any serious discussion has to acknowledge that reality rather than minimizing it.

Fourth, I have never excused everything Israel has done. In fact, I've repeatedly said that I oppose Netanyahu, that I believe Israel has gone too far in many respects, and that Palestinians deserve their own state and basic rights. The problem is that you seem incapable of recognizing any wrongdoing by Hamas while assigning virtually all blame to Israel.

Finally, comparing Israel to Nazi Germany is exactly the kind of hyperbole that makes productive discussion impossible. Once every conflict becomes "Nazis," every opponent becomes genocidal, and every disagreement becomes proof of evil, you've abandoned analysis in favor of slogans. In other words, debating you is like I accuse the righties of chasing their tail.

You can support Palestinian rights without defending Hamas. You can criticize Israeli policy without calling for the dismantling of Israel. Most people understand that. You seem determined not to. YOU are an antisemitic racist!!!!

You're wasting your time. The guy spends his entire day and night here like a droning slave not trying to understand an entirely complex geopolitical conflict but just to shovel the same moronic slogans that every other brain dead Palestinian flag waver shovels. Last time I challenged him I got banned for five days, so it kind of tells you what his other job is other than posting 24/7 nonsense.
 
You're presenting a very one-sided version of events and then treating it as settled fact because you're becoming a MAGA Pali version.

First, Israel has not "wiped Palestine off the map." There are millions of Palestinians living in Gaza, the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and elsewhere. You can argue about borders, settlements, occupation, and statehood, but claiming Palestine has literally been erased is rhetoric, not fact.

The UN passed a resolution demanding Israel end the occupation of Palestine, Israel has responded by announcing they will never allow a state of Palestine.
That means that Israel has officially wiped Palestine off the maps.
Those are facts.

Second, your Ukraine comparison continues to ignore a crucial distinction. Ukraine primarily targets Russian military forces and military infrastructure. Hamas deliberately targeted civilians on October 7th, murdering families in their homes, attacking a music festival, and taking civilian hostages, including children and the elderly. Those actions are not comparable to conventional military operations.

Israel has a record of massacres on Gaza that have at least 80% civilian fatalities, from the Great March of Return to the genocide, Israel targets civilians even more than Gaza. Israel has destroyed all universities, schools, hospitals and medical centres in Gaza. How is that not worse than Hamas trying to take civilians hostage?

Third, you keep referring to October 7th as "one day of war crimes," as though it were some minor event. It was the deadliest attack against Jews since World War II. Any serious discussion has to acknowledge that reality rather than minimizing it.

Again, you refuse to even consider that Palestinians have the right to self defence against an illegal occupation. Second, most of the dead on Oct 7 were by Israeli apaches and tanks, through Israel's 'Hannibal Doctrine'. That is well documented. If Israel doesn't want the native population to resist the illegal occupation they should just get the fark out of Palestine.

Fourth, I have never excused everything Israel has done. In fact, I've repeatedly said that I oppose Netanyahu, that I believe Israel has gone too far in many respects, and that Palestinians deserve their own state and basic rights. The problem is that you seem incapable of recognizing any wrongdoing by Hamas while assigning virtually all blame to Israel.

Bull, I have repeatedly stated that both sides should be charged for war crimes. That includes Hamas for trying to kidnap civilians and using indiscriminate weapons that can't be aimed at military. On Israel's side that includes the illegal occupation, transfer of population, apartheid, illegal blockade of Gaza and the genocide. Feel free to argue why you think Hamas' crimes are worse.

Finally, comparing Israel to Nazi Germany is exactly the kind of hyperbole that makes productive discussion impossible. Once every conflict becomes "Nazis," every opponent becomes genocidal, and every disagreement becomes proof of evil, you've abandoned analysis in favor of slogans. In other words, debating you is like I accuse the righties of chasing their tail.

The nazis were charged with genocide.
Israel is charged with genocide.

The comparisons are fair and will last forever. Israel is forever labelled a genocidal state along with Rwanda, nazi Germany, Pol Pot and Bosnia.
Feel free to tell me how many of those states were allowed to continue after committing genocide.

You can support Palestinian rights without defending Hamas. You can criticize Israeli policy without calling for the dismantling of Israel. Most people understand that. You seem determined not to. YOU are an antisemitic racist!!!!

I'm criticizing Israeli policy, not the Jewish people.
You just committed an antisemitic act by conflating the two.

A year ago 52% of Canadians believed Israel is committing genocide.
You choose to defend genocide and then call those who are against it as racist.
At this point its you who is clearly racist against Palestinians and Muslims.
Israel just killed yet another attempt at peace because they won't stop killing Muslims and Christians in Lebanon.


 
The so-called member, whom I have a hunch I'm still chatting with under a different account, is the one who continually engages on this topic.

If someone repeatedly inserts themselves into the discussion accusing folks of standing for genocide, and steers conversations back to the same subject, it's hardly surprising that people end up replying to them. Zios are loved in Italy; ask @Insidious Von . Do you have issues against Zias too??

I have a tear cup for you and Franky too....I suspect you will only need one cup. ;)

View attachment 605671

They never wanted peace...So this is the end game.

They do believe there is a lot virgins where they are going...So I suppose they have that to look forward too.
 
You're presenting a very one-sided version of events and then treating it as settled fact because you're becoming a MAGA Pali version.

First, Israel has not "wiped Palestine off the map." There are millions of Palestinians living in Gaza, the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and elsewhere. You can argue about borders, settlements, occupation, and statehood, but claiming Palestine has literally been erased is rhetoric, not fact.

Second, your Ukraine comparison continues to ignore a crucial distinction. Ukraine primarily targets Russian military forces and military infrastructure. Hamas deliberately targeted civilians on October 7th, murdering families in their homes, attacking a music festival, and taking civilian hostages, including children and the elderly. Those actions are not comparable to conventional military operations.

Third, you keep referring to October 7th as "one day of war crimes," as though it were some minor event. It was the deadliest attack against Jews since World War II. Any serious discussion has to acknowledge that reality rather than minimizing it.

Fourth, I have never excused everything Israel has done. In fact, I've repeatedly said that I oppose Netanyahu, that I believe Israel has gone too far in many respects, and that Palestinians deserve their own state and basic rights. The problem is that you seem incapable of recognizing any wrongdoing by Hamas while assigning virtually all blame to Israel.

Finally, comparing Israel to Nazi Germany is exactly the kind of hyperbole that makes productive discussion impossible. Once every conflict becomes "Nazis," every opponent becomes genocidal, and every disagreement becomes proof of evil, you've abandoned analysis in favor of slogans. In other words, debating you is like I accuse the righties of chasing their tail.

You can support Palestinian rights without defending Hamas. You can criticize Israeli policy without calling for the dismantling of Israel. Most people understand that. You seem determined not to. YOU are an antisemitic racist!!!!

More discredited Zio drivel.
 
You're presenting a very one-sided version of events and then treating it as settled fact because you're becoming a MAGA Pali version.

First, Israel has not "wiped Palestine off the map." There are millions of Palestinians living in Gaza, the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and elsewhere. You can argue about borders, settlements, occupation, and statehood, but claiming Palestine has literally been erased is rhetoric, not fact.

Second, your Ukraine comparison continues to ignore a crucial distinction. Ukraine primarily targets Russian military forces and military infrastructure. Hamas deliberately targeted civilians on October 7th, murdering families in their homes, attacking a music festival, and taking civilian hostages, including children and the elderly. Those actions are not comparable to conventional military operations.

Third, you keep referring to October 7th as "one day of war crimes," as though it were some minor event. It was the deadliest attack against Jews since World War II. Any serious discussion has to acknowledge that reality rather than minimizing it.

Fourth, I have never excused everything Israel has done. In fact, I've repeatedly said that I oppose Netanyahu, that I believe Israel has gone too far in many respects, and that Palestinians deserve their own state and basic rights. The problem is that you seem incapable of recognizing any wrongdoing by Hamas while assigning virtually all blame to Israel.

Finally, comparing Israel to Nazi Germany is exactly the kind of hyperbole that makes productive discussion impossible. Once every conflict becomes "Nazis," every opponent becomes genocidal, and every disagreement becomes proof of evil, you've abandoned analysis in favor of slogans. In other words, debating you is like I accuse the righties of chasing their tail.

You can support Palestinian rights without defending Hamas. You can criticize Israeli policy without calling for the dismantling of Israel. Most people understand that. You seem determined not to. YOU are an antisemitic racist!!!!
Israel has done some really fucked up shit in the middle east since they were made a country in Arabic lands. Not really sure why the UN didn't give them land in Germany instead. Ever since the Jews have been illegally grabbing more and more land and even stole 200 tons of Belgian uranium when France cut them off because of their illegal land grab wars. I'm not sure if Israel is the most fucked up country in the middle east but given the circumstances I can see why the Palestinians would be pissed. imagine if the UN decided to give Arabs the GTA and you all had to move out and then to make matters worse they kept taking more and more land and stole uranium to make nukes and then the US gave them all the arms and military support they need to obliterate the rest of Canada all the while they kept going to war to grab more and more land
 
More discredited Zio drivel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter